Comparison of Estuarine Water Quality Models for Total Maximum Daily Load Development in Neuse River Estuary
Publication: Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management
Volume 129, Issue 4
Abstract
The North Carolina Division of Water Quality developed a total maximum daily load (TMDL) to reduce nitrogen inputs into the Neuse River Estuary to address the problem of repeated violations of the ambient chlorophyll a criterion. Three distinct water quality models were applied to support the TMDL: a two-dimensional laterally averaged model, a three-dimensional model, and a probability (Bayesian network) model. In this paper, we compare the salient features of all three models and present the results of a verification exercise in which each calibrated model was used to predict estuarine chlorophyll a concentrations for the year 2000. We present six summary statistics to relate the model predictions to the observed chlorophyll values: (1) the correlation coefficient; (2) the average error; (3) the average absolute error; (4) the root mean squared error; (5) the reliability index; and (6) the modeling efficiency. Additionally, we examined each model’s ability to predict how frequently the 40 μg/L chlorophyll a criterion was exceeded. The results indicate that none of the models predicted chlorophyll concentrations particularly well. Predictive accuracy was no better in the more process-oriented, spatially detailed models than in the aggregate probabilistic model. Our relative inability to predict accurately, even in well-studied, data-rich systems underscores the need for adaptive management, in which management actions are recognized as whole-ecosystem experiments providing additional data and information to better understand and predict system behavior.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
Borsuk, M. E., Stow, C. A., and Reckhow, K. H. (2002a). “The confounding effects of nitrogen load on eutrophication of the Neuse River Estuary, North Carolina.” in press.
Borsuk, M. E., Stow, C. A., and Reckhow, K. H.(2002b). “Predicting the frequency of water quality standard violations: A probabilistic approach for TMDL development.” Environ. Sci. Technol., 36(10), 2109–2115.
Borsuk, M. E., Stow, C. A., and Reckhow, K. H. (2003). “Integrated approach to TMDL development for the Neuse River Estuary using Bayesian probability network model (Neu-BERN).” J. Water Resour. Plan. Manage. Div., Am. Soc. Civ. Eng., in press.
Bowen, J. D. (2000). “Calibration performance of a two-dimensional, laterally-averaged eutrophication model of a partially mixed estuary.” Estuarine and Coastal Modeling: Proc., 6th Int. Conf., M. L. Spaulding and A. F. Blumberg, eds., ASCE, New York, 1244–1258.
Bowen, J. D. (2003). “A CE-Qual-W2 model of the Neuse Estuary for TMDL development.” J. Water Resour. Plan. Manage. Div., Am. Soc. Civ. Eng., in press.
Christian, R. R., Bryant, W. L., and Stanley, D. W. (1986). “The relationship between river flow and Microcystis aerunginosa blooms in the Neuse River, North Carolina.” Rep. No. 223, Water Resources Research Institute of the University of North Carolina, Raleigh, N.C.
Clark, J. S., et al. (2001). “Ecological forecasts: An emerging imperative.” Science, 293, 657–660.
Cole, R. W., and Buchak, E. M. (1995). “CE-QUAL-W2: A two-dimensional, laterally averaged, hydrodynamic and water quality model. Version 2.0.” Instructional Rep. EL-95-1, U.S. Army Engineer Waterways Experiment Station, Vicksburg, Miss.
Hobbie, J. E., and Smith, N. W. (1975). “Nutrients in the Neuse River Estuary.” Publication Number UNC-SG-75-21, Univ. of North Carolina Sea Grant Program, Raleigh, N.C.
Holling, C. S., Carpenter, S. R., Brock, W. A., and Gunderson, L. H. (2002). “Discoveries for sustainable futures.” Panarchy, understanding transformations in human and natural systems, L. H. Gunderson and C. S. Holling, eds., Island Press, Washington, D.C.
Leggett, R. W., and Williams, L. R.(1981). “A reliability index for models.” Ecol. Modell., 13, 303–312.
Levin, S. A. (1999). Fragile dominion, complexity and the commons, Perseus, Cambridge, Mass.
