Generic Method of Grading Building Defects Using FMECA to Improve Maintainability Decisions
Publication: Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Volume 25, Issue 6
Abstract
To improve building maintainability by preventing defects, a scientific maintainability scoring system necessitates a centralized database of defects and their systematic analysis or grading. Unlike causes, impacts of defects are not well defined. This research establishes bottom-up, qualitative failure mode effect and criticality analysis (FMECA) as a suitable defect grading tool and develops criticality parameters applicable for buildings. For two major systems, nine subsystems, and 62 components of Singapore commercial buildings, 319 defects were identified. Thirty-four experienced facility managers graded 45% of them as critical in a five-point Likert scale during a face-to-face questionnaire. Most critical defects were from five mechanical-electrical subsystems, namely, sanitary plumbing, HVAC, elevator, electrical, and fire protection. They are rare but significantly affect users and system performance. Though four civil-architectural subsystems were simpler, their defects showed higher frequency and economic impact. These subsystems were basement, facade, wet area, and roof. Here, structural members are excluded as beyond the scope of regular maintenance. The proposed method aptly evaluated defects from both complex and simple subsystems whose general characteristics matched with the identified nature of associated defects. The knowledge elicited will contribute to developing a Comprehensive Maintainability Scoring System (COMASS) with guidelines weighted as per their ability to mitigate both critical and noncritical defects.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
Andi, S., and Minato, T. (2003). “Representing causal mechanism of defective designs: A system approach considering human errors.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 21(3), 297–305.
Arditi, D., and Nawakorawit, M. (1999a). “Designing buildings for maintenance: Designers’ perspective.” J. Archit. Eng., 5(4), 107–116.
Arditi, D., and Nawakorawit, M. (1999b). “Issues in building maintenance: Property managers’ perspective.” J. Archit. Eng., 5(4), 117–132.
Assaf, S., Al-Hammad, A., and Al-Shihah, M. (1996). “Effects of faulty design and construction on building maintenance.” J. Perform. Constr. Facil., 10(4), 171–174.
Audit Commission for Local Authorities in England and Wales. (1988). Local authority property—A management handbook, Her Majesty’s Stationery Office (HMSO), London.
Baker, D., Bridges, D., Hunter, R., Johnson, G., Krupa, J., and Murphy, J. (2002). “Guidebook to decision-making methods.” WSRC-IM-2002-00002, U.S. Dept. of Energy, Washington, DC.
Blanchard, B. S., Verma, D., and Peterson, E. L. (1995). Maintainability: A key to effective serviceability and maintenance management, Wiley, New York.
Bowles, G., Dagpunar, J. S., and Gow, H. (1997). “Financial management of planned maintenance for housing associations.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 15(4), 315–326.
Bowles, J. B., and Pelaez, C. E. (1995). “Application of fuzzy logic to reliability engineering.” Proc. IEEE, 83(3), 435–449.
Briffett, C. (1990). “Balancing design and maintenance issues.” Building maintenance and modernization worldwide, Vol. 2, L. K. Quah, ed., Longman, Singapore, 1097–1105.
British Standards Institute (BSI). (2006). BS EN 60812:2006 Analysis techniques for system reliability. Procedure for failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA), London.
British Standards Institute (BSI) (1993). BS 3811: 1993 Glossary of maintenance management terms in terotechnology, London.
Chanter, B., and Swallow, P. (2007). Building maintenance management, 2nd Ed., Blackwell, Oxford.
Chew, M. Y. L. (2005). “Defect analysis in wet areas of buildings.” Constr. Build. Mater., 19(3), 165–173.
Chew, M. Y. L., and Das, S. (2007). “Maintainability aspects of central chilled water HVAC system.” Proc. CITC-IV: 4th. Int. Conf. on Const. in the 21st Century, Florida International Univ., Miami, FL.
Chew, M. L., Das, S., and Sulaiman, N. H. B. (2008a). “Quantifying maintainability parameters for vertical transport system.” Proc. 11DBMC: 11th Int. Conf. on Durability of Bldg. Materials & Components, Istanbul Technical Univ., Istanbul, Turkey.
Chew, M. Y. L., Das, S., De Silva, N., and Foon, F. Y. (2008b). “Grading maintainability parameters for sanitary-plumbing system for high-rise residential buildings.” Proc BEAR2008: CIB Int. Con. on Bldg. Edu & Res., Univ. of Salford, Manchester, UK.
Chew, M. Y. L., and Tan, S. S. (2004). “A multivariate approach to maintenance prediction of wet areas.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 22(4), 395–407.
Chew, M. Y. L., De Silva, N., and Tan, P. P. (2003). “Maintainability of facades in the tropics.” Proc. Conf. for Facade Design & Procurement, Univ. of Bath, Bath, UK.
