Capacity Assessment of the Titus Tunnel Bridge Using Analytical and Numerical Techniques
Publication: Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Volume 28, Issue 2
Abstract
A great number of masonry arch bridges are still in service in Europe, the Middle East, and other parts of the world. Assessing the capacity of these historical structures is an important problem both for safety and preservation purposes. This paper addresses the assessment of the Titus Tunnel Bridge, a single-span, Roman stone arch pedestrian bridge (Common Era 70) located in Antakya, Turkey, using analytical and numerical techniques. The bridge is located in an active seismic zone and has survived several major earthquakes. Therefore, it is important to understand the Bridge’s subtle features that have helped the structure survive for the last two millennia. Furthermore, being a single-span semicircular stone arch, the bridge exemplifies the main construction blocks of several masonry bridges around the world. First, the analytical techniques, i.e., Heyman’s geometrical factor of safety and the mechanism method, are used to assess the capacity of the bridge under simple loading conditions and to validate the finite-element (FE) models. Then, discrete FE modeling with explicit time integration is used to investigate the arch behavior under both gravity and earthquake loading conditions. It is observed that the Titus Tunnel Bridge has a significant margin of safety against collapse, which also explains the approximately 2,000-year lifetime of the structure. The results are also used to provide estimates on the maximum expected ground motions in the region using a precarious rocks analogy.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Acknowledgments
This research is funded by Bogazici University through Contract No. 06T102. The authors thank the Hatay Office of the Turkish Chamber of Civil Engineers and the deputy secretary, Mr. Yusuf Kanatli, and his company for the help and assistance they provided during the field trip and with the measurements of the stone arch bridge.
References
Ambraseys, N. (2009). Earthquakes in the Mediterranean and Middle East: A multidisciplinary study of seismicity up to 1900, Cambridge University Press, New York.
Anderson, J. G., and Brune, J. N. (1999). “Methodology for using precarious rocks in Nevada to test seismic hazard models.” Bull. Seismol. Soc. Am., 89(2), 456–467.
Audenaert, A., Peremans, H., and Reniers, G. (2007). “An analytical model to determine the ultimate load on masonry arch bridges.” J. Eng. Math., 59(3), 323–336.
Bathe, K.-J. (1996). Finite element procedures, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ.
Bell, G. L. (1908). Syria: The desert and the sown, Heinemann, London.
Bicanic, N., Stirling, C., and Pearce, C. J., (2002). “Discontinuous modelling of structural masonry.” Proc., 5th World Congress on Computational Mechanics, eds. H. A. Mang, F. G. Rammerstorfer, and J. Eberhardsteiner, eds., International Association for Computational Mechanics (IACM), Barcelona, Spain.
Boothby, T. E. (1996). “Discussion: Analytical approach to collapse mechanisms of circular masonry arch.” J. Struct. Eng., 978–980.
Boothby, T. E. (1997). “Elastic plastic stability of jointed masonry arches.” Eng. Struct., 19(5), 345–351.
Boothby, T. E. (2001). “Analysis of masonry arches and vaults.” Prog. Struct. Eng. Mater., 3(3), 246–256.
Brencich, A., and Colla, C. (2002). “The influence of construction technology on the mechanics of masonry railway bridges.” Proc., 5th Int. Conf. on Railway Engineering, Engineering Technics Press, Edinburgh, U.K.
Brencich, A., and De Francesco, U. (2004a). “Assessment of multispan masonry arch bridges. I: Simplified approach.” J. Bridge Eng., 582–590.
Brencich, A., and De Francesco, U. (2004b). “Assessment of multispan masonry arch bridges. II: Examples and applications.” J. Bridge Eng., 591–598.
Brune, J. N. (2002). “Precarious-rock constraints on ground motion from historic and recent earthquakes in southern California.” Bull. Seismol. Soc. Am., 92(7), 2602–2611.
Cancelliere, I., Imbimbo, M., and Sacco, E. (2010). “Experimental tests and numerical modeling of reinforced masonry arches.” Eng. Struct., 32(3), 776–792.
Castigliano, C. A. P. (1879). Theorie de l’equilibre des systemes elastiques et ses applications, A. F Negro, Turin, Italy (in French).
Cavicchi, A., and Gambarotta, L. (2005). “Collapse analysis of masonry bridges taking into account arch-fill interaction.” Eng. Struct., 27(4), 605–615.
Cavicchi, A., and Gambarotta, L. (2006). “Two-dimensional finite element upper bound limit analysis of masonry bridges.” Comput. Struct., 84(31–32), 2316–2328.
Cavicchi, A., and Gambarotta, L. (2007). “Lower bound limit analysis of masonry bridges including arch-fill interaction.” Eng. Struct., 29(11), 3002–3014.
