Multiyear Study on Phosphorus Discharge from Extensive Sedum Green Roofs with Substrate Amendments
Publication: Journal of Sustainable Water in the Built Environment
Volume 8, Issue 4
Abstract
Green roofs are implemented for providing urban ecosystem services like stormwater management, but they have also been identified as a potentially significant source of phosphorus in the runoff, which may cause concern for downstream water quality. A multiyear evaluation of phosphorus in green roof discharge and alternatives for phosphorus mitigation was conducted using 32 pilot-scale experimental green roofs. The extensive green roofs were made from nonproprietary base substrates [90 volumetric percentage (%v/v) lightweight aggregate (either pumice or expanded clay) and compost] and planted with a variety of sedum species. The roofs were initially constructed in 2017, and 38 storm events were sampled over four growing seasons for precipitation, runoff volumes, and total phosphorus (TP) event mean concentrations (EMCs) in discharge from the experimental extensive green roofs and a reference roof. All extensive green roofs tested were a source of elevated TP EMCs compared with the reference roof for the entire monitoring period. The green roofs initially exhibited high TP EMCs and variability, ranging from 0.46 to (first and third quartiles), compared with the reference roof (90% of TP EMCs were below ). Green roof TP EMCs decreased to 0.11 and (first and third quartiles) by the fourth growing season. A combination of measurement and modeling determined that a net reduction in annual cumulative TP mass discharged from the green roofs compared with the reference roof may be achieved because of the stormwater retention capacity of the green roofs. Amending materials, including zeolite, wood-derived biochar, and oat hull–derived biochar, were tested as a downstream permeable reactive barrier or as an additive in the base substrate (zeolite only). A zeolite addition of resulted in lower TP EMCs discharged than the base green roofs (without amendments). None of the other materials tested showed TP mitigating effects. There was no difference in TP EMCs among base green roofs after one growing season. The study highlights the initial excessive phosphorus content of the substrates exceeds the needs of sedum species and results in rapid phosphorus release in runoff discharged from green roofs.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Data Availability Statement
Some or all data, models, or code that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. The data include total phosphorus (TP) event mean concentration (EMCs) from all extensive green roofs, runoff volume from all extensive green roofs, and climate data during monitored period. Physicochemical characteristics of all substrates are included in the Supplemental Materials.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank Stevens Institute of Technology’s Pinnacle Scholars program, particularly including undergraduate researchers Sarah Chan, Samantha Conte, Devin Dragon, Daniel Rosenberger, Katerina Slesarevich, and Dylan Walsh and Stevens Facilities Management, especially Robert Maffia and Richard Snyder. Likewise, gratitude is extended to Washington DC Department of Energy and Environment (DOEE) for funding 2019 sampling and collaboration with University of the District of Columbia for TP analysis during 2019. The experimental configuration would not be possible without materials and support from Emory Knoll Farms (Street, Maryland), St. Cloud Minerals (Winston, New Mexico), and Stancill’s Ltd. (Perryville, Maryland).
References
Ahmad, M., A. U. Rajapaksha, J. E. Lim, M. Zhang, N. Bolan, D. Mohan, M. Vithanage, S. S. Lee, and Y. S. Ok. 2014. “Biochar as a sorbent for contaminant management in soil and water: A review.” Chemosphere 99 (Mar): 19–33. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2013.10.071.
Aitkenhead-Peterson, J. A., B. D. Dvorak, A. Volder, and N. C. Stanley. 2011. “Chemistry of growth medium and leachate from green roof systems in south-central Texas.” Urban Ecosyst. 14 (1): 17–33. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11252-010-0137-4.
Akther, M., J. He, A. Chu, J. Huang, and B. van Duin. 2018. “A review of green roof applications for managing urban stormwater in different climatic zones.” Sustainability 10 (8): 2864. https://doi.org/10.3390/su10082864.