Chew, M. Y. L., De Silva, N., and Tan, P. P. (2004a). “A neural network approach to assessing building façade maintainability in the tropics.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 22(6), 581–594.
Chew, M. Y. L., De Silva, N., and Tan, S. S. (2004b). “Maintainability of wet areas of non-residential buildings.” Struct. Survey, 22(1), 39–52.
Chief of Engineers, U.S. Army. (2006). TM 5-698-4: Failure modes, effects and criticality analysis (FMECA) for command, control, communications, computer, intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (C4ISR), U.S. Army Headquarters, Washington, DC.
Chong, W. K., and Low, S. P. (2006). “Latent building defects: Causes and design strategies to prevent them.” J. Perform. Constr. Facil., 20(3), 213–221.
The Chartered Inst. of Bldg. Services Engineers (CIBSE). (2007). Guide to ownership, operation and maintenance of building services, CISBE, London.
Construction 21 Committee (CTC). (1999). Construction 21: Re-inventing construction, Ministry of Manpower and Ministry of National Development, Singapore.
Das, S. (2007a). “Industry practices and techniques in 21st century construction—A case study of Singapore.” Proc. CeNEM. Int. Conf. on Civil Engg. in the New Millennium: Opportunities & Challenges. Bengal Engineering and Science Univ., Shibpur, India.
Das, S. (2007b). “Techniques and technologies for enhancing total performance at the project development stage.” J. Inst. Eng. (India): Arch. Engg., 88(3), 25–30.
Das, S., and Chew, M. Y. L. (2010). “Multi-criteria decision analysis in building maintainability using analytical hierarchy process.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 28(10), 1043–1056.
Das, S., Poh, K. L., and Chew, M. Y. L. (2009). “Standardizing FM knowledge acquisition when information is inadequate.” Facilities, 27(7/8), 315–330.
Davey, C., McDonald, J., Lowe, D., Duff, R., Powell, J. A., and Powell, J. E. (2006). “Defects liability management by design.” Build. Res. Inf., 34(2), 145–153.
Dept. of Defense. (1976). “Engineering design handbook: Maintainability engineering theory and practice.” AMCP 706-133, Washington, DC.
De Silva, N., Dulaimi, M. F., Ling, F. Y. Y., and Ofori, G. (2004). “Improving the maintainability of buildings in Singapore.” Build. Environ., 39(10), 1243–1251.
Dhillon, B. S. (1983). Systems reliability, maintainability, and management. Petrocelli Books, Princeton, NJ.
Dhillon, B. S. (2006). Maintainability, maintenance, and reliability for engineers, Taylor & Francis, Boca Raton, FL.
Ekanayake, L. L., and Ofori, G. (2004). “Building waste assessment score: Design based tool.” Build. Environ., 39(7), 851–861.
El-Haram, M. A., and Horner, R. L. W. (2003). “Application of the principles of ILS to the development of cost effective maintenance strategies for existing building stock.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 21(3), 283–296.
Floyd, H. L., Eastwood, K., and Liggett, D. P. (2000). “How we can better learn from electrical accidents?” IEEE Industry Appl. Mag., 6(3), 16–23.
Fwa, T. F., and Chan, W. T. (1993). “Priority rating of highway maintenance needs by neural networks.” J. Transp. Eng., 119(3), 419–432.
HAPM Publications Ltd. (1993). HAPM component life manual, Housing Association Property Mutual, Routledge, UK.
Hassanain, M. A., Froese, T. M., and Vanier, D. J. (2003). “Framework model for asset maintenance management.” J. Perform. Constr. Facil., 17(1), 51–64.
Holm, M. G. (2000). “Service management in housing refurbishment: A theoretical approach.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 18(5), 525–533.
Ilozor, B. D., Okoroh, M. I., and Egbu, C. E. (2004). “Understanding residential house defects in Australia from the State of Victoria.” Build. Environ., 39(3), 327–337.
Josephson, P. E., and Hammarlund, Y. (1999). “The causes and costs of defects in construction: A study of seven building projects.” Autom. Constr., 8(6), 681–687.
Kaminetzky, D. (1991). Design and construction failures: Lessons from forensic investigations, McGraw-Hill, New York.
Khan, F. I., and Haddara, M. M. (2003). “Risk-based maintenance (RBM): A quantitative approach for maintenance/inspection scheduling and planning.” J. Loss Prev. Process Ind., 16(6), 561–573.
Korka, J. W., Oloufa, A. A., and Thomas, R. A. (1997). “Facilities computerized maintenance management system.” J. Archit. Eng., 3(3), 118–123.
Lam, K. C. (2000). “Quality assurance in management of building services maintenance.” Southeast Asia Facility Management, Building Services Engineering Dept., The Hong Kong Polytechnic Univ.
