Critical Evaluation of Commonly Used Software Packages for Designing Wastewater Networks
Publication: Journal of Environmental Engineering
Volume 150, Issue 12
Abstract
The wastewater management sector is grappling with a multitude of intricate challenges, including but not limited to insufficient infrastructure, financial constraints, rapid urbanization, population booms, and emerging environmental contaminants. These issues necessitate an urgent pivot toward sustainable wastewater management strategies that harmonize ecological, economic, and societal imperatives—a vision aligned with the United Nations’ sustainable development goals. To extend the reach of wastewater networks globally, software tools play a pivotal role in the efficient design of sewer systems, given the inherent complexity of manual design processes. This research paper presents a comprehensive review of the available literature on sewer network design software and selects the most used options—Bentley SewerGEMS, Urbano CANALIS, and Mike+ SWMM—for in-depth analysis. Furthermore, a novel software solution, INSINCE, based on machine learning principles, is included, and evaluated. The assessment and comparison of results encompass critical parameters such as network length, velocity distribution, depth profiling, and hydraulic design obtained from these four software applications. Qualitative aspects including user-friendliness, cross-platform integration, and software capabilities are also discussed. This study underscores the pivotal role of software selection in achieving optimal sewer system designs, offering invaluable insights to enhance wastewater management practices.
Practical Applications
The research on sewer network design software, including Bentley SewerGEMS, Urbano CANALIS, Mike+ SWMM, and the novel InSINCE, offers crucial insights for practitioners and engineers in the wastewater management sector. These findings underscore the pivotal role of software selection in achieving optimal sewer system designs, with InSINCE showing promise in streamlining design processes through machine learning and optimization techniques. The study highlights the importance of considering critical parameters such as network length, velocity distribution, and hydraulic design in software evaluation. Practitioners can leverage this research to make informed decisions on software choices, ultimately enhancing wastewater management practices. Furthermore, the identified areas for improvement, such as optimal layout selection and life cycle cost analysis, provide valuable guidance for future software development, emphasizing the potential for integrating advanced machine learning algorithms to elevate software functionalities. Overall, this research serves as a valuable resource for stakeholders seeking sustainable solutions in urban wastewater management.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Data Availability Statement
All data, models, or code that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. Specifically, the data comprises the reference maps of IIT Delhi Campus. Additionally, the model run files used in the analysis, which were executed on four different software, are also accessible to facilitate result interpretation. It is important to note that no codes were utilized in the research study.
Acknowledgments
We would like to extend our sincere gratitude to the various software providers who generously provided trial versions of their software packages for the purpose of this study. Access to these trial versions was instrumental in conducting a comprehensive analysis and evaluation of wastewater conveyance system design software.
References
AECOM (Architecture, Engineering, Construction, Operations, and Management). 2013. City of White Rock, sewer master plan update. Québec: AECOM Canada.
Afshar, M. H., M. Shahidi, M. Rohani, and M. Sargolzaei. 2011. “Application of cellular automata to sewer network optimization problems.” Sci. Iran. 18 (3): 304–312. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scient.2011.05.037.
Ahmadi, A., M. A. Zolfagharipoor, and M. Nafisi. 2018. “Development of a hybrid algorithm for the optimal design of sewer networks.” J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 144 (8): 04018045. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)WR.1943-5452.0000942.
Alfaisal, F. M., and L. W. Mays. 2021. “Optimization models for layout and pipe design for storm sewer systems.” Water Resour. Manage. 35 (Nov): 4841–4854. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11269-021-02958-5.
Basupi, I. 2020. “Design of integrated water systems: Water distribution system, household water-saving scheme, and sanitary sewer perspectives.” J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage. 147 (2): 04020102. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)WR.1943-5452.0001309.
Bhavimani, M. H. S., and D. A. V. Shivapur. n.d. “Design of sanitary sewer network for zone 10, Belagavi City using SewerGems V8i software.” Int. Res. J. Eng. Technol. 2 (8).
Brocard, D., S. Gan, L. Koh, T. Tan, W. Cox, T. Schellhase, L. Woo, S. Lo, S. Cheng, and S. Loh. 2019. “Deep tunnel sewerage system phase 2–hydraulics.” Water Pract. Technol. 14 (2): 409–422. https://doi.org/10.2166/wpt.2019.026.
Calvin Craig, D. J. 2021. How to share a read-only version of a hydraulic model for anyone to view. Waltham, MA: Bentley Communities.
