Evaluation of ASCE 43-05 Seismic Design Criteria for Rocking Objects in Nuclear Facilities
Publication: Journal of Structural Engineering
Volume 142, Issue 11
Abstract
The seismic interaction of unanchored objects with a seismically qualified system or component in a nuclear power plant (NPP) can be detrimental to nuclear safety. In order to assess the seismic risk, an accurate quantification of the seismic response of unanchored components, such as spent-fuel dry storage casks, portable standby generators, electrical transformers, unreinforced masonry radiation shielding walls, etc., is required. The rocking response and toppling vulnerability of unanchored objects is not covered in nuclear standards, guidelines, and reports, except for an approximate method provided in ASCE/SEI 43-05 to estimate the maximum rocking angle in lieu of nonlinear time history analysis. In this study, the approximate method adopted by ASCE/SEI 43-05 is evaluated, first qualitatively and subsequently by comparing its predictions against results from a series of nonlinear time history analyses (NLTHA). The study concludes that the ASCE/SEI 43-05 method (which has also been adopted in FEMA P-58-1 and is expected to be adopted in the new revision of ASCE 4) provides highly unreliable, and in many cases unconservative, estimates of peak rocking rotation for a wide range of block geometries, under various levels of excitation. Because a reliable simplified method for estimating rocking rotations is not currently available, the paper recommends that rotation demands be obtained from nonlinear dynamic analysis.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Acknowledgments
The authors acknowledge Bruce Power for providing resources to write this paper as a part of the academic program of the first author at McMaster University. The opinions and conclusions expressed herein are of the authors and are not representative of an official position of Bruce Power. The financial support of the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) is gratefully acknowledged.
References
ASCE. (2005). “Seismic design criteria for structures, systems and components in nuclear facilities.” ASCE 43-05, Reston, VA.
ASCE. (2006). “Seismic rehabilitation of existing buildings.” ASCE 41-06, Reston, VA.
ATC (Applied Technology Council). (2012). “Seismic performance assessment of buildings FEMA P-58-1.” Federal Emergency Management Agency, Washington, DC.
Atkinson, G. M., and Elgohary, M. (2007). “Typical uniform hazard spectra for eastern North American sites at low probability levels.” Can. J. Civ. Eng., 34(1), 12–18.
Blume, J. (1960). “A reserve energy technique for the earthquake design and rating of structures in the inelastic range.” 2nd World Conf. on Earthquake Engineering, International Association for Earthquake Engineering, Tokyo.
Chatzis, M. N., and Smyth, A. W. (2012). “Modeling of the 3D rocking problem.” Int. J. Non-Linear Mech., 47(4), 85–98.
Chaudhuri, S. R., and Hutchinson, T. C. (2005). “Characterizing frictional behavior for use in predicting the seismic response of unattached equipment.” Soil Dyn. Earthquake Eng., 25(7–10), 591–604.
Choi, B., and Tung, C. D. (2002). “Estimating sliding displacement of an unanchored body subjected to earthquake.” Earthquake Spectra, 18(4), 601–613.
Comerio, M. C., ed. (2005). “Testbed study on a laboratory building: exercising seismic performance assessment.”, Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center (PEER), Univ. of California, Berkeley, CA.
Dar, A., and Hanna, J. D. (2012). “Beyond design basis seismic evaluation of nuclear power plants at Bruce site.” Proc., 3rd Int. Structural Specialty Conf., Canadian Society for Civil Engineering, Edmonton, AB, Canada.
Dar, A., Konstantinidis, D., and El-Dakhakhni, W. (2013). “Requirement of rocking spectrum in Canadian nuclear standards.” Transactions, 22nd Conf. on Structural Mechanics in Reactor Technology (SMiRT 22), International Association for Structural Mechanics in Reactor Technology, San Francisco.
Dar, A., Konstantinidis, D., and El-Dakhakhni, W. W. (2014). “Station challenges on seismic qualification of structures, systems and components in Canadian nuclear power plants.” Proc., 10th National Conf. in Earthquake Engineering, Earthquake Engineering Research Institute, Anchorage, AK.
EPRI (Electric Power Research Institute). (1991). “A methodology for assessment of nuclear power plant seismic margin.”, Palo Alto, CA.
Hogan, S. (1989). “On the dynamics of rigid-block motion under harmonic forcing.” Proc. R. Soc. London, Series A, 425(1869), 441–476.
Housner, G. W. (1963). “The behavior of inverted pendulum structures during earthquakes.” Bull. Seismol. Soc. Am., 53(2), 403–417.
Hutchinson, T. C., and Chaudhuri, S. R. (2006). “Bench-shelf system dynamic characteristics and their effects on equipment and contents.” Earthquake Eng. Struct. Dyn., 35(13), 1631–1651.
Jensen, S. R., and Gurbuz, O. (2011). “Sliding and rocking of unanchored components and structures.” Structures Congress 2011, American Society of Civil Engineers, Las Vegas, 2178–2189.
Jeong, M. Y., Suzuki, K., and Yim, S. C. (2003). “Chaotic rocking behavior of freestanding objects with sliding motion.” J. Sound Vibr., 262(5), 1091–1112.
