Representation of Snow in Urban Drainage Models
Publication: Journal of Hydrologic Engineering
Volume 5, Issue 4
Abstract
Modeling guidelines of parsimony (simplicity of assumptions), accuracy, modesty, and testability are discussed in terms of urban snowmelt induced runoff. Heterogeneity and variability at the 10–100-m spatial and <1 day timescales of snow distribution, energy availability, and surface permeability in urban environments are outlined. The snow accumulation and melt routines of three drainage models that have been applied to urban settings are reviewed; two of these, MouseNAM and SWMM, were designed for urbanized catchments; the third, HBV, is a regional-scale model for rural catchments. The surface hydrology of the models have varying degrees of complexity. All contain a temperature index for melt—this method is shown to be theoretically unsound without modification for urban simulations. There are discordant scales between processes important for snowmelt runoff generation and those modeled. Literature on model development, validation, and application is lacking. Urban snow data are also sparse, which limits the possibility of assessing or improving model performance.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
1.
Anderson, E. A. ( 1973). “National Weather Service river forecast system—Snow accumulation and ablation model.” NOAA Tech. Memo. NWS HYDRO-17, U.S. Department of Commerce, Washington, D.C.
2.
Bengtsson, L. ( 1982). “The importance of refreezing on the diurnal snowmelt cycle with application to a northern Swedish catchment.” Nordic Hydrol., Lyngby, Denmark, 13, 1–12.
3.
Bengtsson, L. ( 1984). “Modeling snowmelt induced runoff with short time resolution.” Proc., 3rd Int. Conf. Urban Storm Drain., Gothenburg, Sweden, 305–314.
4.
Bengtsson, L. ( 1986). “Snowmelt simulation models in relation to space and time.” Proc., Budapest Symp. 1986, Modelling Snowmelt-Induced Processes, International Association of Hydrological Sciences, Wallingford, U.K., 115–123.
5.
Bengtsson, L., Seuna, P., Lepistö, A., and Saxena, R. K. ( 1992). “Particle movement of melt water in a subdrained agricultural basin.” J. Hydro., Amsterdam, 135, 383–398.
6.
Bengtsson, L., and Westerström, G. ( 1992). “Urban snowmelt and runoff in northern Sweden.” Hydrological Sci. J., IAHS, Wallingford, U.K., 37, 263–275.
7.
Bergström, S. ( 1976). “Development and application of a conceptual runoff model for Scandinavian catchments.” Hydrologi och Oceanografi, No. RHO 7, SMHI, Norrköping, Sweden.
8.
Bergström, S. ( 1991). “Principles and confidence in hydrological modelling.” Nordic Hydro., Lyngby, Denmark, 22, 123–136.
9.
Bergström, S. ( 1995). “The HBV model.” Computer models of watershed hydrology, V. P. Singh, ed., Water Resources Publications, Highlands Ranch, Colo., 443–476.
10.
Bergström, S., and Graham, L. H. ( 1998). “On the scale problem in hydrological modelling.” J. Hydro., Amsterdam, 211, 253–265.
11.
Beven, K. ( 1993). “Prophecy, reality and uncertainty in distributed hydrological modelling.” Adv. in Water Res., 16, 41–51.
12.
Blöschl, G. ( 1991). “The influence of uncertainty in air temperature and albedo on snowmelt.” Nordic Hydro., Lyngby, Denmark, 22, 95–108.
13.
Blöschl, G., and Kirnbauer, R. ( 1991). “Point snowmelt models with different degrees of complexity–internal processes.” J. Hydro., Amsterdam, 129, 127–147.
14.
Buttle, J. M., and Sami, K. ( 1990). “Recharge processes during snowmelt: An isotopic and hydrometric investigation.” Hydrological Processes, Wiley, New York, 4, 343–360.
15.
Buttle, J. M., and Xu, F. ( 1988). “Snowmelt runoff in suburban environments.” Nordic Hydro., Lyngby, Denmark, 18, 19–40.
16.
Cazorzi, F., and Dalla Fontana, G. ( 1996). “Snowmelt modelling by combining air temperature and a distributed radiation index.” J. Hydro., Amsterdam, 181, 169–187.
17.
Colbeck, S. C. ( 1991). “The layered character of snow covers.” Rev. of Geophys., 29(1), 81–96.
18.
Conway, H., Gades, A., and Raymond, C. F. ( 1996). “Albedo of dirty snow during conditions of melt.” Water Resour. Res., 32(6), 1713–1718.
19.
Dozier, J. ( 1987). “Recent research in snow hydrology.” Rev. of Geophys., 25(2), 153–161.
20.
Engelmark, H. ( 1984). “Infiltration in unsaturated frozen soil.” Nordic Hydro., Lyngby, Denmark, 15, 243–252.
21.
Espeby, B. ( 1990). “An analysis of saturated hydraulic conductivity in a forested glacial till slope.” Soil Sci., 150(2), 485–494.
22.
Falk, J. ( 1990). “Snöupplag: Lokalisering och drift [Snow deposits: location and operation].” Naturevåardsverket Rapport 3785, Solna, Sweden (in Swedish).
23.
