Structural, Construction, and Procedural Failures Associated with Long-Term Pyritic Soil Expansion at a Private Elementary School in Pennsylvania
Publication: Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities
Volume 25, Issue 1
Abstract
This paper examines the background, history, and results of multiple investigations associated with pyrite-based expansive soils spanning almost 40 years in conjunction with a private elementary school located in western Pennsylvania. The school was initially designed in 1960. Original construction was completed in September 1961 and the first signs of distress, which were primarily related to slab heave, were reported in early 1962. One wing of the school, a 1965 classroom addition (1965 addition) with different structural and foundation systems, did not experience any expansive soil-related damages and served as a valuable comparison throughout multiple subsequent investigations. Pyritic soil material in the subgrade in conjunction with oxygen-rich groundwater was determined to be the cause of soil movement and building distress. Expansive soil-related problems at the school continued for decades despite an investigation, civil court action, and judgment in the late 1960s followed by a remediation program in the 1970s and 1980s. Following a second round of investigations and litigation in the late 1990s, all of the original classroom, office, and gymnasium building sections, with the exception of the 1965 addition, were demolished in late 2000 and early 2001 based on safety concerns and economic evaluation. Investigation and monitoring to confirm subgrade conditions continued throughout the demolition process. As a part of this paper, the history of this case dating back to one of the early identifications of pyrite as an expansive element of concern in building construction, including one of the earliest comprehensive identifications of the complete chemical-microbiological oxidation process is presented. The initial 1960s investigation and conclusions are identified as well as the series of engineering, procedural, and construction errors that took place during and after the first remediation process that led to ongoing soil expansion and structural damage, including misguided actions and misunderstandings that complicated and delayed a final resolution in this case. Today, the industry is more familiar with the potential for pyrite-related construction problems, nevertheless, the paper incorporates lessons learned for avoiding problems and in particular, the procedural failures that led to the eventual need to abandon and demolish the school facility.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
American Concrete Institute (ACI). (1995). “Building code requirements for structural concrete and commentary.” ACI 318-95 and ACI 318R-95, Farmington Hills, Mich.
Belgeri, J. J., and Siegel, T. C. (1998). “Design and performance of foundations on expansive shale.” Proc., Ohio River Valley Soils Seminar, Kentucky Geotechnical Engineering Group, Louisville, Ky.
Bell, F. G. (1992). Engineering properties of soils and rocks, 3rd Ed., Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, U.K.
Boward, J. F. (1999). Memorandum: Engineering standards of practice for addressing pyritic/marcasitic materials, Engineering Mechanics, Inc., Pittsburgh.
Bryant, L. D. (2003). “Geotechnical problems with pyritic rock and soil.” M.S. thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State Univ., Blacksburg, Va.
Carr, P. G., Thesier, J. L., and Kimball, M. B. (2006). “An ‘invisible menace’—The impact of pyrite induced expansive forces on long-term building failure—A case study.” Proc., 4th Conf. Forensic Engineering, ASCE, Cleveland, 154–168.
Chen, F. H. (1975). Foundations on expansive soils, Elsevier Science, New York.
Dougherty, M. T., and Barostti, N. J. (1972). “Structural damage and potentially expansive sulfide minerals.” Bull. Int. Assoc. Eng. Geol., 9(2), 105–125.
Engineering News Record (ENR). (1960). “Structures don’t settle in this shale; but watch out for heave (expanding shale gives structures the heave-ho).” Eng. News-Rec., 164(5), 46–48.
Fairbridge, R. W. (1968). “Report on expansion of shale in the foundations of the school.” Dept. of Geology, Columbia Univ., New York.
Feld, J., and Carper, K. L. (1997). Construction failure, 2nd Ed., Wiley, New York.
Garvin, G. R. (1999). Evaluation of building distresses, Engineering Mechanics, Inc., Pittsburgh.
Garvin, Gary R. (2002). “Final report of building distresses evaluation.” Engineering Mechanics, Inc., Pittsburgh.
Hurlbut, C. S. (1941). Manual of mineralogy, Wiley, New York.
Longworth, I. (2006). Sulfate damage to concrete floors on sulfate-bearing hardcore: Identification and remediation, RIBA Publishing, London.
Merriman, M. (1912). American civil engineers’ pocket book, Wiley, New York.
Mitchell, J. K. (1976). Fundamentals of soil behavior, Wiley, New York.
Mitchell, J. K., and Soga, K. (2005). Fundamentals of soil behavior, 3rd Ed., Wiley, Hoboken, N.J.
Nelson, J. D., and Miller, D. J. (1992). Expansive soils: Problems and practice in foundation and pavement engineering, Wiley, New York.
Nowaczyk, K., and Domka, F. (2000). “Oxidation of pyrite and marcasite by Thiobacillus ferrooxidans bacteria.” Pol. J. Environ. Stud., 9(2), 87–90.
Penner, E., and Eden, W. J. (1972). “Expansion of pyritic shales.” Canadian Building Digest, CBD-152, ⟨http://irc.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/pubs/cbd/cbd152_e.html⟩ (June 10, 2009).
Sheetz, B. E., and Ellsworth, C. J. (2007). “Preliminary assessment of acid producing rock on future PennDOT construction.” Draft Final Rep., PennDOT/MAUTC Partnership, Pennsylvania Transportation Institute, Penn State, University Park, Pa.
Skelly and Loy, Inc. (2004). Remediation Plan: I-99 construction sections A12 and C12 acid rock drainage, Harrisburg, Pa.
Spanovich, M. (1968). Evaluation of distresses to elementary school, Engineering Mechanics, Inc., Pittsburgh.
Spanovich, M., and Fewell, R. B. (1969). “The subject is pyrite.” Pennsylvania J. Architecture, 49(1).
Whiting, D. (1997b). “Origins of chloride limits for reinforced concrete.” Concrete Technology Today, 18(3), 5–7.
Whiting, D. A. (1997a). Origins of chloride limits for reinforced concrete, Portland Cement Association, Skokie, Ill.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Copyright
© 2011 ASCE.
History
Received: Jul 1, 2009
Accepted: Jul 27, 2010
Published online: Jul 31, 2010
Published in print: Feb 2011
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.