Performance of Project Delivery Methods for US Airport Projects: A Holistic Quantitative Risk-Based Assessment through Perceptions of Associated Industry Experts
Publication: Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
Volume 150, Issue 10
Abstract
The aviation sector received an underperforming D+ score, indicating its deteriorating qualities in comparison with the overall US infrastructure. In response, US governmental bodies issued investment bills that target the improvement of the nation’s airport system. Airport projects are still being implemented through design-bid-build (DBB), which is notorious for its ineffective risk shift, low contractor input, and poor cost and schedule performance. Studies show that design-build (DB) possesses prospective cost and schedule benefits. Despite this, there is still reluctance toward DB’s usage in airport projects. Moreover, current studies lack in offering frameworks that assist airport practitioners in guiding stakeholders toward improved project delivery decision-making. Accordingly, this research’s goal is to establish a holistic risk-based approach to assess the effect of utilizing DB versus DBB in US airport projects based on cost and schedule performance criteria. A four-step methodology is adopted where (1) risk factors were determined and grouped into eight risk categories, where they were quantified against their criticality to cost and schedule performance metrics; (2) the weights of the risk factors and their respective categories were realized to compute their importance; (3) the distribution of the data was statistically fitted; and (4) a benchmarking evaluation framework was developed and analyzed. The findings revealed that DBB is associated with 6% more perceived cost growth in comparison to DB delivery in airport projects. DBB is also linked to 7% more perceived schedule growth relative to DB airport implementation. It was also found that cost-related aspects influenced cost and schedule performance the most. Conversely, external aspects influenced performance the least. Ultimately, this study presents a novel approach for holistically assessing cost and schedule savings and growth in DB implementation in US airport projects, thus offering industry practitioners valuable insights into critical risk factors for enhanced decision-making and risk management practices that have national and global implications.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Data Availability Statement
All data, models, and code generated or used during the study appear in the published article.
References
Abdul Nabi, M., and I. H. El-adaway. 2022. “A proactive risk assessment framework to maximize schedule benefits of modularization in construction projects.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 148 (7): 04022052. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0002311.
Abdul Nabi, M., I. H. El-adaway, R. Assaad, and M. O. Ahmed. 2022. “Prioritization of project factors affecting the use of modular construction: Comparison between the perspectives of industry and literature.” In Vol. 1 of Proc., Canadian Society of Civil Engineering Annual Conf. 2021: CSCE21 Construction Track, 569–582. Singapore: Springer.
Abou Chakra, H., and A. Ashi. 2019. “Comparative analysis of design/build and design/bid/build project delivery systems in Lebanon.” J. Ind. Eng. Int. 15 (Dec): 147–152. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40092-019-00323-1.
ACINA (Airports Council International-North America). 2012. Airport owner’s guide to project delivery systems. Montreal: ACINA.
Ahmed, M. O., R. Khalef, G. G. Ali, and I. H. El-adaway. 2022. “Using machine learning to identify the most critical factors affecting maintenance of tunnels.” In Proc., Computing in Civil Engineering 2021, 1433–1440. Reston, VA: ASCE.
Alhomadi, A. A., R. Dehghan, and J. Y. Ruwanpura. 2011. “The predictability of fast-track projects.” Procedia Eng. 14 (Jan): 1966–1972. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proeng.2011.07.247.
Alleman, D., A. L. Antoine, M. S. Stanford, and K. R. Molenaar. 2020. “Project delivery methods’ change-order types and magnitudes experienced in highway construction.” J. Leg. Aff. Dispute Resolut. Eng. Constr. 12 (2): 04520006. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)LA.1943-4170.0000380.
Alomari, K. A., J. A. Gambatese, and N. Tymvios. 2018. “Risk perception comparison among construction safety professionals: Delphi perspective.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 144 (12): 04018107. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0001565.
Alwin, D. F., and J. A. Krosnick. 1991. “The reliability of survey attitude measurement: The influence of question and respondent attributes.” Sociological Methods Res. 20 (1): 139–181. https://doi.org/10.1177/0049124191020001005.
