Developing More Competitive Proposals: Relationship between Contractor Qualifications-Based Proposal Content and Owner Evaluation Scores
Publication: Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
Volume 144, Issue 5
Abstract
Construction contractors have historically been procured through price-driven methods. Yet the increased use of alternate project delivery methods, along with owner-perceived concerns over construction performance, has led many owners to introduce qualifications-based selection criteria into their procurement systems. As a result, construction contractors are tasked with preparation of qualifications-based proposal submittals ever more frequently. Contractors must therefore develop strategies to consistently differentiate their qualifications from those of their their competitors, which can lead to more favorable owner evaluation scores and ultimately improve their hit rate. This paper performed a content analysis of 71 contractor proposals containing both successful and unsuccessful bids. Regression results indicate that contractor project management proposals receive more favorable owner evaluation scores when contractor-controlled, design-related, and concealed conditions content are emphasized. Regression results show that contractor scope alternate proposals are encouraged to provide a comprehensive review of potential scope options to enhance the project and ensure the associated cost and schedule impacts are clearly defined.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Data Availability Statement
Data generated or analyzed during the study are available from the corresponding author by request. Information about the Journal’s data sharing policy can be found here: http://ascelibrary.org/doi/10.1061/%28ASCE%29CO.1943-7862.0001263.
References
Abdelrahman, M., Zayed, T., and Elyamany, A. (2008). “Best-value model based on project specific characteristics.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 179–188.
AGC/NASFA (Associated General Contractors of America and National Association of State Facilities Administrators). (2008). “Best practices for use of best value selections.” ⟨http://www.aci-na.org/sites/default/files/best_value_best_practices.pdf⟩ (Jan. 31, 2016).
Ahmed, J., Gharaibeh, N. G., and Damnjanovic, I. D. (2012). “Best-value bid selection methods for performance-based roadway maintenance contracts.” Transp. Res. Rec., 2292, 12–19.
Allen, R. S., and Helms, M. M. (2006). “Linking strategic practices and organization performance to Porter’s generic strategies.” Bus. Process Manage., 12(4), 433–454.
Assaf, S., and Al-Hejji, S. (2006). “Causes of delay in large construction projects.” Int. J. Project Manage., 24(4), 349–357.
Beard, J., Loulakis, M., and Wundrum, E. (2001). Design build: Planning through development, McGraw-Hill, New York.
Bilbo, D., Bigelow, B., Escamilla, E., and Lockwood, C. (2015). “Comparison of construction manager at risk and integrated project delivery performance on healthcare projects: A comparative case study.” Int. J. Constr. Educ. Res., 11(1), 40–53.
Bogus, S. M., Migliaccio, G. C., and Jin, R. (2013). “Study of the relationship between procurement duration and project performance in design-build projects: Comparison between water/wastewater transportation sectors.” J. Manage. Eng., 382–391.
Bowen, P., Edwards, P., Lingard, H., and Cattell, K. (2014). “Occupational stress and job demand, control and support factors among construction project consultants.” Int. J. Project Manage., 32(7), 1273–1284.
Budayan, C., Dikmen, I. M., and Birgonul, M. T. (2013). “Investigation of drivers and modes of differentiation in Turkish construction industry.” Eng. Constr. Archit. Manage., 20(4), 345–364.
Caldwell, N., Roehrich, J., and Davies, A. (2009). “Procuring complex performance in construction: London Heathrow terminal 5 and a private finance initiative hospital.” J. Purchasing Supply Manage., 15(3), 178–186.
Cao, D., Wang, G., Li, H., Skitmore, M., Huang, T., and Zhang, W. (2015). “Practices and effectiveness of building information modelling in construction projects in China.” Autom. Constr., 49(2015), 113–122.
Chan, D., and Kumaraswamy, M. (1997). “A comparative study of causes of time overruns in Hong Kong construction projects.” Int. J. Project Manage., 15(1), 55–63.
Cheah, C. Y. J., Kang, J., and Chew, D. A. S. (2007). “Strategic analysis of large local construction firms in China.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 25(1), 25–38.