Färm, C. ( 1992). “Bräddningsproblem i Norrlandsregionen [Overflow problems in the Norrland region].” MS thesis, VA-Teknik Rapport 38, Luleåa University of Technology, Luleåa, Sweden (in Swedish).
24.
Ferguson, R. I., and Morris, E. M. ( 1987). “Snowmelt modelling in the Cairngorms, NE Scotland.” Trans. Royal Soc.: Earth Sci., Edinburgh, U.K., 78, 261–267.
25.
Gray, D. M., and Prowse, T. D. ( 1993). “Snow and floating ice.” Handbook of hydrology, D. R. Maidment, ed., McGraw-Hill, New York, 7.1–7.58.
26.
Gustafsson, L. G., Lindberg, S., and Olsson, R. ( 1991). “Modelling of the indirect runoff component in urban areas.” Proc., Int. Conf. Urban Drain. and New Technol., Č. Maksimović, ed., Elsevier Science, London, 127–133.
27.
Hernebring, C. ( 1996). “Snösmältningspåaverkan påa avloppssytem inom urbana områaden [Snowmelt induced runoff in sewer systems].” VAV VA-Forsk Publ. 1996-07 (in Swedish with English summary).
28.
Hernebring, C., Marklund, S., and Gustafsson, L.-G. ( 1997). “Modelling of flow components in sewer systems influenced by snowmelt processes using the MouseNAM concept.” 2nd DHI Software User Conf., Danish Hydrological Inst., Helsingør.
29.
Hillel, D. ( 1987). “Modelling in soil physics: A critical review.” Future developments in soil science research, Soil Science Society of America, Madison, Wis., 35–42.
30.
Hogland, W. ( 1994). “Hydrological and environmental effects of agricultural and urban activities in a small Swedish river basin.” Nordic Hydro., Lyngby, Denmark, 25, 247–266.
31.
Huber, W. C., and Dickinson, R. E. ( 1988). “Stormwater management model user's manual; version 4.” EPA/600/3-88/001a (NTIS PB88-236641/AS), U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Athens, Ga.
32.
Kaczmarkek, Z. ( 1991). “A few comments on the future of the science of hydrology.” Proc., Int. Symp. 25 Years of IHD/IHP, UNESCO, Paris, 51–53.
33.
Kirnbauer, R., Blöschl, G., and Gutknecht, D. ( 1994). “Entering the age of distributed snow models.” Nordic Hydro., Lyngby, Denmark, 25, 1–24.
34.
Klemeš, V. ( 1983). “Conceptualization and scale in hydrology.” J. Hydro., Amsterdam, 65, 1–23.
35.
Klemeš, V. ( 1991). “The science of hydrology: Where have we been? Where should we be going? What do hydrologists need to know?” Proc. Int. Symp. 25 Years of IHD/IHP, UNESCO, Paris, 41–50.
36.
Law, F. M. ( 1991). “Comments on Vit Klemeš paper.” Proc., Int. Symp. 25 Years of IHD/IHP, UNESCO, Paris, 55–57.
37.
Leavesley, G. H. ( 1989). “Problems of snowmelt runoff modelling for a variety of physiographic and climatic conditions.” Hydrological Sci. J., Wallingford, U.K., 34(6), 617–634.
38.
Lindström, G., Johansson, B., Persson, M., Gardelin, M., and Bergström, S. ( 1997). “Development and test of the distributed HBV-96 hydrological model.” J. Hydro., Amsterdam, 201, 272–288.
39.
Liston, G. E. ( 1995). “Local advection of momentum, heat, and moisture during the melt of patchy snow covers.” J. Appl. Meteorology, 17, 1833–1842.
40.
Marks, D., and Dozier, J. ( 1992). “Climate and energy exchange at the snow surface in the alpine region of the Sierra Nevada 2. Snow cover energy balance.” Water Resour. Res., 28(11), 3043–3054.
41.
Marsalek, J. ( 1991). “Urban drainage in cold climates: Problems, solutions and research needs.” Proc., Int. Conf. Urban Drain. and New Technol., Č. Maksimović, ed., Elsevier Science, London, 299–308.
42.
Marsh, P., and Woo, M.-K. ( 1984). “Wetting front advance and freezing meltwater within a snow cover. 1. Observations in the Canadian Arctic.” Water Resour. Res., 20(12), 1853–1864.
43.
Matheussen, B. V., and Thorolfsson, S. T. ( 1999). “Simulation errors due to insufficient temporal resolution in urban snowmelt models.” 8th Int. Conf. on Urban Storm Drainage, Sydney.
44.
MouseNAM Reference Manual 1.0. (1994). Danish Hydraulic Institute, Hørsholm, Denmark.
45.
Neumann, N., and Marsh, P. ( 1998). “Local advection of sensible heat in the snowmelt landscape of Arctic tundra.” Hydrological Processes, New York, 12, 1547–1560.
46.
Niemczynowicz, J. ( 1996). “Part 1: Rainfall measurement, processing, and application in urban hydrology.” Rain and floods in our cities: Gauging the problem., Tech. Rep. in Hydrology and Water Resour. No. 53 (WMO/TD-No. 741), Č. Maksimović, ed., World Meteorological Organisation, Geneva.
