Assessing the Water Quality Performance of Limestone Media in Bioretention and Sand Filter Basin Testbeds
Publication: Journal of Sustainable Water in the Built Environment
Volume 9, Issue 4
Abstract
Low impact development (LID) practices are commonly used stormwater control measures (SCMs) designed to mimic the predevelopment hydrologic regime by restoring the natural water cycle and enhancing water quality. A full-scale LID testbed was designed and implemented to evaluate the performance of bioretention and sand filter basins under the same conditions. The LID testbed is composed of six parallel cells including (1) a regional standard bioretention soil mixture, (2) an innovative custom blend bioretention soil mixture with limestone sand, and (3) sand filter basins with limestone sand as filtration media. Each filtration media design was tested with and without an impermeable liner, to investigate the potential impacts of the direct infiltration on their water quality performance. The treatment performance was evaluated through series of water quality analyses comparing the event mean concentrations (EMCs) of the inlet and outlets. The results suggested enhanced pollutant removal efficiencies by use of limestone sand in the bioretention mixture as well as a standalone media within the sand filter basins, particularly for phosphorus. We observed 82%–93% and 97%–94% removal of dissolved and total phosphorus, respectively, and the regional bioretention soil mixture presented leaching of nutrients. No significant difference was observed between the water quality performance of sand filter and bioretention basins, or between lined and unlined systems.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Data Availability Statement
All data, models, or code that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request (field monitoring data, water quality analysis results, and Python codes used for statistical analysis).
Acknowledgments
This research project was funded through the City of San Antonio’s (COSA) Proposition 1 Edwards Aquifer Protection Venue Project and administered by the San Antonio River Authority (SARA).
References
Afrooz, A. R. M. N., and A. B. Boehm. 2017. “Effects of submerged zone, media aging, and antecedent dry period on the performance of biochar-amended biofilters in removing fecal indicators and nutrients from natural stormwater.” Ecol. Eng. 102 (May): 320–330. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoleng.2017.02.053.
Ament, M. R., E. D. Roy, Y. Yuan, and S. E. Hurley. 2022. “Phosphorus removal, metals dynamics, and hydraulics in stormwater bioretention systems amended with drinking water treatment residuals.” J. Sustainable Water Built Environ. 8 (3): 04022003. https://doi.org/10.1061/JSWBAY.0000980.
APHA, AWWA, and WEF (American Public Health Association, American Water Works Association, and World Economic Forum). 2017. Vol. 23 of Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater. Washington, DC: APHA.
Barrett, M. E. 2003. “Performance, cost, and maintenance requirements of Austin sand filters.” J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 129 (3): 234–242. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9496(2003)129:3(234).
Barrett, M. E., M. Limouzin, and D. F. Lawler. 2013. “Effects of media and plant selection on biofiltration performance.” J. Environ. Eng. 139 (4): 462–470. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)EE.1943-7870.0000551.
Baum, P., B. Kuch, and U. Dittmer. 2021. “Adsorption of metals to particles in urban stormwater runoff—Does size really matter?” Water 13 (3): 309. https://doi.org/10.3390/w13030309.
Biswal, B. K., K. Vijayaraghavan, M. G. Adam, D. L. Tsen-Tieng, A. P. Davis, and R. Balasubramanian. 2022. “Biological nitrogen removal from stormwater in bioretention cells: A critical review.” Crit. Rev. Biotechnol. 42 (5): 713–735. https://doi.org/10.1080/07388551.2021.1969888.
Blecken, G.-T., Y. Zinger, A. Deletić, T. D. Fletcher, and M. Viklander. 2009a. “Impact of a submerged zone and a carbon source on heavy metal removal in stormwater biofilters.” Ecol. Eng. 35 (5): 769–778. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoleng.2008.12.009.
Blecken, G.-T., Y. Zinger, A. Deletić, T. D. Fletcher, and M. Viklander. 2009b. “Influence of intermittent wetting and drying conditions on heavy metal removal by stormwater biofilters.” Water Res. 43 (18): 4590–4598. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2009.07.008.
Chahal, M. K., Z. Shi, and M. Flury. 2016. “Nutrient leaching and copper speciation in compost-amended bioretention systems.” Sci. Total Environ. 556 (Jun): 302–309. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.02.125.
Clary, J., J. Jones, M. Leisenring, P. Hobson, and E. Strecker. 2020. International stormwater BMP database: 2020 summary statistics. Denver: Water Research Foundation.
Davis, A. P., W. F. Hunt, R. G. Traver, and M. Clar. 2009. “Bioretention technology: Overview of current practice and future needs.” J. Environ. Eng. 135 (3): 109–117. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9372(2009)135:3(109).
Davis, A. P., R. G. Traver, and W. F. Hunt. 2010. “Improving urban stormwater quality: Applying fundamental principles.” J. Contemp. Water Res. Educ. 146 (1): 3–10. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1936-704X.2010.00387.x.
