Comparing Task Performance of BIM and CAD in Completing Construction Project Activities: A Lab Experiment Approach
Publication: Journal of Architectural Engineering
Volume 30, Issue 4
Abstract
Combined usage of computer-aided design (CAD) and building information modeling (BIM) in the same construction project can result in unwarranted issues. Stakeholders might combine CAD and BIM due to a lack of awareness of the benefits of implementing BIM exclusively. A lateral comparison between the impact of CAD and BIM on different project activities can provide stakeholders with the necessary awareness. Therefore, this study aimed to compare the task performance of BIM and CAD in completing different construction project activities in a controlled environment. To achieve that, this study used an experimental lab research approach. The study participants were industry professionals with experience in using CAD and/or BIM to produce different project outputs. The outputs were analyzed to identify shifts in task performance among the participants, including mean and median analysis and ANOVA. The results, encompassing duration, completeness, and accuracy, highlight BIM’s superiority over CAD. Extrapolating these results to overall task performance, BIM exhibits approximately two times better performance than CAD. The study reveals that BIM’s integrated and dynamic modeling approach contributes to its superior performance, enhancing accuracy, completeness, and efficiency in construction project activities. As a result, the study emphasizes the importance of using BIM exclusively. Nevertheless, this is the first study that laterally compares the performance of BIM and CAD in completing different construction project activities in a controlled environment.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Data Availability Statement
Personal information of the study participants is confidential in nature and may only be provided with restrictions.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by Universiti Malaysia Pahang Al-Sultan Abdullah (RDU223314) and Bimage Consulting (M) Sdn. Bhd. The authors are also thankful to the industry practitioners who participated in this work.
References
Akbar, M. H. U., I. K. Sucita, and E. Yanuarini. 2021. “Comparison between the BOQ of conventional and BIM method on BPJS building in Central Jakarta.” Logic: Jurnal Rancang Bangun dan Teknologi 21 (1): 31–39. https://doi.org/10.31940/logic.v21i1.2260.
Al Hattab, M., and F. Hamzeh. 2013. “Information flow comparison between traditional and BIM-based projects in the design phase.” In Vol. 29 of Proc., 21st Annual Conf. of the Int. Group for Lean Construction. Dublin, Ireland: International Group for Lean Construction (IGLC).
Al-Mohammad, M. S., A. T. Haron, M. Esa, M. N. Aloko, Y. Alhammadi, K. S. Anandh, and R. A. Rahman. 2023. “Factors affecting BIM implementation: Evidence from countries with different income levels.” Constr. Innovation 23: 683–710. https://doi.org/10.1108/CI-11-2021-0217.
Amr Sayed Hassan, M., A. Fathy Eaid, and H. Mohamed Talat Eldaly. 2021. “Applications of building information modeling methods in risk management and time management.” Int. J. Archit. Eng. Urban Res. 4 (1): 184–216. https://doi.org/10.21608/ijaeur.2021.216427.
Azhar, S. 2011. “Building information modeling (BIM): Trends, benefits, risks, and challenges for the AEC industry.” Leadersh. Manage. Eng. 11 (3): 241–252. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)LM.1943-5630.0000127.
Azhar, S., M. Khalfan, and T. Maqsood. 2015. “Building information modelling (BIM): Now and beyond.” Constr. Econ. Build. 12 (4): 15–28. https://doi.org/10.5130/AJCEB.v12i4.3032.
Bansal, V. K. 2021. “Integrated framework of BIM and GIS applications to support building lifecycle: A move toward nD modeling.” J. Archit. Eng. 27 (4): 05021009. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)AE.1943-5568.0000490.
Barlish, K., and K. Sullivan. 2012. “How to measure the benefits of BIM—A case study approach.” Autom. Constr. 24: 149–159. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2012.02.008.
Bryde, D., M. Broquetas, and J. M. Volm. 2013. “The project benefits of building information modelling (BIM).” Int. J. Project Manage. 31 (7): 971–980. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2012.12.001.
Chahrour, R., M. A. Hafeez, A. M. Ahmad, H. I. Sulieman, H. Dawood, S. Rodriguez-Trejo, M. Kassem, K. K. Naji, and N. Dawood. 2021. “Cost-benefit analysis of BIM-enabled design clash detection and resolution.” Construct. Manage. Econ. 39 (1): 55–72. https://doi.org/10.1080/01446193.2020.1802768.
Chen, Y., D. John, and R. F. Cox. 2018. “Qualitatively exploring the impact of BIM on construction performance.” In Proc., Int. Conf. on Construction and Real Estate Management, edited by Y. Wang, Y. Zhu, G. Q. P. Shen, and M. Al-Hussein, 60–71. Reston, VA: ASCE.
Cheung, F. K. T., J. Rihan, J. Tah, D. Duce, and E. Kurul. 2012. “Early stage multi-level cost estimation for schematic BIM models.” Autom. Constr. 27: 67–77. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2012.05.008.
Chu, M., J. Matthews, and P. E. D. Love. 2018. “Integrating mobile building information modelling and augmented reality systems: An experimental study.” Autom. Constr. 85: 305–316. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2017.10.032.
