Are Two Fire Rated Shutters Equivalent to a Shutter Using ASTM E119?
Publication: Journal of Architectural Engineering
Volume 15, Issue 2
Abstract
Performance-based design is commonly applied to projects that have difficulties in complying with prescriptive fire codes in the Far East. There are procedures for evaluating fire resisting construction and structural elements with fire resistance ratings lower than the values specified in the fire codes. The equal temperature-time exposure concept or -equivalent rule is commonly applied to support the argument. This paper will discuss whether installing two fire shutters each of a fire resistance period is equivalent to one shutter. The standard temperature-time curve under ASTM E119 was applied to show they are not equivalent and to illustrate the inadequacy. Further, there are concerns in applying such an approach for bigger fires as the radiative heat flux acting on the construction element is not included. Fire hazard assessment on fire resisting construction with lower ratings under postflashover fires should be evaluated with caution. Full-scale burning tests with bigger fires are suggested as a means to support the argument or demonstrate that the equal temperature-time concept would work as expected.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
ASTM. (2006). “Standard terminology of fire standards.” ASTM E176-06, American Society for Testing and Materials Int., West Conshohocken, Pa.
ASTM. (2007). “Standard test methods for fire tests of building construction and materials.” ASTM E119-07, American Society for Testing and Materials Int., West Conshohocken, Pa.
British Standards Institution (BSI). (1987). “Fire tests on building materials and structures. Method for determination of the fire resistance of loadbearing elements of construction.” BS 476, Part 21, British Standards Institution, London.
British Standards Institution (BSI). (2001). “Application of fire safety engineering principles to the design of buildings—Code of practice.” BS 7974, British Standards Institution, London.
Buildings Dept. (1996). “Code of practice for fire resisting construction.” Buildings Dept., Hong Kong.
Buildings Dept. (1998). “Practice note for authorized persons and registered structural engineers: Guide to fire engineering approach.” BD GP/BREG/P/36, Buildings Dept., Hong Kong Special Administrative Region.
Chow, W. K. (2005). “Building fire safety in the Far East.” Archit. Sci. Rev., 48(4), 285–294.
Chow, W. K. (2006). “Will two fire shutters of fire resistance period equal to one with ?” Int. J. Eng. Perform.-Based Fire Codes, 8(4), 166–169.
Chow, W. K. (2007). “Assessing construction elements with lower fire resistance rating under big fires.” J. Appl. Fire Sci. 14(4), 339–346.
Grosshandler, W., ed. (2002). Proc., Fire Resistance Determination and Performance Prediction Research Needs Workshop, NISTIR 6890, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Technology Administration, U.S. Dept. of Commerce, 1–30.
Harada, K., Kogure, R., Matsuyama, K., and Wakamatsu, T. (2000). “Equivalent fire duration based on time-heat flux area.” Proc., Fourth Asia-Oceania Symp. on Fire Science and Technology, 513–524.
Harmathy, T. Z. (1981). “The fire resistance test and its relation to real-world fires.” Fire Mater., 5(3), 112–122.
Harmathy, T. Z. (1993). Fire safety design and concrete (concrete design and construction series), Longman Scientific and Technical, Essex, England.
Hewitt, N. (2007). “Improving fire-fighting conditions with applications of performance-based fire engineering—A consultant’s point of view.” Proc., 2007 Annual General Meeting, Conf. and Exhibition, Extending the Boundaries of Fire Engineering.
Hung, W. Y., and Chow, W. K. (2002). “Review of the requirements on fire resisting construction.” Int. J. Eng. Perform.-Based Fire Codes, 4(3), 68–83.
Latham, D. J., Kirby, B. R., and Thomson, G. (1987). “The temperatures attained by unprotected structural steelwork in experimental natural fires.” Fire Saf. J., 12(2), 139–152.
Law, M. (1971). “Prediction of fire resistance.” Proc., Symp. No. 5, Fire Resistance Requirements for Buildings—A New Approach, Paper No. 2.
Law, M. (2002). “Some selected papers: Engineering fire safety.” ARUP, London.
National Fire Protection Association (NFPA). (2006). “Building construction and safety code.” NFPA 5000, Quincy, Mass.
National Fire Protection Association (NFPA). (2007). “Standard for fire doors and other opening protectives.” NFPA 80, Quincy, Mass.
Sultan, M. A. (2006). “Incident heat flux measurements in floor and wall furnaces of different sizes.” Fire Mater., 30, 383–396.
Sultan, M. A., Denichou, N., and Min, B. Y. (2003). “Heat exposure in fire resistance furnaces: Full-scale vs intermediate-scale.” Proc., 8th Fire and Materials 2003 Int. Conf., Interscience, London, 43–54.
Sultan, M. A., Harmathy, T. Z., and Mehaffey, J. R. (1986). “Heat transmission in fire test furnaces.” Fire Mater., 10, 47–55.
Wicksröm, U. (1994). “The plate thermometer—A simple instrument for reaching harmonized fire resistance tests.” Fire Technol., 30(2), 195–208.
Wicksröm, U. (2004). “Heat transfer by radiation and convection in fire testing.” Fire Mater., 28, 411–415.
Wicksröm, U., and Wetterlund, I. (2004). “Total heat flux cannot be measured.” Proc., 10th Int. Interflame Conf., Interscience, London, 2, 269–276.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Architectural Engineering
Volume 15 • Issue 2 • June 2009
Pages: 67 - 70
Copyright
© 2009 ASCE.
History
Received: Jan 17, 2008
Accepted: Dec 9, 2008
Published online: May 15, 2009
Published in print: Jun 2009
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.