APHA (American Public Health Association). 2017. “American Water Works Association, and Water Environment Federation. 2540 solids.” In Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater, edited by W. C. Lipps, T. E. Baxter, and E. Braun-Howland. Washington, DC: APHA Press.
ASTM. 2011. Standard test method for maximum media density for dead load analysis of vegetative (green) roof systems. ASTM E2399. West Conshohocken, PA: ASTM.
Ballantine, D. J., and C. C. Tanner. 2010. “Substrate and filter materials to enhance phosphorus removal in constructed wetlands treating diffuse farm runoff: A review.” N. Z. J. Agric. Res. 53 (1): 71–95. https://doi.org/10.1080/00288231003685843.
Barr, C. M., P. M. Gallagher, B. M. Wadzuk, and A. L. Welker. 2017. “Water quality impacts of green roofs compared with other vegetated sites.” J. Sustainable Water Built Environ. 3 (3): 04017007. https://doi.org/10.1061/JSWBAY.0000825.
Beck, D. A., G. R. Johnson, and G. A. Spolek. 2011. “Amending greenroof soil with biochar to affect runoff water quantity and quality.” Environ. Pollut. 159 (8–9): 2111–2118. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2011.01.022.
Beecham, S., and M. Razzaghmanesh. 2015. “Water quality and quantity investigation of green roofs in a dry climate.” Water Res. 70 (Mar): 370–384. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2014.12.015.
Berndtsson, J. C., L. Bengtsson, and K. Jinno. 2009. “Runoff water quality from intensive and extensive vegetated roofs.” Ecol. Eng. 35 (3): 369–380. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoleng.2008.09.020.
Bousselot, J. M., J. E. Klett, and R. D. Koski. 2012. “Evaluating a natural zeolite as an amendment for extensive green roof substrate.” J. Environ. Hortic. 30 (4): 201–206. https://doi.org/10.24266/0738-2898.30.4.201.
Buffam, I., and M. E. Mitchell. 2015. “Nutrient cycling in green roof ecosystems.” In Green roof ecosystems, 107–137. Cham, Switzerland: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-14983-7_5.
Buffam, I., M. E. Mitchell, and R. D. Durtsche. 2016. “Environmental drivers of seasonal variation in green roof runoff water quality.” Ecol. Eng. 91 (Jun): 506–514. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoleng.2016.02.044.
Carpenter, C. M. G., D. Todorov, C. T. Driscoll, and M. Montesdeoca. 2016. “Water quantity and quality response of a green roof to storm events: Experimental and monitoring observations.” Environ. Pollut. 218 (Nov): 664–672. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2016.07.056.
Castleton, H. F., V. Stovin, S. B. M. Beck, and J. B. Davison. 2010. “Green roofs; Building energy savings and the potential for retrofit.” Energy Build. 42 (10): 1582–1591. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2010.05.004.
Cheng, Y. 2021. “Nutrient dynamics and amendments in extensive green roofs.” Ph.D. dissertations, Dept. of Civil, Environmental, and Ocean Engineering, Stevens Institute of Technology.
Connelly, M., and M. Hodgson. 2015. “Experimental investigation of the sound absorption characteristics of vegetated roofs.” Build. Environ. 92 (Oct): 335–346. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2015.04.023.
Cucarella, V., and G. Renman. 2009. “Phosphorus sorption capacity of filter materials used for on-site wastewater treatment determined in batch experiments-a comparative study.” J. Environ. Qual. 38 (2): 381–392. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2008.0192.
Dobbie, K. E., K. V. Heal, J. Aumônier, K. A. Smith, A. Johnston, and P. L. Younger. 2009. “Evaluation of iron ochre from mine drainage treatment for removal of phosphorus from wastewater.” Chemosphere 75 (6): 795–800. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2008.12.049.
Emilsson, T., J. Czemiel Berndtsson, J. E. Mattsson, and K. Rolf. 2007. “Effect of using conventional and controlled release fertiliser on nutrient runoff from various vegetated roof systems.” Ecol. Eng. 29 (3): 260–271. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoleng.2006.01.001.