Edwards, E. C., C. Nelson, T. Harter, C. Bowles, X. Li, B. Lock, G. E. Fogg, and B. S. Washburn. 2022. “Potential effects on groundwater quality associated with infiltrating stormwater through dry wells for aquifer recharge.” J. Contam. Hydrol. 246 (Apr): 103964. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jconhyd.2022.103964.
Esfandiar, N., and E. R. McKenzie. 2022. “Bioretention soil capacity for removing nutrients, metals, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons; roles of co-contaminants, pH, salinity and dissolved organic carbon.” J. Environ. Manage. 324 (Dec): 116314. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2022.116314.
Göbel, P., C. Dierkes, and W. G. Coldewey. 2007. “Storm water runoff concentration matrix for urban areas.” J. Contam. Hydrol. 91 (1–2): 26–42. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jconhyd.2006.08.008.
Hach Method. 2015. Water analysis handbook. 8th ed. Methods 8158, 8164. Loveland, CO: Hach Company.
Hach Method. 2017. Water analysis handbook. 10th ed. Method 8048. Loveland, CO: Hach Company.
Hach Method. 2018a. Water analysis handbook. 11th ed. Method 10029. Loveland, CO: Hach Company.
Hach Method. 2018b. Water analysis handbook. 11th ed. Method 10208. Loveland, CO: Hach Company.
Han, Y., S.-L. Lau, M. Kayhanian, and M. K. Stenstrom. 2006a. “Characteristics of highway stormwater runoff.” Water Environ. Res. 78 (12): 2377–2388. https://doi.org/10.2175/106143006X95447.
Han, Y. H., S. L. Lau, M. Kayhanian, and M. K. Stenstrom. 2006b. “Correlation analysis among highway stormwater pollutants and characteristics.” Water Sci. Technol. 53 (2): 235–243. https://doi.org/10.2166/wst.2006.057.
He, J., C. Valeo, A. Chu, and N. F. Neumann. 2010a. “Characteristics of suspended solids, microorganisms, and chemical water quality in event-based stormwater runoff from an urban residential area.” Water Environ. Res. 82 (12): 2333–2345. https://doi.org/10.2175/106143010X12681059117058.
He, J., C. Valeo, A. Chu, and N. F. Neumann. 2010b. “Characterizing physicochemical quality of storm-water runoff from an urban area in Calgary, Alberta.” J. Environ. Eng. 136 (11): 1206–1217. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)EE.1943-7870.0000267.
He, K., H. Qin, F. Wang, W. Ding, and Y. Yin. 2020. “Importance of the submerged zone during dry periods to nitrogen removal in a bioretention system.” Water 12 (3): 876. https://doi.org/10.3390/w12030876.
Herzog, T., A. Mehring, B. Hatt, R. Ambrose, L. Levin, and B. Winfrey. 2021. “Pruning stormwater biofilter vegetation influences water quality improvement differently in Carex appressa and Ficinia nodosa.” Urban For. Urban Greening 59 (Apr): 127004. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ufug.2021.127004.
Hsieh, C.-H., and A. P. Davis. 2005a. “Evaluation and optimization of bioretention media for treatment of urban storm water runoff.” J. Environ. Eng. 131 (11): 1521–1531. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9372(2005)131:11(1521).
Hsieh, C.-H., and A. P. Davis. 2005b. “Multiple-event study of bioretention for treatment of urban storm water runoff.” Water Sci. Technol. 51 (3–4): 177–181. https://doi.org/10.2166/wst.2005.0589.
Kohlsmith, E., J. Morse, C. Poor, and J. Law. 2021. “Stormwater treatment effectiveness of established lined bioretention facilities in Portland, Oregon.” J. Sustainable Water Built Environ. 7 (2): 05021002. https://doi.org/10.1061/JSWBAY.0000943.
LeFevre, G. H., K. H. Paus, P. Natarajan, J. S. Gulliver, P. J. Novak, and R. M. Hozalski. 2015. “Review of dissolved pollutants in urban storm water and their removal and fate in bioretention cells.” J. Environ. Eng. 141 (1): 04014050. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)EE.1943-7870.0000876.
Li, H., and A. P. Davis. 2008. “Urban particle capture in bioretention media. II: Theory and model development.” J. Environ. Eng. 134 (6): 419–432. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9372(2008)134:6(419).
Li, Y., M. Wen, J. Li, B. Chai, and C. Jiang. 2018. “Reduction and accumulative characteristics of dissolved heavy metals in modified bioretention media.” Water 10 (10): 1488. https://doi.org/10.3390/w10101488.
Limouzin, M., D. F. Lawler, and M. E. Barrett. 2011. Performance comparison of stormwater biofiltration designs. Austin, TX: Center for Research in Water Resources, Univ. of Texas at Austin.
