Handling Unbalanced Bidding in Construction Projects: Prevention Rather Than Detection
Publication: Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
Volume 142, Issue 2
Abstract
Unbalanced bidding is a common practice associated with both unit price and lump sum contracts. This practice is not usually in the owner’s best interests and is used in different forms by contractors for various reasons. Bid evaluation practices try to identify unbalanced bids and may reject the lowest bid if it is perceived to be unbalanced. Previous research on this topic focused on either helping contractors unbalance their bids or detecting imbalance in bids in order to reject them. This paper proposes a model based on a prevention, rather than detection, approach to handling unbalanced bidding. The proposed model balances all the bids submitted for a project and thereby neutralizes the impact of manipulating bid prices to obtain undeserved payments from owners. This approach protects the interests of the owners while maintaining the essence of competitive bidding by awarding the project to the bidder who submitted the lowest bid in a fair competitive process. Two examples, representing the bidding results of two projects, are analyzed to demonstrate the capability of the model in handling various forms of unbalanced bidding. Use of the model by owners will help protect them from the negative consequences of unbalanced bidding. It is also expected that, as owners begin to use the developed model, contractors will be less motivated to practice unbalanced bidding since it will not be possible to attain the desired objective by manipulating bid prices.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
Abdul-Rahman, H., Abd Karim, S., Hanid, M., and Yap, X. (2014). “Does professional ethics affect quality of construction—A case in a developing economy?” Total Qual. Manage. Bus. Excellence, 25(3–4), 235–248.
ADB (Asian Development Bank). (2010). “Guide on bid evaluation.” Manila, Philippines.
Afshar, A., and Amiri, H. (2008). “A fuzzy-based model for unbalanced bidding in construction.” Proc., 1st Int. Conf. on Construction in Developing Countries (ICCIDC–I) Advancing and Integrating Construction Education, Research & Practice, NED Univ. of Engineering and Technology, Karachi, Pakistan.
Afshar, A., and Amiri, H. (2010a). “A min-max regret approach to unbalanced bidding in construction.” KSCE J. Civ. Eng., 14(5), 653–661.
Afshar, A., and Amiri, H. (2010b). “Risk-based approach to unbalanced bidding in construction projects.” Eng. Optim., 42(4), 369–385.
Alaska DOT/PF (Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities). (2004). “Standard specifications for highway construction.” 〈http://www.dot.state.ak.us/stwddes/dcsspecs/assets/pdf/hwyspecs/2004sshc.pdf〉 (Jul. 2, 2014).
Arditi, D., and Chotibhongs, R. (2009). “Detection and prevention of unbalanced bids.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 27(8), 721–732.
Bajari, P., Houghton, S., and Tadelis, S. (2014). “Bidding for incomplete contracts: An empirical analysis of adaptation costs.” Am. Econ. Rev., 104(4), 1288–1319.
Bell, M. (1989). “Unbalanced bidding in government contracts.” Master’s thesis, George Washington Univ., Washington, DC.
Burnett, J., and Wampler, B. (1998). “Unit price contracts: A practical framework for determining competitive bid prices.” J. Appl. Bus. Res., 14(3), 63–72.
Cattell, D. (2013). “The highs and lows of unbalanced bidding models.” Proc., CIB World Building Congress, Queensland Univ. of Technology, Brisbane, Australia.
Cattell, D., Bowen, P., and Kaka, A. (2004). “A model to distribute mark-up amongst quotation component item prices: An outline.” Proc., 2nd Postgraduate Conf. on Construction Industry Development, Construction Industry Development Board, Cape Town, 154–165.
Cattell, D., Bowen, P., and Kaka, A. (2007). “Review of unbalanced bidding models in construction.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 562–573.
Cattell, D., Bowen, P., and Kaka, A. (2008). “A simplified unbalanced bidding model.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 26(12), 1283–1290.
Cattell, D., Bowen, P., and Kaka, A. (2010). “The risks of unbalanced bidding.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 28(4), 333–344.
Chotibhongs, R. (2011). “Managing the bidding process for the construction owner—Detection and prevention of unbalanced bids and collusive bids.” Ph.D. thesis, Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago.
Christodoulou, S. (2008). “A bid-unbalancing method for lowering a contractor’s financial risk.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 26(12), 1291–1302.
Comptroller General. (1976). Index digest of the published decisions of the Comptroller General of the United States, Vol. 976, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.
Dardona, A. (2013). “Valuation of unbalanced bids in construction projects in the Gaza Strip.” Master’sthesis, Islamic Univ. of Gaza, Gaza.
eCFR. (2014). “Electronic code of federal regulations.” 〈http://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/ECFR?page=browse〉 (Jun. 14, 2014).
Enshassi, A., Mohamed, S., and Abdel-Hadi, M. (2013). “Factors affecting the accuracy of pre-tender cost estimates in the Gaza Strip.” J. Constr. Dev. Countries, 18(1), 73–94.