EPA. 2019. “SW-846 test method 9081: Cation-exchange capacity of soils (sodium acetate).” Accessed September 1, 2019. https://www.epa.gov/hw-sw846/sw-846-test-method-9081-cation-exchange-capacity-soils-sodium-acetate.
Fang, C. F. 2008. “Evaluating the thermal reduction effect of plant layers on rooftops.” Energy Build. 40 (6): 1048–1052. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2007.06.007.
Fassman, E., and R. Simcock. 2012. “Moisture measurements as performance criteria for extensive living roof substrates.” J. Environ. Eng. 138 (8): 841–851. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)EE.1943-7870.0000532.
Fassman-Beck, E., and R. Simcock. 2013a. “Hydrology and water quality of living roofs in Auckland.” In Proc., Novatech 2013—8ème Conférence internationale sur les techniques et stratégies durables pour la gestion des eaux urbaines par temps de pluie [8th Int. Conf. on Planning and Technologies for Sustainable Management of Water in the City]. Lyon, France: HAL Open Science.
Fassman-Beck, E., E. Voyde, R. Simcock, and Y. S. Hong. 2013b. “4 living roofs in 3 locations: Does configuration affect runoff mitigation?” J. Hydrol. 490 (May): 11–20. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2013.03.004.
Feng, H., and K. Hewage. 2014. “Energy saving performance of green vegetation on LEED certified buildings.” Energy Build. 75 (Jun): 281–289. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2013.10.039.
FLL (Forschungsgesellschaft Landschaftsentiwicklung Landschaftsbau). 2008. Guidelines for the planning, construction and maintenance of green roofing—Green roofing guideline. Bonn, Germany: Landscape Development and Landscaping Research Society.
Franzaring, J., L. Steffan, W. Ansel, R. Walker, and A. Fangmeier. 2016. “Water retention, wash-out, substrate and surface temperatures of extensive green roof mesocosms—Results from a two year study in SW-Germany.” Ecol. Eng. 94 (Sep): 503–515. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoleng.2016.06.021.
GRHC (Green Roof for Healthy Cities). 2019. “October 2019 2018 annual green roof industry survey executive summary.” Accessed May 2, 2018. https://static1.squarespace.com/static/58e3eecf2994ca997dd56381/t/5967869229687ff1cfbb6ada/1499956889472/GreenRoofIndustrySurvey2016ExecutiveSummary.
Hale, S. E., V. Alling, V. Martinsen, J. Mulder, G. D. Breedveld, and G. Cornelissen. 2013. “The sorption and desorption of phosphate-P, ammonium-N and nitrate-N in cacao shell and corn cob biochars.” Chemosphere 91 (11): 1612–1619. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2012.12.057.
Hathaway, A. M., W. F. Hunt, and G. D. Jennings. 2008. “A field study of green roof hydrologic and water quality performance.” Trans. ASABE 51 (1): 37–44. https://doi.org/10.13031/2013.24225.
Jennett, T. S., and Y. Zheng. 2018. “Component characterization and predictive modeling for green roof substrates optimized to adsorb P and improve runoff quality: A review.” Environ. Pollut. 237 (Jun): 988–999. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2017.11.012.
Johansson Westholm, L. 2006. “Substrates for phosphorus removal—Potential benefits for on-site wastewater treatment?” Water Res. 40 (1): 23–36. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2005.11.006.
Jones, J., N.-B. Chang, and M. P. Wanielista. 2015. “Reliability analysis of nutrient removal from stormwater runoff with green sorption media under varying influent conditions.” Sci. Total Environ. 502 (Jan): 434–447. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2014.09.016.
Karhu, K., T. Mattila, I. Bergström, and K. Regina. 2011. “Biochar addition to agricultural soil increased CH4 uptake and water holding capacity—Results from a short-term pilot field study.” Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 140 (1–2): 309–313. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2010.12.005.
