Assessing the Effect of Uncertainties in Pollutant Wash-Off Dynamics in Stormwater Source-Control Systems Modeling: Consequences of Using an Inappropriate Error Model
Publication: Journal of Environmental Engineering
Volume 143, Issue 2
Abstract
This study investigates the effects of uncertainties associated with pollutant wash-off dynamics in the context of stormwater management practices modeling. A formal Bayesian approach is adopted for the calibration and the uncertainty analysis of a commonly used wash-off model under (1) the unverified assumption of homoscedastic, independent, and normally distributed residuals; and (2) using a more correct heteroscedastic and autoregressive error model. The results obtained for each of these approaches are compared, and the uncertainty associated with water quality modeling is later propagated through a conceptual best management practices (BMP) model for various stormwater management scenarios so as to assess the effect of this uncertainty for BMP modeling and clarify the benefits of a robust description of error structure. This study indicates that the violation of the statistical assumptions about the residuals may result in unreliable estimation of model parameters and total predictive uncertainty. However, the effect of the uncertainty in the intraevent variability of concentrations in runoff is found to have only a limited effect on the outputs of the BMP model, regardless of the error model adopted for calibration.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Acknowledgments
This research was carried out under the Observatoire des Polluants URbains (OPUR) research program. The authors gratefully acknowledge OPUR partners and the French Ministry of Ecology, Sustainable Development and Energy for financial support.
References
Ahiablame, L. M., Engel, B. A., and Chaubey, I. (2012). “Effectiveness of low impact development practices: Literature review and suggestions for future research.” Water Air Soil Poll., 223(7), 4253–4273.
Alley, W. M., and Smith, P. E. (1981). “Estimation of accumulation parameters for urban runoff quality modeling.” Water Resour. Res., 17(6), 1657–1664.
Andrés-Doménech, I., Múnera, J. C., Francés, F., and Marco, J. B. (2010). “Coupling urban event-based and catchment continuous modelling for combined sewer overflow river impact assessment.” Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 14(10), 2057–2072.
Bates, B. C., and Campbell, E. P. (2001). “A Markov chain Monte Carlo scheme for parameter estimation and inference in conceptual rainfall-runoff modeling.” Water Resour. Res., 37(4), 937–947.
Beven, K. (2005). “On the concept of model structural error.” Water Sci. Technol., 52(6), 167–175.
Beven, K., and Binley, A. (2014). “GLUE: 20 years on.” Hydrol. Process., 28(24), 5897–5918.
Beven, K., Smith, P., and Freer, J. (2007). “Comment on ‘Hydrological forecasting uncertainty assessment: Incoherence of the GLUE methodology’ by Pietro Mantovan and Ezio Todini.” J. Hydrol., 338(3–4), 315–318.
Bressy, A., Gromaire, M. C., Lorgeoux, C., Saad, M., Leroy, F., and Chebbo, G. (2014). “Efficiency of source control systems for reducing runoff pollutant loads: Feedback on experimental catchments within Paris conurbation.” Water Res., 57(1), 234–246.
Browne, D., Deletic, A., Mudd, G. M., and Fletcher, T. D. (2008). “A new saturated/unsaturated model for stormwater infiltration systems.” Hydrol. Process., 22(25), 4838–4849.
Burns, M. J., Fletcher, T. D., Walsh, C. J., Ladson, A. R., and Hatt, B. E. (2012). “Hydrologic shortcomings of conventional urban stormwater management and opportunities for reform.” Landscape Urban Plann., 105(3), 230–240.
Chib, S., and Greenberg, E. (1995). “Understanding the Metropolis-Hastings algorithm.” J. Am. Stat. Assoc., 49(4), 327–335.
Clark, M. P., Kavetski, D., and Fenicia, F. (2011). “Pursuing the method of multiple working hypotheses for hydrological modeling.” Water Resour. Res., 47(9), 1–16.
Deletic, A., and Orr, D. (2005). “Pollution buildup on road surfaces.” J. Environ. Eng., 49–59.
Del Giudice, D., Honti, M., Scheidegger, A., Albert, C., Reichert, P., and Rieckermann, J. (2013). “Improving uncertainty estimation in urban hydrological modeling by statistically describing bias.” Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 17(10), 4209–4225.
