Comparison of SWAT and DLBRM for Hydrological Modeling of a Mountainous Watershed in Arid Northwest China
Publication: Journal of Hydrologic Engineering
Volume 21, Issue 5
Abstract
A distributed physically based model, soil and water assessment tool (SWAT), and a distributed conceptual model, distributed large basin runoff model (DLBRM), were selected to compare their applicability and performance in simulating daily runoff in the Heihe River watershed, the second-largest inland river (terminal lake) with a peak elevation of 5,584 m above sea level (asl) in arid northwest China. Both models have been calibrated against the observed daily runoff at the watershed outlet (Yingluoxia Hydrological Station) for the period of 1995–2004 and validated for the period of 2005–2009. Results show that both SWAT and DLBRM produced reasonable results in this study, and DLBRM performed better than SWAT. The difference in performance is mainly due to data constraints, different interpolation schemes, and spatial representations of landscape variations in the models. The tank storage-output principle used in DLBRM seems more suitable than the Soil Conservation Service curve number (SCS-CN) method used in SWAT to simulate daily flow in an arid area. Both models performed worse in simulating low flows mostly occurring in spring and winter, because of a lack of detailed representation of the impacts of snow-melting processes and frozen soils. The authors’ analysis indicates that consideration of the impacts of snow melting and frozen soils on the hydrological process is key to improving performance of hydrological models in mountainous areas. Because of their simpler operations, lower data requirements, fewer input parameters, and better performances, distributed conceptual models such as DLBRM seem more suitable for hydrological modeling in data-deficient, high elevation, and topographically complex mountainous watersheds in arid regions.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Acknowledgments
The project is partially funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (91125010), Scherer Endowment Fund of Department of Geography, Western Michigan University, and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (lzujbky-2015-130). We thank anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments and suggestions.
References
Arnold, J. G., and Fohrer, N. (2005). “SWAT2000: Current capabilities and research opportunities in applied watershed modelling.” Hydrol. Processes, 19(3), 563–572.
Arnold, J. G., Srinivasin, R., Muttiah, R. S., and Williams, J. R. (1998). “Large area hydrologic modeling and assessment: Part I. Model development.” J. Am. Water Resour. Assoc., 34(1), 73–89.
Beven, K. J. (1989). “Changing ideas in hydrology: The case of physically-based models.” J. Hydrol., 105(1–2), 157–172.
Beven, K. J. (2001). “How far can we go in distributed hydrological modelling?” Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 5(1), 1–12.
Boyle, D. B., Gupta, H. V., Sorooshian, S., Koren, V., Zhang, Z., and Smith, M. (2001). “Toward improved streamflow forecasts, value of semi-distributed modeling.” Water Resour. Res., 37(11), 2749–2759.
Carpenter, T. M., and Georgakakos, K. P. (2006). “Intercomparison of lumped versus distributed hydrologic model ensemble simulations on operational forecast scales.” J. Hydrol., 329(1–2), 174–185.
Chen, J. F., and Li, X. B. (2004). “Simulation of hydrological response to land-cover changes.” Chin. J. Appl. Ecol., 15(5), 833–836 (in Chinese).
Chen, R. S., Kang, E. S., Yang, J. P., and Zhang, J. S. (2003a). “A distributed daily runoff model of inland river mountainous basin.” J. Geog. Sci., 13(3), 363–372.
Chen, R. S., Kang, E. S., Yang, J. P., Zhang, J. S., and Wang, S. G. (2003b). “Application of TOPMODEL to simulate runoff from Heihe mainstream mountainous basin.” J. Desert Res., 23(4), 428–434 (in Chinese).
Cornelissen, T., Diekkrüger, B., and Giertz, S. (2013). “A comparison of hydrological models for assessing the impact of land use and climate change on discharge in a tropical catchment.” J. Hydrol., 498(19), 221–236.
Croley, T. E. P., and He, C. (2005). “Distributed-parameter large basin runoff model. I: Model development.” J. Hydrol. Eng., 173–181.
Croley, T. E. P., and He, C. (2006). “Watershed surface and subsurface spatial intraflows.” J. Hydrol. Eng., 12–20.
Dawdy, D. R. (1969). “Considerations involved in evaluating mathematical modelling of urban hydrologic systems.” USGS, Washington, DC.
Gebremariam, S. Y., Martin, J. F., DeMarchi, C., Bosch, N. S., Confesor, R., and Ludsin, S. A. (2014). “Comprehensive evaluation of three watershed models to predict Maumee River flow regime and discharge into Lake Erie.” Environ. Modell. Software, 61, 121–134.