Chen, Y., Ashour, A. F., and Garrity, S. W. (2007). “Modified four-hinge mechanism analysis for masonry arches strengthened with near-surface reinforcement.” Eng. Struct., 29(8), 1864–1871.
Chetouane, B., Dubois, F., Vinches, M., and Bohatier, C. (2005). “NSCD discrete element method for modelling masonry structures.” Int. J. Numer. Methods Eng., 64(1), 65–94.
Clemente, P., Occhiuzzi, A., and Raithel, A. (1995). “Limit behavior of stone arch bridges.” J. Struct. Eng., 1045–1050.
Coulomb, C. A. (1773). “Essai sur une application des regles de maximis et minimis a quelques problemes de statique, relatifs a l’architecture.” Mem. Acad. R. Div. Sav., 7, 343–382 (in French).
Creazza, G., Matteazzi, R., Saetta, A., and Vitaliani, R. (2002). “Analyses of masonry vaults: A macro approach based on three-dimensional damage model.” J. Struct. Eng., 646–654.
Crisfield, M. A. (1988). “Numerical methods for the non-linear analysis of bridges.” Comp. Struct., 30(3), 637–644.
Cuomo, M., and Ventura, G. (2000). “A complementary energy formulation of no tension masonry-like solids.” Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng., 189(1), 313–339.
de Felice, G. (2009). “Assessment of the load-carrying capacity of multi-span masonry arch bridges using fibre beam elements.” Eng. Struct., 31(8), 1634–1647.
DeJong, M. J., De Lorenzis, L., Adams, S., and Ochsendorf, J. A. (2008). “Rocking stability of masonry arches in seismic regions.” Earthquake Spectra, 24(4), 847–865.
Del Coz Díaz, J. J., García Nieto, P. J., Lozano Martínez-Luengas, A., and álvarez Rabanal, F. P. (2007). “Evaluation of the damage in the vault and portico of the pre-Romanesque chapel of San Salvador de Valdediós using frictional contacts and the finite-element method.” Int. J. Comput. Math., 84(3), 377–393.
Downey, G. (1961). A history of Antioch in Syria: From Seleucus to the Arab conquest, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
Fanning, P. J., and Boothby, T. E. (2001). “Three-dimensional modelling and full-scale testing of stone arch bridges.” Comput. Struct., 79(29-30), 2645–2662.
Ford, T. E., Augarde, C. E., and Tuxford, S. S. (2003). “Modelling of masonry arch bridges using commercial finite element software.” Proc., 9th Int. Conf. on Civil and Structural Engineering Computing, Civil-Comp Press, Stirling, U.K.
Gencturk, B., Kilic, S. A., Erdik, M., and Pinho, R. (2007). “Assessment of stone arch bridges under static loading using analytical techniques.” Proc., ASCE Structures Conf., ASCE, Reston, VA.
Ghaboussi, J. (1988). “Fully deformable discrete element analysis using a finite element approach.” Comput. Geotech., 5(3), 175–195.
Gregory, D. (1697). “Catenaria.” Philos. Trans. R. Soc., 19(231), 637–652.
Hallquist, J. O. (2006). LS-DYNA theoretical manual, Livermore Software Technology Corporation, Livermore, CA.
Heyman, J. (1966). “The stone skeleton.” Int. J. Solids Struct., 2(2), 249–279.
Heyman, J. (1969). “The safety of masonry arches.” Int. J. Mech. Sci., 11(4), 363–385.
Heyman, J. (1980). “The estimation of the strength of masonry arches.” Proc. Inst. Civ. Eng., Part 2, 69, 921–937.
Heyman, J. (1982). The masonry arch, Ellis Horwood Series in Engineering and Science, Wiley, New York.
Hooke, R. (1675). The true mathematical and mechanical form of all manner of arches for buildings, University Press, London.
Kayabali, K., and Akin, M. (2003). “Seismic hazard map of Turkey using the deterministic approach.” Eng. Geol., 69(1–2), 127–137.
Livesley, R. K. (1978). “Limit analysis of structures formed from rigid blocks.” Int. J. Numer. Methods Eng., 12(12), 1853–1871.
Lourenço P. B. (2001). “Analysis of historical constructions: From thrust-lines to advanced simulations.” Historical constructions, P. B. Lourenço and P. Roca, eds., Univ. of Minho, Guimarães, Portugal, 91–116.
Mahmoud, Y., et al. (2013). “Kinematic study at the junction of the East Anatolian fault and the Dead Sea fault from GPS measurements.” J. Geodyn., 67, 30–39.