ASCE. 2021.“ASCE’s 2021 American infrastructure report card: GPA: C−.” Accessed March 22, 2021. https://infrastructurereportcard.org/.
Assaad, R., I. H. El-Adaway, and I. S. Abotaleb. 2020. “Predicting project performance in the construction industry.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 146 (5): 04020030. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0001797.
Bayraktar, M. E., M. Hastak, S. Gokhale, and B. Safi. 2011. “Decision tool for selecting the optimal techniques for cost and schedule reduction in capital projects.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 137 (9): 645–655. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0000345.
Biernacki, P., and D. Waldorf. 1981. “Snowball sampling: Problems and techniques of chain referral sampling.” Sociological Methods Res. 10 (2): 141–163. https://doi.org/10.1177/004912418101000205.
Bo, X., and A. P. C. Chan. 2012. “Investigation of barriers to entry into the design-build market in the People’s Republic of China.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 138 (1): 120–127. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0000387.
Britto, R., M. Dresner, and A. Voltes. 2012. “The impact of flight delays on passenger demand and societal welfare.” Transp. Res. Part E: Logist. Transp. Rev. 48 (2): 460–469. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tre.2011.10.009.
BTS (Bureau of Transportation Statistics). 2019a. “November 2020 regularly scheduled flights with more than 50% delayed arrivals of more than 30 minutes.” Accessed March 22, 2021. https://www.bts.gov/november-2020-regularly-scheduled-flights-more-50-delayed-arrivals-more-30-minutes.
BTS (Bureau of Transportation Statistics). 2019b. “Passengers: All carriers—All airports.” Accessed March 22, 2021. https://www.transtats.bts.gov/Data_Elements.aspx?Data=1.
Cao, Q., X. Zou, and L. Zhang. 2022. “Multiobjective robust optimization model for generating stable and makespan-protective repetitive schedules.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 148 (9): 04022099. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0002348.
Chaudhary, A. K., and G. D. Israel. 2000. The savvy survey# 8: Pilot testing and pretesting. Gainesville, FL: Univ. of Florida George A. Smathers Libraries.
Christmann, A., and S. Van Aelst. 2006. “Robust estimation of Cronbach’s alpha.” J. Multivar. Anal. 97 (7): 1660–1674. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmva.2005.05.012.
Chyung, S. Y., K. Roberts, I. Swanson, and A. Hankinson. 2017. “Evidence-based survey design: The use of a midpoint on the Likert scale.” Perform. Improv. 56 (10): 15–23. https://doi.org/10.1002/pfi.21727.
Cochran, W. G. 1977. Sampling techniques. 3rd ed. New York: Wiley.
Collins, W., K. Parrish, and G. E. Gibson Jr. 2017. “Development of a project scope definition and assessment tool for small industrial construction projects.” J. Manage. Eng. 33 (4): 04017015. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)ME.1943-5479.0000514.
Creswell, J. W., A. C. Klassen, V. L. Plano Clark, and K. C. Smith. 2011. Vol. 2013 of Best practices for mixed methods research in the health sciences, 541–545. Bethesda, MD: National Institutes of Health.
Davis, K. A. 2004. “Information technology change in the architecture, engineering, and construction industry: An investigation of individuals’ resistance.” Ph.D. thesis, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State Univ.
El Asmar, M., D. Ramsey, G. E. Gibson Jr., and W. Bearup. 2020. “Design-build for transportation projects: Cost and schedule change performance analysis.” J. Leg. Aff. Dispute Resolut. Eng. Constr. 12 (1): 04519030. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)LA.1943-4170.0000335.
Elsayegh, A. 2021. “Collaborative planning in the construction industry: A holistic framework for assessing collaborative planning practices and predicting project performance.” Doctoral dissertation, Dept. of Civil, Architectural and Environmental Engineering, Missouri Univ. of Science and Technology.
Elsayegh, A., and I. H. El-adaway. 2021. “Collaborative planning index: A novel comprehensive benchmark for collaboration in construction projects.” J. Manage. Eng. 37 (5): 04021057. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)ME.1943-5479.0000953.
