Comparison between Current Industry Methods and an Energy Simulation Model for Quantifying Energy Service Projects
Publication: Journal of Architectural Engineering
Volume 22, Issue 2
Abstract
Different techniques and guidelines are available to select and quantify the savings from energy service projects. In this article, a comparison is presented between the engineering algorithms supported by energy service performance contract technical reference manuals and an as-built, calibrated whole-building energy simulation model. A lighting energy retrofit measure was selected to demonstrate the methodologies. The results show that the industry methods of quantifying the total savings for the lighting energy retrofit measure underreported the savings as compared with the as-built, calibrated whole-building energy simulation model. In particular, the breakdown of savings (e.g., electricity savings, adjustments to energy savings, and demand savings) was inconsistent between the various industry methods that are currently in use. The differences identified in this study were location specific and weather driven, and also included agreements with the local utility companies to quantify the demand savings. The study results also indicate that substituting a single measured occupancy parameter did not improve the current industry methods.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
Abushakra B., Sreshthaputra A., Haberl J., and Claridge D. (2001). “Compilation of diversity factors and schedules for energy and cooling load calculations.” ASHRAE research project 1093-RP, final report, American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, Atlanta.
Ahmad, M. (2003). “Systematic time-based study for quantifying the uncertainty of uncalibrated models in building energy simulations.” M.S. thesis, Texas A&M Univ., College Station, TX.
Ahmad, M., and Culp, C. (2006). “Uncalibrated building energy simulation modeling results.” HVAC&R Res., 12(4), 1141–1155.
ASHRAE (American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers). (2002). “Measurement of energy and demand savings.” ASHRAE guideline 14-2002, Atlanta, 170.
ASHRAE (American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers), IES (Illuminating Engineering Society), and ANSI (American National Standards Institute). (2013). “Energy standard for buildings except low-rise residential buildings.” ANSI/ASHRAE/IES standard 90.1-2013, ASHRAE, Atlanta.
Atmos Energy. (2013). “Gas rates & tariffs.” <http://www.atmosenergy.com/about/tariffs.html?st=mtx&pass=1>.
Augenbroe, G. (1992). “Integrated building performance evaluation in the early design stages.” Build. Environ., 27(2), 149–161.
Bronson, D. J., Hinchey, S. B., Haberl, J. S., and Neal, D. L. (1992). “Procedure for calibrating the DOE-2 simulation program to non-weather-dependent measured loads.” Proc., ASHRAE Winter Meeting, American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, Atlanta, 636–652.
CenterPoint Energy. (2013). 2013 commercial standard offer program manual. Section 2: Measurement and verification guidelines for retrofit projects, Houston.
Chen, C., Pan, Y., Huang, Z., and Wu, G. (2006). “Energy consumption analysis and energy conservation evaluation of a commercial building in Shanghai.” Proc., 6th Int. Conf. for Enhanced Building Operations, ICEBO/APCBC, College Station, TX.
Cho, S. (2010). “Methodology to develop and test an easy-to-use procedure for the preliminary selection of high-performance systems for office buildings in hot and humid climates.” Ph.D. thesis, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX.
Cho, S., and Haberl, J. (2008). “Development of a simulation toolkit for the selection of high-performance systems for office buildings in hot and humid climates.” Proc., 3rd SimBuild Conference, ASHRAE/IBPSA, Atlanta.
City of College Station. (2013). “Electric rates.” <http://www.cstx.gov/index.aspx?page=3852>.
Coakley, D., Raftery, P., and Keane, M. (2014). “A review of methods to match building energy simulation models to measured data.” Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev., 37, 123–141.
DOE. (2008). “M&V guidelines: Measurement and verification for federal energy projects (version 3.0), Washington, DC, 307.
DOE. (2009). International performance measurement and verification protocol, Washington, DC.
DOE-2.1E 136 [Computer software]. James J. Hirsh & Associates, Santa Rosa Valley, CA.
Diamond, R. C. (2001). An overview of the U.S. building stock, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, 17.
Entergy. (2011). “M&V guidelines for lighting efficiency measures.” Program manual v1.0 〈http://www.entergy-texas.com/content/Energy_Efficiency/documents/sim-lighting.pdf〉 (Aug. 13, 2014).
Granade, H. C., Creyts, J., Derkach, A., Farese, P., Nyquist, S., and Ostrowski, K. (2009). Unlocking energy efficiency in the U.S. economy executive summary, McKinsey and Company, New York.