Green, W. H., and Ampt, G. A. (1911). “Studies of soil physics: 1. The flow of air and water through soils.” J. Agric. Sci., 4(1), 1–24.
Grizzetti, B., Bouraoui, F., Granlund, K., Rekolainenb, S., and Bidoglio, G. (2003). “Modelling diffuse emission and retention of nutrients in the Vantaanjoki watershed (Finland) using the SWAT model.” Ecol. Modell., 169(1), 25–38.
Gudmundsson, L., et al. (2012). “Comparing large-scale hydrological model simulations to observed runoff percentiles in Europe.” J. Hydrometeorol., 13(2), 604–620.
Han, J., Zhang, W. C., and Zhao, D. Z. (2004). “TOPMODEL-based simulation of water resources in Heihe river catchment.” Rural Eco-Environ., 20(2), 16–20 (in Chinese).
Hargreaves, G. H., and Samani, Z. A. (1985). “Reference crop evapotranspiration from temperature.” Appl. Eng. Agric., 1(2), 96–99.
He, C., and Croley, T. E. P. (2007). “Application of a distributed large basin runoff model in the Great Lakes basin.” Control Eng. Pract., 15(8), 1001–1011.
He, C., DeMarchi, C., Croley, T. E. P., Feng, Q., and Hunter, T. (2009). “Hydrological modeling of the Heihe watershed by DLBRM in Northwest China.” J. Glaciol. Geocryol., 31(3), 410–420.
He, C., Zhang, L., Fu, L., Luo, Y., Li, L., and DeMarchi, C. (2013). “Simulation of River flow for downstream water allocation in the Heihe River Watershed, Northwest China.” Landscape ecology for sustainable environment and culture, B. Fu and K. B. Jones, eds., Springer, New York, 173–186.
Huang, Y., Zou, Y., Huang, G., Maqsood, I., and Chakma, A. (2005). “Flood vulnerability to climate change through hydrological modeling—A case study of the swift current creek watershed in Western Canada.” Water Int., 30(1), 31–39.
Immerzeel, W. W., Beek, L. P. H., and Bierkens, M. F. P. (2010). “Climate change will affect the Asian water towers.” Science, 328(5984), 1382–1385.
Ives, J. D., Messerli, B., and Spiess, E. (1997). “Introduction.” Mountains of the world: A global priority, B. Messerli and J. D. Ives, eds., Parthenon, New York, 1–15.
Jayakrishnan, R., Srinivasan, R., Santhi, C., and Arnold, J. G. (2005). “Advances in the application of the SWAT model for water resources management.” Hydrol. Processes, 19(3), 749–762.
Jia, Y. W., Wang, H., and Yan, D. H. (2006). “Distributed model of hydrological cycle system in Heihe River basin: I. Model development and verification.” J. Hydraul. Eng., 37(5), 534–542 (in Chinese).
Jin, X., Zhang, L., Gu, J., Zhao, C., Tian, J., and He, C. (2015). “Modelling the impacts of spatial heterogeneity in soil hydraulic properties on hydrological process in the upper reach of the Heihe River in the Qilian Mountains, Northwest China.” Hydrol. Processes, 29(15), 3318–3327.
Kampf, S. K., and Burges, S. J. (2007). “A framework for classifying and comparing distributed hillslope and catchment hydrologic models.” Water Resour. Res., 43, W05423.
Krause, P., Boyle, D. P., and Bäse, F. (2005). “Comparison of different efficiency criteria for hydrological model assessment.” Adv. Geosci., 5, 89–97.
Kundzewicz, Z. W., and Kraemer, D. (1998). “Striving towards assessment of mountain water resources, in ecohydrology of High Mountain areas.” Proc., Int. Conf. on Ecohydrology of High Mountain Areas, S. R. Chalise, et al. eds., Kathmandu, Nepal, 175–185.
Li, Z., Liu, W. Z., Zhang, X. C., and Zheng, F. L. (2010). “Assessing and regulating the impacts of climate change on water resources in the Heihe watershed on the Loess Plateau of China.” Sci. China Earth Sci., 53(5), 710–720.
Li, Z., Xu, Z., Shao, Q., and Yang, J. (2009). “Parameter estimation and uncertainty analysis of SWAT model in upper reaches of the Heihe river basin.” Hydrol. Processes, 23(19), 2744–2753.
