Observed and Modeled Performances of Prototype Green Roof Test Plots Subjected to Simulated Low- and High-Intensity Precipitations in a Laboratory Experiment
Publication: Journal of Hydrologic Engineering
Volume 15, Issue 6
Abstract
With continued urbanization pressure, regulators and developers alike are increasingly looking to new forms of green infrastructure and low-impact development technologies as a means of appropriately integrating built infrastructure into the landscape. This paper describes the results of a series of experiments designed to simulate the hydrologic performance of green roofs under variable precipitation conditions. The experiments were designed in order to test performance under both steady, low-intensity rainfall, as well as under short duration, high-intensity rainfall conditions. A control membrane roof and prototype green roofs of 2.5-, 6.3-, 10.1-cm depths were subjected to simulated precipitation in a laboratory setting. The green roofs delayed, prolonged, and reduced the peak rates of green roof discharge to 22–70% that of a standard roof surface, with greater percent reductions associated with deeper roofs. Negligible discharge was observed from all of the prototypes during the first 10 min of simulated precipitation. Although the fate of the 0.35 cm of precipitation that were applied over this time period can only be determined through additional controlled testing of the prototypes with shorter duration rain events, the potential significance of green roofs that retain this quantity of water is discussed in the context of the historical New York City precipitation record. The results also indicated that nearly all of the precipitation applied was discharged as drainage over the 24 h period immediately following the experiment, suggesting that the percentage of large storms that are retained in green roofs may be insignificant. Green roof runoff coefficients computed from an analysis of the discharge hydrographs ranged from 0.2–0.7, consistent with other studies. Two approaches to predicting the observed discharge using the U.S. EPA’s Stormwater Management Model (SWMM) are also presented. The “storage node” approach achieves better overall predictions than the “curve number” approach, which itself tends to significantly underpredict discharge from these systems. Although reasonable sets of predictions were eventually obtained, the selection of appropriate model parameters would not have been possible without the availability of experimental data with which to calibrate the models. The experimental results support the argument that the storm water benefits of green roofs could be significant. However, the writers urge caution in interpreting the results of green roof drainage discharge calculations made using SWMM until additional calibration and validation attempts have been performed.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Acknowledgments
The writers acknowledge Kate Hofer, Monica Aberion, and Mable Wong for their work in collecting data for the experimental section of this research. We also would like to extend special thanks to Tammo Steenhuis for providing access to Cornell University’s Soil and Water Laboratory to perform the rainfall simulations, and to Theodore Mansfield from Arizona State University for assisting in developing the initial SWMM model setups, during his tenure at Drexel as an NSF-REU student. Finally, the writers acknowledge Lew Rossman for providing initial ideas on the storage node SWMM setup.
References
Banting, D., Doshi, H., Li, J., and Missios, P. (2005). Rep. on the Benefits and Costs of Green Roof Technology for the City of Toronto, Ryerson University, ⟨http://www.toronto.ca/greenroofs/findings.htm⟩ (Apr. 1, 2010).
Bengtsson, L. (2005). “Peak flows from thin sedum-moss roof.” Nord. Hydrol., 36(3), 269–280.
Casey Trees Endowment Fund and Limo Tech Inc. (2002). Re-greening Washington, DC: A green roof vision based on quantifying storm water and air quality benefits ⟨http://www.greenroofs.org/resources/greenroofvisionfordc.pdf⟩ (Apr. 1, 2010).
Casey Trees Endowment Fund and Limo Tech. (2007). The green build-out model: Quantifying the stormwater management benefits of trees and green roofs in Washington, D.C. ⟨http://www.capitolgreenroofs.com/pdfs/Green_Infrastructure_Report.pdf⟩ (Apr. 1, 2010).
Carter, T. L., and Rasmussen, T. C. (2006). “Hydrologic behavior of vegetated roofs.” J. Am. Water Resour. Assoc., 42(5), 1261–1274.
Connecticut Department of Transportation (ConnDOT). (2000). “2000 ConDOT drainage manual and revisions.” ⟨http://www.ct.gov/dot/cwp/view.asp?a=2303&q=300868⟩ (Apr. 1, 2010).
