Probabilistic Risk Assessment for Improvised Explosive Device Attacks That Cause Significant Building Damage
Publication: Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Volume 29, Issue 5
Abstract
Most vulnerability assessments assume that an improvised explosive device (IED) will reach maximum TNT equivalency, and that the IED will successfully detonate. These assumptions will tend to overestimate actual blast-load effects. The paper develops an IED probabilistic risk-assessment model using a systems model for IED attacks based on the reliability of IEDs and by characterizing the human aspects of an IED attack’s operational effectiveness from existing databases of terrorist incidents. The analysis includes estimates of the probability of threat, hazard, and loss for large commercial buildings in the United States. It was found that annual fatality risk for building occupants is similar to acceptable risk criteria. This suggests that strengthening buildings against progressive collapse may not be warranted unless there is a specific threat against a building.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Acknowledgments
The support of the Australian Research Council is gratefully acknowledged.
References
Abrahms, M. (2006). “Why terrorism does not work.” Int. Secur., 31(2), 42–78.
Abrahms, M. (2008). “What terrorists really want: Terrorist motives and counterterrorism strategy.” Int. Secur., 32(4), 78–105.
Arnold, J. L., Halpern, P., Tsai, M. C., and Smithline, H. (2004). “Mass casualty terrorist bombings: A comparison of outcomes by bombing type.” Ann. Emerg. Med., 43(2), 263–273.
ASCE. (2013). “Minimum design loads for buildings and other structures.”, Reston, VA.
Barker, A. D. (2011). “Improvised explosive devices in southern Afghanistan and western Pakistan, 2002–2009.” Stud. Confl. Terrorism, 34(8), 600–620.
Brooks, R. A. (2011). “Muslim “homegrown” terrorism in the United States—How serious is the threat?” Int. Secur., 36(2), 7–47.
Byfield, M. P. (2006). “Behaviour and design of commercial multistory buildings subjected to blast.” J. Perform. Constr. Facil., 324–329.
Carper, K. L. (2006). “Editor’s note—Mitigating the potential for progressive disproportionate structural collapse.” J. Perform. Constr. Facil., 305–306.
Corley, W. G., Mlakar, P. F., Sozen, M. A., and Thornton, C. H. (1998). “The Oklahoma city bombing: Summary and recommendations for multihazard mitigation.” J. Perform. Constr. Facil., 100–112.
Dermisi, S. A. (2009). “International terrorism cyclicality: Predictions and concerns regarding private commercial buildings.” J. Real Estate Lit., 17(1), 87–110.
Dietz, A. S. (2011). “Countering the effects of IED systems in Afghanistan: An integral approach.” Small Wars Insurgencies, 22(2), 385–401.
Eamon, E. (2007). “Reliability of concrete masonry unit walls subjected to explosive loads.” J. Struct. Eng., 935–944.
Eilstrup-Sangiovanni, M., and Jones, C. (2009). “Assessing the dangers of illicit networks: Why al-Qaida may be less dangerous than many think.” Int. Secur., 33(2), 7–44.
Ellingwood, B. R. (2006). “Mitigating risk from abnormal loads and progressive collapse.” J. Perform. Constr. Facil., 315–323.
Ellingwood, B. R. (2007). “Strategies for mitigating risk to buildings from abnormal load events.” Int. J. Risk Assess. Manage., 7(6–7), 828–845.
Enders, W., and Olson, E. (2011). “Measuring the economic costs of terrorism.” Oxford handbook of the economics of peace and conflict, 〈〉 (Jul. 20, 2011).
Grant, M., and Stewart, M. G. (2011). “System and reliability modelling of improvised explosive devices.” PARARI 2011: 10th Australian Explosive Ordnance Symp.
Grant, M., and Stewart, M. G. (2012). “A systems model for probabilistic risk assessment of improvised explosive device attack.” Int. J. Intell. Def. Support Syst., 5(1), 75–93.
Hao, H., Stewart, M. G., Li, Z. X., and Shi, Y. (2010). “RC column failure probabilities to blast loads.” Int. J. Prot. Struct., 1(4), 571–591.
Health and Safety Executive. (2013). “Risk analyses or ‘predictive’ aspects of COMAH safety reports guidance for explosives sites.” 〈http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/assessexplosives/step5.htm〉 (Oct. 10, 2013).
Hegghammer, T. (2013). “Should I stay or should I go? Explaining variation in western Jihadists’ choice between domestic and foreign fighting.” Am. Polit. Sci. Rev., 107(1), 1–15.
Hoffman, B. (2010). “Radicalization and subversion: Al Qaeda and the 7 July 2005 bombings and the 2006 airline bombing plot.” Stud. Confl. Terrorism, 32(12), 1100–1116.
Joint Improvised Explosive Defeat Organization. (2008). Annual Rep. FY 2008, U.S. Dept. of Defense, 〈https://www.jieddo.dod.mil/content/docs/20090625_FULL_2008_Annual_Report_Unclassified_v4.pdf〉 (Jul. 21, 2011).
Jordan, F. (2008). “Predicting target selection by terrorists: A network analysis of the 2005 London underground attacks.” Int. J. Crit. Infrastruct., 4(1–2), 206–214.
Kelliher, D., and Sutton-Swaby, K. (2012). “Stochastic representation of blast load damage in a reinforced concrete building.” Struct. Saf., 34(1), 407–417.
Kenney, M. (2010). “Dumb” yet deadly: Local knowledge and poor tradecraft among islamist militants in Britain and Spain.” Stud. Confl. Terrorism, 33(10), 911–932.