Cazanescu, S., F. Mărăcineanu, and J. Tadjer. 2010. “Sewer network design using urbano Canalis version 7 release 2010.” Sci. Bull Politehnica Univ. Timişoara-Hydrotechnics Trans. 55 (1): 81–86.
Chaudhary, M. U., T. Kumari, S. Bamiri, and B. Robert. 2020. “Sanitary gravity sewer design using SewerGems software connect edition for Utsav Vihar, Karala.” Int. Res. J. Eng. Technol. 9 (2). https://doi.org/10.35940/ijrte.B3255.079220.
CPHEEO (Central Public Health and Environmental Engineering Organisation). 2013. Manual on sewerage and sewage treatment systems. New Delhi, India: Ministry of Urban Development.
Dhawan, H. 2019. “Only 30% of urban households are connected to a central sewer system.” Times of India, November 18, 2019.
Dongare, P., K. V. Sharma, V. Kumar, and A. Mathew. 2024. “Water distribution system modelling of GIS-remote sensing and EPANET for the integrated efficient design.” J. Hydroinf. 26 (3): 567–588. https://doi.org/10.2166/hydro.2023.281.
Dringoli, J. 2024a. “Creating Thiessen polygons for certain nodes in your model.” Bentley Communities. Accessed September 19, 2024. https://bentleysystems.service-now.com/community?id=kb_article&sysparm_article=KB0059046.
Dringoli, J. 2024b. “How do each of the Loadbuilder methods work?” Bentley Communities. Accessed September 19, 2024. https://bentleysystems.service-now.com/community?id=kb_article_view&sysparm_article=KB0016811.
Dringoli, J. 2024c. “Using PondMaker.” Bentley Communities. Accessed September 19, 2024. https://bentleysystems.service-now.com/community?id=kb_article_view&sysparm_article=KB0013546.
Dringoli, J. 2024d. “Using the SCADA element for annotation and reporting.” Bentley Communities. Accessed September 19, 2024. https://bentleysystems.service-now.com/community?id=kb_article_view&sysparm_article=KB0014126#:~:text=SCADA%20Element%20Annotating%20%2F%20Labeling&text=drawing%20very%20easily.-,From%20View%20%3E%20Element%20Symbology%20window%2C%20right%20click%20on%20SCADA%20Element,then%20click%20Apply%20and%20OK.
Duarte, M. S., G. Martins, P. Oliveira, B. Fernandes, E. C. Ferreira, M. M. Alves, F. Lopes, M. A. Pereira, and P. Novais. 2023. “A review of computational modeling in wastewater treatment processes.” ACS ES&T Water 4 (3): 784–804. https://doi.org/10.1021/acsestwater.3c00117.
Duque, N., D. Duque, and J. Saldarriaga. 2016. “A new methodology for the optimal design of series of pipes in sewer systems.” J. Hydroinf. 18 (5): 757–772. https://doi.org/10.2166/hydro.2016.105.
Elie Tawil, P. n.d. Pressure and gravity sewers. Washington, DC: Continuing Education and Development.
Geranmehr, M., M. R. Nikoo, G. Al-Rawas, K. Al-Jabri, and A. H. Gandomi. 2023. “Application of metaheuristic algorithms in optimal design of sewer collection systems.” Compr. Metaheuristics 19 (Jan): 153–161. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-323-91781-0.00008-9.
Guertin, D. 2007. “Historic New England town finds hybrid sewer system a perfect fit.” Water Environ. Technol. 19 (5): 52–55.
Gupta, M., P. Rao, and K. Jayakumar. 2017. “Optimization of integrated sewerage system by using simplex method.” VFSTR J. STEM 3 (1): 2455–3062.
Hassan, W. H., Z. H. Attea, and S. S. Mohammed. 2020. “Optimum layout design of sewer networks by hybrid genetic algorithm.” J. Appl. Water Eng. Res. 8 (2): 108–124. https://doi.org/10.1080/23249676.2020.1761897.
Hassan, W. H., M. H. Jassem, and S. S. Mohammed. 2018. “A GA-HP model for the optimal design of sewer networks.” Water Resour. Manage. 32 (3): 865–879. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11269-017-1843-y.
Hill, C. M. 2014. Hydraulic modeling software recommendation. Tampa, FL: CH2M HILL.