DeCuyper, K., Dinne, K., and Van de Vel, L. (2005). “Rainwater discharge from green roofs.” Plumbing Systems and Design, Nov./Dec., 10–15.
DeNardo, J. C., et al. (2005). “Stormwater mitigation and surface temperature reduction by green roofs.” Trans. ASAE, 48(4), 1491–1496.
eDesign Dynamics LLC. (2008). “Memorandum on technical source controls and bibliography.” Appendix F of New York City’s sustainable stormwater management plan, ⟨http://www.nyc.gov/html/planyc2030/html/stormwater/stormwater.shtml⟩ (Apr. 1, 2010).
Federation of Canadian Municipalities. (2002). “Green municipalities: A guide for green infrastructure for Canadian municipalities.” ⟨http://www.sustainablecommunities.fcm.ca/partners-for-climate-protection/resources-tools.asp⟩ (Apr. 1, 2010).
Getter, K. L., Rowe, D. B., and Andresen, J. A. (2007). “Quantifying the effect of slope on extensive green roof stormwater retention.” Ecol. Eng., 31(4), 225–231.
Hilten, R. N., Lawrence, T. M., and Tollner, E. W., (2008). “Modeling stormwater runoff from green roofs with HYDRUS-1D.” J. Hydrol., 358(3–4), 288–293.
Linsley, R. K. ed. (1992). Water resources engineer, McGraw-Hill, New York.
Mentens, J., et al. (2006). “Green roofs as a tool for solving the rainwater runoff problem in the urbanized 21st century?” Landsc. Urban Plann., 77(3), 217–226.
Miller, C., and Pyke, G. (1999). “Methodology for the design of vegetated roof covers.” Proc., Int. Water Resource Engineering Conf., ASCE, Seattle.
Montalto, F., Behr, C., Alfredo, K., Wold, M., Arye, M., and Walsh, M. (2007). “Rapid assessment of the cost-effectiveness of low impact development for CSO control.” Landsc. Urban Plann., 82, 117–131.
New York City. (2008). “Draft sustainable stormwater management plan.” Mayor’s Office of long term planning and sustainability. ⟨http://www.nyc.gov/html/planyc2030/html/stormwater/stormwater.shtml⟩ (Apr. 1, 2010).
New York City Department of Environmental Protection (NYC DEP). (2000). “The design criteria and procedures for the preparation of drainage plan: Revised version.” ⟨http://www.nyc.gov/html/dep/html/home/home.shtml⟩ (Apr. 1, 2010).
New York City Department of Environmental Protection (NYC DEP). (2008). “Criteria for determination of detention facility volume.” NYCDEP. ⟨http://nyc.gov/html/dep/pdf/water_sewer/30.pdf⟩ (Apr. 1, 2010).
She, N., and Pang, J. (2008). “A deterministic lumped dynamic green roof model.” Proc., 2008 Int. LID Conf. (CD-ROM), ASCE, Seattle, 16–19.
U.S. EPA. (2008). Storm Water Management Model User’s Manual Version 5.0. ⟨http://www.epa.gov/ednnrmrl/models/swmm/epaswmm5_manual.pdf⟩ (Apr. 1, 2010).
VanWoert, N. D., (2005). “Green roof stormwater retention: Effects of roof surface, slope, and media depth.” J. Environ. Qual., 34(3), 1036–1044.
Villarreal, E. L. (2007). “Runoff detention effect of a sedum green-roof.” Nord. Hydrol., 38(1), 99–105.
Waldman, A., and Montalto, F. (2008). “Appendics.” Sustainable Stormwater Management Plan 2008, ⟨http://www.nyc.gov/html/planyc2030/html/sotrmwater/stormwater.shtml⟩ (Apr. 1, 2010).
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Copyright
© 2010 ASCE.
History
Received: Nov 29, 2008
Accepted: Jul 29, 2009
Published online: Jul 31, 2009
Published in print: Jun 2010
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.