Experimental Investigation of a Francis Turbine during Exigent Ramping and Transition into Total Load Rejection
Publication: Journal of Hydraulic Engineering
Volume 144, Issue 6
Abstract
This study investigates the unsteady pressure fluctuations in a hydraulic turbine observed during a dangerous case of steep ramping interrupted by an unexpected transition into total load rejection. Although hydraulic turbines are expected to experience such events only a few times over their lifetime, the resulting pressure amplitudes are so significant that they take a toll on a machine’s operating life. The focus of the present study is to experimentally measure and numerically characterize time-dependent pressure amplitudes in the vaneless space, runner, and draft tube of a model Francis turbine. To this end, 12 pressure sensors were integrated into a turbine, including four miniature sensors mounted in the runner. Steep ramping was performed by changing the rotational speed using a frequency controller. After a few seconds, as the load increased, total load rejection was initiated. This resulted in the generation of strong vibrations throughout the entire structure and strong pressure fluctuations in the turbine. The data analysis shows that pressure amplitudes are in the order of 10–20% of hydraulic energy in the vaneless space and runner, with high-amplitude fluctuations occurring at expected characteristic frequencies, including those associated with rotor-stator interactions, water hammer travel times, and standing waves in the turbine. Various stochastic frequencies were also observed, especially at the runner outlet.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Acknowledgments
These experiments were conducted through a research project entitled “High head Francis turbine.” The project was financially supported by the Research Council of Norway and by the Norwegian hydropower industry.
References
Amiri, K., Mulu, B., Cervantes, M. J., and Raisee, M. (2016). “Effects of load variation on a Kaplan turbine runner.” Int. J. Fluid Mach. Syst., 9(2), 182–193.
Arpe, J., Nicolet, C., and Avellan, F. (2009). “Experimental evidence of hydroacoustic pressure waves in a Francis turbine elbow draft tube for low discharge conditions.” J. Fluids Eng., 131(8), 081102.
Beevers, D., Branchini, L., Orlandini, V., De Pascale, A., and Perez-Blanco, H. (2015). “Pumped hydro storage plants with improved operational flexibility using constant speed Francis runners.” Appl. Energy, 137(1), 629–637.
Béguin, A., Nicolet, C., Hell, J., and Moreira, C. (2017). “Assessment of power step performances of variable speed pump-turbine unit by means of hydro-electrical system simulation.” Proc., HYPERBOLE Conf., IOP Publishing, Bristol, U.K., 5.
Bessa, R., Moreira, C., Silva, B., Filipe, J., and Fulgêncio, N. (2017). “Role of pump hydro in electric power systems.” Proc., HYPERBOLE Conf., IOP Publishing, Bristol, U.K., 7.
Botero, F., Hasmatuchi, V., Roth, S., and Farhat, M. (2014). “Non-intrusive detection of rotating stall in pump-turbines.” Mech. Syst. Signal Process., 48(1–2), 162–173.
Bucur, D. M., Dunca, G., Cervantes, M. J., Călinoiu, C., and Isbăşoiu, E. C. (2014). “Simultaneous transient operation of a high head hydro power plant and a storage pumping station in the same hydraulic scheme.” Earth Environ. Sci., 22(4), 042015.
Caralis, G., Papantonis, D., and Zervos, A. (2012). “The role of pumped storage systems towards the large scale wind integration in the Greek power supply system.” Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev., 16(5), 2558–2565.
Chen, C., Nicolet, C., Yonezawa, K., Farhat, M., Avellan, F., and Tsujimoto, Y. (2008). “One-dimensional analysis of full load draft tube surge.” J. Fluids Eng., 130(4), 041106.
Claude, J.-M. (2017). “Performances achieved to the grid by a full power converter used in a variable speed pumped storage plant.” Proc., HYPERBOLE Conf., IOP Publishing, Bristol, U.K., 6.