47.
Pomeroy, J. W., and Gray, D. M. ( 1995). “Snowcover accumulation, relocation and management.” Nat. Hydro. Res. Inst. Sci. Rep. No. 7, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Sask., Canada.
48.
Rango, A., and Martinec, J. ( 1982). “Snow accumulation derived from modified depletion curves of snow coverage.” Proc. Exeter Symp., Hydrologic Aspects of Alpine and High Mountain Areas, International Association of Hydrological Sciences, Wallingford, U.K., 83–90.
49.
Sand, K. ( 1990). “Modelling snowmelt runoff processes in temperate and arctic environments.” PhD thesis, Div. of Hydr. and Sanit. Engrg., University of Trondheim, Trondheim, Norway.
50.
Savas, E. S. ( 1973). “The political properties of crystalline H2O: Planning for snow emergencies in New York.” Mgmt. Sci., 20(2), 137–145.
51.
Schilling, W. ( 1991). Rainfall data for urban hydrology: What do we need?” Atmos. Res., 27, 5–21.
52.
Semádeni-Davies, A. F. ( 1998). “Modelling snowmelt induced waste water inflows.” Nordic Hydro., Lyngby, Denmark, 29(4/5), 285–302.
53.
Semádeni-Davies, A. F. ( 1999). “Snow-cover heterogeneity in Luleåa, Sweden.” Urban Water, 1, 39–47.
54.
Semadeni-Davies, A. F., and Bengtsson, L. ( 1998). “Snowmelt sensitivity to radiation in the urban environment.” Hydrological Sci. J., 43(1), 67–89.
55.
Singh, V. P., and Fiorentino, M., eds. ( 1996). Geographical information systems in hydrology, Vol. 26., Water Science and Technology Library, Kluwer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
56.
Shook, K., and Gray, D. M. ( 1997). “Synthesizing shallow seasonal snow covers.” Water Resour. Res., 33(3), 419–426.
57.
Sundin, E. ( 1998). “An approach to use the degree day method on urban snow deposit melt.” Vatten, Stockholm, 54, 123–130.
58.
Takamura, T., and Toritani, H. ( 1994). “Surface reflectance in an urbanized area with snow cover.” Snow and ice covers: Interactions with the atmosphere and ecosystems, International Association of Hydrological Sciences, Wallingford, U.K., 197–212.
59.
Thorolfsson, S. T., and Brandt, J. ( 1996). “The influence of snowmelt on urban runoff in Norway.” Proc., 7th Int. Conf. on Urban Storm Drain., IAHR/IAWQ, Pergamon, Oxford, England, 133–138.
60.
Thorolfsson, S. T., and Killingtveit, åA. ( 1991). “The use of conceptual hydrological models for modelling urban runoff form precipitation and snowmelt.” Proc., Int. Conf. Urban Drain. and New Technol., Č. Maksimović, ed., Elsevier Science, London, 317–324.
61.
Thorolfsson, S. T., and Sand, K. ( 1991). “Urban snowmelt research in Norway: Measurements and modelling approach.” Proc., Int. Conf. Urban Drain. and New Technol., Č. Maksimović, ed., Elsevier Science, New York, 309–316.
62.
Todhunter, P. E., Xu, F., and Buttle, J. M. ( 1992). “A model of net radiation over suburban snowpacks.” Atmospheric, Pergamon, Oxford, England, 26B(1), 17–27.
63.
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers ( 1956). “Snow hydrology, summary report of the snow investigations.” Rep., North Pacific Division, Portland, Oreg.
64.
Westerström, G. ( 1984). “Snowmelt runoff from Porsön residential area. Luleåa, Sweden.” Proc., 3rd Int. Conf. Urban Storm Drain., Chalmers University of Technolgoy, Gothenburg, 315–323.
65.
Woo, M. K., and Giesbrecht, M. ( 1999). “Snowmelt in a subarctic open woodland: Scale consideration.” Proc., 12th Northern Res. Basins Symp. and Workshop, IHP, 385–409.
66.
World Meteorological Organization (WMO). ( 1986). “Intercomparisons of models of snowmelt runoff operational hydrology.” Rep. No. 23 (WMO No. 646), Geneva.
67.
Xu, F., and Buttle, J. M. ( 1987). “Patterns of net radiation over urban snowpacks.” Proc., Eastern Snow Conf., 43, 173–184.
68.
Yen, B. C. ( 1986). “Rainfall-runoff process on urban catchments and its modeling.” Urban drainage modelling, Č. Maksimović and M. Radojković, eds., Pergamon, Oxford, England, 3–26.
69.
Zech, Y., Sillen, X., Debources, C., and Van Hauwaert, A. ( 1993). “Rainfall-runoff modelling of partly urbanized watersheds: Comparison between a distributed model using GIS and other model sensitivity analysis.” Water Sci. and Technol., 29(1–2), 163–170.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Hydrologic Engineering
Volume 5 • Issue 4 • October 2000
Pages: 363 - 370
History
Received: Sep 1, 1998
Published online: Oct 1, 2000
Published in print: Oct 2000
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.