Legitimizing Postcrisis Policy Change: Crisis-Framing Strategies by Public Leaders in China
Publication: Natural Hazards Review
Volume 23, Issue 4
Abstract
Research shows that postcrisis policy change in democracies is shaped by how crises are framed. Given structural political differences, the role that such framing plays in postcrisis policy change in other types of political systems is unclear. Therefore, this study adjusts the concept of crisis framing to authoritarian China and subsequently identifies framing strategies used by national leaders in response to the severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS), the Sichuan earthquake, and the 2009 H1N1 influenza pandemic. Based on qualitative thematic analysis of statements made by national leaders, this paper shows that although no framing contests existed between them, these individuals used different framing strategies in response to different crises, and each strategy corresponds with different degrees of crisis-induced policy change. We observed major policy changes when national leaders simultaneously acknowledged the crisis, admitted a malfunctioning status quo, and put forward explicit proposals for postcrisis policy changes. Conversely, we observed minor policy change when national leaders denied the significance of the crisis, blamed the crisis on external forces, or put forward no or only abstract proposals for policy change. We argue that national leaders in China use the former strategies if they want to legitimize major policy changes and use the latter if they want to defend the status quo and restrict policy change.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Data Availability Statement
All data, models, and code generated or used during the study appear in the published article, including in the Supplemental Materials.
Acknowledgments
The authors thank Arjen Boin and Paul ‘t Hart for their helpful comments on a previous version of this article. The research is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (71874198 and 72174201).
References
Alink, F., A. Boin, and P. ‘t Hart. 2011. “Institutional crises and reforms in policy sectors: The case of asylum policy in Europe.” J. Eur. Public Policy 8 (2): 286–306. https://doi.org/10.1080/13501760151146487.
ADB (Asian Development Bank). 2003. Asian development outlook 2003 update. Manila, PH: ADB.
Baumgartner, F., and B. Jones. 2010. Agendas and instability in American politics. 2nd ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Birkland, T. 2006. Lessons of disaster: Policy change after catastrophic events. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
Boin, A., and P. ‘t Hart. 2003. “Public leadership in times of crisis: Mission impossible?” Public Administration Rev. 63 (5): 544–553. https://doi.org/10.1111/1540-6210.00318.
Boin, A., P. ‘t Hart, and A. McConnell. 2008. “Conclusions: The politics of crisis exploitation.” In Governing after crisis: The politics of investigation, accountability, and learning, edited by A. Boin, A. McConnell, and P. ‘t Hart, 285–316. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Boin, A., P. ‘t Hart, and A. McConnell. 2009. “Crisis exploitation: Political and policy impacts of framing contests.” J. Eur. Public Policy 16 (1): 81–106. https://doi.org/10.1080/13501760802453221.
Boin, A., P. ‘t Hart, E. Stern, and B. Sundelius. 2016. The politics of crisis management: Public leadership under pressure. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Bovens, M., and P. ‘t Hart. 1996. Understanding policy fiascos. London: Transaction.
Brändström, A., and S. Kuipers. 2003. “From ‘normal incidents’ to political crises: Understanding the selective politicization of policy failures.” Gov. Opposition 38 (3): 279–305. https://doi.org/10.1111/1477-7053.t01-1-00016.
Burns, C., J. Clifton, and L. Quaglia. 2018. “Explaining policy change in the EU: Financial reform after the crisis.” J. Eur. Public Policy 25 (5): 728–746. https://doi.org/10.1080/13501763.2017.1301535.
CCTV (China Central Television). 2003. “Weisheng buzhang Zhang Wenkang xiangshu feidianxing feiyan (dianshi fangtan quanwen)” [Minister of Health Zhang Wenkang recounts SARS (full text of TV interview)]. Accessed January 27, 2021. http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2003-04-02/2154978515.shtml.
Chen, J., J. Pan, and Y. Xu. 2016. “Sources of authoritarian responsiveness: A field experiment in China.” Am. J. Political Sci. 60 (2): 383–400. https://doi.org/10.1111/ajps.12207.
Christensen, T., and L. Ma. 2020. “Coordination structures and mechanisms for crisis management in China: Challenges of complexity.” Public Organ. Rev. 20 (1): 19–36. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11115-018-0423-9.
Edy, J., and P. Meirick. 2007. “Wanted, dead or alive: Media frames, frame adoption, and support for the war in Afghanistan.” J. Commun. 57 (1): 119–141. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1460-2466.2006.00332.x 10.
