Limits to Water Privatization
Publication: Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management
Volume 134, Issue 6
Abstract
Water allocation under conditions of water scarcity is a looming issue that threatens the economic well being and quality of life of many of the world’s people. Although the causes of water scarcity are varied, many assert the inefficiencies and failures of water allocation by the public sector are to blame. One solution offered by proponents is to privatize the water allocation process, thereby allowing the efficiencies of the market place to resolve most issues. The thesis of this paper is that while privatization of many aspects of the water allocation process may bring increased efficiencies, certain core functions must remain with the public sector. These core functions include the ultimate decision making authority over the assignment of water rights as well as oversight authority to protect and secure both the rights of third parties and those private and public activities and values that may depend on existing uses. While the legal right to the use of water may be placed in the hands of the private sector, these rights must be closely controlled and managed by public institutions.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
Apogee Research, Inc. (1996). “Monetary measurement of environmental goods and services: Framework and summary of techniques for corps planners.” IWR Rep. No. 96-R-24, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Water Resources Support Center, Alexandria, Va.
Asian Development Bank (ADB). (1997). Guidelines for the economic analysis of project, ADB, Manila, Philippines.
Bandaragoda, D. J. (2000). “A framework for institutional analysis for water resources management in a river basin context.” Working Paper No. 5, International Water Management Institute, Colombo, Sri Lanka.
Barlow, M., and Clarke, T. (2002). Blue gold, Stoddart, Toronto.
Bauer, C. J. (2004). Siren song: Chilean water law as a model for international reform. Resources for the future, Resources for the Future, Washington, D.C.
Catley-Carlson, M. (2002). “Water—Key to sustainable development.” Proc., Int. Freshwater Conf. in Bonn, ⟨water-2001.de/outcome/reports/Brief_report_en.pdf6⟩ (Feb. 12, 2008).
Cummings, R. G., Keeler, A., and Thompson, B. (2002). “Georgia water—A public resource or a commodity: What are the real policy questions?” Water Policy Working Paper No. 2002-0081, ⟨gsu.edu/~wwwenv/waterPDF/W2002008.pdf⟩ (Feb. 12 2008).
Dasgupta, P., Kristrom, B., and Maler, K. G. (1995). “Current issues in resource accounting.” Current issues in environmental economics, P.-O. Johansson, B. Kristrom, and K.-G. Maler, eds.
de Haan, E. J. (1997). “Balancing free trade in water and the protection of water resources in GATT.” The scarcity of water: Emerging legal and policy responses, E. Brans, E. de Haan, A. Nollkaemper, and J. Rinzema, eds., 245–259.
Dellapenna, J. W., ed. (1997). Regulated Riparian model water code, ASCE, Reston, Va.
Dellapenna, J. W. (2000). “The importance of getting names right: The myth of markets for water.” William and Mary environmental law and policy review, Vol. 25, 317–377.
Dellapenna, J. W., and Draper, S. E. (2002). “Straight talk about markets for water.” Rep. Prepared for the Comprehensive State Water Plan Joint Study Committee, ⟨cviog.uga.edu/services/policy/environmental/georgiacommittee/whitepapers⟩ (Feb. 12, 2008).
DeMeo, T. (2003). “Rural and urban water tours foster invaluable information exchange on Georgia’s regional water resource issues.” Rep. Prepared for the Association of County Commissioners of Georgia, Atlanta.
de Waart, P. J. I. M. (2000). “Securing access to safe drinking water through trade and international migration.” The scarcity of water: Emerging legal and policy responses, E. Brans, E. de Haan, A. Nollkaemper, and J. Rinzema, eds., 100–121.
Dinar, A., Howitt, R. E., Rassenti, S. J., and Smith, V. L. (1998). “Development of water market using experimental economics.” Markets for water: Potential and performancee, K. W. Easter, M. W. Rosegrant, and A. Dinar, eds., Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
Dinar, A., Rosegrant, M. W., and Meinzen-Dick, R. (1997). “Water allocation mechanisms: Principles and examples.” Policy Research Working Paper No. 1779, The World Bank, Washington, D.C.
Doughman, P. M. (2001). “Discourses and water in the U.S.–Mexico border region.” Reflections on water: New approaches to transboundary conflicts and cooperation, J. Blatter and H. Ingram, eds., 189–211.
Draper, S. E. ed. (2002a). Model water sharing agreements for the 21st century, ASCE, Reston, Va.