Kuoppamäki, K., M. Hagner, S. Lehvävirta, and H. Setälä. 2016. “Biochar amendment in the green roof substrate affects runoff quality and quantity.” Ecol. Eng. 88 (Mar): 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoleng.2015.12.010.
Li, J. F., O. W. H. Wai, Y. S. Li, J. M. Zhan, Y. A. Ho, J. Li, and E. Lam. 2010. “Effect of green roof on ambient concentration.” Build. Environ. 45 (12): 2644–2651. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2010.05.025.
Li, Y., and R. W. Babcock. 2014. “Green roof hydrologic performance and modeling: A review.” Water Sci. Technol. 69 (4): 727–738. https://doi.org/10.2166/wst.2013.770.
Liu, R., and E. Fassman-Beck. 2016. “Effect of composition on basic properties of engineered media for living roofs and bioretention.” J. Hydrol. Eng. 21 (6): 06016002. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)HE.1943-5584.0001373.
Malcolm, E. G., M. L. Reese, M. H. Schaus, I. M. Ozmon, and L. M. Tran. 2014. “Measurements of nutrients and mercury in green roof and gravel roof runoff.” Ecol. Eng. 73 (Dec): 705–712. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoleng.2014.09.030.
Mayer, H. 1999. “Air pollution in cities.” Atmos. Environ. 33 (24–25): 4029–4037. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1352-2310(99)00144-2.
Mitchell, M. E., S. F. Matter, R. D. Durtsche, and I. Buffam. 2017. “Elevated phosphorus: Dynamics during four years of green roof development.” Urban Ecosyst. 20 (5): 1121–1133. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11252-017-0664-3.
Moharami, S., and M. Jalali. 2013. “Removal of phosphorus from aqueous solution by Iranian natural adsorbents.” Chem. Eng. J. 223 (May): 328–339. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cej.2013.02.114.
National Weather Service. n.d. “Measuring winter precipiation.” Accessed April 6, 2017. www.weather.gov/media/ohx/PDF/winterprecip.pdf.
New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection. n.d. “2016 New Jersey integrated water quality assessment report.” Accessed December 1, 2015. https://www.nj.gov/dep/wqmp/docs/202190916-int-wqa-report.pdf.
Nguyen, M. L., and C. C. Tanner. 1998. “Ammonium removal from wastewaters using natural New Zealand zeolites.” N. Z. J. Agric. Res. 41 (3): 427–446. https://doi.org/10.1080/00288233.1998.9513328.
Ntoulas, N., P. A. Nektarios, T. E. Kapsali, M. P. Kaltsidi, L. Han, and S. Yin. 2015. “Determination of the physical, chemical, and hydraulic characteristics of locally available materials for formulating extensive green roof substrates.” Horttechnology 25 (6): 774–784. https://doi.org/10.21273/HORTTECH.25.6.774.
Penn, C., and J. M. Bowen. 2017. Design and construction of phosphorus removal structures for improving water quality. New York: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-58658-8.
Santamouris, M. 2014. “Cooling the cities—A review of reflective and green roof mitigation technologies to fight heat island and improve comfort in urban environments.” Sol. Energy 103 (May): 682–703. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.solener.2012.07.003.
Sarkhot, D. V., T. A. Ghezzehei, and A. A. Berhe. 2013. “Effectiveness of biochar for sorption of ammonium and phosphate from dairy effluent.” J. Environ. Qual. 42 (5): 1545–1554. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2012.0482.
Srinivasan, R., D. W. Hoffman, J. E. Wolfe, and L. J. Prcin. 2008. “Evaluation of removal of orthophosphate and ammonia from rainfall runoff using aboveground permeable reactive barrier composed of limestone and zeolite.” J. Environ. Sci. Health. Part A Toxic/Hazard. Subst. Environ. Eng. 43 (12): 1441–1450. https://doi.org/10.1080/10934520802232220.
Stovin, V., S. Poë, and C. Berretta. 2013. “A modelling study of long term green roof retention performance.” J. Environ. Manage. 131 (Dec): 206–215. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2013.09.026.