Entman, R. M. 1993. “Framing: Toward clarification of a fractured paradigm.” J. Commun. 43 (4): 51–58. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1460-2466.1993.tb01304.x.
Furedi, F. 2010. Politics of fear: Beyond left and right. London: Continuum.
Grossman, P. 2015. “Energy shocks, crises, and the policy process: A review of theory and application.” Energy Policy 77 (Feb): 56–69. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2014.11.031.
Hall, P. 1993. “Policy paradigms, social learning, and the state: The case of economic policymaking in Britain.” Comp. Politics 25 (3): 275–296. https://doi.org/10.2307/422246.
Heilmann, S. 2017. “Political leadership.” In China’s political system, edited by S. Heilmann, 153–192. London: Rowman & Littlefield.
Heilmann, S., L. Shih, and S. Heep. 2017. “The Chinese Communist Party and state institutions.” In China’s political system, edited by S. Heilmann, 46–152. London: Rowman & Littlefield.
Howlett, M., and B. Cashore. 2009. “The dependent variable problem in the study of policy change: Understanding policy change as a methodological problem.” J. Comp. Policy Anal. Res. Pract. 11 (1): 33–46. https://doi.org/10.1080/13876980802648144.
Hu, J. 2016. “Shuli he luoshi kexue fazhanguan” [Establish and implement the Scientific Outlook on Development]. In Hu Jintao wenxuan: Di er juan, edited by Zhonggong Zhongyang and Wenxian Bianji Weiyuanhui. Beijing: Renmin chubanshe.
Keeler, J. 1993. “Opening the window for reform mandates, crises, and extraordinary policy-making.” Comp. Political Stud. 25 (4): 433–486. https://doi.org/10.1177/0010414093025004002.
Kettl, D. F. 2003. “Contingent coordination: Practical and theoretical puzzles for homeland security.” Am. Rev. Public Administration 33 (3): 253–277. https://doi.org/10.1177/0275074003254472.
King, G., J. Pan, and M. Roberts. 2013. “How censorship in China allows government criticism but silences collective expression.” Am. Political Sci. Rev. 107 (2): 326–343. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055413000014.
Kingdon, J. W. 2011. Agendas, alternatives, and public policies. 2nd ed. New York: Longman.
Knight, J. 2014. “China as a developmental state.” World Econ. 37 (10): 1335–1347. https://doi.org/10.1111/twec.12215.
Knutsen, W. 2012. “An institutional account of China’s HIV AIDS policy process from 1985 to 2010.” Politics Policy 40 (1): 161–192. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1747-1346.2011.00339.x.
Kuipers, S., and N. H. Welsh. 2017. “Taxonomy of the crisis and disaster literature: Themes and types in 34 years of research.” Risk Hazards Crisis Public Policy 8 (4): 272–283. https://doi.org/10.1002/rhc3.12123.
Lawrence, S. V. 2013. China’s political institutions and leaders in charts. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service.
Li, C. 2006. “Think national, blame local: Central-provincial dynamics in the Hu era.” China Leadersh. Monit. 17 (1): 24.
Liu, Y. 2019. “Crisis rhetoric and policy change in China: Toward a dynamic process model of crisis exploitation.” Ph.D. dissertation, School of Governance, Utrecht Univ.
Liu, Y., and A. Boin. 2020. “Framing a mega-disaster: Political rhetoric and the Wenchuan earthquake.” Saf. Sci. 125 (May): 1–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssci.2020.104621.
Liu, Y., and T. Christensen. 2021. “The long-term development of crisis management in China—Continuity, institutional punctuations and reforms.” Rev. Policy Res. 39 (3): 282–302. https://doi.org/10.1111/ropr.12455.
Lu, X., and L. Xue. 2016. “Managing the unexpected: Sense-making in the Chinese emergency management system.” Public Administration 94 (2): 414–429. https://doi.org/10.1111/padm.1226.
Nohrstedt, D., and C. Weible. 2010. “The logic of policy change after crisis: Proximity and subsystem interaction.” Risk Hazards Crisis Public Policy 1 (2): 1–32. https://doi.org/10.2202/1944-4079.1035.
Olson, R. S. 2000. “Toward a politics of disaster: Losses, values, agendas, and blame.” Int. J. Mass Emergencies Disasters 18 (2): 265–287.