Chen, W. T., Chang, P., and Huang, Y. (2009). “Assessing the overall performance of value engineering workshops for construction projects.” Int. J. Project Manage., 28(5), 514–527.
Chen, W. T., Chen, T., Lu, C. S., and Liu, S. (2012). “Analyzing relationships among success variables of construction partnering using structural equation modeling: A case study of Taiwan’s construction industry.” J. Civ. Eng. Manage., 18(6), 783–794.
Chua, D., Kog, Y., Loh, P., and Jaselskis, E. (1997). “Model for construction budget performance: Neural network approach.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 214–222.
Davis, P., and Love, P. (2011). “Alliance contracting: Adding value through relationship development.” Eng. Constr. Archit. Manage., 18(5), 444–461.
DBIA (Design-Build Institute of America). (2012). “DBIA position statement: Qualification based selection.” ⟨https://www.dbia.org/resource-center/Documents/ps_qbs.pdf⟩ (Feb. 4, 2016).
Del Puerto, C. L., Gransberg, D. D., and Shane, J. S. (2008). “Comparative analysis of owner goals for design/build projects.” J. Manage. Eng., 32–39.
Del Puerto, C. L., Strong, K., and Miller, M. (2013). “Analysis of owner safety management approaches in design-build projects.” Int. J. Constr. Educ. Res., 9(4), 307–316.
Dikmen, I., Birgonul, M. T., and Budayan, C. (2009). “Strategic group analysis in the construction industry.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 288–297.
El Asmar, M., Hanna, A. S., and Loh, W. (2013). “Quantifying performance for the integrated project delivery system as compared to established delivery systems.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 04013012.
El Asmar, M., Lotfallah, W., Whited, G., and Hanna, A. S. (2010). “Quantitative methods for design-build team selection.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 904–912.
El-Sayegh, S. M. (2009). “Multi-criteria decision support model for selecting the appropriate construction management at risk firm.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 27(4), 385–398.
Eriksson, P. E. (2008). “Procurement effects on coopetition in client-contractor relationships.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 103–111.
Fellows, R., and Liu, A. (2008). Research methods for construction, 3rd Ed., Blackwell, Oxford, U.K.
Fellows, R., and Liu, A. (2015). Research methods for construction, 4th Ed., Wiley, West Sussex, U.K.
Gransberg, D. D., and Barton, R. F. (2007). “Analysis of federal design-build request for proposal evaluation criteria.” J. Manage. Eng., 105–111.
Gransberg, D. D., and Ellicott, M. A. (1997). “Best-value contracting criteria.” Cost Eng., 39(6), 31–34.
Gransberg, D. D., and Shane, J. S. (2014). “Defining best value for construction manager/general contractor project: The CMGC learning curve.” J. Manage. Eng., 04014060.
Gransberg, D. D., and Windel, E. (2008). “Communicating design quality requirements for public sector design/build projects.” J. Manage. Eng., 105–110.
Grönroos, C. (1996). “Relationship marketing: Strategic and tactical implications.” Manage. Dec., 34(3), 5–14.
Guthrie, J., Petty, R., and Yongvanich, K. (2004). “Using content analysis as a research method to inquire into intellectual capital reporting.” J. Intellectual Capital, 5(2), 282–293.
Hasnain, M., and Thaheem, M. J. (2016). “Best value procurement in construction and its evolution in the 21st century: A systematic review.” J. Adv. Perform. Inf. Value, 8(1), 1–21.
Hassanein, A. A. G., and Afify, H. M. F. (2007). “A risk identification procedure for construction contracts: A case study of power station projects in Egypt.” Civ. Eng. Environ. Syst., 24(1), 3–14.
Jelodar, M. B., Yiu, T. W., and Wilkinson, S. (2016). “A conceptualization of relationship quality in construction procurement.” Int. J. Project Manage., 34(6), 997–1011.
Jergeas, G., and Put, J. V. D. (2001). “Benefits of constructability on construction projects.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 281–290.
Jones, T., Shan, Y., and Goodrum, P. M. (2010). “An investigation of corporate approaches to sustainability in the US engineering and construction industry.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 28(9), 971–983.
Kale, S., and Arditi, D. (2003). “Differentiation, conformity, and construction firm performance.” J. Manage. Eng., 122–132.
