Comparative Study on the Use of Output Specifications for Australian and U.K. PPP/PFI Projects
Publication: Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Volume 29, Issue 2
Abstract
An output specification is an integral part of the contract documentation for procuring and monitoring public private partnership (PPP) or private finance initiative (PFI) projects throughout their life cycles. Unlike prescriptive specifications used in the traditional project delivery, the output specifications stipulate what is required from the project rather than how they should be delivered by the private sector. Performance standards or output parameters are used for bid evaluation and operational monitoring. Failure to achieve them would lead to ongoing payment deduction and rectifications that need to be undertaken within a specified time frame. The long concession periods of PPP/PFI projects mean that changes are inevitable, and these, if foreseeable, should be managed using the output specification as a tool. This unconventional approach of specifying requires special skills and care. This paper presents the results of a questionnaire survey conducted in Australia and the U.K. with PPP/PFI practitioners. The findings highlight the common pitfalls and change management issues encountered by the two jurisdictions, which use PPP or PFI extensively in delivering public assets and services. While common pitfalls include conflicts between input and output specifications, and performance standards being compromised with affordability, small changes are often made by the public sector authorities. Changes are dealt with by anticipatory provisions in output specifications, or negotiations as and when they arise. Procedural hiccups may slow down the process of introducing necessary changes, or give rise to disputes.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Acknowledgments
The work described in this paper was fully supported by a grant from the General Research Fund of the Hong Kong SAR Government (Project No. PolyU5214/09E). The authors thank all the respondents to the surveys carried out in Australia and the U.K., without whose support this research would not have been possible.
References
4Ps. (2006). “PFI/PPP operational project review 2006 school sector.” 〈http://goo.gl/kahkz〉, (Jul. 21, 2012).
4Ps. (2007). 4ps sports and leisure procurement pack, Public Private Partnerships Programme, London.
Alfen, H. W., and Bauhaus-Universitat Weimar. (2009). Public-private partnership in infrastructure development: Case studies from Asia and Europe, Bauhaus-Universität Weimar, Weimar, Germany.
Allen Consulting Group, Duffield, C. F., and Raisbeck, P. (2007). Performance of PPPs and traditional procurement in Australia, Final Report to Infrastructure Partnerships Australia, Melbourne, Australia.
Astron. (2004). Output specification building our future: Scotland’s school estate, Scottish Executive St Andrew’s House, Edinburg, TX.
Ball, A. (2007). “KIM project conference: Knowledge and information management through life.” KIM Project Conf., Ariadne 51, 〈http://goo.gl/b23fc〉 (Jun. 23, 2013).
Ball, R. (2011). “Provision of public service infrastructure—The use of PPPs in the UK and Australia: A comparative study.” Int. J. Publ. Sector Manage., 24(1), 5–22.
Canadian Council for Public-Private Partnerships. (2011). Public-private partnerships—A guide for municipalities, Canadian Council for Public-Private Partnerships, Toronto, Canada.
Carol, M. (2003). “PFI schools report shows up cause of user dissatisfaction.” Contract J., 416(6409), 3.
Chan, D. W. M., and Kumaraswamy, M. M. (1996). “An evaluation of construction time performance in the building industry.” Build. Environ., 31(6), 569–578.
Chase, B. (2009). Public-private partnerships in the United States: Evolving market and new opportunities, Collaboratory for Research on Global Projects, Stanford Univ., Stanford, CA.
Cheung, E., and Chan, A. P. C. (2011). “Risk factors of public-private partnership projects in China: Comparison between the water, power, and transportation sectors.” J. Urban Plann. Dev., 409–415.
Cheung, E., Chan, A. P. C., and Kajewski, S. (2009). “Enhancing value for money in public private partnership projects: Findings from a survey conducted in Hong Kong and Australia compared to findings from previous research in the UK.” J. Financial Manage. Property Constr., 14(1), 7–20.
Cheung, E., Chan, A. P. C., and Kajewski, S. (2012). “Factors contributing to successful public private partnership projects: Comparing Hong Kong with Australia and the United Kingdom.” J. Facil. Manage., 10(1), 45–58.
Chew, A., Storr, D., and Casey, B. (2007). “Current issues in hospital PPPs in Australia.” Int. Constr. Law Rev., 24(3), 290–317.