Olson, R. S., N. E. Ganapati, V. T. Gawronski, R. A. Olson, R. Salna, and J. P. Sarmiento. 2020. “From disaster risk reduction to policy studies: Bridging research communities.” Nat. Hazards Rev. 21 (2): 04020014. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)NH.1527-6996.0000365.
Olsson, E., and L. W. Nord. 2014. “Paving the way for crisis exploitation: The role of journalistic styles and standards.” Journalism 16 (3): 341–358. https://doi.org/10.1177/1464884913519032.
Olsson, E. K., L. Nord, and J. Falkheimer. 2015. “Media coverage crisis exploitation characteristics: A case comparison study.” J. Public Rel. Res. 27 (2): 158–174. https://doi.org/10.1080/1062726X.2014.976827.
Pomfret, J. 2003. “Outbreak gave China’s Hu an opening.” Accessed August 20, 2018. https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/2003/05/13/outbreak-gave-chinas-hu-an-opening/6e7ebf75-9689-48bb-81a9-3e28e7f25b56/.
Qiu, W., C. Chu, X. Hou, S. Rutherford, B. Zhu, Z. Tong, and A. Mao. 2018. “A comparison of China’s risk communication in response to SARS and H7N9 using principles drawn from international practice.” Disaster Med. Public Health Preparedness 12 (5): 587–598. https://doi.org/10.1017/dmp.2017.114.
Reilly, J. 2011. Strong society, smart state: The rise of public opinion in China’s Japan policy. New York: Columbia University Press.
Resodihardjo, S. 2009. Crisis and change in the British and Dutch prison services: Understanding crisis-reform processes. London: Routledge.
Rochefort, D., and R. Cobb. 1994. “Problem definition: An emerging perspective.” In The politics of problem definition: Shaping the policy agenda, edited by D. Rochefort and R. Cobb, 1–31. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas.
Roe, E. M. 2019. “Social complexity, crisis, and management.” In Oxford research encyclopedia of Politics. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Romzek, B., and M. Dubnick. 1987. “Accountability in the public sector: Lessons from the Challenger tragedy.” Public Administration Rev. 47 (3): 227–238. https://doi.org/10.2307/975901.
Rosenthal, U., A. Boin, and L. K. Comfort. 2001. “The changing world of crisis and crisis management.” In Managing crises: Threats, dilemmas, opportunities, edited by U. Rosenthal, A. Boin, and L. K. Comfort, 5–27. Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas.
Rosenthal, U., M. Charles, and P. ‘t Hart. 1989. Coping with crises: The management of disasters, riots, and terrorism. New York: Charles C Thomas.
Rosenthal, U., and A. Kouzmin. 1993. “Globalizing an agenda for contingencies and crisis management: An editorial statement.” J. Contingencies Crisis Manage. 1 (1): 1–12. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-5973.1993.tb00001.x.
Schlaufer, C., D. Gafurova, E. Zhiryakova, M. Shikhova, and N. Belyaeva. Forthcoming. “Narrative strategies in a nondemocratic setting: Moscow’s urban policy debates.” Policy Stud. J. https://doi.org/10.1111/psj.12445.
Shanahan, E. A., M. D. Jones, and M. K. McBeth. 2011. “Policy narratives and policy processes.” Policy Stud. J. 39 (3): 535–561. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1541-0072.2011.00420.x.
Shao, L. 2018. “The dilemma of criticism: Disentangling the determinants of media censorship in China.” J. East Asian Stud. 18 (3): 279–297. https://doi.org/10.1017/jea.2018.19.
Shirk, S. L. 2007. China: Fragile superpower. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Shirk, S. L. 2011. Changing media, changing China. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Stark, A. 2018. “New institutionalism, critical junctures and postcrisis policy reform.” Aust. J. Political Sci. 53 (1): 24–39. https://doi.org/10.1080/10361146.2017.1409335.
State Council. 2003a. “Gaodu zhongshi jiaqiang lingdao qieshi zuohao nongcun feidianxing feiyan fangzhi gongzuo zai quanguo nongcun feidianxing feiyan fangzhi gongzuo dianshi dianhua huiyi shang de jianghua” [Highly important: Strengthen leadership, earnestly carry out rural SARS prevention and cure work; speech at the TV and telephone meeting on national rural work of preventing and curing SARS]. Accessed January 28, 2021. http://www.hainan.gov.cn/data/zfgb/2019/10/6857/.
