Comparison of Three Air Transport Models for Safety Applications under Diffusive Conditions Using Full-Scale Experimental Data: EPIcode, ALOHA, and SCIPUFF
Publication: Journal of Hazardous, Toxic, and Radioactive Waste
Volume 15, Issue 1
Abstract
This paper compares three current state-of-the-practice models, ALOHA, EPICode, and SCIPUFF for use in safety evaluations using data from a unique full-scale field experiment under low-wind speed conditions. The experiment included the release and transport of three gases: ammonia (buoyant), ethylene (neutral buoyant), and propylene (dense) in low-wind speed (diffusion) conditions, less than 2 m/s. In total there were 30 releases ranging from 6 to 30 min in duration. The diagnostics included nine meteorology stations on 100-m centers and 36 photo ionization detectors in a radial pattern. Diffusive conditions are difficult to model, and all of the models had difficulty replicating the field measurements. However, the work does show that these models, if used correctly, are conservative (overpredict concentrations) and can be used for safety and emergency planning.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
Arya, S. (1999). Air pollution meteorology and dispersion, Oxford University Press, New York.
ASTM. (2000). “Standard Guide for Statistical Evaluation of Atmospheric Dispersion Model Performance,” D6589-05, West Conshohocken, Pa., 17.
Barad, M. (1959). Project Prairie Grass, a field program in diffusion, Air Force Cambridge Research Center, Cambrige, Mass.
Britter, R., and Hanna, S. (2003). “Flow and dispersion in urban areas.” Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech., 35(1), 469–496.
Chang, J., and Hanna, S. (2004). “Air quality model performance evaluation.” Meteorol. Atmos. Phys., 87(1), 167–196.
Hanna, S. (1983). “Lateral turbulence intensity and plume meandering during stable conditions.” J. Appl. Meteorol., 22(8), 1424–1430.
Hanna, S., Britter, R., and Franzese, P. (2003). “A baseline urban dispersion model evaluated with Salt Lake City and Los Angeles tracer data.” Atmos. Environ., 37(36), 5069–5082.
Hanna, S., and Chang, J. (1992). “Boundary-layer parameterizations for applied dispersion modeling over urban areas.” Boundary-Layer Meteorol., 58(3), 229–259.
Hanna, S., and Chang, J. (2001). “Use of the Kit Fox field data to analyze dense gas dispersion modeling issues.” Atmos. Environ., 35(13), 2231–2242.
Hanna, S., Chang, J., and Strimaitis, D. (1993). “Hazardous gas model evaluation with field observations.” Atmos. Environ. Part A, 27(15), 2265–2285.
Hanna, S., Strimaitis, D., and Chang, J. (1991). “Hazard response modeling uncertainty (a quantitative method), volume 1: User’s guide for software for evaluating hazardous gas dispersion models.” A490072, Air Force Engineering and Service Center, Washington, D.C.
Haugen, D. (1959). “Project Prairie Grass, a field program in diffusion.” J. Geophys. Res., 3, 58–235.
Korsakissok, I., and Mallet, V. (2009). “Comparative study of Gaussian dispersion formulas within the polyphemus platform: Evaluation with prairie grass and kincaid experiments.” J. Appl. Meteorol. Climatol., 48(12), 2459–2473.
MacDonald, R. (2003). “Theory and objectives of air dispersion modeling.” Proc., 11th International Conference on Wind Engineering, American Association for Wind Engineering, International Association for Wind Engineering.
Moreira, D., Tirabassi, T., and Carvalho, J. (2005). “Plume dispersion simulation in low wind conditions in stable and convective boundary layers.” Atmos. Environ., 39(20), 3643–3650.
Nickola, P. (1977). The Hanford 67-series: A volume of atmospheric field diffusion measurements, Battelle Pacific Northwest Laboratories, Richland, Washington, NTIS PNL-2433.
Office of the Federal Coordinator for Meteorology (OCFM). (2007a). General and specific characteristics for model: ALOHA, Silver Spring, Md.
Office of the Federal Coordinator for Meteorology (OCFM). (2007b). General and specific characteristics for model: SCIPUFF, Silver Springs, Md.
Oreskes, N., Shrader-Frechette, K., and Belitz, K. (1994). “Verification, validation, and confirmation of numerical models in the earth sciences.” Science, 263(5147), 641–646.
