Preservation of Historic Thin-Shell Concrete Structures
Publication: Journal of Architectural Engineering
Volume 4, Issue 1
Abstract
Thin-shell concrete structures were developed in the mid-twentieth century in response to the need for economy in large-span structures and in response to the design and aesthetic program of the modern movement in architecture. Although of European invention, these structures were widely employed in the United States for industrial and military structures, stadiums, auditoriums, and shopping centers. Because of changing building economics and changing tastes, significant thin-shell concrete structures have not been built in the United States since the mid-1970s. In spite of their relatively recent construction, many surviving thin-shell structures can be considered as historic according to the Criteria for Eligibility for the National Register of Historic Places. However, a lack of awareness of the significance of these structures has caused the recent removal of two important thin-shell concrete structures, the New Orleans Convention Center and “The Paraboloid,” an entrance canopy for the May D&F store in downtown Denver. Others, such as Seattle's Kingdome Stadium, are clearly threatened. In this paper, we examine the historical and social context of thin-shell concrete structures, discuss the threats to the preservation of these structures, and outline a strategy of professional and public awareness and strategic repair.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
1.
Allen, J. E.(1950). “Construction of long-span concrete arch hangar at Limestone AFB.”J. Am. Concrete Inst., 21(6), 405–414.
2.
Amirikian, A.(1953). “Promising future predicted for precast thin-shell construction.”Civ. Engrg., 23(8), 42–44.
3.
Anderson, B. G. (1950). “Cylindrical roof for circular coliseum. Engrg. News Record, 145, 30–33.
4.
Anderson, B. G. (1952). “Cantilever frames support thin-shell roof.”Civ. Engrg. 21(8).
5.
Arup, O. (1954). “Discussion of `Domes, vaults, and the development of shell roofing'.”Proc., Symp. Concrete Shell Roof Constr. Cement and Concrete Assn., London, England, 14.
6.
“Assembly Hall, University of Illinois.” (1962). Engrg. News Record, 168(21), 44–46.
7.
Behrendt, W. C. (1937). Modern building: its nature, problems, forms. Harcourt, Brace, New York.
8.
Billington, D. B. (1977). “Letter to the editor.”Civ. Engrg. 47(4), 29.
9.
Billington, D. B.(1982). “Anton Tedesko: thin shells and esthetics.”J. Struct. Engrg., 108(11), 2539–2554.
10.
Building Research Institute. (1961). “Requirements for weatherproofing thin shell concrete roofs.”Proc., Conf.-Workshop, Publication 962, Nat. Acad. of Sci.-Nat. Res. Council, Washington, D.C.
11.
Candela, F. (1963). Faber Candela the shell builder. Reinhold Publishing Corp., New York.
12.
Christiansen, J. (1971). “Shell roof for international exhibition facility, New Orleans.”Concrete Thin Shells, American Concrete Institute Special Publication SP-28, ACI, Detroit, Mich.
13.
“City's worst building described as a `blight'.” (1993). Seattle Times. March 28, B2.
14.
Cohen, E., Dobbs, N., and Combs, W. (1985). “Inspection, analysis, and restoration of MIT Kresge Auditorium.”Rehabilitation, renovation, and preservation of concrete and masonry structures, American Concrete Institute Special Publication SP-85, ACI, Detroit, Mich.
15.
Coney, W. (1991). “Preservation of historic concrete: problems and general approaches.”Preservation Brief No. 15, U.S. Dept. of the Interior, Nat. Park Service, Rocky Mountain Regional Ofc., Div. of Cultural Resour., Washington, D.C.
16.
DeLony, E. (1993). Landmark american bridges. Am. Soc. of Civ. Engr., New York.
17.
Department of the Interior. (1990). How to apply the National Register criteria for evaluation, National Register Bulletin No. 15, U.S. Dept. of the Interior, Nat. Park Service, Interagency Resour. Div.
18.
Department of the Interior. (1992). The Secretary of the Interior's standards for the treatment of historic properties. U.S. Dept. of the Interior, Nat. Park Service, Cultural Resources Preservation Assistance, Washington, D.C.
19.
DeSyllas, L. (1954). “Domes, vaults, and the development of shell roofing.”Proc., Symp. Concrete Shell Roof Constr. Cement and Concrete Assn., London, England, 3–17.
20.
“Dim baseball future here? county seems to back Argyros view.” (1989). Seattle Times, May 27, A1.
21.
Dotter, E. (1969). “Do shells have a future? Arch. and Engrg. News, 11(12), 48.
22.
Emmons, P., Vaysbrud, A., and McDonald, J.(1994). “Concrete repair in the future turn of the century—any problems?”Concrete Int., 16(3), 42–49.
23.
“Experts critique the Olympic structures in Montreal.” (1976). Civ. Engrg. 46(12), 50–54.
24.