Haberl, J. S., and Bou-Saada, T. E. (1998). “Procedures for calibrating hourly simulation models to measured building energy and environmental data.” J. Sol. Energy Eng., 120(3), 193–204.
Haberl, J. S., and Thamilseran, S. (1996). “Great energy predictor shootout II: Measuring retrofit savings—Overview and discussion of results.” ASHRAE Trans., 102(2), 419–435.
Huang, J., and Franconi, E. M. (1999). Commercial heating and cooling loads component analysis, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA.
Itron Inc., J. H. A. Synergy Consulting, and Quantum Inc. (2005). “2004–2005 Database for Energy Efficiency Resources (DEER) updated study final report,” Southern California Edison, Rosemead, CA.
Itron Inc., KEMA, and Hirsh, J. J. (2011). DEER database: 2011 update documentation, California Public Utility Commission, San Francisco.
James J. Hirsch & Associates. (2010). eQUEST introductory tutorial, version 3.64, Camarillo, CA.
Kaplan, M. (1992). Guidelines for energy simulation of commercial buildings, Bonneville Power Administration, Portland, OR.
Kaplan, M. B., McFerran, J., Jansen, J., and Pratt, R. (1990). “Reconciliation of a D0E2.IC model with monitored end-use data for a small office building.” ASHRAE Trans., 96(1), 981–992.
Kats, G., Menkin, A., Dommu, J., and DeBold, J. (2012). Energy efficiency financing—Models and strategies, Capital-E, Washington, DC.
Kim, H. (2012). “Methodology for rating a building's overall performance based on the ASHRAE/CIBSE/USGBC performance measurement protocols for commercial buildings.” Ph.D. thesis, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX.
Kim, A., Anderson, S., and Haberl, J. (2015). “Current industry methods for quantifying energy service projects: Key findings and lessons learned.” J. Archit. Eng.,.
Krarti, M. (2011). Energy audit of building systems: An engineering approach, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.
Lebrun, J., and Liebecq, G. (1998). Energy conservation in buildings and community systems. Annex 10: Building HVAC system simulation, International Energy Agency, Paris.
Ma, Z., Cooper, P., Daly, D., and Ledo, L. (2012). “Existing building retrofits: Methodology and state-of-the-art.” Energy Build., 55, 889–902.
Massachusetts Electric and Gas Energy Efficiency Program Administrators. (2011). Massachusetts technical reference manual for estimating savings from energy efficiency measures, Boston.
Norford, L. K., Socolow, R. H., Hsieh, E. S., and Spadaro, G. V. (1994). “Two-to-one discrepancy between measured and predicted performance of a 'low-energy' office building: Insights from a reconciliation based on the DOE-2 model.” Energy Build., 21(2), 121–131.
Office of Federal Environmental Executive. (2003). “The federal commitment to green building: Experiences and expectations,” <http://www.epa.gov/greenbuilding/pdf/2010_fed_gb_report.pdf> (Aug. 21, 2014).
Public Service Company of Colorado. (2011). 2012/2013 demand-side management plan, Xcel Energy, Minneapolis.
Reddy, T. (2005). “Literature review on calibration of building energy simulation programs: Uses, problems, procedures, uncertainty, and tools.” ASHRAE Trans., 112(1), 226–240.
Rhodes, J. D., Gorman, W. H., Upshaw, C. R., and Webber, M. E. (2015). “Using BEopt (EnergyPlus) with energy audits and surveys to predict actual residential energy usage.” Energy Build., 86, 808–816.
Soebarto, V. I., and Degelman, L. O. (1996). “A calibration methodology for retrofit projects using short-term monitoring and disaggregated energy use data.” Proc., 10th Symp. on Improving Building Systems in Hot and Humid Climates, Energy Systems Laboratory, College Station, TX, 38–47.
U.S. Energy Information Administration. (2010). “Annual energy outlook 2010 with projections to 2035,” 〈http://www.eia.gov/oiaf/aeo/pdf/0383(2010).pdf〉 (June 23, 2013).
Visier, J. C., and Jandon, M. (2004). Annex 40: Commissioning tools for improved energy performance, International Energy Agency, Paris.
Waide, P., Amann, J., and Hinge, A. (2007). “Energy efficiency in the North American existing building stock.” Energy efficiency series, International Energy Agency, Paris.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Architectural Engineering
Volume 22 • Issue 2 • June 2016
Copyright
© 2015 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Oct 9, 2014
Accepted: Aug 3, 2015
Published online: Dec 30, 2015
Discussion open until: May 30, 2016
Published in print: Jun 1, 2016
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.