Dotto, C. B. S., Deletic, A., and McCarthy, D. T. (2013). “Uncertainty analysis in urban drainage modelling: Should we break our back for normally distributed residuals?.” Water Sci. Technol., 68(6), 1271–1279.
Dotto, C. B. S., Kleidorfer, M., Deletic, A., Fletcher, T. D., McCarthy, D. T., and Rauch, W. (2010). “Stormwater quality models: Performance and sensitivity analysis.” Water Sci. Technol., 62(4), 837–843.
Dotto, C. B. S., Kleidorfer, M., Deletic, A., Rauch, W., McCarthy, D. T., and Fletcher, T. D. (2011). “Performance and sensitivity analysis of stormwater models using a Bayesian approach and long-term high resolution data.” Environ. Modell. Software, 26(10), 1225–1239.
Evin, G., Kavetski, D., Thyer, M., and Kuczera, G. (2013). “Pitfalls and improvements in the joint inference of heteroscedasticity and autocorrelation in hydrological model calibration.” Water Resour. Res., 49(7), 4518–4524.
Freni, G., Mannina, G., and Viviani, G. (2009a). “Stormwater infiltration trenches: A conceptual modelling approach.” Water Sci. Technol., 60(1), 185–199.
Freni, G., Mannina, G., and Viviani, G. (2009b). “Urban runoff modelling uncertainty: Comparison among Bayesian and pseudo-Bayesian methods.” Environ. Modell. Software, 24(9), 1100–1111.
Freni, G., and Oliveri, E. (2005). “Mitigation of urban flooding: A simplified approach for distributed stormwater management practices selection and planning.” Urban Water, 2(4), 215–226.
Hasting, W. K. (1970). “Monte Carlo sampling methods using Markov chains and their applications.” Biometrika, 57(1), 97–109.
Imteaz, M. A., Ahsan, A., Rahman, A., and Mekanik, F. (2013). “Modelling stormwater treatment systems using MUSIC: Accuracy.” Resour. Conserv. Recycl., 71(1), 15–21.
Kanso, A., Chebbo, G., and Tassin, B. (2006). “Application of MCMC-GSA model calibration method to urban runoff quality modeling.” Reliab. Eng. Syst. Saf., 91(10–11), 1398–1405.
Kavetski, D., Kuczera, G., and Franks, S. W. (2006). “Bayesian analysis of input uncertainty in hydrological modeling: 1. Theory.” Water Resour. Res., 42(3), 1–9.
Kuczera, G., Kavetski, D., Franks, S., and Thyer, M. (2006). “Towards a Bayesian total error analysis of conceptual rainfall-runoff models: Characterising model error using storm-dependent parameters.” J. Hydrol., 331(1–2), 161–177.
Li, L., Xu, C.-Y., Xia, J., Engeland, K., and Reggiani, P. (2011). “Uncertainty estimates by Bayesian method with likelihood of AR (1) plus Normal model and AR (1) plus Multi-Normal model in different time-scales hydrological models.” J. Hydrol., 406(1–2), 54–65.
Locatelli, L., Mark, O., Mikkelsen, P. S., Arnbjerg-Nielsen, K., Wong, T., and Binning, P. J. (2015). “Determining the extent of groundwater interference on the performance of infiltration trenches.” J. Hydrol., 529(3), 1360–1372.
Mantovan, P., Todini, E., and Martina, M. L. V. (2007). “Reply to comment by Keith Beven, Paul Smith and Jim Freer on ‘Hydrological forecasting uncertainty assessment: Incoherence of the GLUE methodology’.” J. Hydrol., 338(3), 319–324.
Milly, P. C. D. (1986). “An event-based simulation model of moisture and energy fluxes at a bare soil surface.” Water Resour. Res., 22(12), 1680–1692.
Monteith, J. L. (1965) “Evaporation and environment.” Symp. Soc. Exp. Biol., 205–234.
Petrucci, G., Rioust, E., Deroubaix, J. F., and Tassin, B. (2013). “Do stormwater source control policies deliver the right hydrologic outcomes?” J. Hydrol., 485, 188–200.
Ramier, D., Berthier, E., and Andrieu, H. (2011). “The hydrological behaviour of urban streets: Long-term observations and modelling of runoff losses and rainfall-runoff transformation.” Hydrol. Process., 25(14), 2161–2178.
