Epistemic Uncertainties in Structural Modeling: A Blind Benchmark for Seismic Assessment of Slender Masonry Towers
Publication: Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Volume 31, Issue 5
Abstract
The paper reports the results of a blind benchmark developed as a part of the preliminary activity of the research project RiSEM (Italian acronym for Seismic Risk on Monumental Buildings). The benchmark was aimed at comparing the results obtained with different analytical models and/or numerical analysis techniques (variational approach, finite elements, macroelements, equivalent frame, etc.) for the assessment of the nonlinear structural behavior of two cantilever masonry elements with different slenderness. The analyzed elements were characterized by a deliberately simple geometry, and the comparison between the numerical results had a twofold purpose. On the one hand, it aimed at estimating the effects of the epistemic uncertainties that are related to the different models and numerical techniques. On the other hand, it aimed at reaching a proper evaluation of the influence of parameters describing the postelastic behavior of the structural typology analyzed within the research project (specifically, the masonry towers). Both these objectives were necessary to further proceed with the development of simplified numerical models needed for the subsequent risk analysis. For both slendernesses, the results have highlighted a significant dispersion of both the displacement capacity and postpeak softening branch of the capacity curves. In addition, after some elaborations it has been observed that the dispersion of the results is proportional to both the shear-force and displacement level.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Acknowledgments
The authors kindly acknowledge the Region of Tuscany that financially supported the research (theme PAR FAS 2007-2013—CIPE n°166/2007—line 1.1.a.3: Science and Technology for the preservation and enhancement of cultural heritage).
References
3DMacro [Computer software]. STA Data, Torino, Italy.
3Muri [Computer software]. Gruppo sismica, Catania, Italy.
Adam, J. M., Brencich, A., Hughes, T. G., and Jefferson, T. (2010). “Micromodelling of eccentrically loaded brickwork: Study of masonry wallettes.” Eng. Struct., 32(5), 1244–1251.
ANSYS [Computer software]. ANSYS, Canonsburg, PA.
Asteris, P. G., et al. (2015). “Numerical modeling of historic masonry structures.” Handbook of research on seismic assessment and rehabilitation of historic structures, P. G. Asteris and V. Plevris, eds., IGI Global, Hershey, PA, 213–256.
Bartoli, G., Betti, M., and Vignoli, A. (2016). “A numerical study on seismic risk assessment of historic masonry towers: A case study in San Gimignano.” Bull. Earthquake Eng., 14(6), 1475–1518.
Bennati, S., Nardini, L., and Salvatore, W. (2005). “Dynamic behavior of a medieval masonry bell tower. II: Measurement and modeling of the tower motion.” J. Struct. Eng., 1656–1664.
Betti, M., Galano, L., Petracchi, M., and Vignoli, A. (2015). “Diagonal cracking shear strength of unreinforced masonry panels: A correction proposal of the b shape factor.” Bull. Earthquake Eng., 13(10), 3151–3186.
Betti, M., Galano, L., and Vignoli, A. (2016). “Finite element modelling for seismic assessment of historic masonry buildings.” Earthquakes and their impact on society, S. D’Amico, ed., Springer, New York, 377–415.
Binante, V., Girardi, M., Padovani, C., Pagni, A., and Pasquinelli, G. (2012). “The NOSA-ITACA code for the modelling of the structural behaviour of historic masonry constructions.” Proc., 5th Int. Congress on “Science and Technology for the Safeguard of Cultural Heritage in the Mediterranean Basin,” Istanbul, Turkey.
Bourdin, B., Francfort, G. A., and Marigo, J. J. (2000). “Numerical experiments in revisited brittle fracture.” J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 48(4), 797–826.
Bradley, B. A. (2010). “Epistemic uncertainties in component fragility functions.” Earthquake Spectra, 26(1), 41–62.
Caliò, I., Marletta, M., and Pantò, B. (2005). “A simplified model for the evaluation of the seismic behaviour of masonry building.” Proc., 10th Int. Conf. on Civil, Structural and Environmental Engineering Computing, Civil-Comp Press, Stirlingshire, U.K.
Caliò, I., Marletta, M., and Pantò, B. (2008). “A discrete element approach for the evaluation of the seismic response of masonry buildings.” Proc., 14th World Conf. on Earthquake Engineering, Beijing.
Caliò, I., Marletta, M., and Pantò, B. (2012). “A new discrete element model for the evaluation of the seismic behaviour of unreinforced masonry buildings.” Eng. Struct., 40, 327–338.
Cattari, S., Galasco, A., Lagomarsino, S., and Penna, A. (2004). “Analisi non lineare di edifici in muratura con il programma TREMURI.” Atti del XI Congresso Nazionale L’Ingegneria Sismica in Italia, ANIDIS, Genova, Italy (in Italian).
Chiostrini, S., Galano, L., and Vignoli, A. (2003). “In situ shear and compression tests in ancient stone masonry walls of Tuscany, Italy.” J. Test. Eval., 31(4), 289–304.
Code ASTER [Computer software]. Code ASTER, Paris.