Peterson, H., Mazzolini, D., O’Neill, S., and Lamb, B. (1999). “Instantaneous spread of plumes in the surface layer.” J. Appl. Meteorol., 38(3), 343–352.
Sawyer, P. (2007a). Atmospheric dispersion model validation for low wind speed conditions, MS thesis, Univ. of Nevada–Las Vegas, Las Vegas.
Sawyer, P. (2007b). “Atmospheric dispersion model validation in low wind conditions.” Proc., Western Regional Meeting, American Chemical Society, Washington, D.C.
Seinfeld, J., and Pandis, S. (1998). Atmospheric chemistry and physics: From air pollution to climate change, Wiley, New York.
Sharan, M., and Modani, M. (2005). “An Analytical study for the dispersion of pollutants in a finite layer under low wind conditions.” Pure Appl. Geophys., 162(10), 1861–1892.
Sharan, M., Singh, M., and Yadav, A. (1996). Mathematical model for atmospheric dispersion in low winds with eddy diffusivities as linear functions of downwind distence, Center for Atmospheric Sciences, Indian Institute of Technology, Hauz Khas, New Delhi, India.
Sharan, M., and Yadav, A. (1998). “Simulation of experiments under light wind, stable conditions by a variable K-theory model.” Atmos. Environ., 32(10), 3481–3492.
Sharan, M., Yadav, A., and Modani, M. (2002). “Simulation of short-range diffusion experiment in low-wind convective conditions.” Atmos. Environ., 36(11), 1901–1906.
Sykes, R., Parker, S., Henn, D., Cerasoli, C., and Santos, L. (1998). PC-SCIPUFF version 1.2 PD technical documentation, Titan Corporation. Titan Research & Technology Div., Princeton, N.J.
Sykes, R. I., Parker, S. F., Henn, D. S., and Chowdhury, B. (2006). “SCIPUFF version 2.2 technical documentation.” AARP Rep. No. 729 (draft), L-3 Titan Corp., Princeton, N.J.
Thoman, D., O’Kula, K., Laul, J., Davis, M., and Knecht, K. (2006). “Comparison of ALOHA and EPIcode for safety analysis applications.” J. Chem. Health Saf., 13(6), 20–33.
U.S. DOE. (2004). EPIcode computer code application guidance for documented safety analysis, Office of Quality Assurance Programs, Office of Environment, Safety and Health, Washington, D.C.
U.S. EPA. (2004). “Air toxics risk assessment reference library.” Rep. No. EPA-452-K-04-001A, Technology Transfer Network FARA (Fate, Exposure, and Risk Analysis), Research Triangle Park, N.C.
U.S. EPA. (2005). “Revision to the guideline on air quality models: Adoption of a preferred general purpose (flat and complex terrain) dispersion model and other revisions; final rule.” 40 CFR, Part 51, Federal Register, Washington, D.C.
U.S. EPA. (2006). ALOHA areal locations of hazardous atmospheres user’s manual. Feb 2006, Office of Emergency Management, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Office of Response and Restoration/Hazardous Materials Response Div., Seattle, Washington, D.C.
U.S. EPA. (2008). Clarification of regulatory status of CALPUFF for near-field applications, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, Research Triangle Park, N.C.
Venkatram, A., Isakov, V., Yuan, J., and Pankratz, D. (2004). “Modeling dispersion at distances of meters from urban sources.” Atmos. Environ., 38(28), 4633–4641.
Wannberg, V. (2008). Quantitative uncertainty of low wind speed modeling using measured field data and stochastic modeling, Brigham Young Univ., Provo, Utah.
Wieringa, J. (1993). “Representative roughness parameters for homogeneous terrain.” Boundary-Layer Meteorol., 63(4), 323–363.
Yadav, A., and Sharan, M. (1996). “Statistical evaluation of sigma schemes for estimating dispersion in low wind conditions.” Atmos. Environ., 30(14), 2595–2606.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Hazardous, Toxic, and Radioactive Waste
Volume 15 • Issue 1 • January 2011
Pages: 26 - 36
Copyright
© 2011 ASCE.
History
Received: Mar 31, 2010
Accepted: Jul 23, 2010
Published online: Jul 26, 2010
Published in print: Jan 2011
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.