Joint Probability Distribution and Correlation Analysis of Wind and Solar Power Forecast Errors in the Western Interconnection
Publication: Journal of Energy Engineering
Volume 141, Issue 1
Abstract
Wind and solar power generation differ from conventional power generation because of the variable and uncertain nature of their power output. This can have significant impacts on grid operations. Short-term forecasting of wind and solar power generation is uniquely helpful for planning the balance of supply and demand in the electric power system because it allows for a reduction in the uncertainty associated with their output. As a step toward assessing the simultaneous integration of large amounts of wind and solar power, this article investigates the spatial and temporal correlation between wind and solar power forecast errors. The forecast and actual data analyzed are obtained from one of the world’s largest regional variable generation integration studies to date. Multiple spatial and temporal scales (day ahead, 4 h ahead, and 1 h ahead) of forecast errors for the Western Interconnection in the United States are analyzed. A joint probability distribution of wind and solar power forecast errors is estimated using kernel density estimation. The Pearson’s correlation coefficient and mutual information between wind and solar power forecast errors are also evaluated. The results show that wind and solar power forecast errors are inversely correlated, and the correlation between wind and solar power forecast errors becomes stronger as the geographic size of the analyzed region increases. The absolute value of the correlation coefficient is generally less than 0.1 in the case of small geographic regions, while it is generally between 0.15 and 0.6 in the case of large geographic regions. The forecast errors are less correlated on the day-ahead timescale, which influences economic operations more than reliability, and more correlated on the 4-h-ahead timescale, where reliability is more impacted by the forecasts. It is also found that the correlation between wind and solar power forecast errors in summer (July) is relatively stronger than in winter (January). The inverse correlation implies that in systems with high penetrations of both wind and solar power, reserves that are held to accommodate the variability of wind or solar power can be at least partially shared. In addition, interesting results are found through time and seasonal variation analyses of wind and solar power forecast errors, and these insights may be uniquely useful to operators who maintain the reliability of the electric power system.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the U.S. DOE under Contract DE-AC36-08-GO28308 with the National Renewable Energy Laboratory.
References
Bessa, R. J., Miranda, V., Botterud, A., and Wang, J. (2011). “‘Good’ or ‘bad’ wind power forecasts: A relative concept.” Wind Energy, 14(5), 625–636.
Bludszuweit, H., Domínguez-Navarro, J. A., and Llombart, A. (2008). “Statistical analysis of wind power forecast error.” IEEE Trans. Power Syst., 23(3), 983–991.
Bruninx, K., Delarue, E., and D’haeseleer, W. (2013). “Statistical description of the error on wind power forecasts via a Lévy α-stable distribution.” Technical Rep. EUI Working Paper RSCAS 2013/50, European Univ. Institute, Florence, Italy.
Castronuovo, E., and Lopes, J. (2004). “On the optimization of the daily operation of a wind-hydro power plant.” IEEE Trans. Power Syst., 19(3), 1599–1606.
Chen, C., Duan, S., Cai, T., and Liu, B. (2011). “Online 24-h solar power forecasting based on weather type classification using artificial neural network.” Solar Energy, 85(11), 2856–2870.
Chow, W. C., et al. (2011). “Intra-hour forecasting with a total sky imager at the UC San Diego solar energy test bed.” Solar Energy, 85(11), 2881–2893.
Chowdhury, S., Zhang, J., Messac, A., and Castillo, L. (2013). “Optimizing the arrangement and the selection of turbines for wind farms subject to varying wind conditions.” Renew. Energy, 52, 273–282.
Cover, T. M., and Thomas, J. A. (2006). Elements of information theory, Wiley, New York.
Crispim, E. M., Ferreira, P. M., and Ruano, A. E. (2008). “Prediction of the solar radiation evolution using computational intelligence techniques and cloudiness indices.” Int. J. Innov. Comput. Inf. Control, 4(5), 1121–1133.
