Tree Root Intrusion in Sewer Systems: Review of Extent and Costs
Publication: Journal of Infrastructure Systems
Volume 7, Issue 1
Abstract
Interference between trees and sewer systems is likely to occur in old systems and in cracked pipes. Factors that contribute to damage include old pipes with joints, shallow pipes, small-dimension pipes, and fast-growing tree species. Because roots are reported to cause >50% of all sewer blockages, costs associated with root removal from sewers is substantial. In smaller-dimension pipes, root removal every year or every other year is common. Major resources are put into replacement and renewal of existing pipes, which is sometimes accelerated because of root intrusion. Collapse repair costs are greater than new construction, but costs associated with root removal may be one-sixth the cost of pipe replacement/renewal due to roots. Major breaks and stoppages seem to occur more frequently in older systems than in new. Therefore, it seems worthwhile to carry out preventative maintenance of the older parts of the sewer system.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
1.
Barker, P. A. ( 1983). “Some urban trees of California: Maintenance problems and genetic improvement possibilities.” Proc., 4th Biennial Conf. of the Metropolitan Tree Improvement Alliance, H. D. Gerhold, ed., School of Forest Resour., Pennsylvania State University, University Park, Pa., 47–54.
2.
Bernhardt, E., and Swicki, T. J. ( 1993). The state of urban forestry in California: Results of the 1992 California urban forest survey, California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, Sacramento, Calif.
3.
Biddle, P. G. ( 1998). Tree root damage to buildings. Patterns of soil drying in proximity to trees on clay soils, Vol. 2, Willowmead Publishing Ltd., Wantage, U.K.
4.
Bradshaw, A., Hunt, B., and Walmsley, T. ( 1995). Trees in the urban landscape. Principles and practice, E & FN Spon, London.
5.
Brennan, G., Patch, D., and Stevens, F. R. W. ( 1997). “Tree roots and underground pipes.” Arboriculture Research and Information Note No. 36-97-TRL, Arboricultural Advisory and Information Service, Surrey, U.K.
6.
Coder, K. D. ( 1998). “Root growth control: Managing perceptions and realities.” Proc., 2nd Int. Workshop on Tree Root Devel. in Urban Soils, The Landscape below Ground II, D. Neely and G. Watson, eds., International Society of Arboriculture, Savoy, Ill., 51–81.
7.
Craul, P. J. ( 1992). Urban soil in landscape design, Wiley, New York.
8.
Cullen, N. ( 1982). “The sewer dereliction problem—Evidence from collapse studies.” Proc., Int. Conf. Organized by Instn. of Civ. Engrs., Restoration of Sewerage Sys., J. E. V. Holmes, D. F. Rees, J. N. Rushbrooke, and W. B. Varley, eds., Thomas Telford, London, 9–16.
9.
Cutler, D. F. ( 1995). “Interactions between roots and buildings.” Proc., Int. Workship on Trees and Build., Trees and Building Sites, G. W. Watson and D. Neely, eds., International Society of Arboriculture, Savoy, Ill., 88–98.
10.
Cutler, D. F., and Richardson, B. K. ( 1989). Tree roots and buildings, 2nd Ed., Longman Scientific and Technical, Harlow, U.K.
11.
Danish Environmental Protection Agency (DEPA). ( 1992). “Fornyelse af aflobssystemer [Renewal of sewer systems].” Rep. No. 33, Ministry of Environment, Copenhagen (in Danish).
12.
Edwards, R. A., Rowe, R. N., and Trought, M. C. T. ( 1999). “Control of tree growth in the urban environment using geotextile fabric bags.” Arboriculture Res. and Information Note No. 148/99/EXT, Arboricultural Advisory and Information Service, Surrey, U.K.
13.
Geyer, J. C., and Lentz, J. L. ( 1964). “An evaluation of the problems of sanitary sewer system design.” Final Rep. of Residential Sewerage Res. Proj. to Fed. Housing Admin., Dept. of Sanitary Engrg. and Water Resourc., Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore.
14.
Groninger, J. W., Zedaker, S. M., and Seiler, J. R. ( 1997). “Herbicides to control tree roots in sewer lines.” J. Arboriculture, 23, 169–172.
15.
Harris, R. V., Clark, J. R., and Matheny, N. P. ( 1999). Arboriculture, integrated management of landscape trees, shrubs, and vines, 3rd Ed., Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle River, N.J.
16.
Holmes, J. E. V., Rees, D. F., Rushbrooke, J. N., and Varley, W. B., eds. ( 1982). Proc., Int. Conf. Organized by Instn. of Civ. Engrs., Restoration of Sewerage Sys., Thomas Telford, London.
17.
Hood, J. W. ( 1957). Copper sulfate for root and fungus control in sanitary sewers and storm drains, Phelps Dodge Refining Corp., New York.
18.
Jim, C. Y. ( 1998a). “Physical and chemical properties of a Hong Kong roadside soil in relation to urban tree growth.” Urban Ecosystems, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2, 171–181.
19.
Jim, C. Y. ( 1998b). “Urban soil characteristics and limitations for landscape planting in Hong Kong.” Landscape and Urban Plng., 40, 235–249.
20.
Kopinga, J. ( 1991). “The effects of restricted volumes of soil on the growth and development of street trees.” J. Arboriculture, 17, 57–63.
21.
Kristoffersen, P., and Tvedt, T. ( 1999). “Afvikling af pesticider påa alle offentlige arealer inden 2003 [Phase out of pesticides on all public land before 2003].” Videnblade Park og Landskab No. 3.5-10, Danish Forest and Landscape Research Institute, Hoersholm, Denmark (in Danish).
22.