Draper, S. E. (2002b). “Water issues white paper: Modification of permits based on consumptive use.” Joint Comprehensive State Water Plan Study Committee, ⟨cviog.uga.edu/services/policy/environmental/georgiacommittee/whitepapers⟩ (Feb. 12, 2008).
Draper, S. E. (2005). “The unintended consequences of tradable property rights to water.” Nat. Resour. Environ., 20(1), 49–55.
Draper, S. E. (2007). “Impact of climate change on transboundary water resources.” J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage., 133(5), 405–415.
DuMars, C. T. (2001). “Commerce clause constraints on regional use of groundwater resources.” Rep. Prepared for Dr. Ronald G. Cummings, Andrew Young School of Policy Studies, Georgia State Univ., Atlanta.
Easter, K. W., and Gershon Feder, F. (1997). “Water institutions, incentives, and markets.” Decentralization and coordination of water resource management, D. Parker and Y. Tsur, eds., Kluwer Academic, Boston.
Environment Canada. (2003). Water policy and legislation, ⟨ec.gc.ca/WATER/en/ policy/federal/e_FNWMS-2.htm⟩ (Feb. 12, 2008).
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). (1993). The state of food and agriculture, Rome.
Ford, S., Butcher, G., Edmonds, K., and Braggins, A. (2001). “Economic efficiency of water allocation.” MAF Technical Paper No. 2001/7, Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, New Zealand.
Fort, D. D., Chair. (1998). “Water in the West: Challenge for the next century.” Rep. of the Western water Policy Review Advisory Commission, June.
Garcia-Acevedo, M. R. (2001). “The confluence of water, patterns of settlement, and construction of the border in the imperial and Mexicali valleys (1900–1999).” Reflections on water: New approaches to transboundary conflicts and cooperation, Blatter and Ingram, eds., MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Gentry, B. D. S., and Auyuan, A. T. (2000). Global trends in urban water supply and waste water financing and management: Changing roles for the public and private sectors, ccnm/env, 36/final, Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris.
Gillilan, D. M., and Brown, T. C. (1997). Instream low protection: Seeking a balance in western water use, Island Press, Washington, D.C.
Gleick, P. H. (1998). “Water in crisis: Paths to sustainable water use.” Entrepreneurship Theory Pract., 8(3), 571–579.
Gooch, G. D., Höglund, P., Roll, G., Lopman, E., and Aliakseyeva, N. (2002). “Review of existing structures, models and practices for transboundary water management.” Prepared for the European Commission under the Fifth Framework Program and Contributing to the Implementation of the Key Action, Sustainable Management and Quality of Water within the Energy, Environment and Sustainable Development EVK1-CT-2000-00076.
Griswold, D. T. (2001). “Cato Journal book review, Anderson, Terry L. and Donald R. Leal, free market environmentalism, Palgrave, New York, NY.” ⟨cato.org/pubs/journal/cj22n1/cj22n1_12.pdf⟩ (Feb. 11, 2008).
Hackett, S. C. (1998). Environmental and natural resources economics: Theory, policy, and the sustainable society, M. E. Sharpe, ed., New York.
Hall, D. (2001). “Water in public hands.” Public sector water management—A necessary option, PSIRU, University of Greenwich, ⟨psiru.org/publicationsindex.asp⟩, (Feb. 11 2008).
Heal, G. (2000). Nature and the marketplace, Island Press, Washington, D.C.
Hermans, L., and Hellegers, P. (2005). “A new economy for water for food and ecosystems synthesis report of E-forum results, food and agriculture Organization of the United Nations.” Proc., Int. Conf. on Water for Food and Ecosystems, Water Resources, Development, and Management Service and Agricultural Economics Research Institute (LEI), Wageningen UR, FAO, The Netherlands, ⟨fao.org/ag/wfe2005/docs/Synthesis_ theme2.pdf⟩ (Feb. 11 2008).
Hirji, R., and Ibrekk, H. O. (2001). “Environmental and water resources management.” Environment strategy paper No. 2, The World Bank, Washington, D.C.
Houston, L. L., Kline, J. D., and Alig, R. J. (2002). “Economics research supporting water resource stewardship in the pacific northwest.” Pacific Northwest Research Station General Technical Rep No. PNW-GTR-550, United States Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Washington, D.C.
Howe, C. (1986). “Innovative approaches to water allocation: The potential for water markets.” Water Resour. Res., 22(4), 439–445.
Ingram, H. (1990). Water politics: Continuity and change, University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque, N.M.
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). (2001). ⟨www.ipcc.ch.