Del Piero, G. (1989). “Constitutive equation and compatibility of the external loads for linear elastic masonry-like materials.” Meccanica, 24(3), 150–162.
Del Piero, G., Lancioni, G., and March, R. (2007). “A variational model for fracture mechanics: Numerical experiments.” J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 55(12), 2513–2537.
Del Piero, G., Lancioni, G., and March, R. (2013). “A diffuse cohesive energy approach to fracture and plasticity: The one-dimensional case.” J. Mech. Mater. Struct., 8(2–4), 109–151.
Der Kiureghian, A., and Ditlevsen, O. (2009). “Aleatory or epistemic? Does it matter?” Struct. Saf., 31(2), 105–112.
DIANA [Computer software]. DIANA FEA, Delft, Netherlands.
Di Pasquale, S. (1992). “New trends in the analysis of masonry structures.” Meccanica, 27(3), 173–184.
Drucker, D., and Prager, W. (1952). “Soil mechanics and plastic analysis or limit design.” Q. Appl. Math., 10(2), 157–165.
Francfort, G. A., and Marigo, J. J. (1998). “Revisiting brittle fracture as an energy minimization problem.” J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 46(8), 1319–1342.
Freddi, F., and Royer-Carfagni, G. (2010). “Regularized variational theories of fracture: A unified approach.” J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 58(8), 1154–1174.
Galano, L., and Vignoli, A. (2001). “Resistenza a Taglio di Murature di Pietrame: Analisi Comparata della Rappresentatività di Tipiche prove di Taglio in Situ.” Atti del X Congresso Nazionale L’Ingegneria Sismica in Italia, ANIDIS, Potenza, Italy (in Italian).
Ginovart, J. L., Costa, A., and Fortuny, G. (2013). “Assessment and restoration of a masonry dome in the cathedral of Tortosa enclosure.” Proc., 13th Int. Conf. on Studies, Repairs and Maintenance of Heritage Architecture (STREMAH2013), New Forest, U.K.
Girardi, M., Padovani, C., and Pellegrini, D. (2015). “The NOSA-ITACA code for the safety assessment of ancient constructions: A case study in Livorno.” Adv. Eng. Software, 89, 64–76.
Helton, J. C., and Oberkampf, W. L. (2004). “Guest editorial to the special issue: Alternative representations of epistemic uncertainty.” Reliab. Eng. Syst. Saf., 85(1–3), 1–10.
Hordijk, D. A. (1991). “Local approach to fatigue of concrete.” Ph.D. thesis, Delft Univ. of Technology, Delft, Netherlands.
Lagomarsino, S. (2011). “Valutazione della sicurezza sismica del patrimonio architettonico in muratura.” Atti del XIV Congresso Nazionale L’Ingegneria Sismica in Italia, ANIDIS, Bari, Italy (in Italian).
Lagomarsino, S., Penna, A., Galasco, A., and Cattari, S. (2013). “TREMURI program: An equivalent frame model for the nonlinear seismic analysis of masonry buildings.” Eng. Struct., 56, 1787–1799.
Lancioni, G. (2015). “Modeling the response of tensile steel bars by means of incremental energy minimization.” J. Elast., 121(1), 25–54.
Lancioni, G., and Royer-Carfagni, G. (2009). “The variational approach to fracture mechanics. A practical application to the French Panthéon in Paris.” J. Elast., 95(1–2), 1–30.
Lancioni, G., Yalcinkaya, T., and Cocks, A. (2015). “Energy based non-local plasticity models for deformation patterning, localization and fracture.” Proc. R. Soc. A, 471(2180), 20150275.
Lin, Y. K. (1967). Probabilistic theory of structural dynamics, Mc-Graw Hill, New York.
Lin, Y. K., and Cai, G. C. (1995). Probabilistic structural dynamics. Advanced theory and applications, Mc-Graw Hill, New York.
Lourenço, P. B., Rots, J. C., and Blaauwendraad, J. (1998). “Continuum model for masonry: Parameter estimation and validation.” J. Struct. Eng., 642–652.
Lucchesi, M., Padovani, C., Pasquinelli, G., and Zani, N. (2008). “Masonry constructions: Mechanical models and numerical applications.” Series: Lecture notes in applied and computational mechanics, Springer, Berlin.
Lucchesi, M., and Pintucchi, B. (2007). “A numerical model for non-linear dynamics analysis of masonry slender structures.” Eur. J. Mech. A/Solids, 26(1), 88–105.
Lucchesi, M., Pintucchi, B., Silhavy, M., and Zani, N. (2015). “On the dynamics of viscous beams.” Continuum Mech. Thermodyn., 27(3), 349–365.
Lucchesi, M., Silhavy, M., and Zani, N. (2012). “Equilibrium problems and limit analysis of masonry beams.” J. Elast., 106(2), 165–188.
Maio, R., Vicente, R., Formisano, A., and Varum, H. (2015). “Seismic vulnerability of building aggregates through hybrid and indirect assessment techniques.” Bull. Earthquake Eng., 13(10), 2995–3014.