Mamaghani, I. H. P., Aydan, O., and Kajikawa, Y. (1999). “Analysis of masonry structures under static and dynamic loading by discrete finite element method.” Proc. JSCE, 16(2), 75–86.
Martinez, J. A. M., Revilla, J. M., and Torre, A. A. (2001). “Critical thickness criteria on stone arch bridges with low rise/span ratio and current traffic loads.” Historical constructions, P. B. Lourenço and P. Roca, eds., Univ. of Minho, Guimarães, Portugal, 609–616.
Millar, F. (1993). The Roman Near East, 31 BC–AD 337, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Molins, C., and Roca, P. (1998). “Capacity of masonry arches and spatial frames.” J. Struct. Eng., 653–663.
Mullapudi, T. R. S., and Ayoub, A. (2010). “Inelastic analysis of semi-infinite foundation elements.” Mech. Res. Commun., 37(1), 72–77.
Navier, C. L. M. H. (1833). Resume des lecons donnees a l’Ecole des Ponts et Chaussees, sur l’application de la mecanique a l’etablis sement des constructions et des machines, Paris (in French).
Ng, K. H., and Fairfield, C. A. (2002). “Monte Carlo simulation for arch bridge assessment.” Constr. Build. Mater., 16(5), 271–280.
Ng, K. H., and Fairfield, C. A. (2004). “Modifying the mechanism method of masonry arch bridge analysis.” Constr. Build. Mater., 18(2), 91–97.
Orduña, A. (2003). “Seismic assessment of ancient masonry structures by rigid blocks limit analysis.” Ph.D. thesis, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Univ. of Minho, Guimarães, Portugal.
Orduña, A., and Lourenço, P. B. (2003). “Cap model for limit analysis and strengthening of masonry structures.” J. Struct. Eng., 1367–1375.
Ozer, O. (2006). “Assessment of masonry arch bridges by the mechanism method.” M.S. thesis, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Bogazici Univ., Istanbul, Turkey.
Papantonopoulos, C., Psycharis, I. N., Papastamatiou, D. Y., Lemos, J. V., and Mouzakis, H. P. (2002). “Numerical prediction of the earthquake response of classical columns using the distinct element method.” Earthquake Eng. Struct. Dyn., 31(9), 1699–1717.
Psycharis, I. N., Lemos, J. V., Papastamatiou, D. Y., Zambas, C., and Papantonopoulos, C. (2003). “Numerical study of the seismic behaviour of a part of the Parthenon Pronaos.” Earthquake Eng. Struct. Dyn., 32(13), 2063–2084.
Roca, P., López-Almansa, F., Miquel, J., and Hanganu, A. (2007). “Limit analysis of reinforced masonry vaults.” Eng. Struct., 29(3), 431–439.
Sevim, B., Bayraktar, A., Altunişik, A., Atamtürktür, S., and Birinci, F. (2011a). “Assessment of nonlinear seismic performance of a restored historical arch bridge using ambient vibrations.” Nonlinear Dyn., 63(4), 755–770.
Sevim, B., Bayraktar, A., Altunişik, A. C., Atamtürktür, S., and Birinci, F. (2011b). “Finite element model calibration effects on the earthquake response of masonry arch bridges.” Finite Elem. Anal. Design, 47(7), 621–634.
Shepherd, W. R. (1911). Historical atlas, Henry Holt, New York.
Thavalingam, A., Bicanic, N., Robinson, J. I., and Ponniah, D. A. (2001). “Computational framework for discontinuous modelling of masonry arch bridges.” Comput. Struct., 79(19), 1821–1830.
Tunc, G. (1978). Tas koprulerimiz, Karayollari Genel Mudurlugu Matbaasi, Ankara, Turkey (in Turkish).
Ural, A., Oruç, Ş., Doğangün, A., and Tuluk, Ö. İ. (2008). “Turkish historical arch bridges and their deteriorations and failures.” Eng. Failure Anal., 15(1–2), 43–53.
Waltham, T. (2009). Foundations of engineering geology, Taylor & Francis, New York.
Winkler, E. (1867). Theory of elasticity and strength, Dominicus, Prague, Czechoslovakia.
Yürür, M. T., and Chorowicz, J. (1998). “Recent volcanism, tectonics and plate kinematics near the junction of the African, Arabian and Anatolian plates in the eastern Mediterranean.” J. Volcanol. Geotherm. Res., 85(1–4), 1–15.
Zhang, L. (2005). Engineering properties of rocks, Elsevier, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Volume 28 • Issue 2 • April 2014
Pages: 349 - 362
Copyright
© 2014 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Jul 2, 2012
Accepted: Sep 25, 2012
Published online: Sep 27, 2012
Published in print: Apr 1, 2014
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.