Assessment of Stream Restoration for Reduction of Sediment in a Large Agricultural Watershed
Publication: Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management
Volume 144, Issue 7
Abstract
In many agricultural watersheds, channel erosion is a major source of sediment. In these watersheds, a comprehensive approach to reducing channel erosion can aid in the feasibility of meeting water quality goals. In the Minnesota River Basin (MRB), a large agricultural watershed, increased peak flows have contributed to greater sediment loading from within the channel. This study focuses on three components of channel restoration that are important in developing a strategic framework: sediment source reduction, working with private landowners, and the economics of restoration. A synthesis of sediment research was done to assess the sediment reduction benefit of restoration projects. While field erosion is the largest source of gross erosion, most of the sediment from fields is not delivered to the river. In the MRB, sediment from stream banks and bluffs is the dominant source, thus requiring water storage and/or stream management in order to reduce sediment load. Landowners favored edge-of-field practices that minimize the conversion of farmland and have minimal government intervention. Economic analysis of restoration showed that the most cost-effective restoration projects reduced large amounts of sediment on short stretches of lower-order streams. However ecological benefits, project sustainability, and local cultural issues suggest a role for smaller stream restoration projects. Sediment reduction estimates and assessment of ecosystem service benefits from stream restoration projects need to be further developed.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Acknowledgments
The McKnight Foundation provided funding support for this study. Linse Lahte, a graduate student at the time, collected data on costs from individual stream projects around Minnesota. Steve Roos of the Minnesota Department of Agriculture created GIS maps. Linda Meschke of Rural Advantage and Rich Perrine of Martin County SWCD helped organize the landowner meeting. Kylene Olson and Paul Wymar of the Chippewa River Watershed Project helped coordinate the public meeting in Montevideo, Minnesota.
Disclaimer
The views expressed are those of the author(s) and should not be attributed to the Economic Research Service or USDA.
References
Argabright, M. S., R. G. Cronshey, J. D. Helms, G. A. Pavelis, and H. R. Sinclair. 1996. Historical changes in soil erosion, 1930–1992: The Northern Mississippi Valley Loess Hills. Historical Notes Number 5. Washington, DC: USDA.
Ashmore, P., and M. Church. 2001. The impact of climate change on rivers and river processes in Canada. Geological Survey of Canada Bulletin # 555. Ottawa, Canada: Geological Survey of Canada.
Beach, T. 1994. “The fate of eroded soil: Sediment sinks and sediment budgets of agrarian landscapes in southern Minnesota, 1851–1988.” Ann. Assoc. Am. Geogr. 84 (1): 5–28. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8306.1994.tb01726.x.
Belmont, P. 2011. “Floodplain width adjustments in response to rapid base level fall and knickpoint migration.” Geomorphology 128 (1–2): 92–102.
Belmont, P., et al. 2011. “Large shift in source of fine sediment in the upper Mississippi River.” Environ. Sci. Technol. 45 (20): 8804–8810. https://doi.org/10.1021/es2019109.
Belmont, P., J. K. Willenbring, S. P. Schottler, J. Marquard, K. Kumarasamy, and J. Hemmis. 2014. “Toward generalizable sediment fingerprinting with tracers that are conservative and non-conservative over sediment routing timescales.” J. Soils Sediments 14 (8): 1479–1492. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11368-014-0913-5.
Bernhardt, E. S., et al. 2007. “Restoring rivers one reach at a time: Results from a survey of US river restoration practitioners.” Restor. Ecol. 15 (3): 482–493. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1526-100X.2007.00244.x.
Burton, R., C. Kuczera, and G. Schwarz. 2008. “Exploring farmers’ cultural resistance to voluntary agri-environmental schemes.” Sociologia Ruralis 48 (1): 16–37. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9523.2008.00452.x.
Burton, R. J., and U. H. Paragahawewa. 2011. “Creating culturally sustainable agri-environmental schemes.” J. Rural Stud. 27 (1): 95–104. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jrurstud.2010.11.001.
Clayton, L., and S. R. Moran. 1982. “Chronology of late-Wisconsinan glaciations in middle North America.” Quat. Sci. Rev. 1 (1): 55–82. https://doi.org/10.1016/0277-3791(82)90019-1.
Cordova, J. M., E. J. Rosi-Marshall, A. M. Yamamuro, and G. A. Lamberti. 2007. “Quantity, controls and functions of large woody debris in Midwestern USA streams.” River Res. Appl. 23 (1): 21–33. https://doi.org/10.1002/rra.963.
Cruse, R. 2012. Assessing the health of streams in agricultural landscapes: How land management changes impact water quality. Edited by R. Cruse. Ames, IA: Council on Agricultural Science and Technology.
