Jury Verdict: Frequency Versus Risk‐based Culvert Design
Publication: Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management
Volume 118, Issue 2
Abstract
A federal district court jury in Cheyenne, Wyoming, ruled that an Act‐of‐God defense could not be used when a railroad culvert backed water onto residential properties during a catastrophic “10,000‐year” rainstorm. The culvert capacity not only met but exceeded industry design standards, yet the jury concluded that the railroad was negligent for not installing a structure large enough to accommodate the “monster” storm. The 5‐ft‐diameter culvert, installed to replace a larger, deteriorating trestle, is sized by frequency‐based methods to discharge the 50‐year peak flow rate, with a nominal surcharge anticipated during the 100‐year event. It is agreed by both sides that the selected structure could have safely passed more than a 500‐year event, but is not able to discharge all the flows from the freak storm. Backwater ponded 9 ft over the top of the culvert, flooding more than 20 basements in one subdivision. The defendant is held liable for the damages and cited as negligent for not anticipating the storm and for failing to consider the risks to the homeowners. Under court order, a large structure is installed. This paper is a review of several matters debated during the trial and in subsequent analyses, presented as a case study from the writer's perspective. The writer participated as an expert witness who performed the analysis for the defense, but was called to the stand as a witness for the plaintiff. The jury verdict was in favor of the plaintiff. Implications for improvements in drainage design and expert testimony are discussed
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
1.
ASCE code of ethics. (1977). ASLE Publications Fulfillment Dept., ASCE.
2.
Daseler, J. (1985). Cheyenne, Wyoming flash flood—August 1, 1985. NOAA, National Weather Service Forecast Office, Cheyenne, WY.
3.
“The design of encroachments on flood plains using risk analysis.” (1980). Hydr. Engrg. Circular No. 17, Fed. Highway Admin., Hydr. Branch, Washington, D.C.
4.
Druse, S. A., Cooley, M. E., Green, S. L., and Lowham, H. W. (1986). “Flood of August 1, 1985 in Cheyenne, Wyoming.” Hydrologic Investigations Atlas, HA‐699, NTIS.
5.
“Hydraulic charts for the selection of highway culverts.” (1965). Hydr. Engrg. CircularNo. 5, Fed. Highway Admin., U.S. Gov. Printing Office, Washington, D.C.
6.
“Interagency flood hazard mitigation report for Wyoming.” (1985). FEMA‐740‐DR‐Wyoming, Fed. Emergency Mgmt. Admin.
7.
“Layout and Design of Shallow Draft Waterways.” (1980). EM 1110‐2‐1611, Dept. of the Army, Corps of Engrs.
8.
Muller, F. (1990). “Don't litigate, negotiate.” Civ. Engrg., ASCE, Dec. 66–68.
9.
Viessman, W., Lewis, G. L., and Knapp, J. W. (1989). Introduction of hydrology. 3rd Ed., Harper and Row Publishers, New York, N.Y.
10.
Young, G. K., Childrey, M. R., and Trent, R. E. (1974). “Optimal design for highway drainage culverts.” J. Hydr. Div., ASCE, 100(7), 971–993.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Copyright
Copyright © 1992 ASCE.
History
Published online: Mar 1, 1992
Published in print: Mar 1992
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.