Crowther, J., and S. O. Ajayi. 2021. “Impacts of 4D BIM on construction project performance.” Int. J. Construct. Manage. 21 (7): 724–737. https://doi.org/10.1080/15623599.2019.1580832.
Czmoch, I., and A. Pękala. 2014. “Traditional design versus BIM based design.” Procedia Eng. 91: 210–215. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proeng.2014.12.048.
Eadie, R., M. Browne, H. Odeyinka, C. McKeown, and S. McNiff. 2013. “BIM implementation throughout the UK construction project lifecycle: An analysis.” Autom. Constr. 36: 145–151. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2013.09.001.
Eastman, C. M. 2011. BIM handbook: A guide to building information modeling for owners, managers, designers, engineers and contractors. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
Espinosa, J. A., S. A. Slaughter, R. E. Kraut, and J. D. Herbsleb. 2007. “Familiarity, complexity, and team performance in geographically distributed software development.” Organ. Sci. 18 (4): 613–630. https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.1070.0297.
Fanning, B., C. M. Clevenger, M. E. Ozbek, and H. Mahmoud. 2015. “Implementing BIM on infrastructure: Comparison of two bridge construction projects.” Pract. Period. Struct. Des. Constr. 20 (4): 04014044. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)SC.1943-5576.0000239.
Farouk, A. M., A. Z. Zulhisham, Y. S. Lee, M. S. Rajabi, and R. A. Rahman. 2023. “Factors, challenges and strategies of trust in BIM-based construction projects: A case study in Malaysia.” Infrastructures 8 (1): 13. https://doi.org/10.3390/infrastructures8010013.
Franz, B., and J. Messner. 2019. “Evaluating the impact of building information modeling on project performance.” J. Comput. Civil Eng. 33 (3): 04019015. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CP.1943-5487.0000832.
Georgiadou, M. C. 2019. “An overview of benefits and challenges of building information modelling (BIM) adoption in UK residential projects.” Constr. Innovation 19 (3): 298–320. https://doi.org/10.1108/CI-04-2017-0030.
González, J., C. Soares, M. Najjar, and A. Haddad. 2021. “BIM and BEM methodologies integration in energy-efficient buildings using experimental design.” Buildings 11 (10): 491. https://doi.org/10.3390/buildings11100491.
Haider, U., U. Khan, A. Nazir, and M. Humayon. 2020. “Cost comparison of a building project by manual and BIM.” Civ. Eng. J. 6 (1): 34–49. https://doi.org/10.28991/cej-2020-03091451.
Hartmann, T. 2010. “Detecting design conflicts using building information models: A comparative lab experiment.” In Vol. 78 of Proc., 27th Int. Conf.—Applications of IT in the AEC Industry & Accelerating BIM Research Workshop, edited by W. Thabet, J. Lucas, and A. Walid. Cairo, Egypt: Virginia Tech.
Hoey, D. 2009. “How do we measure up? Benchmarking the world skills competition.” In International handbook of education for the changing world of work: Bridging academic and vocational learning, edited by R. Maclean and D. Wilson, 2827–2839. Dordrecht, Netherlands: Springer.
Hozo, S. P., B. Djulbegovic, and I. Hozo. 2005. “Estimating the mean and variance from the median, range, and the size of a sample.” BMC Med. Res. Method. 5 (1): 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2288-5-1.
Johnson, R. M., and R. I. I. Babu. 2020. “Time and cost overruns in the UAE construction industry: A critical analysis.” Int. J. Construct. Manage. 20 (5): 402–411. https://doi.org/10.1080/15623599.2018.1484864.
Kelly, D., and B. Ilozor. 2019. “A quantitative study of the relationship between project performance and BIM use on commercial construction projects in the USA.” Int. J. Construct. Educ. Res. 15 (1): 3–18. https://doi.org/10.1080/15578771.2016.1202355.
Kensek, K., and D. Noble. 2014. Building information modeling: BIM in current and future practice. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
Kumar, B., H. Cai, and M. Hastak. 2017. “An assessment of benefits of using BIM on an infrastructure project.” In Proc., Int. Conf. on Sustainable Infrastructure 2017: Technology, edited by L. Soibelman and F. Peña-Mora, 88–95. Reston, VA: ASCE.
Levy, H. M. 2014. Capability-based computer systems. Bedford, MA: Digital Press.
Liao, L., E. A. L. Teo, L. Li, X. Zhao, and G. Wu. 2021. “Reducing non-value-adding BIM implementation activities for building projects in Singapore: Leading causes.” J. Manage. Eng. 37 (3): 05021003. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)ME.1943-5479.0000900.
Lindgren, E., and J. Münch. 2016. “Raising the odds of success: The current state of experimentation in product development.” Inf. Software Technol. 77: 80–91. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.infsof.2016.04.008.
Mahdaviparsa, A., and T. McCuen. 2019. “Comparison between current methods of indoor network analysis for emergency response through BIM/CAD-GIS integration.” In Proc., 35th CIB W78 2018 Conf.: IT in Design, Construction, and Management: Advances in Informatics and Computing in Civil and Construction Engineering, edited by I. Mutis and T. Hartmann, 627–635. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.