Coutu, A., Proulx, D., Coulson, S., and Demers, A. (2004). “Dynamic assessment of hydraulic turbines-high head Francis.” Proc., Hydrovision, Quebec, 13.
Coutu, A., Roy, M. D., Monette, C., and Nennemann, B. (2008). “Experience with rotor-stator interactions in high head Francis runner.” Proc., 24th IAHR Symp. on Hydraulic Machinery and Systems, International Association for Hydro-Environment Engineering and Research, Madrid, Spain, 10.
Dolecek, G. J. (2013). Random signals and processes primer with MATLAB, Springer, New York.
Dörfler, P., Sick, M., and Coutu, A. (2013). Flow-induced pulsation and vibration in hydroelectric machinery, Springer, London.
Dorji, U., and Ghomashchi, R. (2014). “Hydro turbine failure mechanisms: An overview.” Eng. Fail. Anal., 44(9), 136–147.
Ellingsen, R., and Storli, P.-T. (2015). “Simulations of the dynamic load in a Francis runner based on measurements of grid frequency variations.” Int. J. Fluid Mach. Syst., 8(2), 102–112.
Engelberg, S. (2008). Digital signal processing an experimental approach, Springer, London.
Gagnon, M., and Léonard, F. (2013). “Transient response and life assessment: Case studies on the load rejection of two hydroelectric turbines.” Surveillance, 7(1), 1–11.
Gagnon, M., Nicolle, J., Morissette, J. F., and Lawrence, M. (2016). “A look at Francis runner blades response during transients.” Earth Environ. Sci., 49(5), 052005.
Guo, W. C., Yang, J. D., Chen, J. P., Peng, Z. Y., Zhang, Y., and Chen, C. C. (2016). “Simulation of the transient processes of load rejection under different accident conditions in a hydroelectric generating set.” Earth Environ. Sci., 49(5), 052016.
Hasmatuchi, V., Farhat, M., Roth, S., Botero, F., and Avellan, F. (2011). “Experimental evidence of rotating stall in a pump-turbine at off-design conditions in generating mode.” J. Fluids Eng., 133(5), 051104.
He, L. Y., Wang, Z. W., Kurosawa, S., and Nakahara, Y. (2014). “Resonance investigation of pump-turbine during startup process.” Earth Environ. Sci., 22(3), 032024.
Hell, J. (2017). “High flexible hydropower generation concepts for future grids.” Proc., HYPERBOLE Conf., IOP Publishing, Bristol, U.K., 7.
Hübner, B., Weber, W., and Seidel, U. (2016). “The role of fluid-structure interaction for safety and life time prediction in hydraulic machinery.” Earth Environ. Sci., 49(7), 072007.
IEC (International Electrotechnical Commission). (1991). “Field acceptance tests to determine the hydraulic performance of hydraulic turbines, storage pumps and pump-turbines.” IEC 41, Geneva, 430.
IEC (International Electrotechnical Commission). (1999). “Hydraulic turbines, storage pumps and pump-turbines: Model acceptance tests.” IEC 60193, Geneva, 578.
ISO. (2005). “Measurement of fluid flow-Procedures for the evaluation of uncertainties.” ISO 5168:2005(E), Geneva, 65.
Li, Z., Bi, H., Karney, B., Wang, Z., and Yao, Z. (2017). “Three-dimensional transient simulation of a prototype pump-turbine during normal turbine shutdown.” J. Hydraul. Res., 55(4), 520–537.
Liu, X., Luo, Y., Karney, B. W., and Wang, W. (2015). “A selected literature review of efficiency improvements in hydraulic turbines.” Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev., 51(11), 18–28.
Liu, X., Luo, Y., and Wang, Z. (2016). “A review on fatigue damage mechanism in hydro turbines.” Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev., 54(2), 1–14.