“Falling ceiling tiles uncover problems.” (1994). Engrg. News Record, 233(6), 8.
25.
“Fancy formwork shapes largest concrete dome.” (1975). Engrg. News Record, 194(16), 18.
26.
Isler, H. (1989). Heinz Isler, Schalen: Katalog zur Ausstellung. E. Ramm and E. Schunck, eds., K. Kramer, Stuttgart, Germany.
27.
Joedicke, J. (1963). Shell architecture. Reinhold Publishing Corp., New York.
28.
Knight, A. (1995). “Downtown subsidies: how do we know they're working?”Denver Post, May 7, E-1.
29.
LeCorbusier. (1946). Towards a new architecture. Architectural Press, London, England.
30.
Leubkeman, H. C.(1992). “Form swallows function.”Progressive Architecture, 73(5), 106–109.
31.
Medwadowski, S. J. (1971). “Conceptual design of shells.”Concrete Thin Shells, American Concrete Institute Special Publication SP-28, ACI, Detroit, Mich.
32.
Morris, R. M. (1728). “An essay in defence of ancient architecture, or a parallel of the ancient buildings with the modern: shewing the beauty and harmony of the former and the irregularity of the latter.” (republished 1971 by Gregg International Publishers Ltd., Richmond, Surrey, England.
33.
Nervi, P. (1957). The works of Pier Luigi Nervi. F. A. Praeger, New York.
34.
Ohio Department of Transportation. (1983). The Ohio historic bridge inventory, evaluation, and preservation plan. Ohio DOT, Columbus, Ohio.
35.
“One steep roof repair.” (1995). Engrg. News Record, 234(8), 30–32.
36.
Papademitriou, P.(1992). “Interview.”Progressive Architecture, 73(5), 102–106.
37.
Pennsylvania Historic and Museum Commission. (1986). Historic highway bridges in Pennsylvania. Pennsylvania Historic and Museum Commission, Harrisburg, Pa.
38.
“Politics claims historic hall.” (1995). Engrg. News Record, 234(16), 18–19.
39.
Richards, J. M. (1954). “Discussion of `Domes, vaults, and the development of shell roofing'.”Proc., Symp. Concrete Shell Roof Constr. Cement and Concrete Assn., London, England, 9.
40.
Roise, C. K., Rounds, S. P., and deMiranda, C. (1995). Minneapolis-St. Paul Airport reconnaissance/intensive level survey. St. Paul Metropolitan Airports Commission, St. Paul, Minn.
41.
Schueller, W. (1995). The design of building structures. Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle River, N.J.
42.
“Seattle mud-dome Kingdome roof dirties skyline and civic pride.” (1993). Seattle Times, March 29, A6.
43.
Sherfy, M., and Luce, W. R. (1990). “Guidelines for evaluating and nominating properties that have achieved significance within the last fifty years.”National Register Bulletin No. 15, U.S. Dept. of the Interior, Nat. Park Service, Interagency Resour. Div.
44.
Smithson, P. (1954). “Discussion of `Domes, vaults, and the development of shell roofing'.”Proc., Symp. Concrete Shell Roof Constr. Cement and Concrete Assn., London, England, 15.
45.
Spena, F. R., Sangiulaino, C., Sparacio, F., and Sparacio, R. (1995). “L'uso di materiali compositi (resine fibrorinforzate) per il consolidamento delle strutture.”Quaderni di seminari sul restauro architettonico, 1995(1) (in Italian).
46.
“Stadium planners pan Kingdome. `multi-purpose' fading from sports lexicon.” (1994). Seattle Post-Intelligencer, December 8, D1.
47.
“Survival of Kingdome thrown into question.” (1996). Seattle Post-Intelligencer, February 3, A5.
48.
Tedesko, A.(1960). “Shell at Denver—hyperbolic paraboloidal structure of wide span.”J. Am. Concrete Inst., 32(4), 403–412.
49.
Tedesko, A. (1970). “Shells 1970—history and outlook.”Concrete Thin Shells, American Concrete Institute Special Publication SP-28, ACI, Detroit, Mich.
50.
“The Secretary of the Interior's Standards and Guidelines for Archeology and Historic Preservation.” (1983). Federal Register, 48(No. 190).
51.
Torroja, E. (1958). Structures of Eduardo Torroja. F. W. Dodge Corp., New York.
52.
Torroja, E. (1962). Philosophy of Structures. University of California Press, Berkeley, Calif.
53.
Wisconsin Department of Transportation. (1986). Historic highway bridges in Wisconsin, WDOT, Madison, Wis.
54.
Witt, P. J., ed. (1954). Proc., Symp. on Concrete Shell Roof Constr. Cement and Concrete Association, London, England.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Architectural Engineering
Volume 4 • Issue 1 • March 1998
Pages: 4 - 11
Copyright
Copyright © 1998 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Published online: Mar 1, 1998
Published in print: Mar 1998
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.