Little, R. G. (2007). “Cost-effective strategies to address urban terrorism: A risk management approach.” The economic costs and consequences of terrorism, H. W. Richardson, P. Gordon, and J. E. Moore, eds., Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham, Gloucestershire, U.K., 98–115.
Low, H. Y., and Hao, H. (2001). “Reliability analysis of reinforced concrete slabs under explosive loading.” Struct. Saf., 23(2), 157–178.
Low, H. Y., and Hao, H. (2002). “Reliability analysis of direct shear and flexural failure modes of RC slabs under explosive loading.” Eng. Struct., 24(2), 189–198.
Lundberg, R. (2013). “Comparing homeland security risks using a deliberative risk ranking methodology.” Dissertation, Pardee RAND Graduate School, Santa Monica, CA, 〈http://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/rgs_dissertations/RGSD300/RGSD319/RAND_RGSD319.pdf〉 (Apr. 4, 2014).
Mack, A. (2008). “Dying to lose: Explaining the decline in global terrorism.” Human Security Brief 2007, Human Security Report Project, School for International Studies, Simon Fraser Univ., Vancouver, BC, Canada.
Marchand, K. A., and Stevens, D. J. (2013). “Updates to U.S. progressive collapse criteria and design approaches.” 10th Int. Conf. on Shock and Impact Loads on Structures, CI-Premier.
Mueller, J. (2010). “Assessing measures designed to protect the homeland.” Policy Stud. J., 38(1), 1–21.
Mueller, J., and Stewart, M. G. (2011a). Terror, security, and money: Balancing the risks, benefits, and costs of homeland security, Oxford University Press, New York.
Mueller, J., and Stewart, M. G. (2011b). “The price is not right: The U.S. spends too much money to fight terrorism.” Playboy, 58(10), 149–150.
Mueller, J., and Stewart, M. G. (2014). “Evaluating counterterrorism spending.” J. Econ. Perspect., 28(3), 237–248.
Nair, R. S. (2006). “Preventing disproportionate collapse.” J. Perform. Constr. Facil., 309–314.
National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism, and Responses to Terrorism (START). (2010). Global Terrorism Database, Univ. of Maryland, College Park, MD, 〈http://www.start.umd.edu/gtd〉.
National Research Council. (2010). Review of the Department of Homeland Security’s approach to risk analysis, National Academies Press, Washington, DC.
Netherton, M. D., and Stewart, M. G. (2009). “The effects of explosive blast load variability on safety hazard and damage risks for monolithic window glazing.” Int. J. Impact Eng., 36(12), 1346–1354.
Oppenheimer, A. R. (2009). IRA the bombs and the bullets—A history of deadly ingenuity, Irish Academic Press, Dublin, Ireland.
Pentagon Building Performance Study Team. (2003). “The Pentagon building performance report.” ASCE, New York.
Sheehan, I. S. (2012). “Assessing and comparing data sources for terrorism research.” Evidence-based counterterrorism policy, Springer Science and Business Media, New York.
Shi, Y., and Stewart, M. G. (2013). “Spatially variable reliability analysis of reinforced concrete structures subject to explosive blast loading.” 15th Int. Symp. on Interaction of the Effects of Munitions with Structures, T. S. Lok and K. L. Carper, eds., CI-Premier, 85–97.
Shi, Y., and Stewart, M. G. (2014). “Spatial reliability analysis of explosive blast load damage to reinforced concrete columns.” Struct. Saf., in press.
Smith, P. D., and Rose, T. A. (2002). “Blast loading and building robustness.” Prog. Struct. Eng. Mech., 4(2), 213–223.
Speckhard, A. (2011). “Battling the “University of Jihad:” An evidence based ideological program to counter militant Jihadi groups active on the internet.” Countering violent extremism: Scientific methods and strategies, Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, OH.
Stewart, M. G. (2008). “Cost-effectiveness of risk mitigation strategies for protection of buildings against terrorist attack.” J. Perform. Constr. Facil., 115–120.
Stewart, M. G. (2010). “Acceptable risk criteria for infrastructure protection.” Int. J. Prot. Struct., 1(1), 23–40.
Stewart, M. G. (2011). “Life-safety risks and optimisation of protective measures against terrorist threats to infrastructure.” Struct. Infrastruct. Eng., 7(6), 431–440.
Stewart, M. G. (2012). “Integration of uncertainty modelling, structural reliability and decision theory to provide optimal blast protection to infrastructure.” Advances in protective structures research, H. Hao and Z. X. Li, eds., CRC Press, London.
Stewart, M. G., and Grant, M. (2013). “Reliability and blast load efficiency of improvised explosive devices.” 10th Int. Conf. on Shock and Impact Loads on Structures, CI-Premier.
Stewart, M. G., and Melchers, R. E. (1997). Probabilistic risk assessment of engineering systems, Chapman & Hall, London.
Stewart, M. G., and Netherton, M. D. (2008). “Security risks and probabilistic risk assessment of glazing subject to explosive blast loading.” Reliab. Eng. Syst. Saf., 93(4), 627–638.
Twisdale, L. A., Sues, R. H., and Lavelle, F. M. (1994). “Reliability-based design methods for protective structures.” Struct. Saf., 15(1–2), 17–33.
United Facilities Criteria. (2005). “DoD security engineering facilities planning manual.”, Dept. of Defense, Washington, DC.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Volume 29 • Issue 5 • October 2015
Copyright
© 2014 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: May 27, 2014
Accepted: Sep 29, 2014
Published online: Oct 27, 2014
Discussion open until: Mar 27, 2015
Published in print: Oct 1, 2015
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.