Munianday, P., A. R. Radzi, M. Esa, and R. A. Rahman. 2022. “Optimal strategies for improving organizational BIM capabilities: PLS-SEM approach.” J. Manage. Eng. 38 (3): 04022015. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)ME.1943-5479.0001038.
Nawari, N. O. 2020. “Generalized adaptive framework for computerizing the building design review process.” J. Archit. Eng. 26 (1): 04019026. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)AE.1943-5568.0000382.
O’Connor, J. T., and H. J. Koo. 2020. “Analyzing the quality problems and defects of design deliverables on building projects.” J. Archit. Eng. 26 (4): 04020034. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)AE.1943-5568.0000432.
Punch, K. F. 2013. Introduction to social research: Quantitative and qualitative approaches. London, UK: Sage.
Race, S. 2019. BIM demystified. London, UK: Routledge.
Roberti, F., and D. Ferreira. 2021. Increasing Autodesk Revit productivity for BIM projects: A practical guide to using Revit workflows to improve productivity and efficiency in BIM projects. Birmingham, UK: Packt.
Sacks, R., I. Kaner, C. M. Eastman, and Y.-S. Jeong. 2010. “The rosewood experiment—Building information modeling and interoperability for architectural precast facades.” Autom. Constr. 19 (4): 419–432. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2009.11.012.
Shin, J.-C., Y.-I. Baek, and W.-T. Park. 2011. “Analysis of errors in tunnel quantity estimation with 3D-BIM compared with routine method based 2D.” J. Korean Geotech. Soc. 27 (8): 63–71. https://doi.org/10.7843/kgs.2011.27.8.063.
Suermann, P. C., and R. R. Issa. 2009. “Evaluating industry perceptions of building information modelling (BIM) impact on construction.” J. Inf. Technol. Construct. 14 (37): 574–594.
Sun, C., H. Xu, and S. Jiang. 2020. “Understanding the risk factors of BIM technology implementation in the construction industry: An interpretive structural modeling (ISM) approach.” Eng. Constr. Archit. Manage. 27 (10): 3289–3308. https://doi.org/10.1108/ECAM-09-2019-0508.
Tabachnick, B. G., and L. S. Fidell. 2007. Experimental designs using ANOVA. Vol. 724. Belmont, CA: Thomson/Brooks/Cole.
Tang, X., H.-Y. Chong, and W. Zhang. 2019. “Relationship between BIM implementation and performance of OSM projects.” J. Manage. Eng. 35 (5): 04019019. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)ME.1943-5479.0000704.
Thabane, L., J. Ma, R. Chu, J. Cheng, A. Ismaila, L. P. Rios, R. Robson, M. Thabane, L. Giangregorio, and C. H. Goldsmith. 2010. “A tutorial on pilot studies: The what, why and how.” BMC Med. Res. Method. 10 (1): 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2288-10-1.
Utkucu, D., and H. Sözer. 2023. “Building performance optimization throughout the design–decision process with a holistic approach.” J. Archit. Eng. 29 (1): 04022034. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)AE.1943-5568.0000573.
Wahab, A., and J. Wang. 2022. “Factors-driven comparison between BIM-based and traditional 2D quantity takeoff in construction cost estimation.” Eng. Constr. Archit. Manage. 29 (2): 702–715. https://doi.org/10.1108/ECAM-10-2020-0823.
Wan, X., W. Wang, J. Liu, and T. Tong. 2014. “Estimating the sample mean and standard deviation from the sample size, median, range and/or interquartile range.” BMC Med. Res. Method. 14: 135. https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2288-14-1.
Yoon, J. D., H. S. Cho, J. H. Lee, J. Y. Shin, and E. S. Kim. 2020. “A comparison of quantity take-offs of RC structures based on BIM.” J. Comput. Struct. Eng. Inst. Korea 33 (1): 35–44. https://doi.org/10.7734/COSEIK.2020.33.1.35.
Zaker, R., and E. Coloma. 2018. “Virtual reality-integrated workflow in BIM-enabled projects collaboration and design review: A case study.” Visualization Eng. 6 (1): 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40327-018-0065-6.
Zhao, P. A., and C. C. Wang. 2014. “A comparison of using traditional cost estimating software and BIM for construction cost control.” In Proc., Int. Conf. on Construction and Real Estate Management: Smart Construction and Management in the Context of New Technology, edited by Y. Wang, H. Ye, G. Q. P. Shen, and Y. Bai, 256–264. Reston, VA: ASCE.
Zheng, X., Y. Lu, Y. Li, Y. Le, and J. Xiao. 2019. “Quantifying and visualizing value exchanges in building information modeling (BIM) projects.” Autom. Constr. 99: 91–108. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2018.12.001.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Architectural Engineering
Volume 30 • Issue 4 • December 2024
Copyright
© 2024 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Dec 22, 2023
Accepted: Jun 4, 2024
Published online: Aug 19, 2024
Published in print: Dec 1, 2024
Discussion open until: Jan 19, 2025
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.