Comprehensive Evaluation of Virginia Department of Transportation’s Experience with its First Performance-Based Road-Maintenance Contract
Publication: Journal of Transportation Engineering
Volume 137, Issue 12
Abstract
The Virginia Department of Transportation’s (VDOT) first performance-based road-maintenance contract was concluded in July 2007. This contract required the contractor to maintain all assets and carry out incident management and snow and ice removal services on a total of 250 mi (402 km) of a number of Virginia’s interstate highways. This contract acted as a pilot project for VDOT and other states departments of transportation (DOT). Since performance-based road-maintenance contracting is rather new and yet to be utilized by many state DOTs, there is an emerging need to (1) assess whether its use is viable, and (2) inform the state DOTs of the key issues to consider when using performance-based road-maintenance contracting. The purpose of this paper is to address this need by providing a comprehensive evaluation of VDOT’s overall experience with its pilot performance-based road-maintenance contract. The findings from the analyses over a period of 6 years indicate that while meeting or coming very close to the performance targets most of the time, there have been years in which the contractor was not able to meet performance targets in fence-to-fence asset groups and bridges. As far as the comparison of the level-of-service effectiveness performance of the contractor with that of VDOT utilizing traditional maintenance approaches is concerned, our findings show that the contractor outperformed VDOT in fence-to-fence asset groups. The key issues that a state DOT should consider when using performance-based road-maintenance contracting, as learned from VDOT’s pilot project experience, can be summarized as (1) tying payments to be made to the contractor to actual performance, (2) generating a detailed baseline condition information, (3) using performance targets that increase (as opposed to being constant) over the contract period, (4) establishing a performance target for every single item required to be maintained, (5) having multiple inspections per year, (6) developing a standard rating procedure for all elements, and (7) developing objective, quantifiable, and easily measurable performance criteria.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Acknowledgments
The research work described in this paper has been funded by the Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT). The opinions and findings are those of the writers and do not necessarily represent the views of VDOT.
References
Code of VA. (1995). “Chapter 22. Public-Private Transportation Act of 1995.” § 56. Public Service Companies.
de la Garza, J., Piñero, J., and Ozbek, M. (2008). “Sampling procedure for performance-based road maintenance evaluations.” Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2044, 11–18.
de la Garza, J. M., Pinero, J. C., and Ozbek, M. E. (2009a). “A framework for monitoring performance-based road maintenance.” Proc., 45th Annual Int. Conf., Associated Schools of Construction, Gainesville, FL, 433–441.
de la Garza, J. M., Triantis, K., and Fallah-Fini, S. (2009b). “Efficiency measurement of highway maintenance strategies using data envelopment analysis.” Proc., 2009 NSF Engineering Research and Innovation Conf., Honolulu.
ESRI. (2004). “National bridge inventory data made GIS ready.” ArcNews, <http://www.esri.com/news/arcnews/spring04articles/national-bridge.html> (Spring).
Fallah-Fini, S., Triantis, K., Rahmandad, H., de la Garza, J. M., and Seaver, W. L. (2011). “Evaluating highway maintenance performance.” Proc., 2011 NSF Engineering Research and Innovation Conf., Atlanta.
Falls, L. C., Haas, R., McNeil, S., and Tighe, S. (2001). “Asset management and pavement management: Using common elements to maximize overall benefits.” Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 1769, 1–10.
Hardy, P. (2001). “Austroads review of performance contracts: The potential benefits of performance contracts.” Opus International Consultants. World Bank Organization, Washington, DC.
Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission. (2001). “Review of VDOT’s administration of the interstate asset management contract.” Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission of the VA General Assembly Rep., Commonwealth of Virginia, Richmond.
Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission. (2002). “Adequacy and management of VDOT’s highway maintenance program.” Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission of the VA General Assembly Rep., Commonwealth of Virginia, Richmond.
Ozbek, M. E. (2004). “Development of performance warranties for performance-based road maintenance contracts.” Masters Thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State Univ., Blacksburg.
Ozbek, M. E. (2007). “Development of a comprehensive framework for the efficiency measurement of road maintenance strategies using data envelopment analysis.” Ph.D. Dissertation, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State Univ., Blacksburg.
Ozbek, M. E., de la Garza, J. M., and Triantis, K. (2009). “Data envelopment analysis as a decision making tool for the transportation professionals.” J. Transp. Eng., 135(11), 822–831.
Ozbek, M. E., de la Garza, J. M., and Triantis, K. (2010a). “Data and modeling issues faced during the efficiency measurement of road maintenance using data envelopment analysis.” J. Infrastruct. Syst., 16(1), 21–30.
Ozbek, M. E., de la Garza, J. M., and Triantis, K. (2010b). “Efficiency measurement of bridge maintenance using data envelopment analysis.” J. Infrastruct. Syst., 16(1), 31–39.
Pinero, J. C. (2003). “A framework for monitoring performance-based road maintenance.” Ph.D. Dissertation, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State Univ., Blacksburg.
Porter, T. (2001). “International trends in procurement models for highway maintenance.” World Bank Organization, Washington, DC.
Stivers, M. L., Smith, K. L., Hoerner, T. E., and Romine, A. R. (1999). “NCHRP Project 14-12: Maintenance QA program.” Implementation manual—NCHRP Rep. 422, Washington, DC.
Zietlow, G. (2002). “Cutting costs and improving quality through performance-based road management and maintenance contracts.” University of Birmingham (UK)/Transit New Zealand Senior Road Executive Courses Innovations in Road Management, Birmingham, AL.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Copyright
© 2011 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Oct 9, 2009
Accepted: May 9, 2011
Published online: May 11, 2011
Published in print: Dec 1, 2011
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.