Kolbe, R. H., and Burnett, M. S. (1991). “Content analysis research: An examination of applications with directives for improving research reliability and objectivity.” J. Consum. Res., 18(2), 243–250.
Korytarova, J., Hanak, T., Kozik, R., and Radziszewska-Zielina, E. (2015). “Exploring the contractors’ qualification process in public works contracts.” Procedia Eng., 123, 276–283.
Kumaraswamy, M., and Anvuur, A. (2008). “Selecting sustainable teams for PP projects.” Build. Environ., 43(6), 999–1009.
Li, S., and Ling, F. Y. Y. (2012). “Critical strategies for Chinese architectural, engineering, and construction firms to achieve profitability.” Eng. Constr. Archit. Manage., 19(5), 495–511.
Lines, B., Sullivan, K., and Perrenoud, A. (2013). “Design-build application of best value project delivery: Impact of value-based procurement, preplanning, and risk management.” J. Adv. Perform. Inf. Value, 5(1), 1–19.
Lines, B. C., Sullivan, K. T., and Wiezel, A. (2016). “Support for organizational change: Change-readiness outcomes among AEC project teams.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 04015062.
Love, P. E. D., Davis, P., Baccarini, D., and Edwards, D. (2008). “Uncertainty avoidance: Public sector clients and procurement selection.” Int. J. Publ. Sect. Manage., 21(7), 753–776.
Love, P. E. D., Mistry, D., and Davis, P. R. (2010). “Price competitive alliance projects: Identification of success factors for public clients.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 136(9), 947–956.
Love, P. E. D., O’Donoghue, D., Davis, P. R., and Smith, J. (2014). “Procurement of public sector facilities: Views of early contractor involvement.” Facilities, 32(9/10), 460–471.
Minchin, R. E., Jr., Li, X., Issa, R. R., and Vargas, G. G. (2013). “Comparison of cost and time performance of design-build and design-bid-build delivery systems in Florida.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 04013007.
Mintzberg, H. (1987). “The strategy concept. I: Five Ps for strategy.” California Manage. Rev., 30(1), 11–24.
Mir, F. A., and Pinnington, A. H. (2014). “Exploring the value of project management: Linking project management performance and project success.” Int. J. Project Manage., 32(2), 202–217.
Mokhtariani, M., Sebt, M. H., and Davoudpour, H. (2017). “Construction marketing: Developing a reference framework.” Adv. Civ. Eng., 2017, 1.
Naoum, S. G., and Egbu, C. (2015). “Modern selection criteria for procurement methods in construction: A state-of-the-art literature review and survey.” Int. J. Managing Projects Bus., 9(2), 309–336.
NCHRP (National Cooperative Highway Research Program). (2006). “Best-value procurement methods for highway construction projects.”, Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC.
Neuendorf, K. A. (2002). The content analysis guidebook, Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA.
Nijstad, B. A., Berger-Selman, F., and De Dreu, C. K. W. (2014). “Innovation in top management teams: Minority dissent, transformational leadership, and radical innovations.” Eur. J. Work Organizational Psychol., 23(2), 310–322.
Oyewobi, L. O., Windapo, A. O., Rotimi, J. O. B., and Jimoh, R. A. (2016). “Relationship between competitive strategy and construction organization performance: The moderating role of organizational characteristics.” Manage. Decis., 54(9), 2340–2366.
Perrenoud, A. J., Lines, B. C., Savicky, J., and Sullivan, K. (2017). “Using best value procurement to measure the impact of initial risk-management capability on qualitative construction performance.” J. Manage. Eng., 04017019.
Perrenoud, A. J., Smithwick, J. B., Hurtado, K. C., and Sullivan, K. T. (2015). “Project risk distribution during the construction phase of small building projects.” J. Manage. Eng., 04015050.
Phua, F. T. T., and Rowlinson, S. (2004). “How important is cooperation to construction project success? A grounded empirical quantification.” Eng. Constr. Archit. Manage., 11(1), 45–54.
Porter, M. E. (1980). Competitive strategy: Techniques for analyzing industries and competitors, Free Press, New York.