MacLeod, R. D., and Cram, W. J. ( 1996). “Forces exerted by tree roots.” Arboriculture research and information note, 134/96/EXT, Arboricultural Advisory and Information Service, Surrey, U.K.
23.
McPherson, E. G. ( 2000). “Expenditures associated with conflicts between street tree root growth and hardscape in California, United States.” J. Arboriculture, 26, 289–297.
24.
McPherson, E. G., and Peper, P. J. ( 1995). “Infrastructure repair costs associated with street trees in 15 cities.” Proc., Int. Workshop on Trees and Build., Trees and Build. Sites, G. W. Watson and D. Neely, eds., International Society of Arboriculture, Savoy, Ill., 49–64.
25.
McPherson, E. G., Simpson, J. R., Peper, P., and Xiao, Q. ( 1999a). Tree guidelines for San Joaquin Valley communities, Western Ctr. for Urban Forest Res. and Educ., U.S. Dept. of Agriculture Forest Service Pacific Southwest Res. Station, University of California, Davis, Calif.
26.
McPherson, E. G., Simpson, J. R., Peper, P., and Xiao, Q. ( 1999b). “Benefit-cost analysis of Modesto's municipal urban forest.” J. Arboriculture, 25, 235–248.
27.
Morell, J. D. ( 1992). “Competition for space in the urban infrastructure.” J. Arboriculture, 18, 73–75.
28.
Nicoll, B. C., and Coutts, M. P. ( 1997). “Direct damage by urban tree roots: Paving the way for less damaging street trees.” Arboricultural practice, present and future, J. Claridge, ed., Department of Environment, Transport and Regions, London, 77–84.
29.
Perkins, P. H. ( 1982). “Corrosion problems in sewerage structures.” Proc., Int. Conf. Organized by Instn. of Civ. Engrs., Restoration of Sewerage Sys., J. E. V. Holmes, D. F. Rees, J. N. Rushbrooke, and W. B. Varley, eds., Thomas Telford, London, 133–139.
30.
Randrup, T. B. ( 2001). “Occurrence of tree roots in Danish municipal sewer systems.” Arboricultural J., Hereford, U.K., in press.
31.
Randrup, T. B., and Faldager, I. ( 1997). “Trærødder i afløbsledninger [Tree roots in sewer systems].” Park-og Landskabsserien No. 14-1997, Danish Forest and Landscape Research Institute, Hoersholm, Denmark (in Danish with English summary).
32.
Reed, E. C. ( 1982). “The assessment of the problem in the UK.” Proc., Int. Conf. Organized by Instn. of Civ. Engrs., Restoration of Sewerage Sys., J. E. V. Holmes, D. F. Rees, J. N. Rushbrooke, and W. B. Varley, eds., Thomas Telford, London, 3–8.
33.
Rolf, K., and Stal, O. ( 1994). “Tree roots in sewer systems in Malmö, Sweden.” J. Arboriculture, 20, 329–335.
34.
Rolf, K., Stal, O., and Schroeder, H. ( 1995). “Tree roots and sewer systems.” Proc., Int. Workshop on Trees and Build., Trees and Build. Sites, G. W. Watson and D. Neely, eds., International Society of Arboriculture, Savoy, Ill., 68–77.
35.
Russell, R. S. ( 1977). Plant root systems: Their function and interaction with the soil, McGraw-Hill, New York.
36.
Schrock, B. J., ed. ( 1994). “Existing sewer evaluation and rehabilitation.” Prepared by Joint Task Force of Water Envir. Fedn. and ASCE, WEF Manual of Pract. FD-6, ASCE Manuals and Rep. on Engrg. Pract. No. 62, 2nd Ed., ASCE, New York.
37.
Stal, O. ( 1996). “Rotinträgning i avloppsledningar. En undersökning av omfattning och kostnader i Sveriges kommuner [Root intrusion in sewer pipes. A study of the extent of root intrusion in Sweden's municipalities].” Svenska Vatten-och Avloppsverksforeningen, VAV, Svensk Byggtjanst, Litteraturtjanst, 171 88 Solna, Sweden (in Swedish with English summary).
38.
Stal, O., and Rolf, K. ( 1998). “Tree roots and infrastructure.” Proc., 2nd Int. Workshop on Tree Root Devel. in Urban Soils, Landscape below Ground II, D. Neely and G. Watson, eds., International Society of Arboriculture, Savoy, Ill., 125–130.
39.
Stal, O., and Rosenlof, J. ( 1995). “Trädrötter och avloppsledningar. En fördjupad undersökning av rotproblem i nya avloppsledningar [Tree roots and sewer pipes. Root intrusion in new sewer pipes].” Svenska Vatten-och Avloppsverksforeningen, VAV, Svensk Byggtjanst, Litteraturtjanst, 171 88 Solna, Sweden (in Swedish with English summary).
40.
Sullivan, R. H., Gemmell, R. S., Schafer, L. A., and Hurst, W. D. ( 1977). Economic analysis, root control, and backwater flow control as related to infiltration/inflow control, Municipal Envir. Res. Lab., Ofc. of Res. and Devel., U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Cincinnati.
41.
Watson, G. W. ( 1994). “Root development after transplanting.” Proc., Int. Workshop on Tree Root Devel. in Urban Soils, Landscape below Ground, G. W. Watson and D. Neely, eds., International Society of Arboriculture, Champaign, Ill., 54–68.
42.
Watson, G. W., and Himelick, E. B. ( 1997). Principles and practice of planting trees and shrubs, International Society of Arboriculture, Savoy, Ill.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Infrastructure Systems
Volume 7 • Issue 1 • March 2001
Pages: 26 - 31
History
Received: May 30, 2000
Published online: Mar 1, 2001
Published in print: Mar 2001
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.