Elsayegh, A., and I. H. El-adaway. 2022. “Quantitative holistic assessment of implementing collaborative planning practices.” J. Manage. Eng. 38 (3): 04022011. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)ME.1943-5479.0001032.
Emerson, R. W. 2017. “Likert scales.” J. Visual Impairment Blindness 111 (5): 488. https://doi.org/10.1177/0145482X1711100511.
Ernzen, J. J., C. Schexnayder, and G. Flora. 1999. “Design-build effects on a construction company: A case study.” Transp. Res. Rec. 1654 (1): 181–187. https://doi.org/10.3141/1654-21.
FAA (Federal Aviation Administration). 2005. “Advisory circular, AC No. 150/5100-14D.” Accessed May 20, 2018. https://www.faa.gov/documentLibrary/media/Advisory_Circular/150_5100_14d.pdf.
Feghaly, J., M. El Asmar, and S. T. Ariaratnam. 2020. “State of professional practice for water infrastructure project delivery.” Pract. Period. Struct. Des. Constr. 25 (3): 04020018. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)SC.1943-5576.0000500.
Franek, J., and A. Kresta. 2014. “Judgment scales and consistency measure in AHP.” Procedia Econ. Finance 12 (Jan): 164–173. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2212-5671(14)00332-3.
Franz, B., R. Leicht, M. El Asmar, and K. Molenaar. 2022. “Methodological consistency for quantitative analysis and reporting in project delivery system performance research.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 148 (9): 04022080. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0002338.
Gad, G. M., B. Davis, P. P. Shrestha, and P. Harder. 2019. “Lessons learned from progressive design-build implementation on airport projects.” J. Leg. Aff. Dispute Resolut. Eng. Constr. 11 (4): 04519020. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)LA.1943-4170.0000320.
Ghavamifar, K., and A. Touran. 2008. “Alternative project delivery systems: Applications and legal limits in transportation projects.” J. Civ Eng. Educ. 134 (1): 106–111. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)1052-3928(2008)134:1(106).
Haddad, K., and A. Rahman. 2011. “Selection of the best fit flood frequency distribution and parameter estimation procedure: A case study for Tasmania in Australia.” Stochastic Environ. Res. Risk Assess. 25 (Mar): 415–428. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00477-010-0412-1.
Hanna, A. S. 2016. “Benchmark performance metrics for integrated project delivery.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 142 (9): 04016040. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0001151.
Hasanzadeh, S., B. Dao, B. Esmaeili, and M. D. Dodd. 2019. “Role of personality in construction safety: Investigating the relationships between personality, attentional failure, and hazard identification under fall-hazard conditions.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 145 (9): 04019052. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0001673.
Hashem, S. 2014. The power of design-build: A guide to effective design-build project delivery using the SAFEDB-methodology. New York: Business Expert Press.
Isidore, L. J., and W. E. Back. 2001. “Probabilistic optimal-cost scheduling.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 127 (6): 431–437. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9364(2001)127:6(431).
Kalsaas, B. T., G. Hannås, G. Frislie, and J. Skaar. 2018. “Transformation from design-bid-build to design-build contracts in road construction.” In Vol. 18 of Proc., 26th Annual Conf. of the Int. Group for Lean Construction. Chennai, India: International Group for Lean Construction.
Khalafallah, A., N. Kartam, and R. A. Razeq. 2019. “Bilevel standards-compliant platform for evaluating building contractor safety.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 145 (10): 04019054. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0001686.
Khalef, R., and I. H. El-adaway. 2021. “Identifying substantial changes for AIP projects using RF and SVM.” In Proc., Computing in Civil Engineering 2021, 1425–1432. Reston, VA: ASCE.
Khalef, R., and I. H. El-adaway. 2023a. “Advancing airport project delivery: A comparison of design–build and traditional methods in terms of schedule and cost performance.” J. Manage. Eng. 39 (6): 04023041. https://doi.org/10.1061/JMENEA.MEENG-5490.
Khalef, R., and I. H. El-adaway. 2023b. “Identifying design-build decision-making factors and providing future research guidelines: Social network and association rule analysis.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 149 (1): 04022151. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0002431.
