Performance Bonds and Guarantees: Construction Owners and Professionals Beware
Publication: Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
Volume 125, Issue 6
Abstract
Performance bonds and guarantees have been the subject of considerable litigation in recent years in not only the United Kingdom but also some other common law jurisdictions. The aim of the research reported in this paper is to identify the issues most commonly in dispute and the legal principles governing their resolution. Possession of knowledge of the issues and principle should alert the construction and engineering industries and their legal advisers to the matters that need serious attention in the drafting and negotiation of these instruments. Clarity in the legal principles should also contribute to a reduction in litigation. The issues identified include: (1) Whether an instrument is a conditional or an on-demand bond; (2) the effect of failure on the part of the beneficiary to give notices; (3) availability of an injunction to restrain the surety from paying after a call has been made by the beneficiary; (4) availability of an injunction to restrain a beneficiary from receiving payment after a demand has been made; (5) availability of an injunction to restrain a beneficiary from making claim; (6) availability of a Mareva injunction to freeze the fruits of a call; (7) meanings of certain phrases used in the instruments; and (8) a duty to account for proceeds of a call. The principles governing their resolution were also identified. Particular attention must be paid to (1) any ambiguity whether a surety is liable is always construed in the surety's favor; and (2) prejudicial conduct by the beneficiary releases the surety unless the instrument provides expressly to the contrary.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
1.
Andrews, G., and Millett, R. (1995). Law of guarantees, 2nd Ed., FT Law & Tax, London.
2.
Bennet, H. N. (1994). “Performance bonds and the principle of autonomy.” J. Business Law, 574–586.
3.
Chitty on contracts (1995). 27th Ed., Sweet and Maxwell, London.
4.
Collins, L. ( 1989). “The territorial reach of the Mareva injunctions.” The Law Quarterly Rev., 262–299.
5.
Goode, R. ( 1992). “The new ICC uniform rules for demand guarantees.” Lloyds Maritime and Commercial Law Quarterly, 190–206.
6.
Halsbury's laws of England. (1993). Butterworths, London.
7.
Holborn, G. (1993). Butterworths legal research guide. Butterworths, London.
8.
Hsu, L. ( 1992). “Autonomy of performance bonds in Singapore: Royal design studio v. Chang development” Lloyds Maritime and Commercial Law Quarterly, 297–302.
9.
Hudson's building and engineering contracts. (1995). 11th Ed., Sweet & Maxwell, London.
10.
Jeffries, J., and Miskin, C. (1993). Legal research in England and Wales. Legal Resources Ltd., Hebden Bridge.
11.
McKie, S. (1993). Legal research: How to find and understand the law. Cavendish Publishing Ltd., London.
12.
Penn, G. A., Shea, A. M., and Arora, A. (1987). Law and practice of international banking. Sweet & Maxwell, London, 279.
13.
Russell, J. S. (1991). “Construction contract bonds.”J. Mgmt. in Engrg., ASCE, 7(3), 299–313.
14.
“Standard form of building contract.” (1980). Joint Contract Tribunal, RIBA Publications Ltd., London.
15.
“Standard form of building contract with contractor's design.” (1981). Joint Contract Tribunal, RIBA Publications Ltd., London.
16.
Wallace, I. N. D. (1986). Construction contracts: Principles and policies in tort and contract. Sweet & Maxwell, London, 283–293.
17.
Wallace, I. N. D. (1996). “Strict canons in the court of appeal, not `Business Commonsense.”' Constr. Law J., 12, 178–186.
18.
Wallace, I. N. D. (1998). “Perar revisited: When will they every pay? When will they ever learn?.” Constr. Law J., 14, 322–328.
19.
Williams, K. ( 1983). “Performance bonds: Use and usefulness.” Lloyds Maritime and Commercial Law Quarterly, 423–439.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
Volume 125 • Issue 6 • December 1999
Pages: 428 - 436
History
Received: Dec 14, 1998
Published online: Dec 1, 1999
Published in print: Dec 1999
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.