Rahmani, F., Maqsood, T., and Khalfan, M. (2017). “An overview of construction procurement methods in Australia.” Eng. Constr. Archit. Manage., 24(4), 593–609.
Ruparathna, R., and Hewage, K. (2015). “Review of contemporary construction procurement practices.” J. Manage. Eng., 04014038.
Sawyer, J. T., Lines, B. C., Perrenoud, A. J., Smithwick, J. B., and Sullivan, K. T. (2015). “Qualifications-based selection of construction services.” 51st ASC Annual Int. Conf. Proc., Associated Schools of Construction, San Antonio, TX.
Schleifer, T. C., Sullivan, K. T., and Murdough, J. M. (2014). Managing the profitable construction business: The contractor’s guide to success and survival strategies, Wiley, Hoboken, NJ.
Scott, S., Molenaar, K., Gransberg, D., and Smith, N. (2006). “Best value procurement methods for highway construction projects.”, National Research Council, Washington, DC.
Sindhu, J., Choi, K., Lavy, S., Rybkowski, Z. K., Bigelow, B. F., and Li, W. (2017). “Effects of front-end planning under fast-tracked project delivery systems for industrial projects.” Int. J. Constr. Educ. Res., 1–16.
Singh, D., and Tiong, R. L. K. (2006). “Contractor selection criteria: Investigation of opinions of Singapore construction practitioners.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 998–1008.
Stanford, M. S., Molenaar, K. R., and Sheeran, K. M. (2016). “Application of indefinite delivery–indefinite quantity construction strategies at the federal level.” J. Manage. Eng., 04016011.
Sullivan, K. (2011). “Quality management programs in the construction industry: Best value compared with other methodologies.” J. Manage. Eng., 210–219.
Sullivan, K. T., and Guo, Y. (2009). “Contractor cash flow and profitability analysis between best value and low bid.” Cost Eng., 51(9), 16–20.
Sullivan, K. T., and Michael, J. K. (2010). “Performance measurement approach to contracting and delivering design services.” J. Prof. Issues Eng. Educ. Pract., 248–257.
Sun, M., and Meng, X. (2009). “Taxonomy for change causes and effects in construction projects.” Int. J. Project Manage., 27(6), 560–572.
Tatum, C. B. (1987). “Improving constructability during conceptual planning.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 191–207.
Tran, D., Molenaar, K. R., and Gransberg, D. D. (2016). “Implementing best-value procurement for design-bid-build highway projects.” Transp. Res. Board, 2573, 26–33.
Waara, F., and Brochner, J. (2006). “Price and nonprice criteria for contractor selection.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 797–804.
Wardani, M., Messner, J., and Horman, M. (2006). “Comparing procurement methods for design-build projects.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 230–238.
Watt, D. J., Kayis, B., and Willey, K. (2009). “Identifying key factors in the evaluation of tenders for projects and services.” Int. J. Project Manage., 27(3), 250–260.
Watt, D. J., Kayis, B., and Willey, K. (2010). “The relative importance of tender evaluation and contractor selection criteria.” Int. J. Project Manage., 28(1), 51–60.
Wenger, E. C., and Snyder, W. M. (2000). “Communities of practice: The organizational frontier.” Harvard Bus. Rev., 78(1), 139–145.
Wong, C. H., Holt, G. D., and Cooper, P. A. (2000). “Lowest price of value? Investigation of UK construction clients’ tender selection process.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 18(7), 767–774.
Xia, B., Chan, A., Zuo, J., and Molenaar, K. (2013). “Analysis of selection criteria for design-builders through the analysis of requests for proposals.” J. Manage. Eng., 19–24.
Yu, W., and Wang, K. (2012). “Best value of lowest bid? A quantitative perspective.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 128–134.
Zhang, X. Q. (2006). “Factor analysis of public clients’ best-value objective in public-privately partnered infrastructure projects.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 956–965.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
Volume 144 • Issue 5 • May 2018
Copyright
©2018 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Apr 16, 2017
Accepted: Nov 15, 2017
Published online: Mar 15, 2018
Published in print: May 1, 2018
Discussion open until: Aug 15, 2018
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.