National Research Council. (2001). Assessing the TMDL approach to water quality management, National Academy Press, Washington, D.C.
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (NCDENR). (1999). “Total maximum daily load for total nitrogen to the Neuse River Estuary, North Carolina.” North Carolina Dept. of Environment and Natural Resources, Raleigh, N.C.
NCDENR. (2001). “Preliminary reduction target assessment for the Neuse River Estuary.” North Carolina Dept. of the Environment and Natural Resources, Raleigh, N.C.
Office of Water. (1997a). “Compendium of tools for watershed assessment and TMDL development.” EPA-841-B-97-006, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C.
Office of Water. (1997b). “Guidelines for preparation of the comprehensive state water quality assessments.” EPA-841-B-97-002, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C.
Office of Water. (1999). “Protocol for developing nutrient TMDLs.” EPA-841-B-99-007, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C.
Paerl, H. W. (1983). “Factors regulating nuisance blue-green bloom potential in the lower Neuse River, NC.” Rep. No. 188, UNC Water Resources Research Institute, North Carolina State Univ., Raleigh, N.C.
Paerl, H. W. (1987). “Dynamics of blue-green algal (Microcystis aerunginosa) blooms in the lower Neuse River, North Carolina: Causative factors and potential controls.” Rep. No. 229, Water Resources Research Institute of the University of North Carolina, Raleigh, N.C.
Paerl, H. W., and Bowles, N. D.(1987). “Dilution bioassays: Their application to assessments of nutrient limitation in hypereutrophic waters.” Hydrobiologia, 146, 265–273.
Paerl, H. W., Mallin, M. A., Donahue, C. A., Go, M., and Peierls, B. L. (1995). “Nitrogen loading sources and eutrophication of the Neuse River Estuary, North Carolina: Direct and indirect roles of atmospheric deposition.” Rep. No. 291, Water Resources Research Institute of the University of North Carolina, Raleigh, N.C.
Reckhow, K. H.(1999). “Water quality prediction and probability network models.” Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 56(7), 1150–1158.
Reckhow, K. H., and Chapra, S. C.(1983). “Confirmation of water quality models.” Ecol. Modell., 20, 113–133.
Reckhow, K. H., Clements, J. T., and Dodd, R. C.(1990). “Statistical evaluation of mechanistic water-quality models.” J. Environ. Eng., 116(2), 250–268.
Rudek, J., Paerl, H. W., Mallin, M. A., and Bates, P. W.(1991). “Seasonal and hydrological control of phytoplankton nutrient limitation in the lower Neuse River Estuary, North Carolina.” Mar. Ecol.: Prog. Ser., 75, 133–142.
Scheffer, M., Westley, F., Brock, W. A., and Holmgren, M. (2002). “Dynamic interaction of societies and ecosystems—linking theories from ecology, economy, and sociology.” Panarchy, understanding transformations in human and natural systems, L. H. Gunderson and C. S. Holling, eds., Island Press, Washington, D.C.
Stow, C. A., and Borsuk, M. E. (2003). “Assessing TMDL effectiveness using flow-adjusted concentrations: A case study of the Neuse River, NC.” Environ. Sci. Technol., in press.
Stow, C. A., Borsuk, M. E., and Stanley, D. W.(2001). “Long-term changes in watershed nutrient inputs and riverine exports in the Neuse River, North Carolina.” Water Res., 35(6), 1489–1499.
United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). (2001). “U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Region IV, Neuse River/Estuary Hydrodynamic and water quality monitoring report.” Atlanta.
Walters, C. J. (1986). Adaptive management of renewable resources, Macmillan, New York.
Wool, T., and Davie, S. (2003). “An EFDC WASP model of the Neuse Estuary for TMDL development.” J. Water Resourc. Plann. Manage. Div., Am. Soc. Civ. Eng., in press.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management
Volume 129 • Issue 4 • July 2003
Pages: 307 - 314
Copyright
Copyright © 2003 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Jun 13, 2002
Accepted: Aug 2, 2002
Published online: Jun 13, 2003
Published in print: Jul 2003
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.