Contribution of Nonlinear Finite-Element Analysis to Evaluation of Two Structural Concrete Failures

The failure of two reinforced concrete structures is recounted, one involving a warehouse structure and the other an offshore platform base structure. Design details and factors leading to the collapses are identified and discussed. The structures were subsequently analyzed using nonlinear finite-element analysis procedures, taking into account relevant second-order behavior models. The analyses provided an accurate assessment of the load capacities and failure modes observed, as well as meaningful insights into the underlying behavior mechanisms and factors leading to the failures. This paper supports the view that nonlinear analysis techniques have become useful everyday tools for design office applications, particularly in forensic work, and also gives evidence suggesting that errors in the design of modern structures can be potentially more catastrophic than in the past, and that advanced assessment techniques will assume increased importance as a result.