Repairs to Mid-Rise Steel Frame Damaged in Northridge Earthquake

The Borax corporate headquarters building, a low-rise steel moment frame, was less than one year old when it sustained significant structural damage during the 1994 Northridge earthquake. Seventy-five percent of its steel moment-resisting connections suffered severe brittle fractures. This paper presents a detailed documentation of the forensic investigation performed on this structure immediately following the earthquake. A companion paper presents the findings from a subsequent computational investigation performed on the structure. The two primary failure modes at the Borax building were column flange fracture and pull-out of the girder flange from the column. The failures are primarily attributed to a fundamental flaw in the standard code-prescribed welded-flange bolted-web connection and the extreme ground motion at the site. The paper also describes the repairs made to the structure. These repairs were completed before the SAC research that now guides repair and retrofit of these structures was available.