Dietrich, K., Latorre, J., Olmos, L., Ramos, A., and Perez-Arriaga, I. (2009). “Stochastic unit commitment considering uncertain wind production in an isolated system.” Proc., 4th Conf. on Energy Economics and Technology, Dresden Univ. of Technology, Dresden, Germany.
Duong, T., and Hazelton, M. (2003). “Plug-in bandwidth matrices for Bivariate Kernel density estimation.” J. Nonparametric Stat., 15(1), 17–30.
Epanechnikov, V. (1969). “Non-parametric estimation of a multivariate probability density.” Theor. Prob. Appl., 14(1), 153–158.
Foley, A. M., Leahy, G. L., Marvuglia, A., and Mckeogh, E. J. (2012). “Current methods and advances in forecasting of wind power generation.” Renew. Energy, 37(1), 1–8.
Hall, P., Lahiri, S. N., and Truong, Y. K. (1995). “On bandwidth choice for density estimation with dependent data.” Ann. Stat., 23(6), 2241–2263.
Hammer, A., Heinemann, D., Lorenz, E., and Ckehe, B. L. (1999). “Short-term forecasting of solar radiation: A statistical approach using satellite data.” Solar Energy, 67(1–3), 139–150.
Hodge, B.-M., et al. (2012b). “Wind power forecasting error distributions: An international comparison.” Proc., 11th Annual Int. Workshop on Large-Scale Integration of Wind Power into Power Systems as well as on Transmission Networks for Offshore Wind Power Plants, Energynautics GmbH, Germany.
Hodge, B.-M., Ela, E., and Milligan, M. (2012a). “Characterizing and modeling wind power forecast errors from operational systems for use in wind integration planning studies.” Wind Eng., 36(5), 509–524.
Hodge, B.-M., Hummon, M., and Orwig, K. (2011). “Solar ramping distributions over multiple timescales and weather patterns.” Proc., 10th Int. Workshop on Large-Scale Integration of Wind Power into Power Systems as well as on Transmission Networks for Offshore Wind Power Plants, Energynautics GmbH, Germany.
Hodge, B.-M., and Milligan, M. (2011). “Wind power forecasting error distributions over multiple timescales.” Proc., IEEE Power and Energy Society General Meeting, IEEE, Piscataway, NJ.
Hodge, B.-M., Orwig, K., and Milligan, M. (2012c). “Examining information entropy approaches as wind power forecasting performance metrics.” Proc., 12th Int. Conf. on Probabilistic Methods Applied to Power Systems, IEEE, Piscataway, NJ.
Hummon, M., Ibanez, E., Brinkman, G., and Lew, D. (2012). “Sub-hour solar data for power system modeling from static spatial variability analysis.” Proc., 2nd Int. Workshop on Integration of Solar Power in Power Systems, Energynautics GmbH, Germany.
Jeon, J., and Taylor, J. W. (2012). “Using conditional kernel density estimation for wind power density forecasting.” J. Am. Stat. Assoc., 107(497), 66–79.
Jones, M., Marron, J., and Sheather, S. (1996). “A brief survey of bandwidth selection for density estimation.” J. Am. Stat. Assoc., 91(433), 401–407.
Juban, J., Siebert, N., and Kariniotakis, G. N. (2007). “Probabilistic short-term wind power forecasting for the optimal management of wind generation.” 2007 IEEE Lausanne Power Tech, IEEE, Piscataway, NJ.
Kariniotakis, G. N., Stavrakakis, G. S., and Nogaret, E. F. (1996). “Wind power forecasting using advanced neural networks models.” IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., 11(4), 762–767.
Lew, D., et al. (2010). “The western wind and solar integration study.” Technical Rep. NREL/SR-550-47434, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO.
Lew, D., et al. (2013). “The western wind and solar integration study phase 2.” Technical Rep. NREL/TP-5500-55888, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO.
