Overland Flow Modeling with the Shallow Water Equations Using a Well-Balanced Numerical Scheme: Better Predictions or Just More Complexity
Publication: Journal of Hydrologic Engineering
Volume 20, Issue 10
Abstract
In the last decades, several physically based hydrological modeling approaches of various complexities have been developed that solve shallow water equations or their approximations using various numerical methods. Users of the model may not necessarily know the different hypotheses underlying these development and simplifications, and it might therefore be difficult to judge if a code is well adapted to their objectives and test case configurations. This paper aims to compare the predictive abilities of different models and evaluate potential gain by using an advanced numerical scheme for modeling runoff. Four different codes are presented, each based on either shallow water or kinematic wave equations, and using either the finite volume or finite difference method. These four numerical codes are compared with different test cases, allowing to emphasize their main strengths and weaknesses. Results show that, for relatively simple configurations, kinematic wave equations solved with the finite volume method represent an interesting option. Nevertheless, as it appears to be limited in case of discontinuous topography or strong spatial heterogeneities, for these cases they advise the use of shallow water equations solved with the finite volume method.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
Audusse, E. (2004). “Hyperbolic modeling and numerical analysis for shallow water flows.” Ph.D. thesis, Université Pierre et Marie Curie, Paris.
Audusse, E., Bouchut, F., Bristeau, M., Klein, R., and Perthame, B. (2004). “A fast and stable well-balanced scheme with hydrostatic reconstruction for shallow water flows.” SIAM J. Sci. Comput., 25(6), 2050–2065.
Audusse, E., and Bristeau, M. (2005). “A well-balanced positivity preserving ‘second-order’ scheme for shallow water flows on unstructured meshe.” J. Comput. Phys., 206(1), 311–333.
Barré de Saint Venant, A. (1871). “Theory of the nonpermanent movement of waters, with application to the floods of rivers and to the introduction of the tides within their beds.” Compte Rendu de l’Académie des Sciences, Paris, France, 73, 147–154.
Bermudez, A., and Vazquez, M. (1994). “Upwind methods for hyperbolic conservation laws with source terms.” Comput. Fluids, 23(8), 1049–1071).
Boardman, J., and Poesen, J. (2006). Soil erosion in Europe: Major processes, causes and consequences, Wiley, Hoboken, NJ, 477–487.
Boardman, J., Verstraeten, G., and Bielders, C. (2006). Muddy floods, Wiley, Hoboken, NJ, 743–755.
Bouchut, F. (2004). Nonlinear stability of finite volume methods for hyperbolic conservation laws and well-balanced schemes for sources, Birkhäuser Basel.
Brakensiek, D., and Rawls, W. (1983). “Agricultural management effects on soil water processes. Part 2: green ampt parameters for crusting soils.” Trans. Am. Soc. Agric. Biol. Eng., 26(6), 1753–1757.
Bristeau, M., and Coussin, B. (2001). “Boundary conditions for the shallow water equations solved by kinetic schemes.” Research Rep. RR-4282, INRIA. Project M3N, Rocquencourt, France.
Casenave, A., and Valentin, C. (1989). Les états de surface de la zone sahélienne: Influence sur l’infiltration, Didactiques. ORSTOM, 〈http://www.documentation.ird.fr/hor/fdi:27816〉.
Chahinian, N., Moussa, R., Andrieux, P., and Voltz, M. (2005). “Comparison of infiltration models to simulate flood events at the field scale.” J. Hydrol., 306(1–4), 191–214.
Chow, V. (1959). Open channel hydraulics, McGraw-Hill College, New York.
Chow, V., Maidment, D., and Mays, L. (1988). Applied hydrology, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York.
Danaila, I., Postel, M., Joly, P., and Kaber, S. (2007). “An introduction to scientific computing.” Twelve computational projects solved with MATLAB, Springer, New York.
Delestre, O. (2010). “Simulation of rainwater runoff on agricultural surfaces.” Ph.D. thesis, Université d’Orléans, France.
Delestre, O., Cordier, S., James, F., and Darboux, F. (2009). “Simulation of rain-water overland-flow.” Proc., 12th Int. Conf. on Hyperbolic Problems, E. Tadmor, J.-G. Liu, and A. Tzavaras, eds., Univ. of Maryland, College Park, MD, 537–546.
Delestre, O., and James, F. (2009). “Simulation of rainfall events and overland flow.” Proc., X Int. Conf. Zaragoza-Pau on Applied Mathematics and Statistics, Monografías Matemáticas García de Galdeano, Jaca, Spain.
Delestre, O., and Marche, F. (2011). “A numerical scheme for a viscous shallow water model with friction.” J. Sci. Comput., 48(1–3), 41–51.