Dolph, C. L., S. L. Eggert, J. Magner, L. C. Ferrington Jr, and B. Vondracek. 2015. “Reach-scale stream restoration in agricultural streams of southern Minnesota alters structural and functional responses of macroinvertebrates.” Freshwater Sci. 34 (2): 535–546. https://doi.org/10.1086/680984.
Dosskey, M., D. Schultz, and I. Tom. 1997. A riparian buffer design for cropland. Agroforestry Notes (USDA-NAC). Lincoln, NE: National Agroforestry Center.
Environmental Statistics Group. 2013. “Hydrologic unit project.” Accessed 15 June 2013. http://www.esg.montana.edu/gl/huc/07020000.html.
EOR (Emmons and Olivier Resources). 2011. “Minnesota river valley ravine stabilization Charrette.” Scott Watershed Management Organization and Minnesota River Board. Accessed April 28, 2018. http://www.scottcountymn.gov/documentcenter/view/1274.
Foufoula-Georgiou, E., Z. Takbiri, J. A. Czuba, and J. Schwenk. 2015. “The change of nature and the nature of change in agricultural landscapes: Hydrologic regime shifts modulate ecological transitions.” Water Resour. Res. 51 (8): 6649–6671. https://doi.org/10.1002/2015WR017637.
Gran, K. B., P. Belmont, S. S. Day, C. Jennings, A. Johnson, L. Perg, and P. R. Wilcock. 2009. “Geomorphic evolution of the Le Sueur River, Minnesota, USA, and implications for current sediment loading.” In Vol. 451 of Management and restoration of fluvial systems with broad historical changes and human impacts, edited by L. A. James, S. L. Rathburn, and G. R. Whittecar, 119–130. Geological Society of America special paper. Boulder, CO: Geological Society of America.
Gran, K. B., N. Finnegan, A. L. Johnson, P. Belmont, C. Wittkop, and T. Rittenour. 2013. “Landscape evolution, valley excavation, and terrace development following abrupt postglacial base level fall.” GSA Bull. 125 (11–12): 1851–1864. https://doi.org/10.1130/B30772.1.
Green, T. R., S. G. Beavis, C. R. Dietrich, and A. J. Jakeman. 1999. “Relating stream-bank erosion to in-stream transport of suspended sediment.” Hydrol. Process. 13 (5): 777–787. https://doi.org/10.1002/(SICI)1099-1085(19990415)13:5%3C777::AID-HYP780%3E3.0.CO;2-P.
Herzon, I., and M. Mikk. 2007. “Farmers’ perceptions of biodiversity and their willingness to enhance it through agri-environment schemes: A comparative study from Estonia and Finland.” J. Nat. Conserv. 15 (1): 10–25. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnc.2006.08.001.
Kelly, S. A., and P. A. Belmont 2018. “High Resolution Monitoring of River Bluff Erosion Reveals Failure Mechanisms and Geomorphically Effective Flows.” Water 10 (4): 394.
Kelly, S. A., Z. Takbiri, P. Belmont, and E. Foufoula-Georgiou. 2017. “Human amplified changes in precipitation-runoff patterns in large river basins of the Midwestern United States.” Hydrology Earth System Sciences 21 (10): 5065.
Knighton, D. 2014. Fluvial forms and processes: A new perspective. 2nd Ed. London, UK: Routledge.
Kuehner, K. 2001. “Seven-mile creek watershed project: A resource investigation within the middle Minnesota major watershed.” Nicollet-Cottonwood Water Quality Joint Powers Board. Accessed April 28, 2018. https://mrbdc.mnsu.edu/sites/mrbdc.mnsu.edu/files/public/reports/midminn/sevenmile.html.
Laubel, A., B. Kronvang, A. B. Hald, and C. Jensen. 2003. “Hydromorphological and biological factors influencing sediment and phosphorus loss via bank erosion in small lowland rural streams in Denmark.” Hydrol. Process. 17 (17): 3443–3463. https://doi.org/10.1002/hyp.1302.
Lauer, J. W., C. Echterling, C. Lenhart, P. Belmont, and R. Rausch. 2017. “Air-photo based change in channel width in the Minnesota River basin: Modes of adjustment and implications for sediment budget.” Geomorphology 297: 170–184. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geomorph.2017.09.005.
Lenhart, C., K. Brooks, J. Magner, and B. Suppes. 2010. “River corridor-channel restoration and management in Elm Creek, Minnesota.” Ecol. Restor. 28 (3): 240–242. https://doi.org/10.3368/er.28.3.240.