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). (2007). ⟨www.ipcc.ch⟩ (Jan. 4, 2008).
Johannsson, M., Johansson, P., Jonsson, B., and Soderqvist, T. (1995). “Valuing changes in health: Theoretical and empirical issues.” Current issues in environmental economics, P.-O. Johansson, B. Kristrom, and K.-G. Male, eds., Manchester University Press, Manchester, U.K.
Just, R. E., Horowitz, J. K., and Netanyahu, S. (1997). “Peace and prospects for international water projects in the Jordan-Yarmouk River Basin.” Decentralization and coordination of water resource management, D. Parker and Y. Tsur, eds., Kluwer Academic, Boston.
Kakebeeke, W., Wouters, P., and Bouman, N. (2000). Water management: Guidance on public participation and compliance with agreements, ECE/UNEP Network of Expert on Public Participation and Compliance, Geneva, Switzerland.
Karkkainen, T. (2001). “Pennies from Heaven: Pricing irrigation water.” Research Rep. No. 2001, Helsinki Univ. of Technology, Helsinki, Finland.
Le Moigne, G., Dinar, A., and Giltner, S. (1997). “Principles and examples for the allocation of scarce resources among economic sectors.” Aspects économiques de la gestion de l’eau ans le bassin méditerranéen (Options Méditerranéennes, Série A. No 31), B. Dupuy, ed., CIHEAM-IAM, 87–102.
Loehman, E., Nir Becker, E., and Weg, M. H (1999). “Cooperation in a hydro-geologic commons: New institutions and pricing to achieve sustainability and security.” Regional Conf. of the International Water Resources Association, Jerusalem, June.
Lubell, M. (2000). “Cognitive conflict and consensus building in the national estuary program.” Am. Behav. Sci., 44(4), 628–647.
Lund, J. R., and Israel, M. (1995). “Water transfers in water resource systems.” J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage., 121(2), 193–205.
Mentor, J. J. (2001). “Trading water, trading places: Water marketing in Chile and the Western United States.” Globalization and Water Resources Management: The Changing Value of Water, Proc., AWRA/IWLRI-University of Dundee International Specialty Conf., AWRA/IWLRI, Dundee, Scotland, U.K.
Mikula, G. (1980). Justice and social interaction. Experimental and theoretical contributions from psychological research, Springer, New York.
Mitchell, R. C., and Carson, R. T. (1995). “Current issues in the design, administration, and analysis of contingent valuation surveys.” Current issues in environmental economics, P. O. Johansson, B. Kristrom, and K. G. Male, eds., Cambridge University Press, Boston.
Mohamed, K. A. (1998). “The Nile: Sharing experiences, sharing visions.” International Round Table, Transboundary Water Management Experience of International River and Lake Commissions, Berlin Recommendations, German Foundation for International Development (DSE), ⟨inwent.org/ef-texte/nile/rep.htm⟩ (Feb. 11, 2008).
Mohanty, N., and Gupta, S. (2002). “Breaking the gridlock in water reforms through water markets: International experience and implementation issues for India.” Working paper series, Julian L. Simon Centre for Policy Research, ⟨libertyindia.org/policy_reports/water_markets_2002.pdf⟩ (Feb. 10, 2008).
Morgan, S. P., and Chapman, J. J. (1995). “Special district privatization.” Report Prepared for the Association of California Water Agencies (ACWA), Sacramento, Calif.
Murakami, M. (1995). Managing water for peace in the Middle East: Alternative strategies, United Nations University (UNU) on Sustaining Global Life-support Systems, United Nations University Press, Tokyo.
National Research Council, Committee on Valuing Ground Water, Water Science and Technology Board, Commission on Geosciences, Environment, and Resources. (1997). Valuing ground water: Economic concepts and approaches, The National Academy Press, Washington, D.C.
NSW Department of Land and Water Conservation. (1998). Water sharing: The way forward, Sydney, December.
Olem, H., and Duda, A. M. (1995). “International watercourses: The World Bank looks toward a more comprehensive approach to management.” Water Sci. Technol., 31(8), 345–352.
Page, T. (1977). Conservation and economic efficiency, Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore.
Perlman, M. (2003). The perverse economy, Palgrave-Macmillan, New York.
Perry, C. J., Rock, M., and Seckler, D. (1997). “Water as an Economic good: A solution or a problem?” Research Rep. No. 14, International Irrigation Management Institute, Colombo, Sri Lanka.