De Roo, A. (1996). “The LISEM project: An introduction.” Hydrol. Processes, 10(8), 1021–1025.
El Bouajaji, M. (2007). “Overland flow modeling: Study of rainwater runoff.” M.S. thesis, Université Louis Pasteur, Strasbourg, France.
Esteves, M., Faucher, X., Galle, S., and Vauclin, M. (2000). “Overland flow and infiltration modelling for small plots during unsteady rain: Numerical results versus observed values.” J. Hydrol., 228(3–4), 265–282.
Evrard, O., Bielders, C., Vandaele, K., and van Wesemael, B. (2007). “Spatial and temporal variation of muddy floods in central Belgium, off-site impacts and potential control measures.” CATENA, 70(3), 443–454.
Favis-Mortlock, D., Boardman, J., Parsons, A., and Lascelles, B. (2000). “Emergence and erosion: A model for rill initiation and development.” Hydrol. Processes, 14(11–12), 2173–2205.
Fiedler, F., and Ramirez, J. (2000). “A numerical method for simulating discontinuous shallow flow over an infiltrating surface.” Int. J. Numer. Methods Fluids, 32(2), 219–239.
Foster, G., and Meyer, L. (1975). “Mathematical simulation of upland erosion by fundamental erosion mechanics.” Present and Prospective Technology for Predicting Sediment Yields and Sources Agricultural Research Service Rep. ARS-S-40, USDA Agricultural Research Service, Washington, DC, 190–207.
Gallouët, T., Hérard, J., and Seguin, N. (2002). “Some recent finite volume schemes to compute Euler equations using real gas EOS.” Int. J. Numer. Methods Fluids, 39(12), 1073–1138.
Gerbeau, J., and Perthame, B. (2001). “Derivation of viscous Saint-Venant system for laminar shallow water: Numerical validation.” Discrete Continuous Dyn. Syst. Ser. B, 1, 89–102.
Goutal, N., and Maurel, F. (1997). Proc., 2nd Workshop on Dam-Break Wave Simulation, Groupe Hydraulique Fluviale, Département Laboratoire National d’Hydraulique, Electricité de France, Chatou, France.
Green, W., and Ampt, G. (1911). “Studies on soil physics: 1. Flow of air and water through soils.” J. Agric. Sci., 4(1), 1–24.
Greenberg, J., and Leroux, A. (1996). “A well-balanced scheme for the numerical processing of source terms in hyperbolic equations.” SIAM J. Numer. Anal., 33(1), 1–16.
Harten, A. (1997). “High resolution schemes for hyperbolic conservation laws.” J. Comput. Phys., 135(2), 260–278.
Harten, A., Lax, P., and van Leer, B. (1983). “On upstream differencing and Godunov-type schemes for hyperbolic conservation laws.” SIAM Rev., 25(1), 35–61.
Hervouet, J. (2007). Hydrodynamics of free surface flows, modelling with the finite element method, Wiley, Hoboken, NJ.
Jin, S. (2001). “A steady-state capturing method for hyperbolic systems with geometrical source terms.” Math. Modell. Numer. Anal., 35(4), 631–645.
Jinkang, D., Shunping, X., Youpeng, X., Xu, C., and Singh, V. (2007). “Development and testing of a simple physically-based distributed rainfall-runoff model for storm runoff simulation in humid forested basins.” J. Hydrol., 336(3–4), 334–346.
Le, M. (2012). “Multiscale modelling and numerical simulation of soil erosion by water from the plot scale to the catchment scale.” Ph.D. thesis, Université d’Orléans, France.
Leveque, R. J. (1998). “Balancing source terms and flux gradients in high-resolution Godunov methods: The quasi-steady wave-propagation algorithm.” J. Comput. Phys., 146(1), 346–365.
Liu, Q., Chen, L., Li, J., and Singh, V. (2004). “Two-dimensional kinematic wave model of overland-flow.” J. Hydrol., 291(1–2), 28–41.
MacCormack, R. (1969). “The effect of viscosity in hypervelocity impact cratering.” AIAA Paper, 69–354.
MacDonald, I., Baines, M., Nichols, N., and Samuels, P. (1995). “Steady open channel test problems with analytic solutions.”, Dept. of Mathematics, Univ. of Reading, Berkshire, U.K.
MacDonald, I., Baines, M., Nichols, N., and Samuels, P. (1997). “Analytic benchmark solutions for open-channel flows.” J. Hydraul. Eng., 1041–1045.
Malam Issa, O., Valentin, C., Rajot, J., Cerdan, O., Desprats, J., and Bouchet, T. (2011). “Runoff generation fostered by physical and biological crusts in semi-arid sandy soils.” Geoderma, 167–168, 22–29.