Li, Z. L., Xu, Z. X., and Li, Z. J. (2011). “Performance of WASMOD and SWAT on hydrological simulation in Yingluoxia watershed in northwest of China.” Hydrol. Processes, 25(13), 2001–2008.
Lidén, R., and Harlin, J. (2000). “Analysis of conceptual rainfall-runoff modelling performance in different climates.” J. Hydrol., 238(3–4), 231–247.
Liniger, H. P., Weingartner, R., and Grosjean, M. (1998). “Mountains of the world: Water towers for the 21st century—A contribution to global freshwater management.” Dept. of Geography, Univ. of Berne, Switzerland.
Luo, Y., He, C., Sophocleous, M., Yin, Z., and Ren, H. (2008). “Assessment of crop growth and soil water modules in SWAT2000 using extensive field experiment data in the irrigation district of the Yellow River basin.” J. Hydrol., 352(1–2), 139–156.
Marques, J. E., et al. (2011). “Evaluation of water resources in a high-mountain basin in Serra da Estrela, Central Portugal, using a semi-distributed hydrological model.” Environ. Earth Sci., 62(6), 1219–1234.
Michaud, J., and Sorooshian, S. (1994). “Comparison of simple versus complex distributed runoff models on a midsized semiarid watershed.” Water Resour. Res., 30(3), 593–605.
Minville, M., et al. (2014). “Improving process representation in conceptual hydrological model calibration using climate simulations.” Water Resour. Res., 50(6), 5044–5073.
Mishra, S. K., and Singh, V. P. (2003). “SCS-CN method.” Soil conservation service curve number (SCS-CN) methodology, S. K. Mishra and V. P. Singh, eds., Springer, Germany, 84–146.
Mockus, V. (1972). “Estimation of direct runoff from storm rainfall.” SCS national engineering handbook, U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Washington, DC, 10.1–10.16.
Monteith, J. L. (1965). “Evaporation and the environment.” 19th Symp. State and Movement of Water in Living Organisms, Cambridge University Press, U.K., 205–234.
Moriasi, D. N., Arnold, J. G., Van Liew, M. W., Bingner, R. L., Harmel, R. D., and Veith, T. L. (2007). “Model evaluation guidelines for systematic quantification of accuracy in watershed simulations.” Am. Soc. Agric. Biol. Eng., 50(3), 885–900.
Nash, J. E., and Sutcliffe, J. V. (1970). “River flow forecasting through conceptual models: Part I—A discussion of principles.” J. Hydrol., 10(3), 282–290.
Neitsch, S. L., Arnold, J. G., Kiniry, J. R., and Williams, J. R. (2009). “Soil and water assessment tool theoretical documentation, version 2009.” GSWR Agricultural Research Service and Texas Agricultural Experiment Station, Temple, TX.
Niklas, S. C., Wood, A. W., Voisin, N., Lettenmaier, D. P., and Palmer, R. N. (2004). “The effects of climate change on the hydrology and water resources of the Colorado River basin.” Clim. Change, 62(1–3), 337–363.
Ning, B. Y., He, Y. Q., He, X. Z., and Li, Z. X. (2008). “Advances on water resource research in Heihe River basin.” J. Desert Res., 28(6), 1180–1185 (in Chinese).
Ouessar, M., Bruggeman, A., Abdelli, F., Mohtar, R. H., Gabriels, D., and Cornelis, W. M. (2009). “Modelling water-harvesting systems in the arid south of Tunisia using SWAT.” Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 13(10), 2003–2021.
Parajuli, P. B., Nelson, N. O., Frees, L. D., and Mankin, K. R. (2009). “Comparison of AnnAGNPS and SWAT model simulation results in USDA-CEAP agricultural watersheds in south-central Kansas.” Hydrol. Processes, 23(5), 748–763.
Pohl, S., Davison, B., Marsh, P., and Pietroniro, A. (2005). “Modelling spatially distributed snowmelt and meltwater runoff in a small Arctic catchment with a hydrology land-surface scheme (WATCLASS).” Atmos. Ocean, 43(3), 193–211.
Priestley, C. H. B., and Taylor, R. J. (1972). “On the assessment of surface heat flux and evaporation using large-scale parameters.” Mon. Weather. Rev., 100(2), 81–92.
Qi, S., and Luo, F. (2006). “Land-use change and its environmental impact in the Heihe River basin, arid northwestern China.” Environ. Geol., 50(4), 535–540.
