Case Study of the Failure of a Cross Vault: Church of Holyrood Abbey
Publication: Journal of Architectural Engineering
Volume 9, Issue 3
Abstract
The church of Holyrood Abbey, in Edinburgh, collapsed in 1768 after an inappropriate intervention in the nave vaults. This resulted in excessive lateral thrusts, which could not be contained by the existing buttressing systems, causing progressive instability of the lateral walls. This effect was studied on a lateral cross vault of the church. A replica in 1:4 scale was built and tested initially under service loads and subsequently until collapse due to movement of the two front abutments. Analysis of the model was carried out with the finite-element program ABAQUS. The resulting behavior demonstrated the significant load-bearing capacity of the structure under service conditions and its high sensitivity to imposed changes of the geometry. Although the tensile stresses exceeded the flexural strength at the vertices and the abutments, the collapse was dominated by the membrane tensile failure at the groins, hence both the geometry and condition of this area are critical for the safety of the vault. The results of this study can improve the assessment and thus help in the preservation of many important Gothic and neo-Gothic churches.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
ABAQUS user’s manual—version 5.8. (1998). Hibbit, Karlsson & Sorensen, Pawtucket, R.I.
Bunyan, I. T., Fairhurst, J. A., Mackie, A., and McMillan, A. A. (1987). Building stones of Edinburgh, Edinburgh Geological Society, Edinburgh, U.K.
Croci, G., Viskovic, A., and Sabbadini, F. (1995). “Some aspects of the structural behaviour of Gothic cathedrals.” Proc., Spatial structures: past, present and future, International Association for Shell and Spatial Structures, Milan, Italy, 1207–1214.
Fitchen, J. (1961). The construction of Gothic cathedrals, Clarendon Press, Oxford, U.K.
Hendry, A. W., Sinha, B. P., and Davies, S. R. (1997). Design of masonry structures, E&FN Spon, London.
Heyman, J. (1995). The stone skeleton, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K.
Jagfeld, M. (2000). Tragverhalten und statische Berechnung gemauerter Gewölbe: Untersuchungen mit der Finite-Elemente-Methode [Structural behaviour and analysis of masonry vaults. Examination with the FE method], Shaker, Aachen, Germany (in German).
Mark, R., Abel, J. F., and O’Neill, K.(1973). “Photoelastic and finite-element analysis of a quadripartite vault.” Exp. Mech., 13, August, 322–329. (August).
Mylne, W. (1766). “Letter to Mr. Moncrieffe, King’s Remembrancer, dated 10/12/1766.” King’s Remembrancer Letter Book, 1748–1787, National Archives of Scotland, Exchequer.
Ortolani, F. (1988). “Effetti del terremoto sulle strutture laterizie voltate [seismic effects on brickwork vaulted structures].” Palladio, Riv. di Storia dell’Architettura e Restauro, Rome, Italy, n. s., year I, No. 2, 143–146 (in Italian).
RCAHMS. (1951). Inventory of monuments in Edinburgh, Royal Commission of Ancient and Historic Monuments of Scotland, HMSO, Edinburgh, U.K.
Sinha, B. P., Ng, C. L., and Pedreschi, R. F.(1997). “Failure criterion and behaviour of brickwork in biaxial bending.” J. Mater. Civ. Eng., 9(2), 70–75.
Theodossopoulos, D. (1995). “Structural analysis of Burgos Cathedral and restoration proposals.” Specialisation Manuscript: AE/2002/021981, thesis, Specialisation School in Restoration of Monuments, University of Rome “La Sapienza,” Rome.
Theodossopoulos, D., Sinha, B. P., Usmani, A. S., and Macdonald, A. J.(2002). “Assessment of the structural response of masonry cross vaults.” Strain J. Brit. Soc. Strain Measurement, 38(3), 119–127.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Architectural Engineering
Volume 9 • Issue 3 • September 2003
Pages: 109 - 117
Copyright
Copyright © 2003 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Mar 5, 2002
Accepted: May 29, 2003
Published online: Aug 15, 2003
Published in print: Sep 2003
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.