Marche, F. (2005). “Theoretical and numerical study of shallow water models. Applications to nearshore hydrodynamics.” Ph.D. thesis, Université de Bordeaux, France.
Marche, F. (2007). “Derivation of a new two-dimensional viscous shallow water model with varying topography, bottom friction and capillary effects.” Eur. J. Mech. B/Fluids, 26(1), 49–63.
Mein, R., and Larson, C. (1973). “Modeling infiltration during a steady rain.” Water Resour. Res., 9(2), 384–394.
Morgan, R., et al. (1998). “The European soil erosion model (EUROSEM): A dynamic approach for predicting sediment transport from fields and small catchments.” Earth Surf. Processes Landforms, 23(6), 527–544.
Moussa, R., and Bocquillon, C. (2000). “Approximation zones of the Saint-Venant equations for flood routing with overbank flow.” Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 4(2), 251–261.
Najafi, R. (2003). “Watershed modeling of rainfall excess transformation into runoff.” J. Hydrol., 270(3–4), 73–281.
Nearing, M., Foster, G., Lane, L., and Finkner, S. (1989). “A process-based soil erosion model for USDA water erosion prediction project technology.” Trans. ASAE, 32(5), 1587–1593.
Nguyen, D., Shi, Y., Wang, S., and Nguyen, T. (2006). “2D shallow-water model using unstructured finite-volumes methods.” J. Hydraul. Eng., 258–269.
Nord, G., and Esteves, M. (2005). “PSEM_2D: A physically based model of erosion processes at the plot scale.” Water Resour. Res., 41(8), 1–14.
Perthame, B., and Simeoni, C. (2001). “A kinetic scheme for the Saint-Venant system with a source term.” Calcolo, 38(4), 201–231.
Philip, J. (1957). “The theory of infiltration: 4. Sorptivity and algebraic infiltration equations.” Soil Sci., 84(3), 257–264.
Richards, L. (1931). “Capillarity conduction of liquids through porous mediums.” Physics, 1(5), 318–333.
Rousseau, M. (2008). “Overland flow modeling: Study of rainwater runoff.” M.S. thesis, Université de Nantes, France.
Rousseau, M. (2012). “Uncertainty propagation and sensitivity analysis for infiltration and erosion modeling.” Ph.D. thesis, Université Paris-Est, France.
Rousseau, M., Cerdan, O., Ern, A., Le Maître, O., and Sochala, P. (2012). “Study of overland flow with uncertain infiltration using stochastic tools.” Adv. Water Resour., 38, 1–12.
Singh, V. (2001). “Kinematic wave modelling in water resources: A historical perspective.” Hydrol. Processes, 15(4), 671–706.
Singh, V. (2002). “Is hydrology kinematic?” Hydrol. Processes, 16(3), 667–716.
Sochala, P., Ern, A., and Piperno, S. (2009). “Mass conservative BDF-discontinuous Galerkin/explicit finite volume schemes for coupling subsurface and overland flows.” Comput. Meth. Appl. Mech. Eng., 198(27–29), 2122–2136.
Souchère, V., Cerdan, O., Dubreuil, N., Le Bissonnais, Y., and King, C. (2005). “Modelling the impact of agri-environmental scenarios on overland flow in a cultivated catchment (Normandy, France).” Catena, 61(2–3), 229–240.
Tatard, L., et al. (2008). “Measurement and modelling of high-resolution flow-velocity data under simulated rainfall on a low-slope sandy soil.” J. Hydrol., 348(1–2), 1–12.
Viollet, P., Chabard, J., Esposito, P., and Laurence, D. (2002). Applied fluid mechanics. Incompressible flows in pipes, channels and rivers, around structures and in the environment, Presses de l’Ecole Nationale des Ponts et Chaussées, Paris, France.
Wainwright, J., Parsons, A., Müller, E., Brazier, R., Powell, D., and Fenti, B. (2008). “A transport-distance approach to scaling erosion rates: 3. Evaluating scaling characteristics of MAHLERAN.” Earth Surf. Processes Landforms, 33(7), 1113–1128.
Weill, S., Mouche, E., and Patin, J. (2009). “A generalized Richards equation for surface/subsurface flow modelling.” J. Hydrol., 366(1–4), 9–20.
Woolhiser, D., Smith, R., and Goodrich, D. (1990). Kineros, a kinematic runoff and erosion model: Documentation and user manual, United States Dept. of Agriculture–Agricultural Research Service.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Hydrologic Engineering
Volume 20 • Issue 10 • October 2015
Copyright
© 2015 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: May 23, 2014
Accepted: Dec 8, 2014
Published online: Jan 29, 2015
Discussion open until: Jun 29, 2015
Published in print: Oct 1, 2015
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.