Rawls, W. J., Brakensiek, D. L., and Saxton, K. E. (1982). “Estimation of soil water properties.” T. ASAE, 25(5), 1316–1320.
Roberts, G. O., Gelman, A., and Gilks, W. R. (1997). “Weak convergence and optimal scaling of random walk metropolis algorithms.” Ann. Appl. Probab., 7(1), 110–120.
Rossman, L. A. (2010). “Modeling low impact development alternatives with SWMM.” J. Water Manage. Modell, in press.
Sage, J., Bonhomme, C., Al Ali, S., and Gromaire, M.-C. (2015). “Performance assessment of a commonly used ‘accumulation and wash-off’ model from long-term continuous road runoff turbidity measurements.” Water Res., 78(0), 47–59.
Schaefli, B., and Gupta, H. V. (2007). “Do Nash values have value?” Hydrol. Process., 21(15), 2075–2080.
Schoups, G., and Vrugt, J. A. (2010). “A formal likelihood function for parameter and predictive inference of hydrologic models with correlated, heteroscedastic, and non-Gaussian errors.” Water Resour. Res., 46(10), 1–17.
Schriewer, A., Horn, H., and Helmreich, B. (2008). “Time focused measurements of roof runoff quality.” Corros. Sci., 50(2), 384–391.
Shaw, S. B., Stedinger, J. R., and Walter, M. T. (2010). “Evaluating urban pollutant buildup/wash-off models using a Madison, Wisconsin catchment.” J. Environ. Eng., 194–203.
Stedinger, J. R., Vogel, R. M., Lee, S. U., and Batchelder, R. (2008). “Appraisal of the generalized likelihood uncertainty estimation (GLUE) method.” Water Resour. Res., 44(12), 1–17.
Thyer, M., Renard, B., Kavetski, D., Kuczera, G., Franks, S. W., and Srikanthan, S. (2009). “Critical evaluation of parameter consistency and predictive uncertainty in hydrological modeling: A case study using Bayesian total error analysis.” Water Resour. Res., 45(12), 1–22.
Trowsdale, S. A., and Simcock, R. (2011). “Urban stormwater treatment using bioretention.” J. Hydrol., 397(3–4), 167–174.
Vaze, J., and Chiew, F. H. S. (2002). “Experimental study of pollutant accumulation on an urban road surface.” Urban Water, 4(4), 379–389.
Vezzaro, L., and Mikkelsen, P. S. (2012). “Application of global sensitivity analysis and uncertainty quantification in dynamic modelling of micropollutants in stormwater runoff.” Environ. Model. Software, 27–28(1), 40–51.
Vrugt, J. A., ter Braak, C. J. F., Gupta, H. V., and Robinson, B. A. (2008). “Equifinality of formal (DREAM) and informal (GLUE) Bayesian approaches in hydrologic modeling?” Stoch. Env. Res. Risk A., 23(7), 1011–1026.
Wang, Q. J., Shrestha, D. L., Robertson, D. E., and Pokhrel, P. (2012). “A log-sinh transformation for data normalization and variance stabilization.” Water Resour. Res., 48(5), 1–7.
Wild, T. B., and Davis, A. P. (2009). “Simulation of the performance of a storm-water BMP.” J. Environ. Eng., 1257–1267.
Wong, T. H. F., Fletcher, T. D., Duncan, H. P., and Jenkins, G. A. (2006). “Modelling urban stormwater treatment—A unified approach.” Ecol. Eng., 27(1), 58–70.
Yang, J., Reichert, P., and Abbaspour, K. C. (2007). “Bayesian uncertainty analysis in distributed hydrologic modeling: A case study in the Thur River basin (Switzerland).” Water Resour. Res., 43(10), 1–13.
Zhao, H., Li, X., and Wang, X. (2011). “Heavy metal contents of road-deposited sediment along the urban-rural gradient around Beijing and its potential contribution to runoff pollution.” Environ. Sci. Technol., 45(17), 7120–7127.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Environmental Engineering
Volume 143 • Issue 2 • February 2017
Copyright
© 2016 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Oct 28, 2015
Accepted: Jun 2, 2016
Published online: Jul 29, 2016
Discussion open until: Dec 29, 2016
Published in print: Feb 1, 2017
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.