Lindenberg, S. (2008). “20% wind energy by 2030: Increasing wind energy contribution to U.S. electricity supply.” Technical Rep. No. DOE/GO-02008-2567, U.S. DOE: Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy, Washington, DC.
Lorenz, E., Heinemann, D., Wickramarathne, H., Beyer, H. G., and Bofinger, S. (2007). “Forecast of ensemble power production by grid-connected PV systems.” Proc., 20th Eur. PV Conf., European Commission, Ispra, Italy.
Marquez, R., and Coimbra, C. F. M. (2011). “Forecasting of global and direct solar irradiance using stochastic learning methods, ground experiments and the NWS database.” Solar Energy, 85(5), 746–756.
Marquez, R., and Coimbra, C. F. M. (2013). “Intra-hour DNI forecasting based on cloud tracking image analysis.” Solar Energy, 91, 327–336.
Mathiesen, P., and Kleissl, J. (2011). “Evaluation of numerical weather prediction for intra-day solar forecasting in the continental United States.” Solar Energy, 85(5), 967–977.
Methaprayoon, K., Yingvivatanapong, C., Lee, W. J., and Liao, J. R. (2007). “An integration of ANN wind power estimation into unit commitment considering the forecasting uncertainty.” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., 43(6), 1441–1448.
Monteiro, C., Bessa, R., Miranda, V., Botterud, A., Wang, J., and Conzelmann, G. (2009). “Wind power forecasting: State-of-the-art 2009.” Technical Rep. ANL/DIS-10-1, Argonne National Laboratory, Lemont, IL.
Parzen, E. (1962). “On estimation of a probability density function and mode.” Ann. Math. Stat., 33(3), 1065–1076.
Perez, R., Moore, K., Wilcox, S., Renné, D., and Zelenka, A. (2007). “Forecasting solar radiation—Preliminary evaluation of an approach based upon the national forecast database.” Solar Energy, 81(6), 809–812.
Pernick, R., and Wilder, C. (2008). “Utility solar assessment study reaching ten percent solar by 2025.” Technical Rep., Clean Edge, and Co-op America Foundation, Washington, DC.
Potter, C. W., Lew, D., McCaa, J., Cheng, S., Eichelberger, S., and Grimit, E. (2008). “Creating the dataset for the western wind and solar integration study (USA).” Wind Energy, 32(4), 325–338.
Qin, Z., Li, W., and Xiong, X. (2011). “Estimating wind speed probability distribution using Kernel density method.” Electr. Power Syst. Res., 81(12), 2139–2146.
Rodgers, J. L., and Nicewander, W. A. (1988). “Thirteen ways to look at the correlation coefficient.” Am. Stat., 42(1), 59–66.
Rosenblatt, M. (1956). “Remarks on some nonparametric estimates of a density function.” Ann. Math. Stat., 27(3), 832–837.
Zhang, J., Chowdhury, S., Messac, A., and Castillo, L. (2011). “Multivariate and multimodal wind distribution model based on kernel density estimation.” Proc., 5th Int. Conf. on Energy Sustainability, ASME, New York.
Zhang, J., Chowdhury, S., Messac, A., and Castillo, L. (2013a). “A multivariate and multimodal wind distribution model.” Renew. Energy, 51, 436–447.
Zhang, J., Hodge, B.-M., and Florita, A. (2013b). “Investigating the correlation between wind and solar power forecast errors in the western interconnection.” Proc., 7th Int. Conf. on Energy Sustainability, ASME, New York.
Zhang, Z., Sun, Y., Gao, D., Lin, J., and Cheng, L. (2013c). “A versatile probability distribution model for wind power forecast errors and its application in economic dispatch.” IEEE Trans. Power Syst., 28(3), 3114–3125.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Energy Engineering
Volume 141 • Issue 1 • March 2015
Copyright
© 2014 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: May 31, 2013
Accepted: Jan 17, 2014
Published online: May 15, 2014
Discussion open until: Oct 15, 2014
Published in print: Mar 1, 2015
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.