Islam, M. S. 2017. “Comparative evaluation of vacuum sewer and gravity sewer systems.” Int. J. Syst. Assur. Eng. Manage. 8 (1): 37–53. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13198-016-0518-z.
Jones, E. R., M. T. Van Vliet, M. Qadir, and M. F. Bierkens. 2021. “Country-level and gridded estimates of wastewater production, collection, treatment and reuse.” Earth Syst. Sci. Data 13 (2): 237–254. https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-13-237-2021.
Kampa, S. 2024. “aOptions for creating, viewing and exporting profiles.” Bentley Communities. Accessed September 19, 2024. https://bentleysystems.service-now.com/community?id=kb_article_view&sysparm_article=KB0014873.
Kampa, S., and S. Choure. 2024. “Using ModelBuilder to import external data.” Bentley Communities. Accessed May 22, 2024. https://bentleysystems.service-now.com/community?id=kb_article_view&sysparm_article=KB0057220.
Karovic, O., and L. W. Mays. 2014. “Sewer system design using simulated annealing in excel.” Water Resour. Manage. 28 (Oct): 4551–4565. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11269-014-0750-8.
Katti, M., B. Krishna, and M. Kumar. 2015. “Design of sanitary sewer network using sewer GEMS V8i software.” Int. J. Sci. Technol. Eng. 2 (1): 254–258.
Ledergerber, J. M., T. Maruéjouls, and P. A. Vanrolleghem. 2019. “Optimal experimental design for calibration of a new sewer water quality model.” J. Hydrol. 574 (Jul): 1020–1028. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2019.05.004.
Li, G., and R. G. Matthew. 1990. “New approach for optimization of urban drainage systems.” J. Environ. Eng. 116 (5): 927–944. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9372(1990)116:5(927).
Mauricio-Iglesias, M., I. Montero-Castro, A. L. Mollerup, and G. Sin. 2015. “A generic methodology for the optimisation of sewer systems using stochastic programming and self-optimizing control.” J. Environ. Manage. 155 (May): 193–203. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2015.03.034.
Miszta-Kruk, K. 2016. “Reliability and failure rate analysis of pressure, vacuum and gravity sewer systems based on operating data.” Eng. Fail. Anal. 61 (Mar): 37–45. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.engfailanal.2015.07.034.
Moeini, R. 2019. “Ant intelligent applied to sewer network design optimization problem: Using four different algorithms.” Environ. Eng. Manage. J. 18 (5): 957–971.
Moeini, R., and M. H. Afshar. 2013. “Sewer network design optimization problem using ant colony optimization algorithm and tree growing algorithm.” In Proc., EVOLVE-A Bridge between Probability, Set Oriented Numerics, and Evolutionary Computation IV: Int. Conf. held at Leiden University, 91–105. Heidelberg, Germany: Springer.
Moeini, R., and M. H. Afshar. 2019. “Hybridizing ant colony optimization algorithm with nonlinear programming method for effective optimal design of sewer networks.” Water Environ. Res. 91 (4): 300–321. https://doi.org/10.1002/wer.1027.
NCOPMOHF (National Commission on Population Ministry of Health and Family Welfare). 2019. Population projections for India and States 2011–2036. New Delhi, India: NCOPMOHF.
Nema, A. 2009. Simplified sewerage—An appropriate option for rapid sanitation coverage in urban areas. New Delhi, India: Foundation for Greentech Environmental Systems.
Noori, A. R., and S. Singh. 2020. “Modeling of wastewater collection network using arc GIS and SewerGEMS in Kabul, Afghanistan.” EasyChair, August 27, 2020.
Obradović, D., M. Šperac, and S. Marenjak. 2019. “Maintenance issues of the vacuum sewer system.” Environ. Eng.-Inženjerstvo Okoliša 6 (2): 40–48.
Pawar, A., Y. Patil, S. Mane, S. Patil, N. Toche, and Y. Ingale. 2021. “Design of sewer system for village using SewerGEMS.” Int. Res. J. Eng. Technol. 8 (7): 756–760.
Rai, R. K., and D. K. Madavi. 2021. “Optimal design of sewerage networks using Swamee algorithm.” In Proc., Advances in Civil Engineering and Infrastructural Development: Select Proc. of ICRACEID 2019, edited by L. M. Gupta, M. R. Ray, and P. K. Labhasetwar, 397–409. Berlin: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-15-6463-5_37.