Laio, F., G. Di Baldassarre, and A. Montanari. 2009. “Model selection techniques for the frequency analysis of hydrological extremes.” Water Resour. Res. 45 (7). https://doi.org/10.1029/2007WR006666.
Liao, L., E. A. L. Teo, L. Li, X. Zhao, and G. Wu. 2021. “Reducing non-value-adding BIM implementation activities for building projects in Singapore: Leading causes.” J. Manage. Eng. 37 (3): 05021003. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)ME.1943-5479.0000900.
Loulakis, M. C. 2003. Design-build for the public sector. New York: Aspen.
Miller, J. A. 2019. “Evaluating change orders by unforeseen existing conditions in renovation building construction projects.” Master of Science, Dept. of Civil Engineering, California State Univ.
Minchin, R. E., Jr., X. Li, R. R. Issa, and G. G. Vargas. 2013. “Comparison of cost and time performance of design-build and design-bid-build delivery systems in Florida.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 139 (10): 04013007. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0000746.
MoDOT (Missouri DOT). 2020. “RFP TR202105, airport design build documents.” Accessed March 3, 2022. https://www.modot.org/sites/default/files/documents/TR202105_RFP_Final.pdf.
Moon, H., K. Kim, H.-S. Lee, M. Park, T. P. Williams, B. Son, and J.-Y. Chun. 2020. “Cost performance comparison of design-build and design-bid-build for building and civil projects using mediation analysis.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 146 (9): 04020113. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0001873.
Moslem, S., O. Ghorbanzadeh, T. Blaschke, and S. Duleba. 2019. “Analysing stakeholder consensus for a sustainable transport development decision by the fuzzy AHP and interval AHP.” Sustainability 11 (12): 3271. https://doi.org/10.3390/su11123271.
Nguyen, P. H., D. Q. Tran, and S. P. Bypaneni. 2021. “Exploring the impact of project size on design-bid-build and design-build project delivery performance in highways.” Construct. Manage. Econ. 39 (11): 879–893. https://doi.org/10.1080/01446193.2021.1993289.
Nikou Goftar, V., M. El Asmar, and E. Bingham. 2014. “A meta-analysis of literature comparing project performance between design-build (DB) and design-bid-build (DBB) delivery systems.” In Proc., Construction Research Congress 2014: Construction in a Global Network, 1389–1398. Reston, VA: ASCE.
NPIAS (National Plan of Integrated Airport Systems). 2019. “National plan of integrated airport systems (NPIAS) 2015–2019.” Accessed March 22, 2021. https://www.faa.gov/airports/planning_capacity/npias/current/historical/media/2015/npias-2015-2019-report-narrative.pdf.
Palisade. 2019. “RISK for risk analysis.” Accessed November 17, 2020. https://palisade.lumivero.com/.
Panagoulia, E., and T. Rakha. 2023. “Data reliability in BIM and performance analytics: A survey of contemporary AECO practice.” J. Archit. Eng. 29 (2): 04023006. https://doi.org/10.1061/JAEIED.AEENG-1483.
Park, H. S., D. Lee, S. Kim, and J. L. Kim. 2015. “Comparing project performance of design-build and design-bid-build methods for large-sized public apartment housing projects in Korea.” J. Asian Archit. Build. Eng. 14 (2): 323–330. https://doi.org/10.3130/jaabe.14.323.
Park, J., and Y. H. Kwak. 2017. “Design-bid-build (DBB) vs. design-build (DB) in the US public transportation projects: The choice and consequences.” Int. J. Project Manage. 35 (3): 280–295. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2016.10.013.
Peng, Y., Y. Shi, H. Yan, and J. Zhang. 2020. “Multivariate frequency analysis of annual maxima suspended sediment concentrations and floods in the Jinsha River, China.” J. Hydrol. Eng. 25 (9): 05020029. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)HE.1943-5584.0001977.
Pishdad-Bozorgi, P., and J. M. de la Garza. 2012. “Comparative analysis of design-bid-build and design-build from the standpoint of claims.” In Proc., Construction Research Congress 2012: Construction Challenges in a Flat World, 21–30. Reston, VA: ASCE.