Rahman, K., Maringanti, C., Beniston, M., Widmer, F., Abbaspour, K., and Lehmann, A. (2013). “Streamflow modeling in a highly managed mountainous glacier watershed using SWAT: The Upper Rhone River watershed case in Switzerland.” Water Resour. Manage., 27(2), 323–339.
Refsgaard, J. S., and Knudsen, J. (1996). “Operational validation and intercomparison of different types of hydrological models.” Water Resour. Res., 32(7), 2189–2202.
Ritchie, J. T. (1972). “Model for predicting evaporation from a row crop with incomplete cover.” Water Resour. Res., 8(5), 1204–1213.
Ritter, A., and Muñoz-Carpena, R. (2013). “Performance evaluation of hydrological models: Statistical significance for reducing subjectivity in goodness-of-fit assessments.” J. Hydrol., 480(14), 33–45.
Sharpley, A. N., and Williams, J. R. (1990). “EPIC-erosion/productivity impact calculator: 1. Model documentation.” U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Washington, DC.
Srinivasan, R., Zhang, X., and Arnold, J. (2010). “SWAT ungauged: Hydrological budget and crop yield predictions in the Upper Mississippi River basin.” Trans. ASABE, 53(5), 1533–1546.
Stahli, M., Jansson, P. E., and Lundin, L. C. (1996). “Preferential waterflow in a frozen soil—A two-domain model approach.” Hydrol. Processes, 10(10), 1305–1316.
Todini, E. (2007). “Hydrological catchment modelling: Past, present and future.” Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 11(1), 468–482.
Tong, S. T. Y., and Chen, W. (2002). “Modeling the relationship between land use and surface water quality.” J. Environ. Manage., 66(4), 377–393.
Van Griensven, A., Meixner, T., Grunwald, S., Bishop, T., Diluzio, A., and Srinivasan, R. (2006). “A global sensitivity analysis tool for the parameters of multi-variable catchment models.” J. Hydrol., 324(1–4), 10–23.
Viviroli, D., Du¨rr, H. H., Messerli, B., Meybeck, M., and Weingartner, R. (2007). “Mountains of the world, water towers for humanity: Typology, mapping, and global significance.” Water Resour. Res., 43(7), W07447.
Viviroli, D., and Weingartner, R. (2004). “The hydrological significance of mountains: From regional to global scale.” Hydol. Earth Syst. Sci., 8(6), 1016–1029.
Wang, G. X., Liu, C. M., and Huang, Y. B. (2003). “The theory of SWAT model and its application in Heihe basin.” Process Geogr., 2, 79–86 (in Chinese).
Wu, K., and Johnston, C. A. (2007). “Hydrologic response to climatic variability in a Great Lakes Watershed: A case study with the SWAT model.” J. Hydrol., 337(1–2), 187–199.
Xia, J., Wang, G. S., Lv, A. F., and Tan, G. (2003). “A research on distributed time variant gain modeling.” Acta Geographica Sinica, 58(5), 789–796 (in Chinese).
Xie, H., and Lian, Y. (2013). “Uncertainty-based evaluation and comparison of SWAT and HSPF applications to the Illinois River basin.” J. Hydrol., 481, 119–131.
Xu, Y. D., Fu, B. J., and He, C. S. (2013). “Assessing the hydrological effect of the check dams in the Loess Plateau, China, by model simulations.” Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 17(6), 2185–2193.
Zeinivand, H., and Smedt De, F. (2009). “Hydrological modeling of snow accumulation and melting on River basin scale.” Water Resour. Manage., 23(11), 2271–2287.
Zhang, Y., et al. (2013a). “Coupling of a simultaneous heat and water model with a distributed hydrological model and evaluation of the combined model in a cold region watershed.” Hydrol. Processes, 27(25), 3762–3776.
Zhang, Y., Xia, J., Shao, Q., and Zhai, X. (2013b). “Water quantity and quality simulation by improved SWAT in highly regulated Huai River basin of China.” Stochastic Environ. Res. Risk Assess., 27(1), 11–27.
Zhou, J., et al. (2008). “An improved precipitation-runoff model based on MMS and its application in the upstream basin of the Heihe River.” J. Nat. Resour., 23(4), 724–736 (in Chinese).
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Hydrologic Engineering
Volume 21 • Issue 5 • May 2016
Copyright
© 2016 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: May 7, 2015
Accepted: Sep 4, 2015
Published online: Feb 17, 2016
Published in print: May 1, 2016
Discussion open until: Jul 17, 2016
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.