Ewerhart, C., and Fieseler, K. (2003). “Procurement auctions and unit-price contracts.” RAND J. Econ., 34(3), 569–581.
FAR (Federal Acquisition Regulation). (2005). “Federal acquisition regulations system.” 〈http://www.acquisition.gov/far/current/pdf/FAR.pdf〉 (Jul. 18, 2014).
Grilley, D. (2009). “Local transportation agency cost estimating practices: A case for improvement.” Master’s thesis, Mineta Transportation Institute, San José State Univ., San José, CA.
Hongyong, L., Neng, H., and Xia, H. (2010). “Study on the optimization of the bidding program of the EPC engineering project.” Proc., 2010 Int. Conf. on Industry Engineering and Management, Jiangsu Teachers Univ. of Technology, China.
Hoogenboom, J., Dale, W., and Martell, C. (2006). “Risk analysis and optimization of the (un)balanced bid.” Am. Assoc. Cost Eng. Int. Trans, R171–R176.
Liu, X., Lin, L., and Zang, D. (2009). “Stochastic programming models and hybrid intelligent algorithm for unbalanced bidding problem.” Comput. Inf. Sci., 2(1), 188–194.
Mandell, S., and Nystrom, J. (2011). “Endogenous risk in unbalanced bidding.” Proc., Management and Innovation for a Sustainable Built Environment, Delft Univ. of Technology, Delft, Netherlands.
Manzo, F. (1997). “The impact of an unbalanced bid on the change order process.”, Greyhawk, North America, LLC.
Manzo, F., and Tell, S. (1997). “Unbalanced bids and avoiding disputes relating to them.” Chapter 7 of the 1997 Wiley construction law update, N. Sweeney, ed., Wiley, Hoboken, NJ.
McGreevy, S., and Landrum, K. (2014). “Taking risks with numbers: How far can you go?” Construction Financial Management Association (CFMA), Princeton, NJ.
Michigan DOT. (2012). “Standard specifications for construction.” 〈http://www.michiganltap.org/sites/ltap/files/publications/technical /MDOT%20-%202012%20Standard%20Specifications%20for%20Construction.pdf〉 (May 22, 2014).
Morrow, B. (2012). “Low bid? A case of responsiveness and balance in a contract.” Randall-Reilly, Tuscaloosa, AL.
Nassar, K. (2004). “Using spreadsheets to optimally unbalance a construction bid.” Cost Eng., 46(12), 28–32.
Renes, S. (2011). “Balancing the bids, solutions for unit-price auctions.”, Tinbergen Institute, Netherlands.
Roberts, R. A. (1994). “How to unbalance a bid and win the job.” Trans. AACE Int., GVT.4.1–GVT.4.4.
Skitmore, M., and Cattell, D. (2013). “On being balanced in an unbalanced world.” J. Oper. Res. Soc., 64(1), 138–146.
Son, J., Mack, M., and Mattila, K. (2006). “Nonlinear cash flow optimization model.” Can. J. Civ. Eng., 33(11), 1450–1454.
Stramarcos, A., and Cattell, D. (2013). “The ethics of item pricing.” Proc., 38th Australian University Building Educators Association Conf., Univ. of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
Tennessee State DOT. (2006). “Supplemental specifications-section 100 of the standard specifications for road and bridge construction.” 〈http://www.tdot.state.tn.us/construction/specs.htm〉 (Jun. 14, 2014).
Turcotte, J. W. (1997). “Review of the Florida Department of Transportation construction bid and contract administration process.”, Florida Legislature, Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability, Tallahassee, FL.
Wang, W. (2004). “Electronic-based procedure for managing unbalanced bids.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 455–460.
Washington State DOT. (2010). “Standard specifications for road, bridge, and municipal construction.” 〈http://www.wsdot.wa.gov/publications/manuals/fulltext/M41-10/SS2010.pdf〉 (Jun. 13, 2014).
Willms, F., and Ghikas, M. (2005). “Recent developments in the duty of fairness and privilege clauses.” 〈www.faskjen.com〉 (Sep. 24, 2014).
Yin, Y., Qiao, L., and Li, B. (2010). “Research on the owner’s tactics to unbalanced bid under the mode of code of valuation with bill quantity of construction works.” Proc., Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management (IE&EM), 2010 IEEE 17th Int. Conf., IEEE Beijing Section and Industrial Engineering Institute of CMES, China, 249–252.
Yizhe, T., and Youjie, L. (1992). “Unbalanced bidding on contracts with variation trends in client-provided quantities.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 10(1), 69–80.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
Volume 142 • Issue 2 • February 2016
Copyright
© 2015 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Oct 27, 2014
Accepted: Jun 17, 2015
Published online: Jul 27, 2015
Discussion open until: Dec 27, 2015
Published in print: Feb 1, 2016
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.