State Council. 2003b. “Guowuyuan changwu huiyi yanjiu bushu fangzhi feidian he jingji gongzuo” [The State Council Standing Committee researches, deploys people for SARS cure and prevention and the economy]. Accessed January 27, 2021. http://www.gov.cn/misc/2005-08/22/content_25378.htm.
State Council. 2009. “Guowuyuan changwu huiyi yanjiu bushu jiaqiang ren ganran zhuliugan fangkong [The State Council Standing Committee researches, deploys people, and strengthens the prevention and control of swine flu].” Accessed January 27, 2021. http://www.gov.cn/ldhd/2009-04/28/content_1298230.htm.
Steinhardt, C. H. 2017. “Discursive accommodation: Popular protest and strategic elite communication in China.” Eur. Political Sci. Rev. 9 (4): 539–560. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1755773916000102.
Stockmann, D. 2013. Media commercialization and authoritarian rule in China. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Stone, D. 1989. “Causal stories and the formation of policy agendas.” Political Sci. Q. 104 (2): 281–300. https://doi.org/10.2307/2151585.
Sun, Y., and J. Guo. 2017. “The operation process and genetic mechanism of Chinese campaign-style governance model: The case study of APEC blue.” Am. J. Ind. Bus. Manage. 7 (4): 372–385. https://doi.org/10.4236/ajibm.2017.74027.
Tao, P., and C. Chen. 2018. “Towards a politics of disaster response: Presidential disaster instructions in China, 1998-2012.” Disasters 42 (2): 275–293. https://doi.org/10.1111/disa.12243.
Tarrow, S. 1992. “Mentalities, political cultures, and collective action frames.” In Frontiers in social movement theory, edited by A. D. Morris and C. McClurg Mueller, 174–202. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
‘t Hart, P. 1993. “Symbols, rituals, and power: The lost dimensions of crisis management.” J. Contingencies Crisis Manage. 1 (1): 36–50.
‘t Hart, P., and K. Tindall. 2009. Framing the global economic downturn: Crisis rhetoric and the politics of recessions. Canberra, Australia: ANU Press.
Van Aelst, P., and S. Walgrave. 2021. “Information and arena: The dual function of the news media for political elites.” J. Commun. 66 (3): 496–518. https://doi.org/10.1111/jcom.12229.
Van den Dool, A. 2019. “Never again: Legal change after public health crises in China.” Ph.D. dissertation, School of Law, Univ. of Amsterdam.
Vasterman, P., C. Yzermans, and A. Dirkzwager. 2005. “The role of the media and media hypes in the aftermath of disasters.” Epidemiol. Rev. 27 (1): 107–114. https://doi.org/10.1093/epirev/mxi002.
Wade, S. 2016. “Minitrue: 21 rules on coverage of the two sessions.” Accessed January 27, 2021. https://chinadigitaltimes.net/2016/03/minitrue-important-notices-coverage-two-sessions/.
Walgrave, S., and F. Varone. 2008. “Punctuated equilibrium and agenda-setting: Bringing parties back in: Policy change after the Dutroux crisis in Belgium.” Governance 21 (3): 365–395. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0491.2008.00404.x.
Walsh, J. 2006. “Policy failure and policy change: British security policy after the cold war.” Comp. Political Stud. 39 (4): 490–518. https://doi.org/10.1177/0010414005275562.
Wang, S. 2004. “China’s health system: From crisis to opportunity.” Yale-China Health J. 3 (Jan): 5–49.
Wen, J. 2004. “Tigao renshi tongyi sixiang laogu shuli he renzhen luoshi kexue fazhanguan” [Raise awareness, unify the idea, firmly establish, and earnestly implement the Scientific Outlook on Development]. Guowuyuan gongbao (12): 5–15.
WHO (World Health Organization). 2003. “Summary of probable SARS cases with onset of illness from 1 November 2002 to 31 July 2003.” Accessed January 27, 2021. http://www.who.int/csr/sars/country/table2004_04_21/en/.
Wu, J., N. Li, S. Hallegatte, P. Shi, A. Hu, and X. Liu. 2012. “Regional indirect economic impact evaluation of the 2008 Wenchuan earthquake.” Environ. Earth Sci. 65 (1): 161–172. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12665-011-1078-9.