Chinyio, E., and Gameson, R. (2010). “Private finance initiative in use.” Policy, finance and management for public-private partnerships, 1st Ed., A. Akintoye and M. Beck, eds., Wiley, Oxford, U.K., 3–23.
Cove, T. (2007). “Keeping public private partnerships responsive to change.” Publ. Infrastruct. Bull., 1(6), 7.
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs. (2008). Waste infrastructure delivery programme residual waste procurement pack module 5 part I output specification principles, Dept. for Environment Food and Rural Affairs, London.
Doloi, H., and Jin, X. (2007). “Risk management in public-private partnership (PPP) projects from the project management perspective.” Proc., Construction Management and Economics 25th Anniversary Conf.—Past, Present and Future, W. P. Hughes, ed. Univ. of Reading, Reading, U.K.
Duffield, C. (2005). “PPPs in Australia.” One Day Conf. on Public Private Partnerships—Opportunities and Challenges, Hong Kong Convention & Exhibition Centre, Hong Kong Institution of Engineers, Hong Kong.
Duffield, C. F., and Clifton, C. J. (2009). “Combining finance and design innovation to develop winning proposals.” Policy, finance & management for public-private partnerships, A. Akintoye and M. Beck, eds., Wiley, Oxford, U.K., 327–345.
Eaton, D., and Akbiyikli, R. (2005). Quantifying quality: A report on PFI and the delivery of public services, The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, Coventry, U.K.
Edward, P., Shaoul, J., Stafford, A., and Arblaster, L. (2004). “Evaluating the operation of PFI in roads and hospitals.”, Certified Accountants Educational Trust, London.
English, L. (2005). “Using public-private partnerships to deliver social infrastructure: The Australian experience.” The challenge of public-private partnerships: Learning from international experience, G. Hodge and C. Greve, eds., Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, U.K., 290–304.
Ernst & Young. (2008). The journey continues: PPPs in social infrastructure, Ernst & Young, Canberra, Australia. 〈http://goo.gl/wKrLTJ〉 (Aug. 09, 2012).
European Union. (1999). Council Directive 1999/31/EC of 26 April 1999 on the landfill of waste, 〈http://goo.gl/26HRxt〉 (Aug. 12, 2012).
Fitzgerald, P. F., and Machlin, B. N. (2001). Project financing: Building infrastructure projects in developing markets, Practicing Law Institute, New York.
George, D., and Mallery, P. (2003). SPSS for windows step by step: A simple guide and reference. 11.0 update, 4th Ed., Allyn & Bacon, Boston, MA.
Grimsey, D., and Lewis, M. K. (2004). Public private partnerships: The worldwide revolution in infrastructure provision and project finance, Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham, U.K.
Hardcastle, C., and Boothroyd, K. (2003). “Risk overview in public-private partnership.” Public-private partnerships managing risks and opportunities, A. Akintoye, M. Beck, and C. Hardcastle, eds., Blackwell Science, Oxford, U.K., 31–57.
Heavisides, B., and Price, I. (2001). “Input versus output-based performance measurement in the NHS—The current situation.” Facilities, 19(10), 344–356.
Hencke, D. (2005). Private-finance hospital ‘putting lives at risk’, The guardian, 〈http://goo.gl/g8YaTn〉 (May 24, 2012).
HM Treasury. (2007). Standardisation of PFI contracts (SoPC) version 4, HM Treasury, London.
HM Treasury. (2009). Change protocol principles, The Stationery Office, London.
HM Treasury. (2012a). PFI signed projects list, 〈http://goo.gl/5Du9A〉 (Oct. 9, 2012).
HM Treasury. (2012b). A new approach to public private partnerships, HM Treasury, London.
Infrastructure Australia. (2008a). National public private partnership guidelines: Overview, Canberra, ACT, Australia.
Infrastructure Australia. (2008b). National PPP guidelines—Supplemented with partnerships victoria requirements: Vol. 3: Commercial principles for social infrastructure, Canberra, ACT, Australia.
Javed, A. A. (2013). A model of output specifications for public-private partnership projects, (Unpublished Ph.D. thesis), Hong Kong Polytechnic Univ., Hong Kong SAR.