Teotónio, I., C. M. Silva, and C. O. Cruz. 2018. “Eco-solutions for urban environments regeneration: The economic value of green roofs.” J. Cleaner Prod. 199 (Oct): 121–135. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.07.084.
Tian, J., V. Miller, P. C. Chiu, J. A. Maresca, M. Guo, and P. T. Imhoff. 2016. “Nutrient release and ammonium sorption by poultry litter and wood biochars in stormwater treatment.” Sci. Total Environ. 553 (May): 596–606. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.02.129.
Toland, D. C., B. E. Haggard, and M. E. Boyer. 2012. “Evaluation of nutrient concentrations in runoff water from green roofs, conventional roofs, and urban streams.” Trans. ASABE 55 (1): 99–106. https://doi.org/10.13031/2013.41258.
UN (United Nations). 2019. World urbanization prospects: The 2018 revision (ST/ESA/SER.A/420). New York: UN, Dept. of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division.
USGS National Minerals Information Center. n.d. “Statistics and information on the worldwide supply of, demand for, and flow of the mineral commodity zeolites.” Accessed October 14, 2021. https://www.usgs.gov/centers/national-minerals-information-center/zeolites-statistics-and-information.
Vaccari, D. A. n.d. “TaylorFit response surface analysis.” Accessed August 10, 2020. https://www.weather.gov/media/ohx/PDF/winterprecip.pdf.
van Seters, T., L. Rocha, D. Smith, and G. MacMillan. 2009. “Evaluation of green roofs for runoff retention, runoff quality, and leachability.” Water Qual. Res. J. Can. 44 (1): 33–47. https://doi.org/10.2166/wqrj.2009.005.
Yang, J., Q. Yu, and P. Gong. 2008. “Quantifying air pollution removal by green roofs in Chicago.” Atmos. Environ. 42 (31): 7266–7273. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.atmosenv.2008.07.003.
Yao, Y., B. Gao, M. Zhang, M. Inyang, and A. R. Zimmerman. 2012. “Effect of biochar amendment on sorption and leaching of nitrate, ammonium, and phosphate in a sandy soil.” Chemosphere 89 (11): 1467–1471. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2012.06.002.
Zhai, S., L. Yang, and W. Hu. 2009. “Observations of atmospheric nitrogen and phosphorus deposition during the period of algal bloom formation in northern Lake Taihu, China.” Environ. Manage. 44 (3): 542–551. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-009-9334-4.
Zhang, Q., L. Miao, X. Wang, D. Liu, L. Zhu, B. Zhou, J. Sun, and J. Liu. 2015. “The capacity of greening roof to reduce stormwater runoff and pollution.” Landscape Urban Plann. 144 (Dec): 142–150. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landurbplan.2015.08.017.
Zhang, Y., X. Kou, H. Lu, and X. Lv. 2014. “The feasibility of adopting zeolite in phosphorus removal from aqueous solutions.” Desalin. Water Treat. 52 (22–24): 4298–4304. https://doi.org/10.1080/19443994.2013.803317.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Sustainable Water in the Built Environment
Volume 8 • Issue 4 • November 2022
Copyright
© 2022 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Oct 2, 2021
Accepted: May 8, 2022
Published online: Aug 18, 2022
Published in print: Nov 1, 2022
Discussion open until: Jan 18, 2023
ASCE Technical Topics:
- Buildings
- Chemical compounds
- Chemical elements
- Chemicals
- Chemistry
- Environmental engineering
- Geology
- Geomechanics
- Geotechnical engineering
- Green buildings
- Hydrologic engineering
- Hydrology
- Minerals
- Nutrient pollution
- Phosphorus
- Pollution
- Runoff
- Soil mechanics
- Soil properties
- Stormwater management
- Structural engineering
- Structures (by type)
- Substrates
- Water and water resources
- Water discharge
- Water pollution
- Water treatment
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.