Unintended Consequences of Involving Stakeholders Too Late: Case Study in Multi-Objective Management
Publication: Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management
Volume 141, Issue 10
Abstract
This paper examines a case where a plan for aquifer management was constructed on the basis of a single criterion. Though the plan was constructed with stakeholder engagement, the criterion for planning success was predefined before any public input was solicited. The Texas state legislature had mandated all regions establish an aquifer plan but it also created the metric for planning success which it operationalized as the aquifer storage remaining after 50 years. The region of the research reported in this paper met the state’s requirement by setting a target for 50% of aquifer storage to remain after 50 years, a so-called 50/50 rule. As this aquifer is functionally nonrenewable, the 50-year storage target is only meaningful when defined in the context of a so-called terminal condition, or a time period for aquifer exhaustion. It is argued that the technical criterion and the policy target were introduced too early. This obviated important pathways of public discussion that could have addressed how to transition from irrigated to dryland agriculture. Discourse instead was filtered through the lens of this simple so-called future condition criterion, which virtually forced policy and policy discourse to center almost exclusively on irrigation restrictions as the way to extend the life of the aquifer. This narrowed focus had several unintended consequences. The final plan reduces agricultural producer profitability today but it also reduces profitability into the distant future, and the plan actually accelerates rather than slows the pace at which producers eventually exit irrigated agriculture. A more meaningful focus might have been discussion on what a transition to dryland might look like and when it might occur. The attempt to extend the life of the aquifer through irrigation restrictions not only fails to extend aquifer life but it defers any real discussion on dryland conversation. More open and more unconstrained conversation needs to occur before experts ever introduce technical planning criteria.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
Brozovic, N., Sunding, D. L., and Zilberman, D. (2010). “On the spatial nature of the groundwater pumping externality.” Resour. Energy Econ., 32(2), 154–164.
Das, B., Willis, D. B., and Johnson, J. (2010). “Effectiveness of two water conservation policies: An integrated modeling approach.” J. Agric. Appl. Econ., 42(4), 695–710.
Faisal, I. M., Young, R. A., and Warner, J. A. (1994). “An integrated economic hydrologic model for groundwater basin management.”, Colorado Water Resources Research Institute, Fort Collins, CO.
Fischhendler, I., and Zilberman, D. (2005). “Packaging policies to reform the water sector: The case of the Central Valley Project Improvement Act.” Water Resour. Res., 41(7).
ICRISAT (International Council in Research on Indian Sustainable Agriculture). (2006). “Worlds dryland farmers need new agricultural technology.” International Council in Research on Indian Sustainable Agricultural Technology in the Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research (CGIAR) news, Science Advisor Rep., World Bank, Washington, DC.
Jarvis, T., Giordano, M., Puri, S., Matsumoto, K., and Wolf, A. (2005). “International borders, ground water flow, and hydroschizophrenia.” Ground Water, 43(5), 764–770.
Johnson, J. W. (2003). “Regional policy alternatives in response to depletion of the Ogallala Aquifer.” Ph.D. thesis, Texas Tech Univ., Lubbock, TX.
Kim, C. S., Moore, M. R., Hanchar, J. J., and Nieswiadomy, M. (1989). “A dynamic model of adaptation to resource depletion: Theory and an application to groundwater mining.” J. Environ. Econ. Manage., 17(1), 66–82.
Lautze, J., De Silva, S., Giordano, M., and Sanford, L. (2011). “Putting the cart before the horse: Water governance and IWRM.” Nat. Resour. Forum, 35(1), 1–8.
Margat, J., Foster, S., and Droubi, A. (2006). “Concept and importance of non-renewable resources. Into the well from which you drink do not throw stones.” Non-renewable groundwater resources: A guidebook on socially-sustainable management for water-policy makers, S. Foster and D. P. Loucks, eds., World Bank Press, Washington, DC, 13–24.
Marris, E. (2008). “More crop per drop.” Nature, 452(7185), 273–277.
McMahon, G., and Farmer, M. (2004). “Reallocation of federal multipurpose reservoirs: Principles, policy, and practice.” J. Water Resour. Plann. Manage., 187–197.
Nanni, M., Burchi, S., Mechlem, K., and Stephan, R. M. (2006). “Legal and institutional considerations.” Non-renewable groundwater resources: A guidebook on socially-sustainable management for water-policy makers, S. Foster and D. P. Loucks, eds., World Bank Press, Washington, DC, 49–58.
Petiti, O., and Baron, C. (2009). “Integrated Water Resources Management: From general principles to its implementation by the state. The case of Burkina Faso.” Nat. Resour. Forum, 33(1), 49–59.
Petrossian, R., Ridgeway, C., and Donnelly, A. (2007). “Balancing the groundwater checking account through house bill 1763.” Fountainhead, Texas Ground Water Association, TX, 6–7.
Principe, J. (2012). “Optimal groundwater use and dryland adoption utilizing the hotelling framework in the southern High Plains.” Ph.D. thesis, Texas Tech Univ., Lubbock, TX.
TAES (Texas Agrilife Extension Service). (2009). “Cotton herbicide-tolerant, insect-resistant, pivot irrigation and drip irrigated (D2).” 〈http://agecoext.tamu.edu/resources/crop-livestock-budgets/by-commodity/cotton.html〉 (Jan. 30, 2015).
TAES (Texas Agrilife Extension Service). (2010). “Cotton herbicide-tolerant, insect-resistant, pivot irrigation and drip irrigated (D2).” 〈http://agecoext.tamu.edu/resources/crop-livestock-budgets/by-commodity/cotton.html〉 (Jan. 30, 2015).
TAES (Texas Agrilife Extension Service). (2011). “Cotton herbicide-tolerant, insect-resistant, pivot irrigation and drip irrigated (D2).” 〈http://agecoext.tamu.edu/resources/crop-livestock-budgets/by-commodity/cotton.html〉 (Jan. 30, 2015).
Van-Rooijen, D. J., Turral, H., and Biggs, T. W. (2009). “Urban and industrial water use in the Krishna basin, India.” Irrig. Drain., 58(4), 406–428.
Weinheimer, J. A. (2011). “Farm level financial impacts of water policy on the southern Ogallala Aquifer.” Technical Rep. Prepared for the Dept. of Agricultural Economics, Texas Tech Univ., Lubbock, TX.
Young, R. A. (1982). “Energy and water scarcity and the irrigated agricultural economy of the Colorado high plains: Direct economic and hydrologic impact forecasts (1979–2020).” Rep. Prepared for the Colorado Water Resources Research Institute, Colorado State Univ., Fort Collins, CO.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Copyright
© 2015 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Feb 5, 2013
Accepted: Dec 8, 2014
Published online: Mar 4, 2015
Discussion open until: Aug 4, 2015
Published in print: Oct 1, 2015
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.