Javed, A. A., Lam, P. T. I., and Zou, P. X. W. (2013). “Output-based specifications for PPP projects: Lessons for facilities management from Australia.” J. Facil. Manage., 11(1), 5–30.
Jefferies, M., Gameson, R., and Rowlinson, S. (2002). “Critical success factors of the BOOT procurement system: Reflections from the Stadium Australia case study.” Eng., Constr. Archit. Manage., 9(4), 352–361.
Lam, P. T. I., Chan, A. P. C., and Chan, S. H. (2010). “A best practice framework of output specifications for PPP projects.” TG72—Special Track 18th CIB World Building Congress May 2010 Salford, United Kingdom CIB TG72—Public Private Partnership CIB Publication 356, U.K., 10–13 May 2010, 52.
Laryea, S. (2011). “Quality of tender documents: Case studies from the U.K.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 29(3), 275–286.
Likert, R. (1931). A technique for the measurement of attitudes. Archives of Psychology, Columbia University Press, New York.
Lind, D. A., Marchal, W. G., and Mason, R. D. (2002). Statistical techniques in business and economics, 11th Ed., McGraw-Hill, New York.
McKee, M., Edward, N., and Atun, R. (2006). “Public-private partnerships for hospitals.” Bull. World Health Organ., 84(11), 890–896.
Miller, J. D. (2010). Infrastructure 2010: Investment imperative, The Urban Land Institute and Ernst & Young, Washington, DC.
Ministry of Defence. (2010). MOD private finance unit guidance note output-based specifications for PFI/PPP projects version 0.2 consultation draft, Crown copyright, Bristol, England.
NAO. (2005). Darent Valley hospital: The PFI contract in action, National Audit Office, Report by the Comptroller Auditor General, HC 209 Session 2004–2005, The Stationery Office, London.
NAO. (2006). The termination of the PFI contract for the national physical laboratory, National Audit Office, Report by the Comptroller Auditor General, HC 209 Session 2004–2005, the Stationery Office, London.
NAO. (2007). Benchmarking and market testing the ongoing services component of PFI projects, Report by the Comptroller and Auditor General HC 453, Session 2006–2007, The Stationery Office, London.
NAO. (2008). Making changes in operational PFI projects, National Audit Office, Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General, HC 205, Session 2007–08, The Stationery Office, London.
NAO. (2009). Performance of PFI construction, A review by the Private Finance Practice, National Audit Office, London.
NAO. (2010). The performance and management of hospital PFI contracts, Report by the Comptroller and Auditor General HC 68 Session 2010–2011, The Stationery Office, London.
NSW Health. (2008). Facility specification for the Royal North Shore hospital and community health services PPP project, New South Wales Health, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
New South Wales Treasury (NSW). (2006). Working with government: Guidelines for privately financed projects, State of New South Wales through NSW Treasury, Sydney, Australia, 〈www.treasury.nsw.gov.au〉 (Jan. 2, 2014).
New South Wales Treasury (NSW). (2007). Working with government: Risk allocation and commercial principles, New South Wales Government, Sydney, Australia.
Nunnally, J. C. (1978). Psychometric theory, 2nd Ed., McGraw-Hill, New York.
Nunnally, J. C., and Bernstein, I. H. (1994). Psychometric theory, McGraw-Hill, Sydney, Australia.
Oyedele, L. O. (2013). “Avoiding performance failure payment deductions in PFI/PPP projects: A model of critical success factors.” J. Perform. Constr. Facil., 283–294.
Parliament UK. (2006). Debate questions [Homepage of U.K. House of Commons], 〈http://data.gov.uk/dataset/private-finance-initiative-pfi-data〉 (Jan. 2, 2011).
Partnerships Victoria. (2003). Contract management guide, State Government of Victoria, Melbourne, Australia, 〈http://www.dtf.vic.gov.au/Infrastructure-Delivery/Public-private partnerships〉 (Jan. 4, 2011).
PricewaterhouseCoopers. (2001). Output specifications, public private partnerships: A clearer view, PriceWaterhouseCoopers, London.
PricewaterhouseCoopers. (2005). Delivering the PPP promise—A review of PPP issues and activity, PricewaterhouseCoopers, London.