Marvin, J. T., E. Passeport, and J. Drake. 2020. “State-of-the-art review of phosphorus sorption amendments in bioretention media: A systematic literature review.” J. Sustainable Water Built Environ. 6 (1): 03119001. https://doi.org/10.1061/JSWBAY.0000893.
Mateus, D. M. R., M. M. N. Vaz, and H. J. O. Pinho. 2012. “Fragmented limestone wastes as a constructed wetland substrate for phosphorus removal.” Ecol. Eng. 41 (Apr): 65–69. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoleng.2012.01.014.
McNett, J., W. F. Hunt, and A. P. Davis. 2011. “Influent pollutant concentrations as predictors of effluent pollutant concentrations for Mid-Atlantic bioretention.” J. Environ. Eng. 137 (9): 790–799. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)EE.1943-7870.0000373.
Minnesota Stormwater Manual. 2021. Liners for stormwater management. Saint Paul, MI: Minnesota Pollution Control Agency.
Morse, J. W., and F. T. Mackenzie. 1990. Geochemistry of sedimentary carbonates. Amsterdam, Netherlands: Elsevier.
Mullane, J. M., M. Flury, H. Iqbal, P. M. Freeze, C. Hinman, C. G. Cogger, and Z. Shi. 2015. “Intermittent rainstorms cause pulses of nitrogen, phosphorus, and copper in leachate from compost in bioretention systems.” Sci. Total Environ. 537 (Dec): 294–303. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2015.07.157.
Nguyen, D. X., R. W. Nairn, and R. C. Knox. 2021. “Sand filtration enhanced by various reactive materials for bioretention cell design considerations.” J. Environ. Eng. 147 (11): 04021050. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)EE.1943-7870.0001916.
Oates, J. A. 2008. Lime and limestone: Chemistry and technology, production and uses. Weinheim: Wiley.
O’Neill, S. W., and A. P. Davis. 2012. “Water treatment residual as a bioretention amendment for phosphorus. I: Evaluation studies.” J. Environ. Eng. 138 (3): 318–327. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)EE.1943-7870.0000409.
Palmer, E. T., C. J. Poor, C. Hinman, and J. D. Stark. 2013. “Nitrate and phosphate removal through enhanced bioretention media: Mesocosm study.” Water Environ. Res. 85 (9): 823–832. https://doi.org/10.2175/106143013X13736496908997.
Patel, D., J. Johnston, W. Lucas, and K. McCamman. 2020. “Bioretention system enhancements for nutrient removal.” J. Sustainable Water Built Environ. 6 (2): 04020006. https://doi.org/10.1061/JSWBAY.0000901.
Reck, A., M. Thalmann, E. Paton, and B. Kluge. 2021. “Seepage metal concentrations beneath long-term operated bioretention systems.” Blue-Green Syst. 3 (1): 128–144. https://doi.org/10.2166/bgs.2021.014.
San Antonio River Authority. 2019. San Antonio river basin LID technical design manual. 2nd ed. San Antonio, TX: San Antonio River Authority.
Shahrokh Hamedani, A., A. Bazilio, C. Cerda, A. Manjarres, A. Hall, H. Shipley, and M. Giacomoni. 2019. “Assessing the performance of bioretention and sand filter media using columns and synthetic stormwater.” In World environmental and water resources congress 2019: Water, wastewater, and stormwater; urban water resources; and municipal water infrastructure, 57–70. Reston, VA: ASCE.
Shahrokh Hamedani, A., A. Bazilio, H. Soleimanifar, H. Shipley, and M. Giacomoni. 2021. “Improving the treatment performance of low impact development practices—Comparison of sand and bioretention soil mixtures using column experiments.” Water 13 (9): 1210. https://doi.org/10.3390/w13091210.
Shrestha, P., M. T. Salzl, I. J. Jimenez, N. Pradhan, M. Hay, H. R. Wallace, J. N. Abrahamson, and G. E. Small. 2019. “Efficacy of spent lime as a soil amendment for nutrient retention in bioretention green stormwater infrastructure.” Water 11 (8): 1575. https://doi.org/10.3390/w11081575.
Si, Q., M. G. Lusk, and P. W. Inglett. 2021. “Inorganic nitrogen production and removal along the sediment gradient of a stormwater infiltration basin.” Water 13 (3): 320. https://doi.org/10.3390/w13030320.
Skorobogatov, A., J. He, A. Chu, C. Valeo, and B. van Duin. 2020. “The impact of media, plants and their interactions on bioretention performance: A review.” Sci. Total Environ. 715 (May): 136918. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.136918.
Søberg, L. C., M. Viklander, and G.-T. Blecken. 2021. “Nitrogen removal in stormwater bioretention facilities: Effects of drying, temperature and a submerged zone.” Ecol. Eng. 169 (Nov): 106302. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoleng.2021.106302.