Xiao, Y. 2013. “The politics of crisis management in China.” Ph.D. dissertation, Dept. of Politics and International Studies, Univ. of Warwick.
Xinhua. 2003a. “Quanguo fangzhi feidian gongzuo huiyi zai Beijing juxing” [National meeting on SARS prevention and cure work has been held in Beijing]. Accessed January 28, 2021. http://zqb.cyol.com/content/2003-07/29/content_705147.htm.
Xinhua. 2003b. “Wen Jiabao zhuchi Guowuyuan changwu huiyi yanjiu feidian feiyan fangzhi” [Wen Jiabao chairs State Council Standing Committee meeting studying SARS prevention and control]. Accessed February 1, 2021. http://news.eastday.com/epublish/gb/paper148/20030402/class014800018/hwz917250.htm.
Xinhua. 2003c. “Wu Yi qiangdiao Zhongguo zhengfu you xinxin you nengli kongzhi bing xiaochu yiqing” [Wu Yi emphasizes that the Chinese government has the confidence and capability to control and eliminate the epidemic situation]. Accessed January 29, 2021. http://news.eastday.com/epublish/gb/paper148/20030409/class014800018/hwz921762.htm.
Xinhua. 2003d. “Zhang Wenkang huijian Shijie Weisheng Zuzhi daibiao tan feidianxing feiyan qingkuang” [Zhang Wenkang met with representatives of the World Health Organization to discuss the SARS situation]. Accessed January 28, 2021. http://news.sohu.com/20/01/news207270120.shtml.
Xinhua. 2003e. “Zhonggong zhongyang zhengzhiju changweihui 17 ri zhaokai fangzhi feidian de huiyi” [The Politburo Standing Committee of Chinese Communist Party on the 17th convened a meeting on preventing and curing SARS]. Accessed February 1, 2021. http://news.sohu.com/78/14/news208581478.shtml.
Xinhua. 2008. “Li Yuanchao: Dangyuan ganbu yao shizhong zhan zai kangzhen jiuzai zui qianlie” [Li Yuanchao: Party members must stand at the very front of earthquake relief all along]. Accessed January 29, 2021. https://www.chinanews.com/gn/news/2008/05-27/1262741.shtml.
Xinhua. 2009. “Wen Jiabao kanwang Beijing quezhen jiaxing liugan huanzhe he yihu renyuan” [Wen Jiabao visits H1N1 patients and medical personnel in Beijing]. Accessed February 2, 2021. http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/hqgj/mobfzlg/2009-05/18/content_7788179.htm.
Xinhua. 2010. “Kexue fazhan guan de tichu” [Proposing the Scientific Outlook on Development]. Guangming Ribao, January 9, 2010.
Xue, L., and G. Zeng. 2019. A Comprehensive evaluation on emergency response in China: The case of pandemic influenza (H1N1) 2009. Singapore: Springer.
Yang, G. 2013. “Contesting food safety in the Chinese media: Between hegemony and counter-hegemony.” China Q. 214 (May): 337–355. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0305741013000386.
Yu, H. 2013. “Chuanranbing fangzhi de 'feichang shi nian'” [The unusual ten years of infectious disease prevention]. Zhongguo Renda 15 (Aug): 12–14.
Zhang, H., and G. Tang. 2021. “Paired assistance policy and recovery from the 2008 Wenchuan earthquake: A network perspective.” Disasters 45 (1): 126–157. https://doi.org/10.1111/disa.12413.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Natural Hazards Review
Volume 23 • Issue 4 • November 2022
Copyright
© 2022 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Sep 14, 2021
Accepted: Apr 8, 2022
Published online: Jul 12, 2022
Published in print: Nov 1, 2022
Discussion open until: Dec 12, 2022
ASCE Technical Topics:
- Analysis (by type)
- Business management
- Diseases
- Earthquakes
- Engineering fundamentals
- Engineering profession
- Frames
- Geohazards
- Geotechnical engineering
- Health hazards
- Leadership
- Management methods
- Political factors
- Practice and Profession
- Professional development
- Public administration
- Public health and safety
- Public policy
- Quality control
- Quantitative analysis
- Structural engineering
- Structural members
- Structural systems
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.
Cited by
- Colette S. Vogeler, Annemieke van den Dool, Meifang Chen, Programmatic action in Chinese health policy—The making and design of “Healthy China 2030”, Review of Policy Research, 10.1111/ropr.12533, (2023).