Lenhart, C., B. Gordon, J. Gamble, D. Current, N. Ross, L. Herring, J. Nieber, and H. Peterson. 2016. “Design and hydrologic performance of a tile drainage treatment wetland in Minnesota, USA.” Water 8 (12): 549. https://doi.org/10.3390/w8120549.
Lenhart, C. F., H. Peterson, and J. Nieber. 2011. “Increased streamflow in agricultural watersheds of the Midwest: Implications for management.” Watershed Sci. Bull. 2 (1): 25–31.
Lenhart, C. F., M. L. Titov, J. S. Ulrich, J. L. Nieber, and B. J. Suppes. 2013. “The role of hydrologic alteration and riparian vegetation dynamics in channel evolution along the lower Minnesota River.” Trans. ASABE 56 (2): 549–561. https://doi.org/10.13031/2013.42686.
Magner, J. A. 2011. “Tailored watershed assessment and integrated management (TWAIM): A systems thinking approach.” Water 3 (4): 590–603. https://doi.org/10.3390/w3020590.
Miller, T. P., J. R. Peterson, C. F. Lenhart, and Y. Nomura. 2012. The agricultural BMP handbook for Minnesota. St. Paul, MN: Minnesota Dept. of Agriculture.
Minnesota State Government. 2018. “Minnesota buffer law website.” Accessed April 28, 2018. https://mn.gov/portal/natural-resources/buffer-law/.
Moerke, A. H., and G. A. Lamberti. 2004. “Restoring stream ecosystems: Lessons from a Midwestern state.” Restor. Ecol. 12 (3): 327–334. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1061-2971.2004.0340.x.
MPCA (Minnesota Pollution Control Agency). 2009a. Identifying sediment sources in the Minnesota River basin. St. Paul, MN: MPCA.
MPCA (Minnesota Pollution Control Agency). 2009b. Minnesota River Basin turbidity TMDL and Lake Pepin excessive nutrient TMDL: Model calibration and validation report. St. Paul, MN: MPCA.
MPCA (Minnesota Pollution Control Agency). 2012. Minnesota River turbidity total maximum daily load: Draft report. St. Paul, MN: MPCA.
MPCA (Minnesota Pollution Control Agency). 2013. Poplar River watershed total maximum daily load report: Turbidity impairment. St. Paul, MN: MPCA.
MPCA (Minnesota Pollution Control Agency). 2014. “The Minnesota nutrient reduction strategy.”. St. Paul, MN: MPCA.
Nassauer, J. I., J. A. Dowdell, Z. Wang, D. McKahn, B. Chilcott, C. L. Kling, and S. Secchi. 2011. “Iowa farmers’ responses to transformative scenarios for Corn Belt agriculture.” J. Soil Water Conserv. 66 (1): 18–24. https://doi.org/10.2489/jswc.66.1.18A.
Nelson, E., G. Mendoza, J. Regetz, S. Polasky, H. Tallis, D. Cameron, and M. Shaw. 2009. “Modeling multiple ecosystem services, biodiversity conservation, commodity production, and tradeoffs at landscape scales.” Front. Ecol. Environ. 7 (1): 4–11. https://doi.org/10.1890/080023.
Nieber, J., C. Lenhart, D. Mulla, B. Hansen, J. Ulrich, and S. Wing. 2010. Ravine, bluff, streambank (RBS) erosion study for the Minnesota River basin. St. Paul, MN: MPCA.
Norton, D. J., J. D. Wickham, T. G. Wade, K. Kunert, J. V. Thomas, and P. Zeph. 2009. “A method for comparative analysis of recovery potential in impaired waters restoration planning.” Environ. Manage. 44 (2): 356–368. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-009-9304-x.
Novotny, E. V., and H. G. Stefan. 2007. “Stream flow in Minnesota: Indicator of climate change.” J. Hydrol. 334 (3–4): 319–333. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2006.10.011.
Renard, K. G., G. R. Foster, G. A. Weesies, and J. P. Porter. 1991. “RUSLE: Revised universal soil loss equation.” J. Soil Water Conserv. 46 (1): 30–33.
Rosgen, D. L., H. L. Silvey, and D. Frantila. 2006. Watershed assessment of river stability and sediment supply (WARSSS). Fort Collins, CO: Wildland Hydrology.
Sass, C. K., and T. W. Keane. 2012. “Application of Rosgen’s BANCS model for NE Kansas and the development of predictive streambank erosion curves.” J. Am. Water Resour. Assoc. 48 (4): 774–787. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1752-1688.2012.00644.x.