Local Authorities Management Services and Computer Committee (LAMSAC). (1981). Terotechnology and the maintenance of local authority building, LAMSAC, London.
Lee, R., and Wordsworth, P. (2001). Lee’s building maintenance management, 4th Ed., Blackwell Science, Malden, MA.
Low, S. P., and Wee, D. (2001). “Improving maintenance and reducing building defects through ISO 9000.” J. Qual. Mainten. Eng., 7(1), 6–24.
Olubodun, F. (1996). “An empirical approach to the evaluation of factors in local authority housing.” Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Salford, Manchester, UK.
Omdahl, T. P., ed. (1988). MIL-STD-1629A: Reliability, availability, and maintainability (RAM) dictionary, American Society for Quality Control Press, Milwaukee.
Rausand, M., and Hoyland, A. (2004). System reliability theory: Models, statistical methods, and applications, 2nd Ed., Wiley-Interscience, Hoboken, NJ.
Richardson, B. A. (1991). Defects and deterioration in buildings, E & FN Spon, London.
Shen, Q. P., Lo, K. K., and Wang, Q. (1998). “Priority setting in maintenance management of public buildings—A modified multi-attribute approach using analytic hierarchy process.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 16(6), 693–702.
Shohet, I. M. (2003). “Building evaluation methodology for setting maintenance priorities in hospital buildings.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 21(7), 681–692.
Shohet, I. M., and Perelstein, E. (2004). “Decision support model for the allocation of resources in rehabilitation projects.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 130(2), 249–257.
Sctrick, L., and Goussy, B. (2003). “Biological hazards—Risk of accidents involving exposure to blood and other fluids.” 〈http://anmteph.chez-alice.fr/docuniqaes.pdf〉 (Oct. 21, 2007).
Sommerville, J. (2007). “Defects and rework in new build: An analysis of the phenomenon and drivers.” Struct. Surv., 25(5), 391–407.
SPRING Singapore. (2002). “Code of practice for construction electronic measurement standards (CEMS)—Standard method of measurement (SMM) for building works.” SS CP 97-1: 2002, SPRING, Singapore.
SPRING Singapore. (2004). “Code of practice for construction electronic measurement standard (CEMS)—Standard method of measurement for mechanical and electrical works.” SS CP 97-2, SPRING, Singapore.
Talon, A., Chevalier, J. L., and Hans, J. (2006). Failure modes effects and criticality analysis research for and application to the building domain, CIB Publication, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Talon, A., Boissier, D., Hans, J., Lacasse, M. A., and Chorier, J. (2008). “FMECA and management of building components.” Proc., 11DBMC 11th Int. Conf. on Durability of Bldg. Materials & Components, Istanbul Technical Univ., Istanbul, Turkey.
Tan, W. (2008). Practical research methods, 3nd Ed. (revised), Pearson Education, Singapore.
Tay, L., and Ooi, J. T. L. (2001). “Facilities management: A ’Jack of all trades.’ ” Facilities, 19(10), 357–362.
Vanier, D. J., Lacasse, M. A., and Parsons, A. (1996). “Using product models to represent user requirements.” Proc., CIB Workshop Constr. on the Information Highway, Bled, Slovenia.
Villacourt, M. (1992). Failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA): A guide for continuous improvement for the semiconductor equipment industry (Technology Transfer #92020963B-ENG), International SEMATECH, Austin, TX.
von Nitzsch, R., and Weber, M. (1993). “The effect of attribute ranges on weights in multiattribute utility measurements.” Manage. Sci., 39(8), 937–943.
Walker, D. (1997). “Choosing an appropriate research methodology.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 15(2), 149–159.
Wani, M. F., and Gandhi, O. P. (1999). “Development of maintainability index for mechanical systems.” Reliab. Eng. Syst. Saf., 65(3), 259–270.
Wardhana, K., and Hadipriono, F. C. (2003). “Analysis of recent bridge failures in the United States.” J. Perform. Constr. Facil., 17(3), 144–150.
Watt, S. D. (1999). Building pathology: Principles and practice, Blackwell Science, Oxford.
Wong, J. K., and Li, H. (2006). “Development of a conceptual model for the selection of intelligent building systems.” Build. Environ., 41(8), 1106–1123.
Yeung, H. W. C. (1995). “Qualitative personal interviews in international business research: Some lessons from a study of Hong Kong transnational corporations.” Int. Bus. Rev., 4(3), 313–339.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Volume 25 • Issue 6 • December 2011
Pages: 522 - 533
Copyright
© 2011 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Jul 4, 2010
Accepted: Jan 19, 2011
Published online: Jan 20, 2011
Published in print: Dec 1, 2011
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.