Luna-Ramírez, A., Campos-Amezcua, A., Dorantes-Gómez, O., Mazur-Czerwiec, Z., and Muñoz-Quezada, R. (2015). “Failure analysis of runner blades in a Francis hydraulic turbine—Case study.” Eng. Fail. Anal., 59(1), 314–325.
Melot, M., Monette, C., Coutu, A., and Nenneman, B. (2013). “Speed-no-load operating condition: A new standard Francis runner design procedure to predict static stresses.” 18th Int. Conf. on Hydraulics, Water Resources, Coastal and Environmental Engineering, HYDRO, Innsbruck, Austria, 8.
Moisan, E., Giacobbi, D.-B., Gagnon, M., and Léonard, F. (2014). “Self-excitation in Francis runner during load rejection.” Earth Environ. Sci., 22(3), 032025.
Monette, C., Marmont, H., Chamberland-Lauzon, J., Skagerstrand, A., Coutu, A., and Carlevi, J. (2016). “Cost of enlarged operating zone for an existing Francis runner.” Earth Environ. Sci., 49(7), 072018.
Morissette, J., et al. (2016). “Stress predictions in a Francis turbine at no-load operating regime.” Earth Environ. Sci., 49(7), 072016.
Mossinger, P., and Jung, A. (2016). “Transient two-phase CFD simulation of overload operating conditions and load rejection in a prototype sized Francis turbine.” Earth Environ. Sci., 49(9), 092003.
Nennemann, B., et al. (2014). “Challenges in dynamic pressure and stress predictions at no-load operation in hydraulic turbines.” Earth Environ. Sci., 22(3), 032055.
Nicolet, C. (2007). “Hydroacoustic modelling and numerical simulation of unsteady operation of hydroelectric systems.” Ph.D. thesis, Ecole Polytechnique Federale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Nicolet, C., Alligné, S., Kawkabani, B., Koutnik, J., Simond, J.-J., and Avellan, F. (2009). “Stability study of Francis pump-turbine at runaway.” Proc., 3rd Meeting of IAHR Workgroup on Cavitation and Dynamic Problems in Hydraulic Machinery and Systems, International Association for Hydro-Environment Engineering and Research, Madrid, Spain, 14.
Nicolet, C., Alligné, S., Kawkabani, B., Simond, J.-J., and Avellan, F. (2008). “Unstable operation of Francis pump-turbine at runaway: Rigid and elastic water column oscillation modes.” Proc., 24th IAHR Symp. on Hydraulic Machinery and Systems, International Association for Hydro-Environment Engineering and Research, Madrid, Spain, 13.
Nicolet, C., Ruchonnet, N., Alligné, S., Koutnik, J., and Avellan, F. (2010). “Hydroacoustic simulation of rotor-stator interaction in resonance conditions in Francis pump-turbine.” Earth Environ. Sci., 12(1), 012005.
Nishi, M., and Liu, S. (2013). “An outlook on the draft-tube-surge study.” Int. J. Fluid Mach. Syst., 6(1), 33–48.
Pacot, O., Kato, C., Guo, Y., Yamade, Y., and Avellan, F. (2016). “Large eddy simulation of the rotating stall in a pump-turbine operated in pumping mode at a part-load condition.” J. Fluids Eng., 138(11), 111102.
Pejovic, S., and Karney, B. (2014). “Guidelines for transients are in need of revision.” Earth Environ. Sci., 22(4), 042006.
Sivakumar, N., Das, D., and Padhy, N. P. (2014). “Variable speed operation of reversible pump-turbines at Kadamparai pumped storage plant—A case study.” Energy Convers. Manage., 78(2), 96–104.
Trivedi, C. (2017). “A review on fluid structure interaction in hydraulic turbines: A focus on hydrodynamic damping.” Eng. Fail. Anal., 77(7), 1–22.
Trivedi, C. (2018). “Investigations of compressible turbulent flow in a high head Francis turbine.” J. Fluids Eng., 140(1), 011101.