Soleimanifar, H., Y. Deng, K. Barrett, H. Feng, X. Li, and D. Sarkar. 2019. “Water treatment residual-coated wood mulch for addressing urban stormwater pollution.” Water Environ. Res. 91 (6): 523–535. https://doi.org/10.1002/wer.1055.
TCEQ (Texas Commission on Environmental Quality). 2005. Complying with the Edwards Aquifer rules. Austin, TX: Texas Commission on Environmental Quality.
Tirpak, R. A., A. R. M. N. Afrooz, R. J. Winston, R. Valenca, K. Schiff, and S. K. Mohanty. 2021. “Conventional and amended bioretention soil media for targeted pollutant treatment: A critical review to guide the state of the practice.” Water Res. 189 (Feb): 116648. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2020.116648.
Tong, S. T. Y., A. J. Liu, and J. A. Goodrich. 2009. “Assessing the water quality impacts of future land-use changes in an urbanising watershed.” Civ. Eng. Environ. Syst. 26 (1): 3–18. https://doi.org/10.1080/10286600802003393.
USEPA. 1983. EPA administered permit programs: The national pollutant discharge elimination system. Rep. No. 48 FR 14153. Washington, DC: USEPA.
USEPA. 1992. Method 3005A (SW-846): Acid digestion of waters for total recoverable or dissolved metals for analysis by flame atomic absorption (FLAA) or inductively coupled plasma (ICP) spectroscopy. Revision 1. Washington, DC: USEPA.
USEPA. 1994. Potential groundwater contamination from intentional and non-intentional stormwater infiltration. Washington, DC: USEPA.
USEPA. 1999. Preliminary data summary of urban storm water best management practices. Rep. No. EPA-821-R-99-012. Washington, DC: USEPA.
USEPA. 2005. National management measures to control nonpoint source pollution from urban areas. Rep. No. EPA-841-B-05-004. Washington, DC: USEPA, Office of Water.
USEPA. 2007. Reducing stormwater costs through low impact development (lid) strategies and practices. Rep. No. EPA 841-F-07-006. Washington, DC: USEPA.
USEPA. 2014. Method 6020B (SW-846): Inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry. Revision 2. Washington, DC: USEPA.
Vaze, J., and F. H. S. Chiew. 2004. “Nutrient loads associated with different sediment sizes in urban stormwater and surface pollutants.” J. Environ. Eng. 130 (4): 391–396. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9372(2004)130:4(391).
Wang, F., J. Li, and H. Duan. 2022a. “A sulfur-limestone bioretention system for stormwater treatment: Nitrogen removal performance and microbial community.” Sci. Total Environ. 827 (Jun): 154301. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2022.154301.
Wang, R., X. Zhang, and M.-H. Li. 2019. “Predicting bioretention pollutant removal efficiency with design features: A data-driven approach.” J. Environ. Manage. 242 (Jul): 403–414. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2019.04.064.
Wang, S., Y. Ma, X. Zhang, and Z. Shen. 2022b. “Transport and sources of nitrogen in stormwater runoff at the urban catchment scale.” Sci. Total Environ. 806 (Feb): 150281. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.150281.
Waschbusch, R. J., W. Selbig, and R. T. Bannerman. 1999. Sources of phosphorus in stormwater and street dirt from two urban residential basins in Madison, Wisconsin, 1994-95. Madison, WI: Dept. of the Interior, USGS.
WERF (Water Environment Research Foundation). 2005. Critical assessment of stormwater treatment and control selection issues. Alexandria, VA: WERF.
Yin, Y., C. A. Impellitteri, S.-J. You, and H. E. Allen. 2002. “The importance of organic matter distribution and extract soil:solution ratio on the desorption of heavy metals from soils.” Sci. Total Environ. 287 (1–2): 107–119. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0048-9697(01)01000-2.
Zarezadeh, V., T. Lung, T. Dorman, H. J. Shipley, and M. Giacomoni. 2018. “Assessing the performance of sand filter basins in treating urban stormwater runoff.” Environ. Monit. Assess. 190 (12): 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-018-7069-5.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Sustainable Water in the Built Environment
Volume 9 • Issue 4 • November 2023
Copyright
© 2023 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Nov 4, 2022
Accepted: May 26, 2023
Published online: Jul 14, 2023
Published in print: Nov 1, 2023
Discussion open until: Dec 14, 2023
ASCE Technical Topics:
- Business management
- Engineering materials (by type)
- Environmental engineering
- Filters
- Filtration
- Foundation construction
- Foundations
- Geotechnical engineering
- Hydration
- Laminating
- Limestone
- Materials engineering
- Materials processing
- Practice and Profession
- Retention basins
- Sand filters
- Soil mixing
- Stilling basins
- Stones
- Sustainable development
- Water quality
- Water treatment
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.