Failure as Source of Engineering Judgment: Case of John Roebling
This article has a reply.
VIEW THE REPLYPublication: Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Volume 7, Issue 1
Abstract
The proper use of the concepts and realities of failure is essential for successful design practice, which involves proper engineering judgment. Among the most valuable sources of good design judgment are case studies of how great engineers designed against failure. John Roebling is among the engineers whose works provide excellent models of good judgment and the explicit use of the knowledge of failures in designing successful structures. Roebling's use of failure concepts and case studies to avoid failure in his own designs provides a paradigm for good engineering practice generally. Although the analytical state of the art has certainly advanced since Roebling's time, the basic ideas of good engineering practice are no different now than they were in the 19th century. It therefore follows that a study of the methods of model engineers like Roebling can help develop judgment in modern engineers and thereby reduce the occurrence of failures in modern designs.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
1.
Brunel, I. (1870). The Life of Isambard Kingdom Brunel, civil engineer. Longmans, Green, London, U.K.
2.
Clark, E. (1850). The Britannia and Conway tubular bridges. Day and Son, London, U.K.
3.
Kuesel, T. R. ( 1990 ). “ Whatever happened to long‐term bridge design ?” Civ. Engrg., Feb., 60 ( 2 ), 57 – 60.
4.
McCullough, D. (1972). The great bridge. Simon and Schuster, New York, N.Y.
5.
Navier, C. L. M. H. (1823). Rapport à Monsieur Becquey … et Meoire sur les Pontes Suspendus. Paris, France.
6.
Pasley, C. W. ( 1842 ). “ Description of the state of the suspension bridge at Montrose, after it had been rendered impassible by the hurricane of the 11th of October, 1838; with remarks on the construction of that and other suspension bridges, in reference to the action of violent gales of wind.” Trans. Inst. Civ. Engrs., Inst. of Civ. Engrs., 3, 219 – 227.
7.
Peck, R. B. (1981). “Where has all the judgment gone?” Publikasjon No. 134, Norges Geoteckiske Institutt. Oslo, Norway.
8.
Petroski, H. ( 1991a ). “ Human error and the case for case histories in design.” J. Engrg. Design, 2 ( 1 ), 81 – 88.
9.
Petroski, H. (1991b). “The Britannia tubular bridge: A paradigm of failure‐driven design.” submitted for publication.
10.
Provis, W. A. ( 1842 ). “ Observations on the effects of wind on the suspension bridge over the Menai Strait, more especially as relates to the injuries sustained by the roadways during the storm of January, 1839; together with brief notices of various suggestions for repairing the structure.” Trans. Inst. Civ. Engrg., Inst. of Civ. Engrs., 3, 357 – 370.
11.
Pugsley, Sir A. (1968). The theory of suspension bridges. Edward Arnold, London, U.K.
12.
Rendel, J. M. ( 1841 ). “ Memoir on the Montrose suspension bridge.” Minutes of Proc., Inst. of Civ. Engrg., I, 122 – 127.
13.
Roebling, J. A. ( 1841 ). “ Remarks on suspension bridges, and on the comparative merits of cable and chain bridges,” American Railroad J., 6 ( 7 ), 193 – 196.
14.
Roebling, J. A. (1855). Final report to the presidents and directors of the Niagara Falls Suspension and Niagara Falls International Bridge Companies. Lee, Mann, Rochester, N.Y.
15.
Roebling, J. A. (1867). Annual report of the president and directors to the stockholders of the Covington and Cincinnati Bridge Company for the year ending Feb. 28th, 1867. Murphy & Bechtel, Trenton, N.J.
16.
Roebling, J. A. (1870). Report to the president and directors of the New York Bridge Company, on the proposed East River Bridge. Daily Eagle Print, Brooklyn, N.Y.
17.
Roebling, W. A. (1877). Report of the chief engineer of the New York & Brooklyn Bridge, January 1, 1877. Eagle Print, Brooklyn, N.Y.
18.
Russell, J. S. ( 1839 ). “ On the vibration of suspension bridges and other structures; and the means of preventing injury from this cause.” Trans., Royal Scottish Society of Arts, 1, pp. 304 – 314.
19.
Steinman, D. B. (1950). The builders of the bridge: The story of John Roebling and his son. Harcourt, Brace, New York, N.Y.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Volume 7 • Issue 1 • February 1993
Pages: 46 - 58
Copyright
Copyright © 1993 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Oct 17, 1991
Published online: Feb 1, 1993
Published in print: Feb 1993
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.