Ravikiran, K., and A. S. Virupakshi. 2016. “Design of sewer network system for the Janwad village using SewerCAD V8i.” Int. Res. J. Eng. Technol. 3 (7): 4.
Ridgway, K., and G. J. Kumpula. 2008. “Surge modeling in sewers using alternative hydraulic software programs.” J. Water Manage. Model. https://doi.org/10.14796/JWMM.R228-10.
Rohani, M., and M. H. Afshar. 2015. “GA–GHCA model for the optimal design of pumped sewer networks.” Can. J. Civ. Eng. 42 (1): 1–12. https://doi.org/10.1139/cjce-2014-0187.
Roy, P. K., S. Mallick, S. Pal, G. Banerjee, A. Mazumdar, and R. Chakraborti. 2015. “Comparative study of gravity waste water network development with different load pattern helps of software modeling.” Econ. Environ. Constr. 21 (4): 303–308.
Saldarriaga, J., J. Zambrano, J. Herrán, and P. L. Iglesias-Rey. 2021. “Layout selection for an optimal sewer network design based on land topography, streets network topology, and inflows.” Water 13 (18): 2491. https://doi.org/10.3390/w13182491.
Scarlat, N., S. Cazanescu, and S. Malureanu. 2009. “Modeling of sewage networks with computer aided design software.” Bull. UASVM Agric. 66 (2). https://doi.org/10.15835/buasvmcn-agr:4112.
Schwetschenau, S. E., Y. Kovankaya, M. A. Elliott, M. Allaire, K. D. White, and U. Lall. 2022. “Optimizing scale for decentralized wastewater treatment: A tool to address failing wastewater infrastructure in the United States.” ACS ES&T Eng. 3 (1): 1–14. https://doi.org/10.1021/acsestengg.2c00188.
Semadeni-Davies, A. 2004. “Urban water management vs. climate change: Impacts on cold region waste water inflows.” Clim. Change 64 (1–2): 103–126. https://doi.org/10.1023/B:CLIM.0000024669.22066.04.
Shafiei, A., and M. Tabesh. 2023. “Optimal design of municipal wastewater collection networks with long-term performance improvement approach.” Sci. Iran. 30 (3): 833–844. https://doi.org/10.24200/sci.2022.57731.5391.
Sopariya, H., R. Patel, and Y. Pathak. 2018. “Analysis and design of sewer network using SewerGEMS.” Int. J. Creative Res. Thoughts 6 (2): 1538–1543.
Sourabh, N., and P. Timbadiya. 2015. “Evaluation of sewerage network through simulation.” In Proc., 20th Int. Conf. on Hydraulics, Water Resources and River Engineering. Roorkee, India: Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee.
Strong, K. L., J. Pedersen, E. W. Johansson, B. Cao, T. Diaz, R. Guthold, D. You, J. Requejo, and L. Liu. 2021. “Patterns and trends in causes of child and adolescent mortality 2000–2016: Setting the scene for child health redesign.” BMJ Global Health 6 (3): e004760. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjgh-2020-004760.
Swamee, P. K. 2001. “Design of sewer line.” J. Environ. Eng. 127 (9): 776–781. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9372(2001)127:9(776).
Swamee, P. K., and A. K. Sharma. 2013. “Optimal design of a sewer line using linear programming.” Appl. Math. Modell. 37 (6): 4430–4439. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apm.2012.09.041.
Taing, L., N. Armitage, N. Ashipala, and A. Spiegel. 2013. Sanitation services in informal settlements. Pretoria, South Africa: Water Research Commission.
Vaidya, R., K. Verma, M. Kumar, C. Hoysall, and L. Rao. 2024. “Assessing wastewater management challenges in developing countries: A case study of India, current status and future scope.” Environ. Dev. Sustainability 26 (8): 19369–19396. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-023-03540-2.
Van Vuuren, S., and M. Van Dijk. 2011. Waterborne sanitation design guide. Pretoria, South Africa: Water Research Commission.
Wankhade, K. 2015. “Urban sanitation in India: Key shifts in the national policy frame.” Environ. Urbanization 27 (2): 555–572. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956247814567058.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Environmental Engineering
Volume 150 • Issue 12 • December 2024
Copyright
© 2024 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Nov 21, 2023
Accepted: Jul 12, 2024
Published online: Oct 7, 2024
Published in print: Dec 1, 2024
Discussion open until: Mar 7, 2025
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.