Marra, A. M., Salvatori, L., Spinelli, P., and Bartoli, G. (2017). “Incremental dynamic and nonlinear static analyses for seismic assessment of medieval masonry towers.” J. Perform. Constr. Facil., 04017032.
Mazars, J. M., and Pijaudier-Cabot, G. (1989). “Continuum damage theory. Application to concrete.” J. Eng. Mech., 345–365.
Mendes, N., and Lourenço, P. B. (2014). “Sensitivity analysis of the seismic performance of existing masonry buildings.” Eng. Struct., 80(1), 137–146.
Most, T. (2011). “Assessment of structural simulation models by estimating uncertainties due to model selection and model simplification.” Comput. Struct., 89(17–18), 1664–1672.
Munjiza, A. (2004). The combined finite-discrete element method, Wiley, New York.
NTC2008. (2008). “Decreto Ministeriale del Ministero delle Infrastrutture e dei Trasporti del 14/01/2008. Nuove Norme Tecniche per le Costruzioni.” S.O. n.30 alla G.U. del 4.2.2008, No. 29 (in Italian).
Orlando, M., Salvatori, L., Spinelli, P., and De Stefano, M. (2016). “Displacement capacity of masonry piers: Parametric numerical analyses versus international building codes.” Bull. Earthquake Eng., 14(8), 2259–2271.
Pan, Q., Grimmelsman, K., Moon, F., and Aktan, E. (2011). “Mitigating epistemic uncertainty in structural identification: Case study for a long-span steel arch bridge.” J. Struct. Eng., 1–13.
Pham, K., Amor, H., Marigo, J. J., and Maurini, C. (2011). “Gradient damage models and their use to approximate brittle fracture.” Int. J. Damage Mech., 20(4), 618–652.
Pieraccini, M., Dei, D., Betti, M., Bartoli, G., Tucci, G., and Guardini, N. (2014). “Dynamic identification of historic masonry tower through and expeditious and no-contact approach: Application to the “Torre del Mangia” in Siena (Italy).” J. Cultural Heritage, 15(3), 275–282.
Pintucchi, B., and Zani, N. (2009). “Effects of material and geometric non-linearities on the collapse load of masonry arches.” Eur. J. Mech. A/Solids, 28(1), 45–61.
Pintucchi, B., and Zani, N. (2014). “Effectiveness of nonlinear static procedures for slender masonry towers.” Bull. Earthquake Eng., 12(6), 2531–2556.
Pintucchi, B., and Zani, N. (2016). “A simple model for performing nonlinear static and dynamic analyses of unreinforced and FRP-strengthened masonry arches.” Eur. J. Mech. A/Solids, 59, 210–231.
Porcelli, M., Binante, V., Girardi, M., Padovani, C., and Pasquinelli, G. (2015). “A solution procedure for constrained eigenvalue problems and its application within the structural finite-element code NOSA-ITACA.” Calcolo, 52(2), 167–186.
Salvatori, L., Marra, A. M., Bartoli, G., and Spinelli, P. (2015). “Probabilistic seismic performance of masonry towers: General procedure and a simplified implementation.” Eng. Struct., 94, 82–95.
Salvatori, L., and Spinelli, P. (2010). “Microstructural, homogenised, and multiscale models for masonry structures based on rigid blocks.” Proc., 8-IMC, Dresden, Germany.
SMARTmasonry [Computer software]. SMARTmasonry, Littleton, CO.
Tarque, N., Camata, G., Spacone, E., Varum, H., and Blondet, M. (2014). “Nonlinear dynamic analysis of a full-scale unreinforced adobe model.” Earthquake Spectra, 30(4), 1643–1661.
Theodossopoulos, D., and Sinha, B. (2013). “A review of analytical methods in the current design processes and assessment of performance of masonry structures.” Constr. Build. Mater., 41, 990–1001.
Thorenfeldt, E., Tomaszewicz, A., and Jensen, J. J. (1987). “Mechanical properties of high-strength concrete and applications in design.” Proc., Symp. on Utilization of High-Strength Concrete (Stavanger, Norway), Tapir, Trondheim, Norway.
Tondelli, M., Rota, M., Penna, A., and Magenes, G. (2012). “Evaluation of uncertainties in the seismic assessment of existing masonry buildings.” J. Earthquake Eng., 16(sup1), 36–64.
Valente, M., and Milani, M. (2016). “Non-linear dynamic and static analyses on eight historical masonry towers in the North-East of Italy.” Eng. Struct., 114, 241–270.
Willam, K. J., and Warnke, E. P. (1975). “Constitutive model for the triaxial behaviour of concrete.” IABSE Seminar on Concrete Structures Subjected to Triaxial Stresses, Bergamo, Italy.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Volume 31 • Issue 5 • October 2017
Copyright
©2017 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Jul 12, 2016
Accepted: Jan 13, 2017
Published online: May 5, 2017
Published in print: Oct 1, 2017
Discussion open until: Oct 5, 2017
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.