Impact of Flow Variability on Error in Estimation of Tributary Mass Loads
Publication: Journal of Environmental Engineering
Volume 118, Issue 3
Abstract
Annual mass load estimators are evaluated for application to a range of tributary types including highly responsive systems. Evaluations are performed by conducting retrospective studies with comprehensive sets of field data for total phosphorus concentration and discharge. Four estimators from three broad categories are selected for study based on their performance in previous research. Extimators are evaluated using Monte Carlo sampling studies in which load estimates made from random subsamples are compared to true loads calculated from a complete loading record. The performance of the estimators differs strongly among the tributary test cases. Hydrograph characteristics and/or concentration/discharge relationships appear to play a strong role in the precision of all of the estimators and in the bias of averaging and regression estimators. Beale's ratio estimator is the only estimator to provide unbiased estimates for both stable and responsive systems, although stratification is necessary under event sampling. Consistent accuracy of the ratio estimator is valuable because it will allow the design of future sampling programs and accurate estimation of confidence intervals from collected sample data.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
1.
Baker, D. B. (1988). “Sediment, nutrient and pesticide transport in selected lower Great Lakes tributaries.” EPA‐905/4‐88‐001, U.S. Envir. Protection Agency, Washington, D.C.
2.
Beale, E. M. L. (1962). “Some uses of computers in operational research.” Industrielle Organisation, 31, 51–52.
3.
Bierman Jr., V. J., Preston, S. D., and Silliman, S. E. (1988). “Development of estimation methods for tributary loading rates of toxic chemicals.” Water Resources Research Center Tech. Report No. 183. Purdue Univ., West Lafayette, Ind.
4.
Bodo, B., and Unny, T. E. (1984). “Sampling strategies for mass‐discharge estimation.” J. Envir. Engrg., ASCE, 109(4), 812–829.
5.
Cochran, W. G. (1977). Sampling techniques, Third Ed., John Wiley and Sons, New York, N.Y.
6.
Cohn, T. A., Delong, L. L., and Gilroy, E. J. (1989). “Estimating constituent loads.” Water Resour. Res., 25(5), 937–942.
7.
Dann, M. S., Lynch, J. A., and Corbett, E. S. (1986). Comparison of methods for estimating sulfate export from a forested watershed.” J. Envir. Quality, 15(2), 140–145.
8.
Dolan, D. M., Yui, A. K., and Geist, R. D. (1981). “Evaluation of river load estimation methods for total phosphorus.” J. Great Lakes Res., 7(3), 207–214.
9.
El‐Shaarawi, A. H., Kuntz, K. W., and Sylvestri, A. (1986). “Estimation of loading by numerical integration.” Statistical aspects of water quality monitoring, A. H. El‐Shaarawi and R. E. Kwiatkowski, eds., Elsevier Sci. Publishers, New York, N.Y.
10.
Ferguson, R. I. (1987). Accuracy and precision of methods for estimating river loads. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 12(1), 95–104.
11.
Guariso, G., Whittington, D., Abdel‐Samie, M. E., and Kramer, C. (1980). “A salt balance simulation model in Lake Nasser.” Water Supply Mgmt., 4, 73–80.
12.
Hartley, H. O., and Ross, A. (1954). “Unbiased ratio estimates.” Nature, 174, 270–271.
13.
Johnson, A. H. (1979). “Estimating solute transport in streams from grab samples.” Water Resour. Res., 15(5), 1224–1228.
14.
Preston, S. D., Bierman, Jr., V. J., and Silliman, S. E. (1989a). “An evaluation of methods for the estimation of tributary mass loads.” Water Resour. Res., 25(6), 1379–1389.
15.
Preston, S. D., Bierman, Jr., V. J., and Silliman, S. E. (1989b). “Evaluation of methods for the estimation of tributary mass loading rates.” Water Resources Research Center Tech. Report No. 187, Purdue Univ., West Lafayette, Ind.
16.
Richards, R. P. (1989). “Measures of flow variability for Great Lakes tributaries.” Envir. Monitoring and Assessment, 12, 361–377.
17.
Richards, R. P., and Holloway, J. (1987). “Monte Carlo studies of sampling strategies for estimating tributary loads.” Water Resour. Res., 23(10), 1939–1948.
18.
Stack, W. P., and Belt, K. T. (1989). “The selection of appropriate flow averaging periods in evaluating pollutant loadings using the flow interval method.” Lake and Reservoir Mgmt., 5(2), 67–73.
19.
Thomas, R. B. (1985). Estimating total suspended sediment yield with probability sampling.” Water Resour. Res., 21(9), 1381–1388.
20.
Tin, M. (1965). “Comparison of some ratio estimators.” J. American Statistical Association, 60, 294–307.
21.
Walling, D. E. (1977). “Assessing the accuracy of suspended sediment rating curves for a small basin.” Water Resour. Res., 13(3), 531–538.
22.
Verhoff, F. H., Yaksich, S. M., and Melfi, D. A. (1980). “River nutrient and chemical transport estimation.” J. Envir. Engrg., ASCE, 106(3), 591–608.
23.
Yaksich, S. M., and Verhoff, F. H. (1983). “Sampling strategy for river pollutant transport.” J. Envir. Engrg., ASCE, 109(1), 219–231.
24.
Young, T. C., DePinto, J. V., and Heidtke, T. M. (1988). “Factors affecting the efficiency of some estimators of fluvial total phosphorus load.” Water Resour. Res., 24(9), 1535–1540.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Environmental Engineering
Volume 118 • Issue 3 • May 1992
Pages: 402 - 419
Copyright
Copyright © 1992 ASCE.
History
Published online: May 1, 1992
Published in print: May 1992
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.