Konstantinidis, D., and Makris, N. (2005). “Experimental and analytical studies on the seismic response of freestanding and anchored laboratory equipment.”, Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center (PEER), Univ. of California, Berkeley, CA.
Konstantinidis, D., and Makris, N. (2007). “The dynamics of a rocking block in three dimensions.” Proc., 8th Hellenic Society for Theoretical and Applied Mechanics Int. Congress on Mechanics, Hellenic Society for Theoretical and Applied Mechanics, Athens, Greece.
Konstantinidis, D., and Makris, N. (2009). “Experimental and analytical studies on the response of freestanding laboratory equipment to earthquake shaking.” Earthquake Eng. Struct. Dyn., 38(6), 827–848.
Konstantinidis, D., and Makris, N. (2010). “Experimental and analytical studies on the response of 1/4-scale models of freestanding laboratory equipment subjected to strong earthquake shaking.” Bull. Earthquake Eng., 8(6), 1457–1477.
Konstantinidis, D., and Nikfar, F. (2015). “Seismic response of sliding equipment and contents in base-isolated buildings subjected to broad-band ground motions.” Earthquake Eng. Struct. Dyn., 44(6), 865–887.
Lin, S. L., MacRae, G. A., Dhakal, R. P., and Yeow, T. Z. (2015). “Building contents sliding demands in elastically responding structures.” Eng. Struct., 86, 182–191.
Lopez-Garcia, D., and Soong, T. (2003). “Sliding fragility of block-type non-structural components. Part 1: Unrestrained components.” Earthquake Eng. Struct. Dyn., 32(1), 111–129.
Luk, V. K., Spencer, B. W., Lam, I. P., and Dameron, R. A. (2005). “Parametric evaluation of seismic behavior of freestanding spent fuel dry cask storage systems.”, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC.
Makris, N., and Konstantinidis, D. (2001). “The rocking spectrum and the shortcomings of design guidelines.”, Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center (PEER), Univ. of California, Berkeley, CA.
Makris, N., and Konstantinidis, D. (2003). “The rocking spectrum and the limitations of practical design methodologies.” Earthquake Eng. Struct. Dyn., 32(2), 265–289.
Makris, N., and Roussos, Y. (2000). “Rocking response of rigid blocks under near-source ground motions.” Géotechnique, 50(3), 243–262.
Makris, N., and Zhang, J. (1999). “Rocking response and overturning of anchored equipment under seismic excitations.”, Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center (PEER), Univ. of California, Berkeley, CA.
Mathcad 15.0 [Computer software]. Parametric Technology Corporation, Needham, MA.
McGuire, R. K., Silva, W. J., and Constantino, C. J. (2001). “Technical basis for revision of regulatory guidance on design ground motions: Hazard- and risk-consistent ground motion spectra guidelines.”, U.S. Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC.
Newmark, N. M., Blume, J. H., and Kapur, K. K. (1973). “Seismic design spectra for nuclear power plants.” J. Power Div., 99(2), 287–303.
NRC. (1973). “Design response spectra for seismic design of nuclear power plants, Regulatory Guide 1.60, revision 1.” U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC.
NRC. (2014). “Design response spectra for seismic design of nuclear power plants, Regulatory Guide 1.60, revision 2.” U.S. Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC.
Priestley, M. J. N., Evison, R. J., and Carr, A. J. (1978). “Seismic response of structures free to rock on their foundations.” Bull. N. Z. Natl. Soc. Earthquake Eng., 11(3), 141–150.
Reed, J. W., and Kennedy, R. P. (1994). “Methodology for developing seismic fragilities EPRI TR-103959.” Electric Power Research Institute, Palo Alto, CA.
Schau, H., and Johannes, M. (2013). “Rocking and sliding of unanchored bodies subjected to seismic load according to conventional and nuclear rules.” 4th Int. Conf. on Computational Methods in Structural Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering (COMPDYN), Institute of Structural Analysis and Antiseismic Research, Athens, Greece.
Shao, Y., and Tung, C. (1999). “Seismic response of unanchored bodies.” Earthquake Spectra, 15(3), 523–536.
Shenton III, H. W. (1996). “Criteria for initiation of slide, rock, and slide-rock rigid-body modes.” J. Eng. Mech., 690–693.
Taniguchi, T. (2002). “Non-linear response analyses of rectangular rigid bodies subjected to horizontal and vertical ground motion.” Earthquake Eng. Struct. Dyn., 31(8), 1481–1500.
Wesley, D. A., Kennedy, R. P., and Richter, P. J. (1980). “Analysis of the seismic collapse capacity of unreinforced masonry wall structures.” Proc., 7th World Conf. on Earthquake Engineering, International Association for Earthquake Engineering, Tokyo.
Yim, C. K., Chopra, A., and Penzien, J. (1980). “Rocking response of rigid blocks to earthquakes.” Earthquake Eng. Struct. Dyn., 8(6), 565–587.
Zhang, J., and Makris, N. (2001). “Rocking response of free-standing blocks under cycloidal pulses.” J. Eng. Mech., 473–483.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Structural Engineering
Volume 142 • Issue 11 • November 2016
Copyright
© 2016 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Aug 24, 2015
Accepted: Mar 30, 2016
Published online: Jun 13, 2016
Published in print: Nov 1, 2016
Discussion open until: Nov 13, 2016
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.