Project Finance International. (2005). PFI—Views across the divide, PFI Issue 325—16 November 2005, Project Finance International, 〈http://goo.gl/wXYR2n〉 (Jan. 10, 2013).
Public Works Financing. (2013). Public works financing newsletter, Public Works Financing, 279, 〈http://goo.gl/14aWC〉 (Jun. 26, 2013).
Raisbeck, P., Duffield, C. F., and Xu, M. (2010). “Comparative performance of PPPs and traditional procurement in Australia.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 28(4), 345–359.
Rameezdeen, R., and Rajapakse, C. (2007). “Contract interpretation: The impact of readability.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 25(7), 729–737.
Ramsey, V. (2007). Construction law handbook, Thomas Telford, ICE, London.
Regan, M., Smith, J., and Love, P. (2011). “Impact of the capital market collapse on public-private partnership infrastructure projects.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 6–16.
Regan, M., Smith, J., and Love, P. E. D. (2009). “Public private partnerships: What does the future hold?.” The Construction and Building Research Conf. (COBRA 2009) of the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) RICS COBRA Research Conf., Univ. of Cape Town, Sep. 10–11, 462–474.
RICS. (2011). The future of private finance initiative and public private partnership, The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, London.
Robinson, H., Carrillo, P., Anumba, C. J., and Patel, M. (2010). Governance & knowledge management for public-private partnerships, 1st Ed., Wiley, Chichester, U.K., Malden, MA.
Robinson, H. S., and Scott, J. (2009). “Service delivery and performance monitoring in PFI/PPP projects.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 27(2), 181–197.
Sanders, S., and Lipson, M. (2001). Output specifications for PFI projects: A 4P’s guide for schools, Public Private Partnerships Programme (4Ps), London.
Shaoul, J., Stafford, A., and Stapleton, P. (2008). “The cost of using private finance to build, finance and operate hospitals.” Publ. Money Manage., 28(2), 101–108.
Sheskin, D. J. (2011). Handbook of parametric and nonparametric statistical procedures, 5th Ed., Chapman and Hall/CRC, FL.
Siegel, S., and Castellan, N. J. (1988). Nonparametric statistics for the behavioral sciences, 2nd Ed., McGraw-Hill, New York.
Surveymonkey. (2011). 〈www.surveymonkey.com〉 (Jan. 2, 2011).
U.S. Department of Transportation. (2005). Synthesis of public-private partnership projects for roads, bridges and tunnels from around the world-1985–2004, Federal Highway Administration, AECOM Consultant, Los Angeles.
Victorian Auditor-General. (2007). Audits of 2 major partnerships Victoria projects, Victorian Auditor-General’s Office, Melbourne, Australia.
Victorian Auditor-General. (2008). The new royal women’s hospital—A public private partnership, Victorian Auditor-General, Melbourne, Australia.
Victorian Auditor-General. (2010). Audit summary of management of prison accommodation using public private partnerships, Victorian Auditor-General’s Office, Melbourne, Australia.
Wang, S. Q., Tiong, R. L. K., Ting, S. K., and Ashley, D. (2000). “Evaluation and management of political risks in China’s BOT projects.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 242–250.
Wooldridge, J. M. (2006). “Cluster sample methods in applied econometrics: An extended analysis.” Economics Dept. Working Paper Series, Michigan State Univ., East Lansing, MI, 1–57.
World Bank. (2011). A World Bank resource for PPPs in infrastructure, 〈http://goo.gl/tbR4〉 (Jun. 10, 2013).
Yescombe, E. R. (2007). Public-private partnerships: Principles of policy and finance, Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, U.K.
Yuan, J., Zeng, A. Y., Skibniewski, M. J., and Li, Q. (2009). “Selection of performance objectives and key performance indicators in public–private partnership projects to achieve value for money.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 27(3), 253–270.
Zhang, X. Q. (2006). “Factor analysis of public clients’ best value objective in public–privately partnered infrastructure projects.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 956–965.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Volume 29 • Issue 2 • April 2015
Copyright
© 2014 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Jul 2, 2013
Accepted: Dec 3, 2013
Published online: Dec 7, 2013
Discussion open until: Dec 24, 2014
Published in print: Apr 1, 2015
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.