Rajsekhar, D., V. P. Singh, and A. K. Mishra. 2015. “Hydrologic drought atlas for Texas.” J. Hydrol. Eng. 20 (7): 05014023. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)HE.1943-5584.0001074.
Rojas, E. M., and I. Kell. 2008. “Comparative analysis of project delivery systems cost performance in Pacific Northwest public schools.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 134 (6): 387–397. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9364(2008)134:6(387).
Saaty, T. L. 2002. Decision making with the analytic hierarchy process. Geneva: Inderscience Publishers.
Saaty, T. L., and K. P. Kearns. 1985. Analytical planning: The organization of systems. The analytic hierarchy process series, 4. Pittsburgh: RWS Publications.
Saaty, T. L., and L. G. Vargas. 2012. “The seven pillars of the analytic hierarchy process.” In Models, methods, concepts & applications of the analytic hierarchy process, 23–40. Boston: Springer.
Sakka, Z. I., and S. M. El-Sayegh. 2007. “Float consumption impact on cost and schedule in the construction industry.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 133 (2): 124–130. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9364(2007)133:2(124).
Santos, J. R. A. 1999. “Cronbach’s alpha: A tool for assessing the reliability of scales.” J. Ext. 37 (2): 1–5.
Shapira, A., and M. Goldenberg. 2005. “AHP-based equipment selection model for construction projects.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 131 (12): 1263–1273. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9364(2005)131:12(1263).
Shen, L. Y., G. W. Wu, and C. S. K. Ng. 2001. “Risk assessment for construction joint ventures in China.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 127 (1): 76–81. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9364(2001)127:1(76).
Sullivan, J., M. E. Asmar, J. Chalhoub, and H. Obeid. 2017. “Two decades of performance comparisons for design-build, construction manager at risk, and design-bid-build: Quantitative analysis of the state of knowledge on project cost, schedule, and quality.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 143 (6): 04017009. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0001282.
Touran, A. 2009. Vol. 21 of A guidebook for selecting airport capital project delivery methods. Washington, DC: Transportation Research Board.
Touran, A., D. Gransberg, K. Molenaar, B. Bakshi, and K. Ghavamifar. 2009. A guidebook for selecting airport capital project delivery. Washington, DC: Transportation Research Board.
Tran, D. Q., G. Diraviam, and R. E. Minchin Jr. 2018. “Performance of highway design-bid-build and design-build projects by work types.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage. 144 (2): 04017112. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0001437.
Vyas, G. S., K. N. Jha, and D. A. Patel. 2019. “Development of green building rating system using AHP and fuzzy integrals: A case of India.” J. Archit. Eng. 25 (2): 04019004. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)AE.1943-5568.0000346.
Wakchaure, S. S., and K. N Jha. 2012. “Determination of bridge health index using analytical hierarchy process.” Construct. Manage. Econ. 30 (2): 133–149. https://doi.org/10.1080/01446193.2012.658075.
Weijters, B., E. Cabooter, and N. Schillewaert. 2010. “The effect of rating scale format on response styles: The number of response categories and response category labels.” Int. J. Res. Market. 27 (3): 236–247. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijresmar.2010.02.004.
Wubbels, M. B. 2021. “Cost performance analysis between design-build and design-bid-build projects in the Netherlands.” Doctoral dissertation, Dept. of Faculty of Spatial Sciences, Univ. of Groningen.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
Volume 150 • Issue 10 • October 2024
Copyright
© 2024 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Dec 18, 2023
Accepted: May 21, 2024
Published online: Aug 9, 2024
Published in print: Oct 1, 2024
Discussion open until: Jan 9, 2025
ASCE Technical Topics:
- Air transportation
- Airports and airfields
- Benefit cost ratios
- Business management
- Construction costs
- Construction engineering
- Construction management
- Design-bid-build
- Disaster risk management
- Financial management
- Infrastructure
- Management methods
- Practice and Profession
- Project management
- Risk management
- Scheduling
- Transportation engineering
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.