Spurious Correlation in the USEPA Rating Curve Method for Estimating Pollutant Loads
Publication: Journal of Environmental Engineering
Volume 134, Issue 8
Abstract
Water quality models are important tools used for developing total maximum daily loads (TMDLs), which are used to implement water quality standards. The writers have developed a tool which spatially interpolates output from the Chesapeake Bay Program Watershed Model (WSM) and requires little time, data, or training. In contrast, the WSM requires extensive time, data, and training to run. This study examines if the writers’ tool provides accurate estimates of pollutant loads as compared to observed pollutant loads calculated using two different rating curve methods. The accuracy of the tool was assessed based on Nash–Sutcliffe coefficients. This study found that the tool provided moderate estimates of total nitrogen, poor estimates of total phosphorus, and that the rating curve method used to calculate observed loads affected the conclusion of the accuracy of the writers’ tool for predicting total sediment. A key finding of this study is that the widely used load-derived method for calculating observed loads exhibits spurious correlation. The writers discuss the imperative need to use sound statistical methods when estimating pollutant loads and TMDLs, and suggest an alternative approach for developing rating curves which is not subject to the problem of spurious correlation.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
Benson, M. A. (1965). “Spurious correlations in hydraulics and hydrology.” J. Hydr. Div., 91(4), 35–42.
Berges, J. A. (1997). “Ratios, regression statistics, and ‘spurious’ correlations.” Limnol. Oceanogr., 42(5), 1006–1007.
Brett, M. T. (2004). “When is a correlation between non-independent variables ‘spurious?’” Oikos, 105, 647–656.
Carpenter, S. R., Caraco, N. F., Correll, D. L., Howarth, R. W., Sharpley, A. N., and Smith, V. H. (1998). “Nonpoint pollution of surface waters with phosphorus and nitrogen.” Ecol. Appl., 8(3), 559–568.
Chesapeake Bay Program (CBP). (2004). “The state of the Chesapeake Bay and its watershed.” CBP-TRS-273-05, EPA-903-R-04-009, USEPA Chesapeake Bay Program Office, Annapolis, Md.
Chesapeake Bay Program (CBP). (2005). “Nutrient pollution.” ⟨http://www.chesapeakebay.net/nutr1.htm⟩ (March 2007 ).
Correll, D. C., Wu, T., and Pierce, J. W. (1976a). “Aquatic plant die-offs in Chesapeake Bay: Relationship to light penetration and/or herbicide pollution.” EPA903/9-76-001, EPA, Athens, Ga., Vol. I.
Correll, D. C., Wu, T., and Pierce, J. W. (1976b). “Aquatic plant die-offs in Chesapeake Bay: Relationship to light penetration and/or herbicide pollution.” EPA903/9-76-001, EPA, Athens, Ga., Vol. II.
Evans, B. M., Lehning, D. W., Corradini, K. J., Petersen, G. W., Nizeyimana, E., Hamlett, P. D., Robillard, P. D., and Day, R. L. (2002). “A comprehensive GIS-based modeling approach for predicting nutrient loads in watersheds.” J. Spatial Hydrology, 2(2), 1–18.
Gilroy, E. J., Kirby, W. H., Cohn, T. A., and Glysson, G. D. (1990). “Discussion of ‘Uncertainty in suspended sediment transport curves’ by McBean and Al-Nassri.” J. Hydraul. Eng., 116(1), 143–145.
Hao, O. J., and Neethling, J. B. (1987). “Effect of ratio correlation on data interpretation.” J. Environ. Eng., 113(1), 205–211.
Hopkins, K., Brown, B., Linker, L. C., and Mader, R. L., Jr. (2000). “Chesapeake Bay Watershed model land use and model linkages to the airshed and estuarine models.” Rep. of the Modeling Subcommittee, USEPA Chesapeake Bay Program Office, Annapolis, Md.
Kenney, B. C. (1982). “Beware of spurious self-correlations!” Water Resour. Res., 18(4), 1041–1048.
Maryland Cooperative Extension (MCE). (2006). “How the MCE agricultural nutrient management program got started.” Agricultural Nutrient Management Program, ⟨http://www.agnr.umd.edu/users/agron/nutrient/Bkgrnd/HistoryANMP.pdf⟩ (March 2007 ).
Maryland Department of the Environment (MDE). (2005). “Total maximum daily loads of nitrogen, phosphorus and biochemical oxygen demand for Breton Bay in St. Mary’s County, Maryland.” Maryland Department of the Environment, Baltimore, ⟨http://www.mde.state.md.us/assets/document/bb-main060805_final.pdf⟩ (March 2007).
Mattikalli, N. M., and Richards, K. S. (1996). “Estimation of surface water quality changes in response to land use change: Application of the export coefficient model using remote sensing and geographical information system.” J. Environ. Manage., 48, 262–282.
McCuen, R. H. (1993). Microcomputer applications in statistical hydrology, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J.
Moglen, G. E. (2007). “GISHydro nutrient loading interpolator for the Chesapeake Bay program model.” ⟨http://www.gishydro.umd.edu/documents/mde-reports/MDE-Loading-Final-Report.pdf⟩ (May 2007 ).
Nash, J. E., and Sutcliffe, J. V. (1970). “River flow forecasting through conceptual models. Part I—A discussion of principles.” J. Hydrol., 10, 282–290.
Pearson, K. (1897). “On a form of spurious correlation which may arise when indices are used in the measurement of organs.” Proc. R. Soc. London, 60, 489–498.
Shoemaker, L., Dai, T., and Koenig, J. (2005). “TMDL model evaluation and research needs.” EPA 600-R-05-149, Office of Research and Development, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Cincinnati.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). (1999). “Protocol for developing nutrient TMDLs.” EPA 841-B-99-007, Office of Water (4503F), U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). (2005). Draft handbook for developing watershed plans to restore and protect our waters, EPA 841-B-05-005, Office of Water: Nonpoint Source Control Branch, Washington, D.C.
U.S. Geological Survey (USGS). (2005). “The impact of sediment on the Chesapeake Bay and its watershed.” ⟨http://chesapeake.usgs.gov/SedimentBay605.pdf⟩ (March 2007 ).
U.S. Geological Survey (USGS). (2007a). “National water quality assessment data warehouse.” ⟨http://infotrek.er.usgs.gov/traverse/f?p=NAWQA:HOME:755096144276101⟩ (March 2007 ).
U.S. Geological Survey (USGS). (2007b). “Water—Nutrients.” USGS Chesapeake Bay Activities, ⟨http://chesapeake.usgs.gov/nutrients.html⟩ (March 2007 ).
U.S. Geological Survey (USGS). (2007c). “Water—Sediments.” USGS Chesapeake Bay Activities, ⟨http://chesapeake.usgs.gov/sediments.html⟩ (March 2007 ).
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Environmental Engineering
Volume 134 • Issue 8 • August 2008
Pages: 610 - 618
Copyright
© 2008 ASCE.
History
Received: Sep 4, 2007
Accepted: Feb 4, 2008
Published online: Aug 1, 2008
Published in print: Aug 2008
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.