Schaffrath, K. R., P. Belmont, and J. M. Wheaton. 2015. “Landscape-scale geomorphic change detection: Quantifying spatially variable uncertainty and circumventing legacy data issues.” Geomorphology 250: 334–348. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geomorph.2015.09.020.
Schilling, K. E., and M. Helmers. 2008. “Effects of subsurface drainage tiles on streamflow in Iowa agricultural watersheds: Exploratory hydrograph analysis.” Hydrol. Process. 22 (23): 4497–4506. https://doi.org/10.1002/hyp.7052.
Schottler, S. P., J. Ulrich, P. Belmont, R. Moore, J. Lauer, D. R. Engstrom, and J. E. Almendinger. 2014. “Twentieth century agricultural drainage creates more erosive rivers.” Hydrol. Process. 28 (4): 1951–1961. https://doi.org/10.1002/hyp.9738.
Sekely, A. C., D. J. Mulla, and D. W. Bauer. 2002. “Streambank slumping and its contribution to the phosphorus and suspended sediment loads of the Blue Earth River, Minnesota.” J. Soil Water Conserv. 57 (5): 243–250.
Siebert, R., M. Toogood, and A. Knierim. 2006. “Factors affecting European farmers’ participation in biodiversity policies.” Sociologia Ruralis 46 (4): 318–340. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9523.2006.00420.x.
Smith, S. M. C., P. Belmont, and P. R. Wilcock. 2011. “Closing the gap between watershed modeling, sediment budgeting, and stream restoration.” In Vol. 194 of Stream restoration in dynamic fluvial systems: Scientific approaches, analyses, and tools, edited by A. Simon, S. J. Bennett and J. M. Castro. AGU geophysical monograph series, 293–317. Washington, DC: AGU.
Solow, A., S. Polasky, and J. Broadus. 1993. “On the measurement of biological diversity.” J. Environ. Econ. Manage. 24 (1): 60–68. https://doi.org/10.1006/jeem.1993.1004.
Stout, J. C., P. Belmont, S. P. Schottler, and J. K. Willenbring. 2014. “Identifying sediment sources and sinks in the Root River, Southeastern Minnesota.” Ann. Assoc. Am. Geogr. 104 (1): 20–39. https://doi.org/10.1080/00045608.2013.843434.
Stutter, M. I., W. J. Chardon, and B. Kronvang. 2012. “Riparian buffer strips as a multifunctional management tool in agricultural landscapes: Introduction.” J. Environ. Q. 41 (2): 297–303. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2011.0439.
Trimble, S. W. 1999. “Decreased rates of alluvial sediment storage in the Coon Creek Basin, Wisconsin, 1975-93.” Science 285 (5431): 1244–1246.
Underhill, B. L. 2013. “The influence of vegetation and root density on erosion for three streams in Minnesota.” M.S. thesis, Univ. of Minnesota-Twin Cities.
USDA. 2007. Summary report 2007 National resources inventory. Washington, DC: NRCS.
Vaughan, A. A., P. Belmont, C. P. Hawkins, and P. Wilcock 2017. “Near-channel versus watershed controls on sediment rating curves.” J. Geophys. Res.: Earth Surf. 122 (10): 1901–1923.
Wilcock, P., et al. 2016. CSSR: Collaborative for sediment source reduction greater Blue Earth River Basin. St. Paul, MN: MPCA.
Wilcock, P. R. 2009. “Identifying sediment sources in the Minnesota River Basin.” Minnesota River sediment colloquium report. St. Paul, MN: Minnesota Pollution Control Agency.
Wilson, C. G., R. A. Kuhnle, D. D. Bosch, J. L. Steiner, P. J. Starks, M. D. Tomer, and G. V. Wilson. 2008. “Quantifying relative contributions from sediment sources in Conservation Effects Assessment Project watersheds.” J. Soil Water Conserv. 63 (6): 523–532. https://doi.org/10.2489/jswc.63.6.523.
Yan, B., M. D. Tomer, and D. E. James. 2010. “Historical channel movement and sediment accretion along the South Fork of the Iowa River.” J. Soil Water Conserv. 65 (1): 1–8. https://doi.org/10.2489/jswc.65.1.1.
Zaimes, G., R. C. Schultz, and T. M. Isenhart. 2006. “Riparian land uses and precipitation influences on stream bank erosion in central Iowa.” J. Am. Water Resour. Assoc. 42 (1): 83–97. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1752-1688.2006.tb03825.x.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management
Volume 144 • Issue 7 • July 2018
Copyright
©2018 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: May 12, 2016
Accepted: Sep 22, 2017
Published online: May 11, 2018
Published in print: Jul 1, 2018
Discussion open until: Oct 11, 2018
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.