Trivedi, C., and Cervantes, M. (2017). “Fluid structure interaction in hydraulic turbines: A perspective review.” Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev., 68(1), 87–101.
Trivedi, C., Cervantes, M., Dahlhaug, O., and Gandhi, B. (2015a). “Experimental investigation of a high head Francis turbine during spin-no-load operation.” J. Fluids Eng., 137(6), 061106.
Trivedi, C., Cervantes, M., Gandhi, B., and Dahlhaug, O. G. (2013a). “Experimental and numerical studies for a high head Francis turbine at several operating points.” J. Fluids Eng., 135(11), 111102–1111017.
Trivedi, C., Cervantes, M., Gandhi, B., and Dahlhaug, O. (2014a). “Experimental investigations of transient pressure variations in a high head model Francis turbine during start-up and shutdown.” J. Hydrodyn. Ser. B, 26(2), 277–290.
Trivedi, C., Cervantes, M., Gandhi, B., and Dahlhaug, O. (2014b). “Pressure measurements on a high-head Francis turbine during load acceptance and rejection.” J. Hydraul. Res., 52(2), 283–297.
Trivedi, C., Cervantes, M., Gandhi, B., and Dahlhaug, O. (2014c). “Transient pressure measurements on a high head model Francis turbine during emergency shutdown, total load rejection, and runaway.” J. Fluids Eng., 136(12), 121107.
Trivedi, C., Cervantes, M. J., and Dahlhaug, O. G. (2016a). “Experimental and numerical studies of a high-head Francis turbine: A review of the Francis-99 test case.” Energies, 9(12), 74.
Trivedi, C., Cervantes, M. J., and Dahlhaug, O. G. (2016b). “Numerical techniques applied to hydraulic turbines: A perspective review.” Appl. Mech. Rev., 68(1), 010802.
Trivedi, C., Cervantes, M. J., and Gandhi, B. K. (2016c). “Numerical investigation and validation of a Francis turbine at runaway operating conditions.” Energies, 9(3), 149.
Trivedi, C., Gandhi, B., and Cervantes, M. (2013b). “Effect of transients on Francis turbine runner life: A review.” J. Hydraul. Res., 51(2), 121–132.
Trivedi, C., Gandhi, B., Cervantes, M., and Dahlhaug, O. (2015b). “Experimental investigations of a model Francis turbine during shutdown at synchronous speed.” Renewable Energy, 83(11), 828–836.
Widmer, C., Staubli, T., and Ledergerber, N. (2011). “Unstable characteristics and rotating stall in turbine brake operation of pump-turbines.” J. Fluids Eng., 133(4), 041101.
Yang, W., Norrlund, P., Saarinen, L., Yang, J. D., Guo, W. C., and Zeng, W. (2016a). “Wear and tear on hydro power turbines—Influence from primary frequency control.” Renewable Energy, 87(3), 88–95.
Yang, W., Norrlund, P., and Yang, J. (2016b). “Analysis on regulation strategies for extending service life of hydropower turbines.” Earth Environ. Sci., 49(5), 052013.
Yasuda, M., and Watanabe, S. (2016). “How to avoid severe incidents at pumped storage power plants.” Earth Environ. Sci., 49, 112002.
Zeng, W., Yang, J., Tang, R., and Yang, W. (2016). “Extreme water-hammer pressure during one-after-another load shedding in pumped-storage stations.” Renewable Energy, 99(12), 35–44.
Zuo, Z., Liu, S., Sun, Y., and Wu, Y. (2015). “Pressure fluctuations in the vaneless space of high-head pump-turbines—A review.” Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev., 41(1), 965–974.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Hydraulic Engineering
Volume 144 • Issue 6 • June 2018
Copyright
©2018 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Apr 5, 2017
Accepted: Dec 7, 2017
Published online: Apr 10, 2018
Published in print: Jun 1, 2018
Discussion open until: Sep 10, 2018
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.