Pigram, J. J. (1997). “Australia’s water situation: Resource allocation and management in a maturing system.” Decentralization and coordination of water resource management, D. Parker and Y. Tsur, eds., Kluwer Academic, Boston.
Planning and Management Consultants, Ltd. (2000). “U.S. Army Corps of Engineers regional listening session meeting notes.” Rep. Submitted to U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Alexandria, Va.
Rosegrant, M. W., and Binswanger, H. P. (1994). “Markets in tradable water rights: Potential for efficiency gains in developing-country water resource allocation.” World Dev., 22(11), 1613–162.
Rothfeder, J. (2001). Every drop for sale, J. P. Tarcher, ed., Putnam, New York.
Roumasset, J. (1997). “Designing institutions for water management.” Decentralization and coordination of water resource management, D. Parker and Y. Tsur, eds., Kluwer Academic, Boston.
Segerfelot, F. (2003). Water for sale: How business and the market can resolve the world’s water crisis, The Cato Institute, Washington, D.C.
Shen, D. (2003). “Water rights and their management: A comparative country study and its implication for China.” Rethinking water management: Innovative approaches to contemporary issues, C. Figueres, C. Tortajada, and J. Rockstrom, eds., Earthscan Publications, Sterling, Va.
Shiva, V. (2002). Water wars: Privatization, pollution and profit, South End Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Stockton, W. C., and Jacoby, G. C., Jr. (1976). “Long-term surface-water supply and streamflow trends in the upper Colorado River Basin based on tree-ring analyses.” Lake Powell Research Project Bull. No. 18, Univ. of Arizona, Tucson, Ariz.
Tarlock, A. D. (1997). Decentralization and coordination of water resource management, D. Parker and Y. Tsur, eds., Kluwer Academic, Boston.
Thobani, M. (1997). Formal water markets: Why, when, and how to introduce tradable water, The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, World Bank, Washington, D.C.
Tietenberg, T. H. (1998). Environmental economics and policy, Addison-Wesley, Boston.
Tucker, I. B., III. (1995). Survey of economics, South-Western, Mason, Ohio.
United Nations (UN). (2002). “Water for people, water for life.” The United Nations World Water Development Rep., UNESCO, Paris.
U.S. Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations. (1991). Coordinating water resources in the federal system: The groundwater-surface water connection, ACIR, Washington, D.C.
Weston, R. T. (2004). “Intershed watershed management—The Deleware and Susquehanna Basin experience.” Proc., Eastern Water Resources: Law, Policy and Technology, American Bar Association, Section on Environment, Energy, and Resources, Hollywood, Fla.
Whiteley, P., and Masayesva, V. (1998). “The use and abuse of aquifers: Can the Hopi Indians survive multinational mining.” Water, culture, and power, J. M. Donahue and B. R. Johnston, eds., Island Press, Washington, D.C., 9–34.
Winpenny, J. (1997). “Water policy issues.” Occasional Paper No. 2, Department for International Development, London.
Wittfogel, K. A. (1957). Oriental despotism: A comparative study of total power, Yale University Press, New Haven, Conn.
Wodraska, J. R., and von Haam, P. E. (1998). “Developments in California water management.” Water policies for the future, Universities Council on Water Resources, Issue No. 111, Spring 1998, ⟨ucowr.siu.edu/updates/111⟩ (Jan. 10, 2008).
Wolf, A. T. (1999). “Criteria for equitable allocations: The heart of international water conflict.” Nat. Resour. Forum, 23(1), 3–30.
Wolf, A. T. (2000). “Indigenous approaches to water conflict negotiations and implications for international waters.” International Negotiation: A Journal of Theory and Practice, December.
World Bank. (1993). Water resources management, A World Bank policy paper, World Bank, Washington, D.C.
World Bank. (1998). “Strategy for integrated water resources management.” N ENV-125, World Bank, Washington, D.C.
World Commission on Dams. (2000). Dams and development: A new framework for decision-making, Earthscan Publications Ltd., London, and Sterling, Va.
World Water Commission. (1999). A water secure world: Visions for water, life, and the environment, World Water Vision and World Water Council, Marseille, France, ⟨worldwatercouncil.org/Vision/Documents/CommissionjReport.pdf⟩ (Dec. 28, 2004).
Zajac, E. E. (1995). Political economy of fairness, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management
Volume 134 • Issue 6 • November 2008
Pages: 493 - 503
Copyright
© 2008 ASCE.
History
Received: Oct 17, 2005
Accepted: May 7, 2008
Published online: Nov 1, 2008
Published in print: Nov 2008
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.